Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
This Is Your FBI artwork

From the This Is Your FBI collection

The Seagull Shakedown

Episode 388September 5, 195229 min 26 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 18 min to read

The Equitable Life Assurance Society presents, This is Your FBI. This is Your FBI, the official broadcast from the files of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. Presented transcribed as a public service by the Equitable Life Assurance Society of the United States and the Equitable Society's representative in your community. Many doctors agree that worry is often the real cause of what seem to be physical ailments. The cause of much needless worry is money. Some men worry about the future security of their wives and children. Others worry about poverty and dependency in old age. Others wonder how they'll ever give their children a good education. If any or all of these problems bother you, get in touch with a neighbor of yours. He's your local representative of the Equitable Life Assurance Society of the United States. In about 13 minutes, I'd like to tell you more about him and the freedom from worry that comes with membership in the Equitable Life Assurance Society. Tonight, the subject of our FBI file, extortion. It's titled, The Seagull Shakedown. The professional criminal, almost without exception, depends on some kind of protection which will, he hopes, keep him out of prison. Sometimes this takes the form of gun and getaway car, or an attempt to establish alibis, or buy witnesses.

However, there is one lawbreaker who counts on getting his protection from the very victims of his crime. This is the extortionist. Statistics in the FBI files show that, as in the case you are about to hear, many of these criminal parasites have been able to operate for years without their activities ever being reported to law enforcement agencies. Once the payoff starts, the hapless victim of the extortionist finds himself an accomplice. in a conspiracy against his own pocketbook, his own peace of mind, and perhaps even his life. Tonight's FBI file opens at a fashionable beach club located in a small resort town a few miles from a large west coast city. An attractive young woman lies stretched out on the sand watching a pair of husky twin boys who race the waves toward shore.

Darling, I'm watching. Well, well, well, in that bathing suit, my dear, you hardly look old enough to be anyone's mother. Much less the parent of a pair of seals. Oh, hello, Mr. Worth. Now, now, now, Mary, not Mr. Worth. Oh? The boys call me Uncle Albert, you know. Uncle Albert, then. That's better. Won't you sit on? Thank you, my dear. Isn't often a man my age gets to spend time with such a pretty girl? No, Uncle Albert. You know, vacation's done you worlds of good, Mary. You look positively radiant. I wish I could stay out this season. Well, why not, hmm? Well, Chris didn't leave us that well provided. Oh, too bad, too bad. You know, it'd be fine for the boys. Are you staying long, Uncle Albert? Indefinitely, I hope. You see, I live here now.

How wonderful. You're retired then, huh? Ah, one can never retire from life, my dear. Let's just say that I've withdrawn from the main arena. Well, all the same, I envy you. It's so quiet here. Peaceful. Ah, but the sea's not peaceful. In these very waves, the tragedy of life goes on. Big fish eat little fish, and are in turn. I see, I see, dear. You see, my dear? Fish to go to Jaeger. Jaeger? Yes, that's a remarkably smart variety of seagull. You see, he lets the other gulls find the fish. Then he frightens them and steals their catch. That's horrible. No, that's natural. Oh, dear, dear, dear, I almost forgot. The carnival. Carnival? Mm-hmm.

One's open down the beach, and I thought the boys might join me in a ride on the merry-go-round. Oh, I bet they would. Well, how about it, Chris? Want to go on the merry-go-round? Can we? Can we, Uncle Albert? Why, of course you may. Mommy? Oh, it's all right. Come along, come along. Your Uncle Albert will show you how to catch the brass ring. What's that? Well, it's a very important thing in life, knowing how to catch the brass ring. Come on, boys. We're off to catch the bass. Ring the bass. Ring the bass. We're off to catch the bass.

Mary, for the life of me, I just can't understand it. Understand what, Sue? How your twins and my jeans can keep riding that thing. Oh, boy, Chris. Well, that's the first time he's gotten free. I get seasick just watching him. Oh, Sue. Well, you've no need to worry about your offspring, Mrs. Bradley. I don't? You know, it's a proven fact that the stomach of the immature Homo sapiens is lined with cast iron. On it? Oh, mister. Uh-oh, there she goes, straight for the ice cream stand. Excuse me, everybody. Dean, honey, you want to spoil your dinner? No, don't. Oh, dear, dear, dear, dear me, the protective instincts of motherhood. It's good to sit down.

Uncle Albert, you're wonderful with the children. Well, I can't help it. I just actually love them. Uncle Albert. Yes, my dear? I've got to talk to somebody. Well, if I can help you, I... Well, I don't know. Read this. Shocking. Uh-huh. No signature? No. There's been one in the mail every day for a week. Like this? Worse. Well, is it true? Any of it? Of course not. My husband was a fine man. A fine officer. To claim that he took money and sold out his men. Now, now, now. You've nothing to worry about. As long as you can prove he's innocent. Prove? They're all dead. How can I? What shall I do? Well, I'd advise paying off. But it's all a lie. Well, so is much of what you read. Truth isn't important. It's what people believe to be true. And they'll believe...

The worst about Chris? Inevitably. So, well, I should pay the $5,000 if I were you. $5,000? Well, that would be sufficient, I should think. But the letters don't say how much. Well, I'm sure that $5,000 will do. How can you be? The man who wrote the letters may want... Mary, I wrote them. You wrote them? Yes. Like the Jaeger, I too... Let others do my fishing for me. Well, my dear? I don't know what to say. Well, you'll be at the club dance tomorrow night? Yes. My joints are a bit creaky for the samba, but I often stand on the pier, you know, listen to the music, watch the sea. I'll be there. I'm sure of it. Mommy! Hey, wait, Chris! Save the white horse for your Uncle Albert.

The following morning at the FBI field office in the nearby metropolis, Special Agent Taylor reports to Agent in Charge Robert Woods. Oh, yes, Taylor. Here. Take a look at this photograph. Thank you, sir. Mean anything to you? Well, I'd guess she's somebody's rich aunt. Name's Anna Allen, local society leader. Prominent in half a dozen charitable organizations. And? Her body was found at 9 a.m. yesterday. Coroner lists cause of death as coronary thrombosis. Where do we fit in, sir? Her death may or may not have been attributable to a series of threatening letters found in her effects. Which classification? Bodily harm or personal scandal? Some of both, according to her lawyer. She pay off? Mm-hmm. Here's the file, what there is of it. Thanks. Ten years. And in cash. That's right. Regular withdrawal, small bills. Mm-hmm. Attorney for the estate is Frank Harriman down in the First National Building. He has the letters, so you might as well start there. All right, I'll get right on it.

You know, it's funny, Mr. Woods. If she'd come to us ten years ago, she could have saved herself a lot of money. Yes, a lot of money and maybe a heart attack. 320. Your serve, Mary. Of course, I told her it's none of my business, but while we're talking about the dignity of the club, you'd think the board would do something about those bikini bathing suits Betty Booth is always wearing. That's my game. Like I was saying to Jeff last week, of course he's a man, he doesn't look at things quite the same, but... Sure, because it's yours, sir. Sue, remember that fur cape of mine? Pastel mink? Sure, what about it? You always liked it, didn't you? Honey, I've been green with Emmett for two years. Would you... Would you be interested in buying it? What? You can have it for a thousand. It's worth twice that. Well, I don't know, ma'am. It's in perfect condition. Yeah, but there's... Jeff, he's kind of conservative. About money, anyway. You could ask him.

Okay. Well, how come you want to sell it? I need the money. Oh? It's for a friend. She... Well, she's pretty desperate. How desperate? Five thousand dollars. Wow. I promised to help her. Is she sick or something? No, it's... Well, I guess you'd call it blackmail. She's going to pay it. Well, what else can she do? I know what I'd do. What? I'd tell my husband all about it. Jeff's always getting me out of trouble. Like the time I drove the car through Carson's plate glass window. Well, this girl can't do that. Why not? She hasn't got a husband. She's a widow. Oh, I see. Turn up anything on the extortion, Taylor? Well, looks like these notes were an outside job, Mr. Woods. They're all typed in the same machine. An Adler Model 37. Foreign. Manufactured in Frankfurt. There's not many around this part of the country. Well, we'll send out photographic samples, check the distributor. That all you got?

I think the writer was a man. Close friend of the deceased. He had a lot of friends. Yeah, I know. Three address books full. Well, get on it. Maybe you can narrow them down. All right, sir. Good evening, Mary. I expected you sooner. I couldn't get away. My, my, my, what a lovely gal. You shouldn't have come without a wrap, though. The sea air is chill. Thanks. Oh, but I am concerned about your health. Very important to me, my dear. I know. Mary, I'm afraid that you don't understand. I... I bear you no malice. My child, as a matter of fact, it's quite the contrary. It's because I'm so very fond of the boys and of you that I... I selected you to be my... Well, my family. Your family? Yes. See, I'm not young anymore, and I...

have a certain standard to maintain. Since I haven't any children or grandchildren to support me in my old age, I've had to adopt them. I'd hoped it wouldn't be necessary to call them. I had an old friend who kept me in, shall we say, fish and chips. But she had a bad heart and, well, I've only a few more years at best. You want them to be happy years, don't you, Mary? Oh. Now, Mary, wait. Wait, wait. You haven't given your old Uncle Albert his fish. Let go of me. Mary. Leave away from me. Be careful. It's raining. Dear old, dear old, dear old, dear old. We will return in just a moment to tonight's exciting case from the official files of your FBI. One way to get the most out of life is to have a good, solid education. Now, you want that kind of education for your child.

but you may not be sure that you're making enough money to see the child through. That was the problem that had Mr. William Warden bothered until he became a member of the Equitable Society. How about that, Mr. Warden? That's true, Mr. Keating. I have three children, two girls and a boy, and I wanted them to have a good education. What had me sitting up nights was this. How in the world could I do it on the kind of money I make or if something happened to me? And how did you solve your problem, Mr. Warden? My local Equitable representative solved it for me. You see, I heard you describe an educational plan on this program that seemed to fit my pocketbook. That's our equitable education fund. That is correct. Then my equitable man showed me how I could spread the cost for my children's education over 15 years while they were growing up and without putting a crimp in our budget. And it was mighty reassuring to know, too, that if something happened to me, the entire fund became established with no more premiums to pay. Lucky day for me and my children when I called my equitable man.

He's a real credit to equitable, and he's a good man to do business with. If there are any other fathers listening in who want to give their children a real break, it's easy. Call up your local equitable representative. Yes, you'll find your local equitable representative a helpful neighbor and a good man to do business with. He knows life insurance. So no matter what your life insurance problem, security for your wife and youngsters, and independent old age, ownership of your home free and clear, talk it over with your friendly and helpful... equitable representative. Simply consult your local telephone directory for the name of your local representative of the Equitable Life Assurance Society of the United States. And now back to the FBI file, The Seagull Shakedown. Figures in the possession of your FBI clearly show crime to be America's poorest paid occupation. Added to this factor are hazards, imprisonment, nervous strain, bodily injury, degenerative illness.

Yet, as in tonight's case, the FBI files frequently reveal a professional criminal of apparent superior intellect and education. This so-called smart crook thinks the world owes him a living, that he's too smart to work for it, too smart for the law. He has to find out the hard way the futility of playing a lone hand against the intelligent, scientific, thorough army of law enforcement agents. By then, it's too late. A mind that might have served mankind has been used only for its own destruction. Tonight's FBI file continues at headquarters where special agent in charge Woods receives a phone call. Woods speaking. Yes, Rich. What can we do for you? Need a little help. Glad to do what we can. Anything in our jurisdiction? Yes. What's the case? Down at the shore, Bert. Foul play? Not at all. Where do we fit in? Threatening bodily harm? Yeah. I'll get an agent on it.

Where will you be? Then you think Mary Cornell's so-called friend was really Mary herself. I'm just positive of it, Mr. Taylor. In the first place, that stuff about her having no husband and being a widow, and just ain't no woman in her right mind trying to sell her only mink coat just to help out a friend. Mrs. Bradley, you're sure Mary didn't drop any hint about who might be trying to extort money from her? No, not a whisper. But I know who it was. You do? The man who killed her, that's who. Well, that's right, isn't it? That's why she was... She was murdered. Well, we don't know that she was murdered, Mrs. Bradley. That's one of the things we're trying to find out. He killed her, all right. One way or another, he killed her. Poor kid. Yes, I know. If I ever lay my hands on him, I'll... Suppose you leave that to the law, Mrs. Bradley. That's our job. Hold it, Rich, will you? You found something? I think so. Some blood on its piling. The coroner's report showed skull fracture as cause of death, didn't it? That's right. Rich, you got a pocket knife? Yeah. Here, Jim, catch.

Thanks. Get a lab report on this blood smear and see if it types out like the dead woman's. You figure she fell through that railing and hit her head on the way down? Yeah, it sure looks that way. Which could rule out murder. Yeah. Yeah, it might. Want to check anything more out here? No. Let's shove off. I want to get this specimen to the laboratory for examination right away.

Here's the lab report on the Cornell extortion notes, Mr. Woods. Show anything? Done on ordinary typing paper. 25% rag content bond. Common brand. What about the machine? Old office model Remington. Elite type. Capital A off-center. And? And that's it so far. Oh, I spotted a Noel Remington in the lobby at the Shorebird Club. Rich Franklin's picking up a specimen for us now. Well, this one sounds full-time. You want to ship someone else onto the Allen case? No, no, sir. I don't. You think there's a tie? Could be. Mrs. Allen belonged to Shorebird, along with a dozen other clubs. Notes reveal the same method of operation? No, I'm afraid not. The women know each other? Well, not well, anyway. Mary Cornell wasn't on my list. There's no Allen in the drowned woman's address book. Different typewriter, different M.O. I know there's nothing tangible, sir. Well, it's just that there's something about those notes. They're smooth and literate, almost too literate. Hmm.

How do you account for the switch typewriter? Maybe he was short of money, pawned or sold his own. Then used the club machine to go after his next victim. Sounds worth a try. I'll put Phillips on the pawn shops. You correlate the two sets of address books and run down the duplications. Right. While Agent John Phillips checked local pawn shops and second-hand stores for a recently disposed of Adler Model 37, Agent Jim Taylor made a tedious comparison of address books. Twenty names were duplicated, starting with Anderson Marie and ending with Worth Albert, each a potential suspect, each to be investigated, checked, and, if innocent, cleared. Meanwhile, on the pier at the Shorebird Club, Albert Worth went fishing. Hello there, Mr. Worth. Catching anything? Well, it seems, Mrs. Bradley, that the fish have already had their lunch. Right over here.

That's where they say the accident happened, right here. Oh, it was an accident, then. Well, I guess so. That's what the police say. Oh, a tragedy, a real tragedy. I wish there was something more I could do. Why, you were just wonderful to the boys, taking care of them till their aunt came from Cincinnati. Poor lost twins. Just like Romulus and Remus alone in the wilderness. Huh? Oh, yeah. I wonder why she was on the pier that time of night. Well, the way the FBI figures it... FBI? I thought you said it was an accident. Oh, sure, but... Well, I guess it's all right to tell you, you and her being so friendly and all. It looks like Mary came out here to meet a man. Oh? An extortionist. Really? You mean someone was trying to blackmail her? Uh-huh. Well, that's why the FBI's on the case. Well, how do you know? Well, Mary told me all about it that afternoon before. All? Well, not exactly everything.

Well, I don't figure the FBI would like me to be talking about it. Dear, dear, dear, dear. Poor Mary. Who was this man? Someone out of her past? Well, I don't rightly know. She didn't say. Oh, how unfortunate. I figure the FBI find out pretty quick, though. They most always do, I guess. Do they? Oh, I guess your luck's improving. You got a bite. Yeah, yeah. So I have. Oh, he got off the hook. I'm afraid so. Well, you don't seem very concerned. Well, when you've lived as long as I have, my dear, you'll learn that there are always other fish in the ocean. All right, Mrs. Dunman. Yes, thank you very much for your help. We appreciate it. Twelve down, eight to go. Who's next? Ah, next one's Mervyn Richards, dealer in antiques, married, three kids, lives over in the... I'll get it. Okay. Wood speaking. What? Oh, fine, Philip, good. Yes. Okay, shoot.

Jack's Tech Criteria, 218 West 3rd Avenue. Stick around. Someone will be right down. Is that our idler? Sounds like it. Salesman remembers taking one as a trade-in on a Corona portable. Seller was a fellow named Goldsmith. Goldsmith. A mill Goldsmith. Goldsmith. Not on the list. Oh, did Phillips check the machine's identity? Store a job to an eastern wholesaler. Okay, here I go.

Oh, Mr. Worth, are you moving out? Oh, no, no, no, my dear. These bags are just for little...

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑