The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read
It's time now for Edmund O'Brien as... Johnny Dollar. Lou Crager, Mr. Dollar. Yeah, Lou, what's up? They found the boat a few miles off the Atlantic side of St. Croix. Oh? She was empty. Neither one of them aboard? No. From what I understand, it looks like there was trouble, all right. How's that? Bloodstains. I guess signs of a struggle. The engine had run until it was out of gas. They're sure it's the boat, huh? Yeah, they must be. Oh, they're sure. It's registered to Willard South. Yeah, all right. Where can I see it? Well, they won't have it in for another 30 minutes. The police dock is next to Royal Mail. You can't miss it. I'll meet you there if you want. Good, Lou. I'll see you in about 20 minutes. Edmund O'Brien and the transcribed adventure of the man with the action-packed expense account, America's fabulous freelance insurance investigator, yours truly, Johnny Dollar. Expense account submitted by Special Investigator Johnny Dollar.
to Great Eastern Insurance Company, Hartford, Connecticut. The following is an accounting of expenditures during my investigation of the Willard South matter. Expense account item one, $143.80, airfare and incidentals between Hartford and the city of Charlotte Amelie, island of St. Thomas, Virgin Island Group. I arrived there two days after the disappearance of your policyholders, Willard South and his wife, Georgina, and one day after the report had been made by his foster mother. She was too upset to be questioned, but I did find a local guide and boat owner who claimed to know the boating habits of Willard South through a number of fishing trips. I made arrangements with him to start my own search the next morning, but it was this guide, Luke Crager, who phoned that second evening to tell me that South's cruiser had been found empty. I didn't know if you'd... You could do better on light down here. Part of the romance of the island. Ah, this is the boat, huh? Police officers still aboard.
A native by the name of Shoy. I told him you were coming. We can go aboard now. In the cabin. Officer Shoy? Yes. Mr. Dollar is here. Come inside, then. Thanks for letting me aboard, officer. Glad to meet you, Mr. Dollar. I was sent to your University of Iowa to learn to be a policeman. A good school. I learned what they taught me, but I've had no chance to learn if what they taught me is right. It is our boast that there is no crime in the Virgin Islands. That has been right. Now this. Well, it happens in the best of circles sooner or later. What do you make of it? Let me show you with my light. Near the wheel. Is the bullet still in the wood? Yes. I will take out the piece of the panel with the saw and take the bullet from that. There's bloodstain under the wheel. Are there more like it? This is the large one. As if somebody fell there. As if somebody fell there. There are more here and more in the passageway.
Then on the deck, there on the rail, as if somebody climbed over the side or was pushed over. There's one other thing back here. This piece of line. Look, it's been cut. Mr. Crager says a small boat was usually tied to the stern. You sure of that, Lou? Oh, yeah, I'm sure. Willard always trailed a dinghy. You know, a skiff, unless he was trolling. Then he hoisted it aboard. But where is it now? You're searching for it, aren't you? Yes. So is the Coast Guard boat. I wish you luck. A little skiff will be a lot harder to find than a cruiser like this. Well, I'll be anxious to learn of any developments, Officer Choi. I'm staying at the Grand. Nothing had developed by noon the next day. I spent the morning on routine legwork. In the 12.30, I was back at the Willard South address. It was an old building with enough elevation to give its windows a view of Charlotte Amelie's pleasant harbor.
The man who met me at the door. I'm Willard's brother. I was told you'd called yesterday. Mr. Dollar, come in. Your mother was too upset to talk with me yesterday. You've gotten the news on what they found, I suppose. Yes, I went down to see the boat. Has anything further been learned? No, not yet. Sit down, Mr. Dollar. It's cooler here on the veranda. Thank you. I wasn't here yesterday because I was searching for Willard's boat, too. I'm surprised to learn Willard has a brother. I've asked a lot of questions about him in the village. Nobody mentioned you. Well, I'm only here a few days a year. My home is in Tampa. I arrive the first of the week, Tuesday. I'm glad I met you before I had to see your mother. It's a lot easier to be blunt with a brother. Blunt, Mr. Dollar? How about Willard's reputation on the island? I can't seem to find anybody who doesn't hate him. I'm afraid you won't either. Do you know anyone who hated him enough to shoot him? Well, I hardly know how to answer that.
I know a number of men have been hurt seriously by him. The ones that have lost wives? Yes. Do you think he's dead? I don't know. The only thing I'm sure of is that there was a shooting on his boat and somebody was hurt. I'm told your brother and his wife were seen leaving on it at dusk, night before last. Is that right? Yes. They'd packed an evening meal. The meal had never been eaten. Well, little trips like this are... Regular habit of theirs? No, they weren't at all. It was a special occasion. Georgina's never stopped hoping she could reform Willard and win him back. This trip was one more of her efforts. Did they say where they were going? No, but I thought it would be Calibra. That's an island about 20 miles from here in a westerly direction. Mother said they started that way, but the boat was found almost 40 miles in the other direction. It's a matter of 60 miles. Yes, 60 miles.
Mr. Dollar, what could have happened in those 60 miles? I don't know yet, but I hope to find out. You knew about the skiff being cut loose? Yes, they told me, but... Paul, dear. Yes, Mother. Who's with you? Is there any news? Nothing yet. Mother, this is Mr. Dollar from the insurance company. How do you do, Mr. Dollar? Mrs. South, I'm sorry I have to meet you at a time like this. A great many crises in the past 10 years have revolved around my son, Willard. I've conditioned myself to expect them. Even his death by violence, if that should be. Mother, please. But if harm has come to Georgina... There's no evidence of that, Mrs. South. Well, if it does, I shall hold myself responsible. Mother. Because I allowed her to become the wife of the beast I have called my son. It was a rare situation. There was no actual evidence that Willard South had been murdered. But almost everyone I talked to seemed to think he had been. Simply because there were so many motives. One of the people who didn't think so...
was a newcomer to the island, Celeste Robertson, there to take advantage of the six weeks divorce law. Who told you about me? A bartender up the street. He said you and South had been seen together recently. Yes, I know him. As a matter of fact, I've spent quite a bit of time with him in the last couple of weeks. Where do you think he is? I don't know. Do you think he's dead? No. No, I don't. Most people do. Well, I can't help that. I know a lot of people don't like him. Would there be anyone close to you that doesn't like him? No, there wouldn't. I'm here alone. When did you see him last? The afternoon before he and his wife disappeared in their boat. You answered that almost as if you knew you'd be asked the question. Well, I didn't. I just remembered it was only a couple of days ago. But you wouldn't remember his mentioning anybody who might be out after a scalp, huh?
I understand he enjoys that sort of thing. He never mentioned anybody. What are you holding back, Mrs. Robertson? Nothing. I don't have anything to hold back. Did he ever say anything to you about getting rid of his wife? I don't know what you mean. Look, all we have to work with is a bullet hole in the boat and some bloodstains that could have come from her or from him. He never said anything. And what are you afraid of? I'm not. Look, Mr. Dollar, please, I... I don't want to get my name mixed up in this if I can help it. I'm here sort of on... Good behavior. I know I was wrong to see him because he was married, but... But what? Just because I did see him, I don't think I have to get mixed up in things like shooting. Something I don't know about at all. I guess you can't be blamed for that. You don't have to get mixed up in it. Unless you already are. All that day, planes searched the sea for the missing skiff. Boats, too, swept back and forth between the islands. It wouldn't seem possible that anything they missed would ever be found.
But it was. That evening, after the planes had given up in order to get back to their fields before dark, a radio report was received from one of the boats. The skiff had been found, and in it, still alive, was Mrs. Willard South. I was with Officer Shoy when the boat was docked under the steady hand of a leathery old skipper with the help of one crewman. Get some things over, Gerald. What's the matter with you? All right. You're strained now.
We can go aboard now, Mr. Dollar. All right. Aloy, Captain Bracken. Aloy yourself, Officer Shaw. Your luck is good. Used these eyes for 72 years for nothing, Officer Shaw. How's Mrs. South? Can she talk to us? She cannot. She's been put through a hard time. She gets turned over to Dr. Gar before she talks to anybody else. What about her husband? Did she say what happened? Yes, she did. She's seen him shot down before her very eyes. and his dead body heaved to the sharks. And then somebody go fetch Dr. Gore. She needs some work, else she'll die. We'll return you to the second act of Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar, in just a moment. Have you heard the new Sing It Again? The new comedy of Jan Murray, your host, on that coast-to-coast phone? The new cash prizes for cracking the mystery of Sing It Again's phantom voice?
The new speed and color of the tuneful little riddle songs that make Sing It Again a Saturday night must for radio listening. You'll like the new Sing It Again. Be listening for it tonight on most of these same CBS stations. Now with our star, Edmund O'Brien, we return you to the second act of Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar. It wasn't until the next morning that Dr. Gar decided Mrs. South was strong enough to be questioned. He'd taken her to the single small hospital in Charlotte, Amelie. And at ten, he beckoned from the door to her room. I think it'll be all right, but please don't tire her. Mr. Dollar. Yeah? I want you to question her. I never learned about a case like this one. I never did either. Anything you say. All right, Doctor. Georgina, this is Officer Choi, and this is Mr. Dollar. Yes? Mr. Dollar is here to ask you some questions, but I don't want you to let him tire you. I'll try not to, Mrs. Holmes.
Why are you here? I was sent down from the States when you and your husband disappeared by your insurance company. I see. Now, I know it's pretty horrible to go back over it, but we've got to find out just what happened on that boat. The quicker we do it, the quicker we can get to the bottom of it. Captain Bracken told us just the bare details. He's the boat captain who found you. He told us you saw somebody shoot your husband. Who was it? I don't know. There were two men. I've never seen them before. How did they get aboard, Mrs. Allen? We were on our way to Calibra. Almost halfway, I think. It was dark, and we saw a light blinking from under the boat. Will said it was a signal that somebody was in trouble, and we went over. This man said they'd run out of fuel and asked if we had any to spare. But when Will pulled alongside, this man jumped on our boat with a gun.
It's all right, Georgina. Don't go on if you don't want to. He shot Will. That's all. He shot him, and then the other man jumped aboard, too. What did they say? They didn't say anything. You think your husband knew them? No. No, he didn't know them. What did they do then? One of them hit me because I was screaming. I was wearing a bracelet, and he grabbed it off my wrist. And they made me take off two rings and give them to him. They took Will's wallet and they dragged him out of them. They pushed him into the water. I don't remember anymore. It's all right, Georgina. Nobody can hurt you now. Gentlemen, I think we'd better let her rest now. Sure, Doctor. I'm sorry we had to bother you, Mrs. Allen. Sorry. Don't be. Considering what she's been through, I think she did very well. Actually, her physical condition, except for exhaustion, is quite good.
She did have water during the time she was adrift and some shelter from the sun. What do you make of it? The whole thing seems pretty brutal for simple robbery. Say, where is the nearest prison, Choi? Puerto Rico. Now, that's something that had not occurred to me. Escaped convicts might carry out such a ruthless attack, might they not? Yeah, even more so. I will send cables to both of those prisons. I think you'd better. There's little enough to go on. but it was obviously useless to try to get any more information from Mrs. South then. Dr. Guy had every right to insist that we leave his patient alone. Officer Shoy went to his headquarters to cable his questions, and I went back to the waterfront. The skiff was still on the dock, but before I even got to it, I was hailed. Whatever your name is... How are you, Captain Bracken? How's the invalid? Have you heard? Yeah, I just left her. She'll be okay. Yeah, lots of spunk, that one. What are you figures behind? She wasn't strong enough to tell us much.
Officer Choi is checking the possibility that those two men she talks about might be escaped convicts. Say, they might have been. I can't see anybody like that leaving her alive to talk about it. No matter how low they get, there's them that can't kill a woman, I suppose. What are you doing down here? I want to take a look at that skiff by daylight. The escaped prisoner theory is too long a chance to rest on. It still may have been a local job. Oh, I hate to see it turn out that way somehow. Why do you say that? Oh, this wants to be a peaceful island. It's the truth. Nobody wastes any affection on Willard. But if it'd been downright fitting if two escaped convicts done that devil in. I spent 30 minutes looking over the skiff and another hour going over Willard South's cruiser again. Nothing I dug out of either one added up. Neither did the results of a trip to the cable office.
There had been no recent escapes from the prisons. Right from the beginning, for all my prying and all my questions, I hadn't gotten one positive lead. But by this time, there were so many things I couldn't put my finger on that I began to reason why not make a weapon of just that. So I started again with Lou Krager, the first person I'd met in the investigation. I found him aboard his boat. Dollar, what's got into you anyway? I'm sick and tired of the runaround and double talk I've been getting. I don't get it. You will. You were quick to make yourself available to me when I showed up here. Why, Crater? I thought you needed some help. You wanted a boat, I had one. I think you mean somebody else needed help. That piece of line you pointed out to Officer Shoy and me on South's cruiser. The short piece. Who cut it? I don't know. How should I know who cut it? It's one of the things you better get straight. You said it had been used to tow the skiff. The line of the skiff had not been cut. What does that mean?
That you were lying. Now, I'm no sailor. But why cut a line when loosening a couple of half hitches would free the skiff? But it was cut, wasn't it? The line you pointed out was cut. And you made your point that Willard South always trailed the skiff. Why? Because you wanted the search for it to go on. Because you knew his wife was alive and would be found in it. I think the tropics have got you, Dollar. You don't think I can break this case down, do you? Because half of the non-tourists on the island are willing to lie to cover up for us. I don't care how noble their loyalty is. This case is going to be broken down. Because there's a reason Coast Guard planes can search for three days and not find her. But that night, after dark, your friend Bracken can. Her story of the other boat and the two men. If the South Cruiser had been stolen, the other boat would have been found. How do you know what happened? I know that a doctor will be here in less than 18 hours who will prove that Georgina South did not spend three days adrift. Tower, you don't know what you're talking about.
Where are you going? To the cave of the doctor. Now, wait a minute. You don't know what you're doing, Dollar. I was told what to do when I was sent down here. Well, he thinks as they are, Dollar. Believe me, it's the right thing to do. Not where I come from. Well, I can't let you. Mr. Krager, I told you to stop. Stop or I have the right to use you. You heard him, Krager. You heard him. Take it easy. Listen to me, Dollar. Sometimes right, the way you find it in the book, isn't right. Remember that I told you. Mr. Dollar. Oh, I'm sorry, Mrs. South. I didn't see you in the swing. I wouldn't have barged in. You startled me. I must have been dozing. There's been so little sleep. Yes, I know. I went to the hospital first. They told me that Georgina had come home. Yes, she did. I'll have to see her, please. Why must you see her, Mr. Dollar? I think you know. You know, Willard's brother knows, Captain Bracken and his crewmen know, Luke Crager, Dr. Garr. I'm not sure how many others.
I'm afraid I... Please, please, what's the use? You shouldn't have tried it, no matter how you felt. You should have realized that it wouldn't work. Even way down here in the Virgin Islands, a murderer is hard to protect. Where is she? Who told you this? There were too many mistakes. Lou Crager made the biggest one. You two are making one, Mr. Dollar. I'm sorry, Mrs. South. Murder is murder. They speak of heredity and environment. Many say that heredity will never be overcome. Others say that environment will win out. But both are right and both are wrong. My husband and I took our boys from the poorest foundling home we could find. Paul is one of the best. But Willard, Willard didn't deserve to live. He became more bestial every day. He couldn't live any longer. No more secrets, Georgina, my dear. I must tell Mr. Dollar the truth.
It's I who've been hiding behind my friends. I'm the murderer. I killed Willard. I had to. I had to before he destroyed us all. Expense account item two, $85.40. Miscellaneous expenses and Charlotte Amelie. Item three, same as item one, transportation back to Hartford. Expense account total, $373. Remarks? I tabbed the confession as a false one when they heard it. And I'm not charging the company for the time I spent trying to prove it false. But it wasn't. It was true. And so is the awkward fact that a large number of the leading villagers are liable as accessories after the fact of murder. It should develop into quite a trial. Yours truly, Johnny Dollar. Yours truly, Johnny Dollar stars Edmund O'Brien in the title role and is written by Gil Dowd with music by Wilbur Hatch.
Edmund O'Brien's latest pictures, the Paramount Pictures production, The Redhead and the Cowboy. Featured in tonight's cast were Irene Hubbard as Evangela, Jan Miner as Georgina, Gilbert Mack as Lou, Fran Lafferty as Celeste, Ed Latimer as Sam, Maurice Tarplin as Shoy, and Bernard Lindrow as the Doctor. This is Olin Tice inviting you to join us next week at this time when Edmund O'Brien returns in another transcribed adventure of Yours truly, Johnny Dollar.
Everybody wants to help America's defense program. And part of everybody's duty is to be extremely careful with the handling of fire. This is especially true in wooded territory, where forest fires can cause terrible losses in valuable natural resources, lives, and manpower. Nine out of every ten of these disastrous fires can be prevented because they're man-made. Don't leave fire prevention to the other fellow. Only you can prevent forest fires. Stay tuned now for five minutes of the latest news. This is CBS, where you laugh at Jack Benny every Sunday night. The Columbia Broadcasting System.
