Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar artwork

From the Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar collection

The Howard Caldwell Matter

Episode 066September 30, 195028 min 50 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 22 min to read

From Hollywood, it's time now for Evan O'Brien as... Johnny Dollar. Oh, yes, Mrs. Caldwell. I'm the investigator your insurance company has hired to look for your son. I understood that. When did you learn this? Oh, I see. Well, an insurance company is bound to operate from a basis of facts, not intuition. If you're going to be in this afternoon, I'd like to drop by and talk to you about him. Edmund O'Brien in another adventure of the man with the action-packed expense account. America's fabulous freelance insurance investigator. Yours truly, Johnny Dollar. Expense account submitted by Special Investigator Johnny Dollar to Home Office Britannia Life Insurance Company, Hartford, Connecticut. The following is an accounting of my expenditure during investigation of the Howard Caldwell matter. Expense account item 1, $6.50 transportation round trip between my Hartford apartment and the Caldwell country estate. From every angle, inside and out, the place looked more like a museum than a dwelling.

And Mrs. Caldwell struck me as the mother of all the answers as to why boys leave home. I don't know why Howard left. I simply can't understand it. No mother could have been more devoted than I. Except school, I never left him alone for a moment. I made him share everything with me. I protected him and I advised him. And yet... Yeah. Well, now let's get these facts in order. Name, Howard. Age 23, left here for San Francisco, California about a year ago. What was he doing in San Francisco? Oh, he was studying to be an artist. In a rather deceitful way, he knew I didn't approve. He told me he wanted to go to the coast to see a football game. Then he wired me that it had been delayed. And the next thing I knew, this letter arrived, saying that he'd met some people out there, that he didn't need any money.

and that he'd enrolled in this art school. I didn't believe it. I knew he was in trouble then. What's the name of the school? The Orlando School of Art. I wrote and begged him to come back, and he answered that he thought it would be better if he didn't, as if he were being threatened. Why would anybody threaten him? Well, I don't know. He told me very little of what he was doing. That's why I knew he was in trouble. Because we always shared everything. He'd never kept secrets from me. I think you're exaggerating this thing, Mrs. Goldwell. You are not. You haven't told me anyone. What should I think when he writes that I'll never see him again? When he tells me not to go to the police because it won't do any good? That he's gone to another life? Here. Here's a letter. Read it for yourself. The letter did say that. The date on it was a week old.

and it went on to make other vague references to danger and death. But a statement that the mother had ignored came to my mind closest to the truth. Howard Caldwell had written, If I had been mentally equipped for life as other people are, this wouldn't have happened, and I could have lived. This is Johnny Dollar. Is he in? No, that's neither here nor there. How'd she happen to turn to you? Yeah, I read it. Well, it sounded vague. He's been writing his mother a lot of double talk that... She's been interpreting in her own motherly way. She was supposed to come home this summer and didn't. I don't know what to make of it. If you want to find out anything, you won't get it from her. Oh, sure, but let's not share this with Mrs. C. She'd probably beat me out there. Expense account item two, $200 airfare and incidental costs, Hartford to San Francisco. Expense account item three, $170 cab fare from my hotel, the Bellevue, to the last known address of Howard Caldwell. A brownstone in a row of brownstones on Taylor.

a street that climbs one of San Francisco's seven hills. The apartment house manager was in and would oblige. He hasn't been here for a week and a half. I've been taking his mail up to his apartment, but his box gets so full they can't get any more in. The apartment is still in his name? He paid up three months in advance. Do you mind if I look it over? I suppose it's all right if you're trying to help us. It's up here. Did Mr. Caldwell say anything to you about leaving? No, he didn't. I hope there isn't any trouble. But you'd think he'd come for some of his clothes if there wasn't, wouldn't you? They're still here? I couldn't help noticing after he'd been gone so long. Without a word. Oh, sure. Yeah, this is it. Twenty-two. After you. Thanks. All this mail on the table. I hope everything's all right. He's a nice, likable young man. Know any of his friends?

Well, no, I don't. I expect he had some, though. He was out at night lots. He never came home drunk or anything, no. Well, if you don't mind, I think I'll run through the place. I won't be long. I suppose it's all right as long as I'm here. After I'd finished, I knew very little about Howard Caldwell that I hadn't already known. The letters on the table were, as to be expected, all from his mother. A drawer in a bedside table gave me something too odd to be ignored. Twenty-five or thirty match folders, all from bars or restaurants, all empty of matches, and each marked in pencil with a date. The earliest, May 4th, 1950. The most recent, September 12th. A closet gave me a portfolio of sketches from various perspectives, and they looked like a brunette. Nothing else in the play seemed to point in any direction, so I copied the addresses on the match folders and helped myself to three of the most descriptive sketches.

Expense account item four, a dollar and thirty cents, cab fare to the Orlando School of Art. I'm Beatrice Orlando. Did you wish to see me? Yes, I'm a private investigator from Hartford, Connecticut. I'm here trying to locate a student of yours. Howard Caldwell. Oh, that's right. You're fast. Not at all. I take a personal interest in my students. It was so strange the way he just stopped coming to class. He's doing so nicely and seemed to enjoy his work. Is he in trouble? I don't know. I wonder if you could tell me which of his classmates were personal friends of his. I don't think any of them were. Here, look at these. That's Howard's work. Excellent, don't you think? And that model, she must be a gorgeous girl. Isn't she one of your models? I only wish she were. Remarkable, the lines and planes. Do you think she's real? Drawn from life, of course.

No wonder he didn't bother to make friends here. Expense account item 5, $45, see enclosed bar tabs. That night I started making the rounds of the addresses I'd copied from Howard Caldwell's collection of dated match folders. They led me from San Francisco's North Beach section to another area called the Mission, across the bay to the city of Oakland, and back to San Francisco. The only pattern I could set up was that none of the joints were worth remembering. They were neighborhood bars as a rule. and the routine in each was about the same, except that the one called the stop sign. Is the drink all right, mister? Yeah, it's fine. Say, I wonder if you could help me. How? I'm looking for an old friend of mine. I understand he used to come into this bar. Here. Here's a photograph of him. Name's Howard. No. No, I don't remember him. I got a mind for faces, too. Well, then look at this. It's only a sketch. Have you ever seen a girl who looks like this?

Is this a gag? No, it isn't. What makes you think it would be? You mean this is a drawing of a real dame? Right. And for ten or twenty bucks extra, I can have the genuine photograph to hang up behind my... Get out of here. Wait a minute. Has somebody tried to sell you a deal like that? You're the first, and I can tell you won't go over in this town. I'm not trying to sell you anything. Well, then go someplace else and don't try. I never saw the guy or the dame, and I don't expect a good night. Hey. Hey, let me see a picture, will you? Darling, I can describe it. Oh, wait a minute. Maybe I know who she is.

Why should you? Because I know everybody that comes to this bar. If her boyfriend's name is Howard, I bet I know him. That's what I said it was. Did you say it was Caldwell? Where can we talk? Come on, outside. You know where Caldwell is? Yes, sucker, I know where he is. Keep it quiet. Hey, we'll both keep it quiet, huh? I'll take this out of your ribs if you play ball. That's a deal. Up to the corner then, and across the street. Now across that parking lot.

The yellow club coupe. Don't bother memorizing the license number. It's phony. Here he is. I'm fine. Thanks for asking. Get in the back. We could drive out towards the beach, J.B. What do you think? It's better in here. I'll swing over to Folkman and pick that up. How'd you get the addresses of these bars? How did you find out about me? We've been waiting for somebody to show up. Been watching his apartment. We saw you go in and then tell you to that school. Is Caldwell alive? Yeah, but he won't stay that way if people start crying. Why not? Who hired you? I'm a private investigator. I'm not supposed to tell people things like that. We aren't getting any place, are we? Now, look, from where you sit, how is it going to hurt you to tell us? You working for the old lady? His insurance company. They carry him as a pal as they are. Well, lay off, J.B. It's not funny. Jerk. Watch it, J.B., will you?

I've only got one thing to say, though. Stop looking for them. Leave things the way they are. I'm giving you the best advice anybody could. Drop it. Go on home. Can't do it. I'm stuck. You ought to understand that. It's my business. If I give up on one job, I'll never get another. Yeah, I guess you got a point at that. Drive him back to his hotel, J.B. It's Bellevue, isn't it? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. Yeah? What is it? Who is this? You'll remember when you wake up.

Send me some coffee, will you? And the early examiner. Yes, the coffee shop is just open. A couple of cigarettes later, room service arrived. The headline read, Syndicate Head Found Slain in Auto Trunk. Benjamin Miller, Western Gang Chief, Shot to Death. I didn't see how there could be any connection between a dead mobster and the Howard Caldwell matter. But that only proves how wrong an investigator can be.

In just a moment, we will return to the second act of yours truly, Johnny Dollar, starring Edmund O'Brien. But first, to more of radio's greatest stars, check in at CBS The Star's Address this Sunday night. The first you'll hear are Amos and Andy. Then a little later this Sunday, we welcome Red Skelton back from summer vacation. With Joey Adams, Eve Arden, Jack Benny, and Corliss Archer already on hand to bring you great comedy, be sure you add Amos and Andy and Red Skelton to your Sunday night listening dates. starting this Sunday over most of the same CBS stations. And now, back to our star, Edmund O'Brien, and the second act of Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar. The story under the headlines went on to explain that Benjamin Miller's body had been found in an abandoned car after a phone tip at 11.15 the preceding night. The chief had been shot to death approximately a week before.

It was feared that an underworld war would be touched off by the killing since eastern operators allegedly had threatened to force Miller out of business on the west coast. The police had decided to play a waiting game. No lead in all that. But on page four, there was a picture. Ben Miller in happier days. At his side stood a brunette that matched the one in Caldwell's sketches point for point. Nora Rush with an address on Ardmore Street in Los Angeles. Is this hotel of the travel agency? Now, I want to leave for Los Angeles as quickly as I can. What plane is there? Can I make it? Oh, I'll thank you late, Angel. Just one more thing. If I get any calls, you don't know where I am, huh? Expense account item 7, $5 cab fare and $5 tip for a taxi driver who got me to the airport in 20 minutes. Item 8, $20, United Airlines to Los Angeles. And item 9, same as 7, taxi trip to Nora Rush's Ardmore Street address. I arrive there at 9.15.

She was still in a robe when she answered the door, but the trace of makeup, which was all she needed for her face, and the soft hairdo made me wonder if she was expecting me. There's certainly no reason to be anything but truthful. Yes, I've been expecting you. Won't you come in, Mr. Dollar? Thanks. Come in here. You have good friends in San Francisco. Yes, I have. Very good friends. Just put your coat anyplace and sit down. Thank you. Well, then I take it they've told you why I'm on the West Coast. He's come to look for Howard Caldwell. There's coffee. Would you like some? No, thanks. I've had plenty. Do you know where he is? No. No, I don't. No, I don't know where he is. Oh, come on now. Stop then. That was the end of the test run. I rattled around the rest of the place for almost an hour while I waited for her to come out of the bedroom. I didn't feel like snooping, but I couldn't help seeing a framed photograph that had been hastily hidden under a mat on the piano. It was young Caldwell.

But not the subdued, dead-faced kid in the picture I'd gotten at his Connecticut estate. Instead, a guy with some enthusiasm in his friendly eyes. I was in the kitchen drinking a coffee when she came out. What are you doing? Waiting for you. Why don't you leave? Well, if I did, somebody else just like me would show up. Maybe he'd make you unhappier than I do. That kind of a racket. I sympathize with you. You should. You've put me on the defensive. I hadn't noticed. How did I do that? You started by posing for some sketches. And you're stronger in person. You saw them? Yeah. They're in a hotel room in San Francisco. Or at least, that's where I left them. Who else saw them? A few bartenders and his art teacher. Oh, that little fool. Tell me he destroyed them. You say bartenders? Yeah. He had a match folder collection all dated from a series of nondescript hideaway type bars. Could he have been in love? Well, he didn't ask you out of his mind.

He lied to me. He told me there was nothing to link us together. What's the difference if there is? Of course. Because Howard killed Ben Miller. And nobody will believe it now. Why won't they believe it? It was my gun. Registered? Yes. Where is it? Howard has it hidden. I loved him and all that. But the two-story... You haven't told me. I will. I will, Mr. Towers. I have to sit down. All right, come on.

How did you meet Caldwell? I was going with Ben Miller. Not because I thought anything about him, but he was so powerful out here, and I'd just come from Chicago. Caldwell? Well, it was one of those parties. Some of the models from the Orlando school were invited just to fill out. It was Howard School, and one of the girls had talked him into coming. That's when we met. There was something about him. I don't know. This was in May, I take it. I think so. Spring, anyway. He was supposed to go home for the summer and didn't. I'd meet him in his bars, and he'd come to my place when Ben was out of town. He wanted to sketch me, so... But it's not important. Ben saw me meet him and followed us to my apartment. This was at your place? You had an apartment in San Francisco? Ben hit me, and Howard went for the gun and killed him. He knew where you kept the gun? Yes. Why? How did he know?

in case he ever needed it. Miller's body was found stuffed into the trunk of a car. You don't believe me, do you? Well, there are little things like how did he manage to get the body into the trunk of that car and how did he manage to steal the car? I'll tell you. He had help. Everybody knew that combination from the East was moving in on Ben and would tell him if they had to. So they've been trying to help Howard. And it was all right till you came out here. Oh, that's a pretty good setup. Ben Miller would be checked off as a gang-killing, the kind they so seldom get around to solving. When it cooled off, you could take up where you dropped them. A plural you. You're all in it. But I can't quite figure it. What? Why those two friends of yours who picked me up last night would go to bat for a worthless eastern aristocrat? They want to help him. Why? Well, because he's my friend. Why should anybody take a rap for killing a man like Ben Miller? You don't want him to die for it, do you? Do you? Of course not. We're trying to help him. What are you going to do?

Well, the Frisco police are combing the city for leads on the scene of the murder, the murder weapon, and the definite link between dead man and killer. I seem to be sitting on all three. You aren't going to the police. That depends on how fast you tell me where Caldwell is. I want to hear his version of the story. I don't know where he is. I told you that. Yeah, I know you did. Wait. Wait now, please. Wait just a minute. Please. But just a minute, please. Oh, will you stop it? Just listen to me. I know what you think of me. And I know you don't believe me. But I wish you would, just for a little while. How long? An hour or so. My brothers are flying down. They'll be here by noon. Brothers? The men you met last night. I wished them before you do anything. You won't be in my name. I wish you had hit me over the head with something. That's a funny thing to say. Well, what I mean is that that kind of trouble makes me mad enough to fight. Oh, there they are, Johnny. I'll go. Wait a minute. Sit down. We're back in business again, gorgeous. Sorry. I'll let him in.

All right, go ahead, you stubborn jerk. Come in. Where's the other one? He stayed in Fusco. Sorry I couldn't get here faster, honey. Are you all right? I'm all right, Al. Did you tell him how it happened? Yes. She told me and we made a deal. I wouldn't phone the police until I talked to you. It still stands. Yeah, a drink would help. All right. Look, Dollar, for some reason my sister fell for this kid. I guess it was the first time in her life that something decent came along for her. He wanted to marry her. Then it fell to pieces when Caldwell lost his head and shot Ben. What really happened, Al? Ben made a lot of threats and stirred up all the mud in Nora's life. She tried to stop him, he slugged her, and that was it. Were you there? No, I wasn't, but that's what happened. Leave it alone, Dollar. Ben had the thing around him anyway. Why not let it cool off? There are a number of reasons. Unfortunately, I'm burdened down with a vague but heavy thing called ethics. That is on my license. Another thing, if I forget it, it makes me an accessory to the killing.

The most important at the moment is the fact that I'm not sure that Caldwell is guilty. Keep coming, darling. It would make more sense if you were protecting your sister instead of that punk. Don't you agree? Stay out of it, honey. Isn't that why all of you have been working so hard to keep me away from Caldwell? Because you don't want me to hear his pitch? Okay, I'll take you to him. He's here in Los Angeles. Pour the drinks. I'm giving ground, darling. What do I get from you? You've already gotten it. I didn't call the police. Somebody is going to blow your head off one of these times, darling. There's a car in the garage, honey. This is it. Upstairs. Quite a come-down for a cyan type. That's a good spot for him. He could live in this part of town for a hundred years and nobody would know who you were or what you were unless you wanted him to. Up front here. Howard. Howard. It's Al, Howard. Howard. What about it, Al? What's this? We told him not to leave. No clothes.

This is an empty room, Al. This is where he was. You check downstairs. He was the same, the name Harris. Save it, Al. There's only one place he'll go, to Norris. I'll try the rest of this without you. You've got nothing but a mouthful of lies. I don't want any more of them. Come on, get out of my way. Caldwell here? Yes, he's been here all morning. He left right after you did and hid outside. He's like a crazy man. Where is he? In the bedroom. You stay here. My first sight of the all-important Howard Caldwell was not a pleasant one. He was face down on the bed, his head buried in a pillow. and his body shaking with sobs. It took 30 minutes of treatment, some of it not too gentle, to get him into a chair in a reasonably sane state. I'm glad you came. I'm glad you found me. I'm glad to talk to somebody who isn't stupid. I want you to calm down, Howard, and tell me what happened. What happened? Do you know her? I do, too. She didn't want to marry me. She wanted to marry my respectable name, Money. Who killed Ben Miller? I did.

I killed him because I didn't know what else to do. Because I lived with these people, these low-class people, and I began to think like them. Because I've never thought for myself all my life. I've never done anything before. Anything. I killed Ben Miller, and it's the only thing I've ever done. All by myself. Why did you risk all this to protect him? I don't know. Because there was something that drew us together. He was lost, and so was I. And I figured it was my fault I'd drawn him into my life. He hadn't drawn me into his. I thought I owed it to him. But he's a snob, isn't he? Yeah. Yeah, I'm afraid so. He called me a tramp. I guess when you take a guy like him, who wants to get away from his kind of life, and a dame like me who wants to get away from her kind, neither one can figure it out. What can you expect with trouble? I guess she summed it up as well as anybody could.

I turned them in for murder and those who try to help them as accessories. It's for the legal brains to decide whether the policyholder will live or the executor. Expense account item 10, $200, miscellaneous. Item 11 is item 2, transportation back to Hartford. Expense account total $1,050. Yours truly, Johnny Dollar. Yours truly, Johnny Dollar stars Edmund O'Brien in the title role and was written by Gil Dowd with music by Wilbur Hatch. Edmund O'Brien may soon be seen in the Paramount picture Warpath. Featured in our cast were Lorene Tuttle, John McIntyre, Bob Sweeney, High Averbach, John Boehner, Gene Bates, and Jeanette Lolan. Yours truly, Johnny Dollar, is produced and directed by Jaime Del Valle. Join us next week at the same time when, from Hollywood, Edmund O'Brien returns in another adventure of Yours truly, Johnny Dollar. This is Roy Rowan speaking.

Stay tuned now for Vaughn Monroe's Caravan, which follows immediately over most of these same CBS stations. This is CBS, the Columbia Broadcasting System.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑