Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar artwork

From the Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar collection

The All Too Easy Matter

EpisodeJune 17, 196223 min 18 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 18 min to read

Johnny Dollar. Hi, Johnny. How are you? Who's that, Ted? That's right. Well, how are you, Ted? What goes with you these days? Problems. Haven't we all? There's a fire, Johnny, that has been costing Western Indemnity a heap of dough. Suspect arson? Suspect? I'm sure of it. But, Johnny, somebody's got to... You make it? Sure, Ted. Why not? The CBS Radio Network brings you Mandel Kramer in the exciting adventures of the man with the action-packed expense account. America's fabulous freelance insurance investigator, yours truly. Johnny Dollar. Expense account submitted by Special Investigator Johnny Dollar to Western Indemnity Company, Los Angeles office. Following is an account of expenses incurred during my investigation of the all-too-easy matter. Shortly after Dom cracked the next morning, I drove to the airport and spent item one, $204.20 plane fare for a 930 jet out of New York. It dropped into Los Angeles International just ten minutes before noon Pacific time. Item two, six and a half bucks into the office of Western Indemnity.

As I sounded through the front door of the building, a man rushing out bumped into me. Oh, sorry, mister, but I'm in a... Johnny! Ted! Ted, what's the hurry? Listen, I'm glad you're here. Come on. My car's right around the corner. Come on. Anything you say, but what's the big emergency? Another one, Johnny. Another one of these fires I called you about. That'll be number six, Johnny. Six in a row. Here, get in. Come on, see for yourself why I'm going off my nuts. I'll say this, Clem. That old building is going up about as fast as anything I've ever seen. You ask me, that's going to be a total loss. Sure, like the others. Thank God no people have been living in it, not for years. But that doesn't lower the insurance we're going to have to pay. If only I didn't know there were going to be more of them. What do you mean you know? I mean that firebug will start exactly 15 more of them before he's through if somebody doesn't stop him. You seem to know an awful lot about him. You bet I do, plenty.

Except for his next method and where he's going to strike next. Oh, wait a minute. Then where's the arson squad and all this? Yeah, where? Don't you know your fire department out here is one of the best in the country? And if it is, aren't you? Sure it is. They agree it is. But in spite of all I tell them, they refuse to grab the guy who's doing it. I mean, you know who this torch man is? I sure do, John. Well, who is this? Look. That wall is up. There it goes.

Boy, that was too close for comfort, Ted. Come on, let's get out of here. Nothing for up here until it cools off. Good, let's go someplace where I can get a drink. Boy, I can use it. Look, Ted, tell me, who benefits? Okay, listen. This client of ours, name is Alpheus Brockway Brock. Yep, widower, 82 years of age. Lives on Peckway Drive in Beverly Hills. Doctor says he has only a couple of years to go at the most. Heart condition. Uh-huh. But he doesn't look it, Johnny. If I look as good as that when I'm 60, I'll be mighty thankful. Well, what about him, Tim? Johnny, old man Brock was one of those guys who never had to do a lick of work in his life. A playboy in space. But by the time his beautiful young wife died, he had to quit all that because of his age and his heart. Well, the old boy had just about had and done everything. And at first, he'd gone through a stack of dough. I should think so. But he was apparently content to settle back and take it easy.

to live this simple life and just to live out the end of his days. He had no responsibilities. His only child, really a stepdaughter, had gotten married, followed by the name of Ben Clayton in the import-export business. And, oh, she, incidentally, is beneficiary of his small life policy and whatever else he manages to leave, if any. You mean he's broke now? Well, he isn't rolling in dough the way he used to, but he isn't broke because he's old. A man who never worked for a living. He had been smart enough way back to buy up all the property he could let his hand on here in L.A. Ah, I see. But now all he has left is a little bit here and a little bit there. And what turned out to be pretty poor sections of town. An old broken down frame house on South Port Odero Street. The remains of a creepy law building on some land that won't be redeveloped for another 10 years and so on. So what happened? Go ahead, you tell me. Taxes.

Higher and higher every year on this land of his. Yeah. So he has to get up the dough for them every year. Oh, naturally. He still has insurance on the worthless old buildings on that land. So you figure that old Alpheus Broxton is eating his cake and having it too. Right. Now you're with me. He burned down a worthless old building that would have cost him money to wreck. He collects a big hunk of insurance from me. And he still has the valuable part, the land. Oh, boy, what a racket. Well, maybe so. Sure. Well, let's go back to the office and I'll... What's the matter? I don't know, Ted. But it has to be that way. It's the only thing that makes any sense. Broxton is burning down those buildings. And he's not only costing the company a fortune, but making a bunch of suckers of us. I wonder... Wonder? Isn't it obvious? Maybe it's too obvious.

Makes the answers seem all too easy. Oh, now, Johnny. Yes, sir. Just a little too easy. But we'll see. When you have to stay alert, don't let drowsiness slow you down. Perk up. Perk up with no dose. The safe way to stay alert without harmful stimulants. Remember, when you're driving, working, studying, and monotony makes you feel drowsy. Perk up. Back up with no-dose. No-dose. Okay, Johnny, here it is. The old man's address and the list of all his properties that haven't gone up in flames. Not yet. Not until he gets to them. Now, look, Ted, if you're so sure that Houston is setting those fires... Have you forgotten that favorite thing of yours? I don't know. Have I? Queen Bono. Who benefits? Well, Alpheus Brockway Broxton is the only one who has benefit and the only one who will benefit.

when the rest of his property's burned. I guess you have a point there, Ted, but if the fire department arson squad can't pin it on him, they simply refuse to look at the obvious. And you listen, Johnny. That's all I am doing. Oh, you think it's too obvious, huh? Well, haven't I heard you say, and more than once, that the obvious makes the best cover-up of all? Perhaps, on occasion. Well, it's true now. The police, the fire department say, oh, no, a crook would never be so dumb as to leave a clue or evidence or a motive right out in the open. So it has to be somebody else, they say. It simply can't be poor, dear, sweet old Mr. Broxton. It has to be somebody without a motive. Somebody all the suspicion doesn't point to. You sure that's their reasoning? Well, I say they're wrong. And what about Broxton's age? 82, did you say? Okay, so perhaps he has somebody else do it for him. Is there any difference?

Aren't there bound to be plenty of pros in a town like this? Ted, whether you realize it or not, the Arson boys know the pros. All of them. And they usually keep pretty close tabs on them. Usually, huh? Well, they haven't done it this time. So, Johnny, you've got to work on it. Okay? Okay. Okay, Ted. Oh, excuse me. Sure. All of them. Oh, hello, Commissioner. Huh? Oh, no. You wait. Okay, then you listen. I... I know, I know. But now listen. Do you know what I've done? I brought somebody out here who's going to prove that I'm right. Yeah. Johnny Dollar. Huh? Well, yeah, I guess so. Johnny. Yes, sir? Another fire, Johnny. Another one of Brockton's buildings. That's two in one day, and now... We want to talk to you. Who, Brockton? No, Fred Klein. Fred Klein? Yeah, he's a fire commissioner. Oh, no. Here, let me have the phone. Here. Fred, how are you? You're just the man I want to see. What? Tell me where and when.

Are you, Johnny? Good. Where? I'm on my way. Want to see him, Johnny? Yes, sir. Then get him working on this thing from the right angle. And I know that you can do it, Johnny, that you can prove to him that I'm right about his old outfit. Yeah? We'll see. Item three, 50 bucks deposit on a rental car, and 20 minutes later, after the usual amenities, Fire Commissioner Fred Klein sets me straight on a few things. No, Johnny. All our feelings on the matter don't bother me at all. A lot of people don't think too much of us until they see the results of our work. I know. Luckily, knock on wood, we usually do manage to get some results. Luckily, hmm? What? Fred, in my book, it takes a lot of hard work to get lucky. And in a department like yours, I'd say a lot of ability, too. But, uh, now, what about this stubborn notion of Ted Orloff? In the beginning, we were inclined to think the same way he does. Until we really were into things. And now?

I don't see a sproxton, a little 82-year-old man with a heart condition who wouldn't stand any kind of excitement. Will you talk to him, Johnny? And I think you should, by the way. Yes, I want to. Now, see if you come up with the same idea that we have. That he's hiring a pro? His six fives, seven as of now, have not been set by a profession. You're sure of that? I'd stake the reputation of this old apartment on it. Why? A pro has a pattern, Johnny, almost invariably. Easily identifiable motors are handy. I may not realize it, but it's their... their trademarks that enable us to nail so many of them. Yes, I know. What's more, we have files on those boys that are so complete that... well, we're like an expert dry fly fisherman. It's always set to strike just before the trout hits the fly. Exactly. And I take it these fires don't fit the pattern of any known arsonist. They don't fit any pattern. But we believe they're all the work of an amateur. Oh? Yeah.

He tries one method here, another there, and so on. The same amateur? Only because of the frequency and regularity old man Broxton's properties have made. Seven of us in six weeks. That would seem to indicate at least that he's in back of them, wouldn't it? Would it? Go see him, Johnny. I will. And who knows? Maybe you'll come up with the same idea we're working on. Which is what? Talk to him. Then we'll compare notes. And remember one thing. Yeah? In spite of its inadequate size... The Austin squad is my pride and joy. Eleven of the best men in the country. But only eleven of them. And they're called all over the city every day. We do have other fires, you know. Which means that not one of them can afford to spend the time on a single assignment that you can. I'll go see Barton. Right. I drove out to South Peckway Drive and talked with Mr. Barton. Fred Lyon was right. That old man would have been utterly incapable of setting those fires. The excitement alone.

would have killed him in a minute. What's more, although he was no longer wealthy, he was perfectly content to live out the rest of his days taking care of his modest little house. Motives? Absolutely none. He didn't care about accumulating money to lead to his stepdaughter Lois and her husband. They were grown up and able to take care of themselves. He didn't see much of them. They'd never been to him for help of any kind. And they'd assured him they were getting along just fine. So on the strength of that one brief conversation with him, By the time I thanked him and left, I was completely convinced it was innocent. But then, a few blocks away, it suddenly hit me. A couple of things. Ted Orlov's reminder of my own words. Cui bono. Who benefits. And the old man's insurance policy in the state. The same idea Fred Klein said that he had? Maybe. Maybe not. But it was certainly worth following up. I like that idea. Newport filter cigarette.

Newport menthol cigarette. I like that idea. Good, rich tobacco flavor. The right amount of menthol is just a hint of cool, refreshing mint. That's the thing about Newport. That's the combination that makes Newport more refreshing to begin with. More refreshing all the way. Just enough menthol to make Newport so refreshing while you're smoking. Without hiding the rich taste of... Great tobaccos. Express account item four at dime for a phone call to Mr. Broxton. I want a call on them. Just give me the address, please, Mr. Broxton. Thank you. Thank you very much. Item five, 1040 for a fancy imitation leather portfolio, plus a dollar for some gold lettering on it that says Federal Housing and Occupation Survey.

Then I drove to the San Fernando Valley, to Sherman Oaks, to another modest little home. A rather poor sort of home, more like it, because of the neglect it showed both inside and out. And the woman who met me at the door? Well, she was young, good-looking, cheerful, well-spoken, but there was something about her that belied not only what I had heard, but what she told me. More important, what she told me about her husband. Oh, you'll have to pardon my looking this way, but I just got home from work. Oh, that's perfectly all right. Federal Housing and Occupation Survey, isn't it? Right. Another big government investigation? Well, it's just a kind of general survey. Oh, I see. Why'd you have him pick on us? Us? Yes. Oh, you're married then? Oh, yes. My husband's name is Ben Plater. And I'm Lois Plater, Mr. Dollar, did you say? That's right.

Won't you sit down, Mr. Dollar? Oh, I'm sorry. I guess this pacing of mine is just kind of a nervous habit. I hope you don't mind. Oh, not at all. Now, what can I tell you? You say you go to work? Oh, just to fill in time, you know. I'm a tie-picked over there again. Oh, I see. And your husband, does he work? Oh, yes. He's in the import-export business. Oh. And his office address? Well, that's his little office right behind that door. Oh, I see. But he isn't here now, miss? No, no, he left for Mexico, where he had a lot of business contacts. And when did he leave, Mrs. Lane? Yesterday. Yesterday morning. I see. Now, what are you doing? Oh, there's a big sort of cement machine that's used in building work, and it's made by Centroica Corporation over in East Los Angeles. And then there's a sort of a crane that goes on a truck that imports from Finland. I see. And an air conditioner that's made over in Long Beach, and some Japanese transistor walkie-talkies.

Oh, of course it is. Oh, that's some of the literature on that desk beside you. Yes, I see. Well, would you say he's pretty successful at it? Oh, yes, very. Good. All right, now suppose I look around the house. All right. And we'll start with his office. Oh, dear, I'm sorry. Sorry? Well, he always keeps it locked. And he gets the only key with him. Oh, well, that's all right. We'll skip it for now. That. The house was a successful living room? Oddly. And among the papers on the desk, I'd glimpsed a reposition notice for their TV set. So, as soon as I'd made a cursory inspection of the rest of the house, I left and drove to the nearest gas station and ran up item six, $1.30 on two phone calls. The first was to the head of the Santorgo Corporation that she'd mentioned over in East L.A. Oh, why not, sir? No, thanks. I don't think it'll be necessary. The information from the air conditioner out in the long deep was virtually the same.

Then I dropped in at the state employment office near where they lived. And there I learned Clayton had had something like a dozen jobs in the last five years. Had held each one of them just long enough to get fired, then collect unemployment insurance. And some disability insurance as well. All right. Tie that in with the fact that old man Broxton didn't have long to live. Sure. It all tied in. I put in the call to Fred Klein, then drove back to the house. And there... Oh, Mr. Dollar. I'm afraid I didn't really finish my job here. May I come in again? Oh, of course. I was just fixing myself some beer. There are plenty for two if you'd like to stay. Oh, well, thank you. But all I want is to look at your husband's office. Oh, I told you, Mr. Dollar. It's all locked up. Well, then I'm going to have to break my way in, won't I? What? Break? Well, without a warrant or something? Well, I mean, why? Just stand aside, Mrs. Plater. Mr. Dollar. Please stand aside. No. No.

What I found in that room after turning on the light? Long strips of paraffin tape. Handlers, cans of solvent, gasoline. Even a couple of crude timing devices made to set off a blaze. I'd been right. Ben Plater was behind the fires. And the reason? They had every possible dollar to the old man's bank account before he died and left it to Lois. And there was all the evidence I could need. The case was closed. Almost. Okay, darling, don't move. Ben Plater, hmm? I said don't move. Ben! The gun! Yes, he has one, Lois. Yes. Yes, here it is. Just hang on to it. You made a bad mistake giving Lois your right name, Dollar. I guess my big mistake was believing you might really be in Mexico. But, um, don't you think you're making one now? You think I didn't know all about you? Didn't figure something was up when you came here before? Too bad you got up so soon, Dollar, before I had a chance to clear out this room. And it doesn't give me much of a choice, does it?

Nice fellow you married to, Lois. Now he's going to be a killer. Ben. This is it, darling. No, no, Ben. No, no, you can't. Who said I can't? The fire's all right. Because of the money they get it, but not this. It's him or me, isn't it? No, no, no. No, I won't let you. Put that thing down and get away. No, no. Get away. You won't stop me. I'll stop you. under control. Yes, Fred, I think so. I suspected you might lead us to something. That looks like you have, doesn't it? I think so, Commissioner. Ben and Lois Plater. I think they're through playing with fire. Not a very pretty one, I know. And I hope the shock of it all isn't too much for old Mr. Broxton. Expense account total, including the trip home? $491.34. Yours truly, Johnny Dollar. Now, here's our star to tell you about next week's story. Next week.

Two good men, two beautiful girls, and one not-so-beautiful motive for murder. Join us, won't you? Yours truly, Johnny Dollar. Can you get premium gasoline performance at regular gasoline price? Find out what so many other car owners have found. In three out of five cars, regular-priced Sinclair dyno gasoline matches performance of premium gasoline, saves you up to four cents a gallon. Almost anywhere you see the Sinclair sign, you can save up to four cents a gallon with Dyno and still get premium performance and mileage. Drive with care and buy Sinclair Dyno gasoline. Yours truly, Johnny Dollar is written by Jack Johnstone. Produced and directed by Fred Hendrickson. Music supervision by Ethel Huber. Johnny Dollar is played by Mandel Kramer. Be sure to join us next week, same time, same station.

for another exciting story of yours truly, Johnny Dollar. This is Art Hanna speaking.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑