Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar artwork

From the Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar collection

The Hope to Die Matter

EpisodeNovember 24, 195720 min 16 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 15 min to read

Frugal band, and... Johnny Dollar. Johnny, this is Reed. Well, nice to hear from you, George. Especially when I have no assignment. That's fine. What's fine about it? No expense account to pay? That means how do I keep the wolf from the door? Unless, of course, Floyd's of England has the case for me. Huh? Well? Johnny. Yeah? Now, George, how could I ever kid you? Yeah, you better. Don't tell me. You mean, instead of insuring somebody against dying, you've insured him against living? Yes. Okay, Georgie. Say no more. I'll be right over. Bob Bailey. In the exciting adventures of the man with the action-packed expense account. America's fabulous freelance insurance investigator. Yours truly, Johnny Dollar. Yours truly, Johnny Dollar. Expense account submitted by Special Investigator Johnny Dollar. To Floyd's of England, American office, Hartford, Connecticut. Following is an account of expenses incurred during my investigation of the hope to die matter. Expense account item one, a dollar ten taxi from my apartment at George Reed's office.

Or I found him pacing the floor and wearing an even more worried expression than usual. And believe me, that's something. This thing has me so riled up, Johnny, I can hardly see straight. Well, you should have known better than to issue a policy like that, George. I? It was Harry Baxter. Baxter? He filled in here for me while I was on vacation. I should have known better. What'd he do, sell a lot of policies that you shouldn't have to handle? No, just this one. And I swear I don't understand it. He of all people. All right, you said on the phone that it was kind of life insurance in reverse. That's exactly what it is. Explain, please. Well, usually, of course, we pay the face value of a policy when the insured dies. Right. In this case, however, the company will have to pay the $250,000 that the insured doesn't die. $250,000? Yes. How under the sun can a man be crazy enough to issue a policy like that? John, you know how it is. The company prides itself on the fact we'll insure anything. Not only life and property and health and so on, but the...

Voice of a singer, the feet of a dancer, hands of a pianist, even the dimples on the knees of a chorus girl. Yeah, and singing mice, an old alley cat, a sick whale. Of course, I can't say that Harry wasn't in position to do it, but Johnny, you've got to help me. First, you'd better tell me who and why and what it's all about. It's just the trouble. I don't know. Well, in that case, you don't know. I only got back here to the office this morning. I found our copy of the policy lying here on my desk. But if you don't even... Oh, look, I've handled some pretty screwy cases for you, George. Yes, but they've all finally made sense one way or the other. And, Johnny, we have paid you some very nice fees. You can't deny that. George. Tell me, have I ever questioned your expense account? But death insurance, it doesn't make sense. Have I? Insuring somebody against living. Have I? I'm sorry, but this time the answer is no. Listen, if you take this on, I'll okay your expense account without even reading it. Death insurance. Expense account unlimited. Johnny?

George, there are some things even a conniving, chiseling, unprincipled rascal like myself won't even... Unlimited? Johnny? Okay, George, I'll take it. Act two of yours truly, Johnny Dollar, in a moment. And now act two of yours truly, Johnny Dollar, and the hope to die matter. Boys of England insure anything. At least that was their boast. And now it looked as though it had finally backfired on them. Because somebody in the organization, some character named Harry Baxter, had issued not life, but death insurance. If it hadn't been for my friendship for George Reed, well, plus his promise of unlimited expense account, I'd have thrown the whole problem right back into his face, as it was. Thanks, Johnny, from the bottom of my heart. I'll never forget you for this. Believe me, George, I'll never forget you for this. And if you can get it off the hook... All I can do is try, so come on, give me the dope on it. Yeah, now here.

The name of the insured is Miss Mary Ellen Markham. Yeah, I got it. Where does she live? 514 East 52nd Street, New York City. Pretty fancy address. Yes. Okay. Now tell me why this Mary Ellen has insured herself against living. Well, that's the point, Johnny. She hasn't. Well, now, wait a minute. You... Albert Schwinner has. You mean somebody else took out this policy on her life? Or rather, Deb? Yes. Holy... Well, what is this guy, a professional gunsel who's going to wipe her out and then collect? I suppose he's the beneficiary, too. Yes, he is. Oh, fine. Well, come on, who is... I don't know. As I told you, the policy was lying here on my desk when I got back this morning. I do know this much about him. It's Dr. Albert Schwinner. Doctor? What kind? Those are the things you've got to find out. Who he is, what he is, why he's bought insurance against this woman's living beyond November 10th. The 10th? Well, that's only a few days from now. Oh.

George, this gets worse and worse. If only Harry Baxter hadn't issued that policy. But he has. Oh, boy, you sure picked a dilly to fill in for you while you were away. Picked him? What else could I do? After all, he never did anything like this before. You've known him before? Are you serious? Of course I have. Why, Harry Baxter... All right, now look. Time's a-wasting and we haven't got much of it. I take it you want me to see if I can find some legal grounds for canceling this policy. Yes, immediately. Now, have you got an address on the beneficiary, this Dr. Schwinner? I've been so upset about this whole thing, I haven't even looked. Let me see. According to this, he lives at... Hmm. What's the matter? Dr. Albert W. Schwinner, C.L. C.L.? What kind of a doctor is that? I don't know. The address is 14327 E Street, Union City, New Jersey. C.L.? Well, I'll soon find out.

Where can I reach this Harry Baxter who sold the policy? In New York at the... Here, I'll jot down the address. I still don't see how Baxter could get away with this. After all, when you consider his position... Here. He offered no explanation at all. I'm afraid I didn't give him much chance. I practically threw him out of here. I can't say that I blame you. And that's another thing. Look, Johnny, perhaps you can reason with... Oh, don't worry, George. He's number one on my calling list. I'll be talking to you.

Expense account item two, 785, fare to New York and taxi to Harry Baxter's address. A real snooty one over near Sutton Place. And people don't live in that joint unless they've earned or chiseled a lot of money from somewhere. In the case of Baxter, I suspected a big chisel. My suspicion was considerably heightened when he opened the door. His apartment was luxury from stem to stern. As for Baxter himself... Dollar? Well, of course, old boy. I've heard a great deal about you from my dear friend and colleague, George Reed. Dear friend, huh? Well, you say that as though you doubted it. Oh, I know, that filling in for him while he was away. Well, I really should have done better for the old thing, but I've had so many social obligations to meet these past few months, and after all, one must keep up with those things. Oh, I'm sure one must. Well, I did so one policy, you know, a real dilly.

Ah, that's the understatement of the week. I suppose I can't really blame him for being a bit excited about it, but he gave me no chance to explain why I assumed the policy. Why did you? Oh, now, really. Well? Well, I made it very clear to George that I would tell him when he calms down enough to be reasonable. Really, Mr. Dollar, he was in quite a tizzy. Brother, he still is. That's why he sent for me. Well, when he calms down, he'll be sorry he bothered you. Suppose you tell me why you issued that policy. You? No. What? No, I'll tell George when he's ready and when I'm ready. Oh, now, just a minute. And you may tell George I said exactly that. Good-bye, Dollar. You'll tell me, Baxter, right now. I'll do nothing of the sort. And what's more, since my plane for Europe is leaving shortly, I have no time to... Would you kindly remove your foot from the door? Not until I get an answer from you. Now, start talking. If you can show some legal cause... Legal cause? Furthermore...

Your behavior at the moment constitutes trespass, illegal entry. Call it what you like. And believe me, unless you leave here immediately, I shan't hesitate to ring up the police. All right, all right. Now, look, just tell me one thing. I might. What? What is your connection with the beneficiary of this policy? Dr. Schwinner. That's right, Albert Schwinner. Albert happens to be a very close personal friend. Oh, I might have guessed as much. All right, then tell me this. I'm sorry, just one question. I've given the answer. Goodbye. Are you hard of hearing? Look here now. Goodbye. Well, there was no point in trying to batter down the door of Harry Baxter's apartment, so I left. Downstairs in the lobby, I put in a phone call. That's item 355 cents to George Reed's office in Hartford. I'm sorry, Mr. Dollar, but he seems to have stepped out for a few minutes. Oh, well, then please tell him when he gets back that I want a complete rundown on Harry Baxter.

Right. Having hired him, George shouldn't have much trouble getting that for me. Now, as a matter of fact, I think I can tell you just about... Now, let George do it. I'll call him back. Item 4, 65 cents taxi to Mary Ellen Markham's apartment on East 52nd Street. A uniformed nurse met me at the door, told me I could stay with Miss Markham only a very short time, then led me into the bedroom. And there, carefully propped up in bed, lay a pale, wan, tired woman who looked to be 65 or 70. The room was full of flowers. You may... Leave us, Mr. Pascoe. I'll ring when I need you. Yes, Miss Michaels. Sit down, Mr. Dollar. I'm sorry I won't be able to speak with you very long. But as you can see... Yes, yes, I can, of course. I'll get right to the point. You must know, I'm sure, that someone has just taken out a policy on your... Well, an insurance policy on you. Yes. And you're so smart. And so...

And so helpful with Harry Baxter. Oh. You see, I am suffering from a rare, incurable disease of the blood. I don't have long to live. A few days, perhaps. A few weeks at the most. This is such an effort. Well, you're getting the best of care, I trust. It's the very best. Now, what do you wish to know? You know a Dr. Albert Schwinner, don't you? I... I've known Albert for many years. We've been great friends. Then why does he take out a policy that... Well, it indicates he hopes that you'll die. Hopes I'll die? Yes. What else could it be? Oh, you don't understand. Don't you see? Schwinner has bought insurance against your living beyond November 10th. Yes. Yes. My 50th birthday. You mean to say you're... The reason... The reason so. Yes? Oh, I'm tired of you. Yes. But just...

One more thing. Your doctor, the doctor who's taking care of you. Albert. This same Dr. Schwinner? Yes. Now, now you must leave. Johnny Dollar in a moment. Truly Johnny Dollar and the hope to die matter. Little that Mary Ellen Markham had been able to tell me left me more puzzled than ever. I've never been given such a runaround in my life, deliberate or otherwise. But I didn't dare tax her strength further, so I left. Item 5, another 55 cents for another call to George Reed in Hartford. This time he was in. What do you mean seemingly absurd? George's whole thing has me in a tizzy now, a double-barreled one. Well, I... Apologize. What for? What? He just left for Europe. Where? I don't know, and right now I don't care. 250 Gs. You've got... Would you like to tell me how? Mary Ellen Markham dies on or before November 10th. Floyd's of England pays Dr. Albert Schwinner $250,000.

On a policy taken out by him. And he is her doctor with her life in his hands. And if there isn't something wrong with that setup. Expense account item six, eight dollars for a taxi to Schwinner's address in Union City, New Jersey. And there at last I learned what the CL meant behind his name. It was an abbreviation. For this was the Albert Schwinner Clinic. Devoted to the study of rare diseases of the blood. But Schwinner wasn't there. He'd gone to New York to see Miss Markham. Item seven, ten dollars even for a fast taxi ride back there to Manhattan. As the nurse led me into the unfortunate woman's apartment, he was just coming out of the bedroom door. Oh, Dr. Schwinner, this is Mr. Johnny Dollar. Oh, Mr. Dollar, Harry Baxter told me I might expect you. Oh, he did, huh? Yes, he phoned me just before his plane took off for you. You're pretty smart. You're an insurance investigator, aren't you? That is right. Oh, you may go in to see Miss Markham now, Mrs. Haskell. Very well, doctor. How is Miss Markham, doctor? Much better, thank God. Why do you say that?

If she dies before this week is out, you stand to collect a cool quarter of a million, don't you? I? No, the clinic. Isn't that the same thing? Hardly. Sit down, Mr. Dollar. Now, you're concerned about the rather unorthodox insurance policy that Mr. Baxter issued. I certainly am. I think you'd better let me tell you the reason for it. I think you'd better. At the onset of her illness some 15 years ago, the best doctors in the country gave her five years to live at the most. And that's when you came into the picture? Yes. Because of the devotion, the concentration of all our efforts to this one field of medicine, the clinic was able for the first time to give her hope. Hope was justified. We have given her years of life. But now, wait a minute, Doctor. She told us then that if she could be helped to live until she was 50... And that'll be on the 10th. Yes.

That would prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that our methods, our practices were right. That we could prolong and possibly ultimately save not only her own, but thousands, perhaps millions of lives. Therefore, she agreed that if she reached 50, she would make an outright gift of $250,000 to the clinic and its work. Money which is much needed, by the way. But then it began to look as though she might never reach 50. Yes. And she suggested this unusual insurance policy. On her death, rather than on her life. Why Harry Baxter, chairman of the board of the insurance company, its biggest stockholder, whatever. I don't get it. His mother died of the same disease, Mr. Do. How necessary this money is to the clinic. Yes. And let's face it, Baxter is something of an eccentric. And that's the reason he chose this.

This offbeat way to make sure you get the financial help you need. Exactly. Then, if I try to get this policy canceled, a great many lives in the future may depend on its remaining in force. Of course, if you feel it your duty. Doctor, my duty as I see it is to do just exactly nothing. Mary Ellen Markham did live to see 50, but only for a few days. Just long enough to make her gift to the clinic. Harry Baxter and the company? Well, Harry came back from Europe and he said he found some, quote, mistake, unquote, in the policy that requires the company to pay off on it anyway. Eccentric? We should have more of them like that. Expense account total? Are you kidding? Yours truly, Johnny Dollar.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑