Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Witch's Tale artwork

From the The Witch's Tale collection

The Puzzle

EpisodeSeptember 7, 193425 min 2 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read

The witch, old Nancy, and Satan, the wise black cat, they are waiting, waiting for you, now. You'll be today, yes sir, a hundred and seventeen year old. Satan, let's get down to our yarn spinning. Come on, have doused out them lights so we'll have it nice and dark. All up to the fire. So that you can gaze into the embers. You'll need a fire to warm your blood. You'll listen to this perky tale. You'll gaze into the embers deep. And soon you'll see a big railway depot in the town of London, England. Hear them funny little engines the English people got? Soon you'll see a funny little coach like the ones they pulls behind them.

I'm so nearly around yarn about the puzzle. Told me, Mr. Irons, that you'll have the compartment of yourself there all the way to here. Ah, that's just bully. This chauffeur of yours is a born fixer, Cecil. Yes. You know, since I first came to England, I've learned to appreciate the privacy of your railway compartment system. And today, I take it, you're especially appreciative. A chap who's on his way to meet the parents of his prospective bride for the first time will want privacy for the examination of his conscience. Ah, Julia has much respect for her stepmother's opinion. I really have only my future father-in-law to worry about. You know, it's funny you haven't heard of him. I'm told he's one of the most successful attorneys in London. Well, his name's very familiar. Omoroid. Omoroid? Yeah, Theodore Omoroid. Firm of Omoroid and Harding. Does he have any other claim to fame? Well, uh...

Julia tells me he's a puzzle expert. Puzzle expert? Yeah, you know, puzzles are his hobby. Oh, you mean he solves those crossword thingy-bobs and plays with those wire and steel, what do you call them? Yeah, that's it. Well, let's be walking towards the train, then. Lead the way, Colin. Yes, sir. I'm death sorry you won't stay until the next train, Willis. We've only had these few minutes together since you arrived from Dover. Oh, I can't stay over. It was awfully good of you to meet me here for this brief get-together. Oh, I have to hear more of the wonderful girl you've been writing me about.

You met her in France? Yes. Well, deucedly romantic. You from USA and she from England go to France to find each other. Well, the poet says, two shall be born, a whole wide world apart. Oh, the man is in love. He's even quoting poetry. Yes, I guess I have got it pretty badly. Well, here's a page. Nearly ready to start. I'm very anxious to rejoin her. Why did she leave Paris just ahead of you? Ah, stupid convention. Julia Chaperone couldn't get away, and she maintained it wasn't proper for engaged people to travel unaccompanied. Oh, I say. I'm sorry I didn't tell the old daughter to go jump in the Seine with the Victorian notions. Julia shouldn't have made that trip alone. She was too badly upset. Upset? Well, you see, she was called home by a telegram from her stepmother. It was one of those vaguely worded, your presence is required immediately messages. Makes you imagine all sorts of calamities. Well, Julia decided something had happened to her father. She's very devoted to him. Well, to ease her mind, I called her home by long distance and was told there was no illness there or accident or death.

I just wouldn't explain the reason for her summon, though. Well, that only made it more urgent. So when I put her on the train, she was still greatly worried. Sounds rather mysterious. Yeah, it does. Yeah, but whatever the trouble is, it can be very serious. Illness, death, and accident have been definitely ruled out. Uh-uh, that means me. Which is my compartment, Collins? Right here, sir. Number three. This is my gentleman guard, which I promised to take care of. Oh, yes. Sit right in, sir. You'll be alone in the compartment all the way, sir. I've arranged for this. Oh, that's the spying guard.

Here. Thanks very much. Oh, thank you, Dad. Thank you very much. Well, now, in perfect solitude, you can prepare yourself to meet your future father-in-law. Too bad you haven't made the study of puzzles, Willis. Then it accepts you as a kindred soul. I suppose I'll have to give that subject a lot of serious thought. Goodbye, Colin. I may need it. But where is it? You weren't in this compartment a moment ago. How did you... A puzzle, isn't it? You really must give serious thought to the subject of puzzles, Mr. Holmes. You know my name? Very well. Now, permit me to tell you mine. I am Theodore Elmeroy. You're Julia's father? Yes. Of course. Now I recognize you from the photographs. Oh, this is a pleasure, sir. Excuse me if I don't shake hands. I've recently met with a serious injury. An injury? A rather painful one. Although...

As you see, I wear no bandages. Was it merely your hand that was injured, sir? You were very pale, though you had experienced a serious illness. You have been ill. That's the reason Mrs. Omoroid sent that telegram to Julia. It was because of me that telegram was sent. But let's not talk about that now, if you don't mind. I prefer a more pleasant subject. I'm very glad to know you, my boy. And I to know you, sir. But how did you know me? Well, that's an easy puzzle to solve. According to my daughter's letters, there can be but one Willis Holmes. Well, I hope I can convince you of that, sir. But the guard said I was to be alone in this compartment. And when he closed the door, I was alone. How on earth did you... I came aboard from the other side. The other side? Yes. You see how simple puzzles are when one is told the answers. Gracious.

Here I've been talking of puzzles for a solid hour. I hope you'll forgive me. You see, to me, all life is an endless succession of intricate problems, which the successful man must solve for himself, and which the good man, the man who loves, must solve for others. I wanted you to know my philosophy, and now I won't bore you any longer. Oh, you haven't bored me at all, sir. I've been intensely interested. Ticket, please, sir. Good Lord, conductor, not again. Sorry to bother you, but it's rule, sir. And thank you. One puzzle I wish you'd solve for me, Mr. Elroyd, is why that conductor never asked to see your ticket. He's looked at mine four times. I arrived free, my boy. Are you a stockholder of this road? No. I'm well acquainted with the chairman of Mr. Pettus. My firm handles his legal business. The last time I rode this train, I carried 50,000 pounds of his money.

In currency. In currency? Thousand pound notes. That's rather dangerous, isn't it? Men would be murdered for a great deal less. It is a dangerous business. But when one is accustomed to handling large sums, one grows careless. We're pulling into Whittam. I leave you here, my boy. Oh, aren't you going home to Fiering, Mr. Omari? Not now. First I must return to Whittam. That's where Mr. Trezor has his residence. You won't see me again until tomorrow. In the meantime, will you give a little serious thought to the subject of puzzles? I certainly shall, Mr. Omroyd. But I value your expert opinion as to where and how I best begin. Circumstances will indicate your course of thought. It would be wonderful meeting you like this. I was a little worried at the prospect of formally asking you to accept me as your son-in-law. I accept you gladly. You'll look after Julia, won't you? I love your daughter very dearly, sir. And you will remember...

that he who loves must solve life's problems for others. I must leave you until tomorrow. Again, excuse my hand. The injury I mentioned. Dear me, where's my cigarette case, sir? Cigarette case? I haven't seen you use one, sir. I'm sure I had it with me. I must have dropped it here. Oh, I'll look for it. Just take care of it if you find it. You and Julia, take good care of it. All right, I found it already. It's fallen behind these cushions. Mr. Omeloy, where did the gentleman go who was with me in this compartment? A gentleman with you? In this compartment, sir? Of course. He just stepped out. He was standing right beside the door. You must have seen him. This door's been closed, sir, until you opened it yourself just now. You've been alone in this compartment all the way from London. The gentleman we've been expecting has arrived, Mrs. Omeloy.

Mr. Willis Holmes. Show him in, Barker, and then inform Miss Julia that he's there. I'll fetch Julia if you wish, Mrs. Omeroy. Perhaps you'd better, Mr. Tom. You're going to let Julia tell the young man our bad news? Naturally. He's her affianced husband at present. You think he'll break the engagement when he learns? Well, what would you do if you were in his place, Mr. Hardy? Mr. Willis Holmes. Oh, well, come in, Mr. Holmes. Julia will be here directly. I am Mrs. Omeroy. Oh, this is a great pleasure, Mrs. Omeroy. As Julia has told me so many things about you, I feel I already know you. I'll wait if you never told you many nice things about me. Agatha, control yourself. Really, I... Allow me to present these gentlemen. Mr. Harvey and Mr. Holmes. How do you do, young man? Mr. Harvey? You're Mr. Omoroid's partner, I imagine. I'm the junior member of Omoroid and Harvey. And this is Mr. Justice Rowley, Mr. Holmes. How do you do, Justice Rowley? Justice is a difficult title, isn't it? In America, I believe you would call me Judge, although I'm merely a provincial justice of the peace.

Do you know the town directly, Mrs. Romeroid? Oh, excuse me. Oh, this is Mr. Toms, Mr. Holmes. How do you do? Pleasure, old chap. Charmed, all that you know. Mr. Toms is my husband's personal secretary. Won't you all sit down? Why, thank you. Mr. Holmes looks rather uncomfortable. I don't imagine he expected to encounter such a large gathering. Of course he's uncomfortable. But, uh, he comes to pay a visit to Mrs. Romeroid's family and finds the house party in full swing about the place. House party? Agatha, you must control yourself. I don't understand you. There's nothing you need to understand, old man. Not now. And Joel, you're an American. How do you like England? I have learned to like it very much, Mr. Toms. With some exceptions. What are they? One is the type of guard employed on your railway train. You don't approve of our railway guard. I've just had a very ridiculous experience with one. A chap either afflicted with blindness or a very faulty sense of humor. It's a rather silly story, but if you care to hear it... Willis! Julia! Oh, Willis, I'm so glad you're here. So glad.

Darling, what's the matter? Julia, control yourself. Things are already bad enough, Julia. If you wish to tell him now of our disgrace, at least wait until I can leave the room. Disgraced? What do you mean? Julia, dear, I talked to your father on the train an hour ago, and he didn't mention any trouble here. What did you say? You're talking now? Yes, yes, we traveled from London together as far as Whitham. I don't believe it. He wouldn't have cared. Quiet. This is my father. Of course I am quiet. Didn't he say where he was going when he left you? Did he say where he would be home? Yes. He was on his way to a place called Whitham.

They say he'll be home tomorrow. Tomorrow? Oh, thank God. Everything would come out all right. The father would come back and explain. Mr. Holmes was mistaken in the man he talked to. Yes, or I couldn't have traveled on that train as far as Whittam. The police would have arrested him before he got aboard. Police? Every guard and conductor on that road has his description. Well, I haven't the faintest idea what any of you are talking about. Though I've never met him before, I've seen his autograph. I was neither mistaken nor the dupe of an imposter. What does he think you will, besides the other things you've told us?

It's mostly about puzzles. It's not that. Won't someone please explain to me what all this is about? Perhaps that's my painful duty, Mr. Holmes. Through powerful influence, we've thus far kept the story from the newspapers. But two weeks ago, Theodore Ormeroy disappeared with 50,000 pounds belonging to a client of our firm, a Mr. Travis of Whittam. There's no indication that it's been found that Mr. Ormeroy met with accident or foul play. The inference is obvious. And he left me, his wife, to face the scandal. Travis is the man he was on his way to see today. You have been imposed upon. No, it was Father. I know he talked with Father. So do I. And I hardly think, Justice Rowley, that a practical joker would have possessed this cigarette case with Mr. Omoroid's monogram upon it. Father! It's Omoroid. Where did you get that silver case? From the compartment where he left it, at the Aladdin from the train. Everything will be explained. He said he'd be home tomorrow. Willis, he said he'd be home tomorrow? Yes.

Maybe let him know. Maybe it won't be ridiculous. Your father wouldn't ring his own doorbell. If he comes here, the police will bring him as a prisoner. Come in. A police officer is here to see you, Mrs. Omeroit. Oh, they've arrested him. If they have, dear, they'll soon let him go. Show the officer in. Yes, ma'am. I asked to come in on you like this, ladies and gentlemen. Mr. Justice Rowley. What is it, ma'am? Speak up. Bad news, sir. The constables at Whitlam have found Mr. Omeroit, sir. They've arrested him? No, ma'am. I found him dead. Doctor say he's been dead two weeks. Dead two weeks? Yes, sir. Now bring his body home first thing tomorrow. Bring his body home tomorrow? Merciful God! What was it that rode with me in that compartment? But my dear Holmes, it's been established conclusively that my partner was lying dead in that pit where they found him.

The very time Ewing said he was with you on that train. Nevertheless, he or his spirit was with me, as I said. Oh, I know it sounds mad impossible. I've always laughed at the tales of the supernatural, just as you're laughing at me now. But I saw Mr. Omroy. He talked with me an hour, I tell you. Julia, you at least believe me. I don't know. It's all so horrible. It's too fantastic for anyone to believe. And even if you did see a ghost, Holmes, what purpose did the thing accomplish? Oh, none, I guess. Still, I feel it had a purpose in coming to me. One I can't grasp. It seems to me the traditional storybook phantom would have been of more practical service, Mr. Holmes. They always accuse their murderer. And such an accusation seems the only means by which the killer can ever be brought to justice. We know now that poor Omroy was struck down for that large sum of money he carried. But other than that obvious conclusion...

We of the law haven't found a single clue. The ghost should have known his murder had left no trail. But instead of dropping a helpful hint, Mr. Holmes says his specter merely talked of puzzles. That would have been my father's way. Julia, you're not going to become a champion of this young man's mad delusion. If your father's spirit could return to us, it appeared to you or to me, rather than to that young fiancé whom he never met in life. Father always said, a man who loves solves the problems of others. That's what he said to me. Oh, this is asinine. You've had a dream, my boy. Better forget it. No, for it wasn't a dream. It was real. And it had a purpose. Only I'm too blind to see it. I didn't dream this silver cigarette case. Isn't that tangible proof? I'm afraid that now I must shatter your illusions. I was advised today that the coach in which you traveled from London by a strange coincidence was the one in which two weeks before Mr. Romeroy took his fatal journey to Witham. Lying in idleness, The car had not been cleaned carefully. So you found that case where the unfortunate man had mislaid it. And he returned to put it in my hands. That was his purpose. I see it now. Somehow in this cigarette case is the solution of the puzzle. If you regard the case in that light, perhaps you'd better keep it into my keeping as a possible clue for the police. No. I give it to no one. For now I know a guilty conscience has been keener than my wits. A guilty conscience?

Are you accusing... I accuse no one yet. Oh, what do you mean? I mean that now everyone in this room, at different times with a different excuse, has asked me for this case. George, you hear? We can then talk in private. Willis, what did you mean by the insinuation you made a moment ago? Exactly what I said. That perhaps a guilty conscience has been keener than my wits. The killer of your father wants this cigarette case because he has some reason to be afraid of it. Your father's partner, Hardy, came to me two days ago. and requested it as a keepsake. The day before that, Tom made the same request. Yesterday, his stepmother asked for it, and now Roly would like to have it. But something seemed to make me refuse to give it up, even before I guessed it was the solution of my ghastly puzzle. But your suspicions are terrible. In spite of the frightful way they'd acted, those people were my father's friends. Your father was killed for a sum of money, but only his friends or his confidants. You carried on his person. If I can only solve the puzzle of the cigarette case, I'll learn which one is guilty.

His last words to me were, take care of it. You and Julia, take good of it. Your theory must be right. With father, everything was the foundation of a puzzle. You think there may be a secret compartment in the case? Yes, in which something is hidden. The metal is unnaturally thick on the sides and heavily embossed. There may be a shallow cavity between. Look for a spring or a lever hidden in that screw work. Here I am. Feel around the edges. Maybe something slides. That's it, that's it, a sliding edge. Found it, look. The metal slides are hollow. And there's a folded paper in the recess. What's written on it? It's dated June the 12th, the day your father went to Whittam with that 50,000 pounds. It says, on the understanding that if I have not left England by tomorrow noon, Theodore Omoroid, to whom I give this writing, will make its contents public. I hereby confess... Confess? To what? Oh, that can wait. Let me see whose name is signed here.

Who turned out those lights? Come on, let's get in this room. Don't get this paper. Coming through now. Nothing wrong with a bump on the head. What happened in this room before you screamed, Julia? Yes, for heaven's sake, what happened? One of you know what happened as well as I do. For one of you came in that door while our backs were turned. One of you turned out these lights. One of you stuck Willis. Then seized the paper we found and ran. And the one of you who did it. Is the one who killed my father. The girl's insane. Mad. How dare you accuse one of us. Your father's friend. Because one of you is guilty. Julia. Over this, darling. Are you all right now? Yes. Whoever hit me got away with the paper. Before we throw the name apart. Yes. They got away. I failed your father. When you failed, I may succeed. If my father came to you, perhaps he'll come again to me. What are you doing, Julia? I have locked the one door leading from this room. Why? What are you doing?

Just turn off the lights. Stop it. Turn on those lights. Boy, so you're going too far. No. Only one of you needs the other dark in this locked room. And if my prayer is answered, that one must face the man he killed. Lord, I pray thee, send my father from the dead to bring justice. Open the door. Turn on these lights. Are you afraid? No, no, I didn't kill him. Father, father, come to me from the grave. This nonsense has gone far enough. Are you afraid? I have no cause to be afraid. Lord, send my father here to bring justice. Oh, I'm not going to be made a fool of by a sick-brained girl. Think what you like. I'm going to leave this room. Yes, yes, we'll all leave. Open that door. Come on, quickly. Oh, they're terrible. Stay where you are. Mr. Omeroy. Oh, no. God has let you answer. Some puzzles are too difficult for men to solve alone. Help!

Don't be afraid. That's not Homeroid's voice. You see, Holmes and the girl are playing a trick upon us in the darkness. No. Something awful here. A hazy light is growing in this room. Homeroid's face is taking shape there. Keep him away. Keep him away. You help us with our puzzle, Roly. I'll do anything you say. Only don't come near me with your cold, dead hands. Keep away. I'll tell them. I'll confess. But keep away. I killed him. Tell them why. He learned I'd taken bribes. He made me sign a confession that would send me to prison if I stayed in England. I waited for him on the road to private house. I didn't know about the money he had with him. All I wanted was the paper that I didn't find. The paper in that cigarette case that I never found until tonight. Here it is. Use it to send me to the gallows.

But don't come near me with your cold, dead hands. Don't come near me with your cold, dead hands. I have the paper. It's confession. You and Tom hold on to him. I'll phone for the police. I won't try to get away. There's no escape of the dead. Father. Goodbye, Julia. My task is over. We will not meet here again. Father. Julia, dear. Take care of her, my boy. And remember, he who loves must solve the puzzles of life for others. That's the end of that little thing. You folks come see us next time I has a birthday.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑