Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar artwork

From the Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar collection

The Sara Dearing Matter

EpisodeJune 8, 195428 min 30 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 16 min to read

your listening enjoyment, John Lund as Johnny Dollar. No, I just finished the case. How can I help you? That name has a familiar ring. She was in her 20s, didn't she? Who benefits by her death? You guessed the name of this man. During his 50 years of public health, almost every born in Virginia in 1758. At the age of 18, the cabinet boasted the names of such as John Quincy Adams and John C. Calhoun. When he was re-elected in 1820, he carried every state in the Union. and won every electoral vote except one, which was cast for John Quincy Adams. If you don't have his name by now, here are two more clues. During his presidency, the first public high school with the first steamship crossed. Who was he? James Monroe, fifth. His life is part. Expense account submitted by Special Investigator Johnny Dollar to Home Office Federal Life Insurance, Comfort, Connecticut. An accounting of expenditures during my investigation of the Sarah... Expense account item one.

$153 plane fare and incidentals from Hartford to International Airport, Inglewood, California. I rented a convertible and drove to a little village perched high in the Santa Rosa Mountains, overlooking a thousand square miles of Mojave Desert. I registered at the town's only hotel, then dropped around the offices of the Palmer News. Can I help you? I'm looking for the editor, Lacey, M. Lacey. I'm Lacey, Maggie Lacey. The editor? The editor. You're kidding. I wish you salesmen would think of a new approach. I'm just a little weary excusing the fact that I'm not a grizzled old character who drinks ink in his coffee. Miss Lacey. And I've got all the printing supplies I need. I'm sorry. Perhaps next time you're back, too. I'm here to talk about a news item, Miss Lacey. Which item? This one. Well, what about it? Well, it says that there are some rather peculiar circumstances surrounding the recent death of Palma's most famous citizen, Miss Sarah Dearing. These circumstances were discovered by the Palma News.

and brought to the attention of Dan Cox, county sheriff. As of this writing, Sheriff Cox has chosen to ignore the evidence submitted by the news. Why? Unquote. You write that? Yes. And you submitted the evidence to Sheriff Cox? Yes, I did. What sort of evidence, Lacey? I'm not sure that's any of your business, Mr... Dollar. Johnny Dollar. My credentials. Oh, an insurance investigator. For Federal Life. They insured, sir, dear? For $100,000. Who's the beneficiary, Mr. Dollar? Her estate. The executor hasn't contacted my company as yet. In fact, we don't know who he is or where to reach him. $100,000, you say? Just waiting to be claimed. That would explain why she... What did you say? Sarah Deering was murdered, Mr. Dollar. I'm almost positive on it. You better explain, Miss Lacey. Well, as you know, Sarah Deering was burned to death in her bed. At least that's what the county coroner certified.

Accidental death due to fire of unknown origin. But you disagree. And I'll show you why. I found this in the ruins of her bedroom. A medicine bottle. Well, the label was burnt off. What's this stuff caked in the bottom? Well, Pete, the local pharmacist, analyzed it for me. It's what's left of a very powerful sedative. Is this the evidence you submitted to the sheriff? Mm-hmm. And he said it wasn't anything to be concerned about. Now listen, Mr. Dollar. The stuff in this bottle can only be purchased by prescription. And it wasn't purchased here in Palma. So? So I think those two men brought it. I think they drugged Sarah Deering and then rigged up some kind of contraption that would start a fire in her bedroom after they got out of town. Hey, hold on. You left me with two men. What two men? The ones who come to see Sarah Deering every year on the same day. Who are they? Nobody seems to know. They usually come together on the noon bus and leave town on the 620. I took a photograph of them last year.

Plan to do a story on them someday. You know, from the angle of mysterious admirers make dearly pilgrimage to see ex-movie queen. There it is. Oh. And these men appeared on the day of her death? Mm-hmm. They left on the 620 and the fire was discovered at 8. Any idea where they come from? Hollywood. I checked with the bus drivers. Oh. You've done a very thorough job, Miss Lacey. Sarah Deering has been my idol ever since I was old enough to dream. I've read everything ever written about her. She's a wonderful woman. Yeah, so I've heard. I understand she was a recluse. What woman wouldn't be after the heartbreak she's had? You know, she died broke, Mr. Dollar. Except for the insurance policy. Did she owe anyone? No. No, there was just enough left in her bank account to pay her a few debts and Hilda's wages. Who's Hilda? Hilda Brower, her crystal maid. Been with her ever since she started in pictures. Well, thanks for your help, Miss Lacey. I'll keep in touch.

I found County Sheriff Dan Cox seated behind a well-ordered desk in his well-ordered office. He listened carefully. And when I finished, he wagged his massive shock of silver-white hair. Maggie Lacey claims there were prescription drugs not purchased here. And Miss Dearing, Mr. Monswear. A close who hadn't been off her estate for 20 years. Hilda Brower, her maid, went lots of places for Miss Dearing. How about the two men who called on her the day of her death? Oh, you care to give me their names? I would care, Mr. Dollar. I would very fine like them to be annoyed because of... about her death. You seem very certain that it was accidental. It couldn't have been anything else. I get the impression that you knew her rather well. Did you consider the possibility of suicide? Impossible. Who enjoyed living as much as she did doesn't take her own life. Yet she shut herself away from the world. And why not? Autopsy? County courses didn't warrant. And you agreed? Naturally, Mr. Dollar. I happened to be sheriff. Drove to the outskirts of town and located Sarah Deering's rambling Spanish villa. Found Hilda Brower.

An enormous. It was my evening out. Same as every Thursday, Mr. Dollar. I go to early movie. I'm home at eight. I smell smoke. It comes from her bedroom. There's fire. I try to reach her, but the flames. You did what you could, I'm sure. If you please, I'm not myself, you understand? Of course. Who were the two men who visited Miss Jerry that day? Two men? The ones who came every year on her birthday. I do not know any men. Now, Hilda, I know you're upset, but... I cannot tell you anymore. I don't know anymore. You know their names, Hilda. What are they? I cannot say anymore. Please, go away now. Now, look, Hilda, all I... Please, Mr. Dollar. I've got a job to do. I'll be going. Cox didn't bother to see me out, so I had a chance to pause in Sarah Deering's living room and study some photographs. There were four of them, all enshrined in gold frames, all of the same handsome young man. The face was weak-mouthed, without...

character and vaguely familiar. Oh, Mr. Dollar, back so soon? Any luck? Miss Mackey, may I see the photograph of those mysterious visitors you showed me before? Oh, of course. Here you are. You've got a lead, Mr. Dollar. I think so. You see this man, the tall one? Well, there are four photos of him in Sarah Deering's living room. Were they autographed? No. But they were framed in enough gold to indicate he must have held a very special place in her life. Of course, he's a lot older in this photograph. How about his pudgy little companion here? Well, apparently he didn't rate enshrinement. Only the tall one made the hall of fame. I wonder who he is. Miss Lacey, are you absolutely positive these two men visited Sarah during the day she died? Oh, yes, absolutely. Thanks. I'll borrow this photo if you don't mind. Be back tomorrow. Uh, Mr. Dullard. Johnny, wait. Yeah?

Where are you going in such a matter? To the Hollywood Public Library to find a name for this space. If you think the person in this photograph was an actor, Mr. Dollar, this picture and name will undoubtedly be cataloged in the player's directory or prior to 1937, the standard casting directory. Well, fine. However, unless you know approximately when he was active, you may be in for a very long search. Oh? A new edition of the directory is published three times a year. Each contains hundreds of performers. I see. Well... Dust off the 1923 editions. I'll work my way forward. In what seemed to be 400,000 faces later, I found my man in a 1928 edition of the Standard Casting Directory. He was Neville Thomas, represented by an agent named Matty Freeman. A phone call to the Artist Managers Guild disclosed that Freeman had gone out of business ten years ago. He was now owner of Matty's Steakhouse, an expensive eatery on Las Vienega Boulevard.

Hollywood Restaurant Row. At the bar, I was about to relieve my parched throat when who should approach but the pudgy little man in the photo Maggie Lacey had loaned me. Oh, I'm Matty Freeman. Headway said you wanted to see me. Yeah, that's right. I didn't touch your name, Mr... Dollar. Johnny Dollar. Insurance investigator. What can I do for you? Well, I was looking for an actor you used to represent. Neville Thomas. But you'll do fine. I don't understand... Uh, this... I'll give you a hint. Neville and me. Taken in Parma last year. What'd you get, Titch? That's not what I'm here to talk about, Mr. Freeman. Okay, so you've got a photograph. And a witness who saw you and Neville Thomas in Parma a few hours before Sarah Deering died. I don't know what you're talking about, Mr. Dollar, and if you'll excuse me... Just a minute. What is it? You mean to say that you've never heard of Sarah Deering?

Was my privilege to be in the business when Sarah Deering was making motion picture history? Well, feeling the way you do, it seems to me you'd be willing to cooperate. Explain what you were doing in Parma the day Sarah Deering died. I can explain anything to you. I just thought maybe you'd like to clear yourself. What? Suspicion of Sarah Deering's murder. I'm having a pipe dream, Dallas. Sarah Deering died in a fire. Okay. Then let's move on to Neville Thomas. Where can I find him? I wouldn't know. All right. Have it your way. I'll find Neville Thomas with or without your help. My company can usually get police cooperation. I'll see you, Mr. Freeman. Uh, one second, Dollar. Yeah? Just what does police cooperation imply? Oh, a statewide alarm for Neville Thomas. Wanted for questioning in connection with the death of Sarah Deering. The sheriff at Palma certified a death was accidental. The matter's closed. Any matter of murder can always be reopened. It'll be messy.

Lots of newspaper publicity. Find Thomas. Oh, wait, Dollar. Devil Thomas is in my office. Mind if I break in here for a moment to... Just the other day, I was having lunch with a group of newspaper... It's a funny thing, I said. They call one branch of the government the State Department. Well, one of the reporters who writes the State Department does more than handle foreign... ...publishes all of the laws that have been passed by Congress. Well, just then, the waitress brought us our coffee.

The moon by telling them that the State Department has the job of making sure the great seal of the United States doesn't get lost. And it acts sort of like a governmental emily. She was making out our checks. She added this bit of it. Did you ever hear of the division that makes sure foreign diplomats who visit America introduce the way they see it in the right places? Information we tip. And now with our star, John Lund, we bring you the second act of Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar. The kid surrendering a stolen man he introduced as Neville Thomas was still handsome, but branded with a bitter, down-at-the-mouth expression. You ask me if I knew Sarah Deering. I was her leading man in five pictures, Mr. Dollar. She was a vixen, temperamental, the most exasperating woman in the world. But she had a great gift, Neville. A gift for stealing scenes, yes. When was your last fair, Mr. Thomas? No, your corporate with Mr. Dollar. Stole me blind when I was on the top of the heap. Wanted to admire the house my money built.

Let's get back to Sarah Dearing. Why, if you insist. When did you see her last? Not since our last picture. Our star of the day she died. I'm afraid you're mistaken, Mr. Dollar. You are positively identified. By whom? By someone who's seen you in Palma every year on Sarah Dearing's birthday. Only to this extent, Mr. Dollar. I'll admit I did visit Sarah Dearing after she besieged me with letters and had been for many years. And you? I'm afraid I didn't share Mattie's adoration for her, Mr. Dollar. Pity is the nicest word to express my feeling to Sarah. I see. What do you know about the real cause of her death? She died in a fire. Has there been some further... I can prove I was here in Hollywood at the apartment of a friend, Mattie Freeman. Well, it didn't take a mental colossus to deduce that Thomas and his ex-agent had rehearsed their alibi before I ever sat in the steakhouse. A clincher, if I needed one, came as I pulled out of the parking. I spotted Mattie talking to someone in a parked sedan. The someone obliged by striking a match to his cigar.

which revealed that it was Sheriff Dan Cuck. Right then, I decided to call it a day. I registered at the plaza, took an aspirin, a hot shower, and a sleeping tablet, in that order. Well, lucky you, lucky you, wherever you are. Oh, for Maggie. Two o'clock in the morning. I'll drive down first thing tomorrow. Maggie? Oh, you look awful. I told you, you're a sleeping damsel. Come here. Let's sit down over here. Okay. Better, Maggie. Well... When I missed you at the library, I decided to do a little research on Sarah Deering. Well, good for you. Well, they have a wonderful Sarah Deering scrapbook with all her new photos and clippings. I, um, borrowed this. Hey. Hey, do these agonized eyes deceive me, or the people in this photo... Read the caption, Johnny. Relaxing with Miss Sarah Deering beside her Hollywood swimming pool are the four lucky people to whom the motion picture star will someday leave her multi-million dollar estate.

They are, left to right, Miss Hilda Brower, her personal maid, Mr. Matty Freeman, her agent, Neville Thomas, her current leading man, and Van Cox, her attorney. Think of it, Johnny. Sheriff Cox, the man who insists her death was accidental, is one of her heirs. Well, that would be surprising. Wait, aren't you going to do something? I'm going to point you toward the YWCA, then send a wire to my company. Wait, how about Sarah Dillings Insurance? Anybody claim the $100,000 yet? I checked out of the plaza, expense account item 3, $12, and was halfway to Palma before I realized I'd forgotten to pick up Maggie Lacey. But I quieted my conscience by making a mental promise that she'd get an exclusive story on Hilda Brower's confession. At this point, confronted with all the information I had, I figured Hilda would be the easiest of the four heirs to break. As long a guy can be, when I pulled into the drive of Sarah Deering's villa, see that I don't talk to Hilda again. Here is your caption on an old newspaper.

Relaxing with Miss Sarah Deering beside her Hollywood swimming pool are the four lucky people to whom the motion picture star will someday leave her month-a-million-dollar estate. They are, left to right, Hilda Brower, Mattie Freeman... Oh, you needn't go on, Mr. Dollar. I see what you're driving at. You think the four murdered Miss Deering... Most logical theory today, Sheriff. Especially since you happen to be the executor of the estate. Mr. Dollar, Sarah Deering was not murdered. That she did not die. Deering dead, an open bottle of sedatives beside the bed. Suicide.

She told me later that her only... Deering's name from the shame of... So she set the fire to destroy the... Is? And to circumvent the suicide clause in Sarah Deering's policy. What's that? Policy is not payable if the insured dies by her own hands, Sheriff. You're Mr. Dollar? I'm not interested one way or the other. My job is finished. I'm reporting death by suicide to my company. You haven't heard the full story. You just said she was. I said he was. Sir Matty Freeman and Neville Thomas paid Miss Deering... The man you're going to meet. Oh, and I knew you'd be tracking... down matty freeman thomas that you dig into this deering's pants which would be leading hoovering is over now this is dr james harding a lot of trouble dollar broke up the vacation i've had in 10 years i'm sorry but there's a matter of a hundred thousand please don't interrupt i've got to be back in beverly hills by noon your patient's waiting almost got stopped off the teacher doctor physicians and a very old friend sarah deering has been dying for years won't go into the medical details her courage couldn't hold off the inevitable any longer came down to my office i didn't want to wait so i filled out a death certificate Left it with a note on Dan's desk, and I drove on to my desert place. Meanwhile, Hilda, you know, Mr. Dollar, why did you report Sarah Deering died as a result of the fire? If I'd reported the real truth, Hilda did set the fire, and there's a crime. Mr. Dollar, do you think Hilda committed a crime? Well, legally, yes. But as I said, it's none of my affair, is it? Goodbye, Mr. Dollar. Spence account item number four. Five dollars to check out of the Palma hotel room I never had the chance to use.

Item five, $51.75, gas, oil, and rental on the convertible. Item number six, $150, plane fare and incidentals back to Hartford. Expense account total, $372.25. Yours truly, Johnny Dollar.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑