The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 24 min to read
21st Precinct, Sergeant Burns. 61? What apartment number? Would that be your seat? You're in the muster room at the 21st Precinct, the nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct.
Yes, sir. All right. I'll send an officer right over there. Yes, sir. They'll be there in a few minutes. You just wait. Just wait there. 21st Precinct.
It's just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the nine-tenths of a square mile between Fifth Avenue and the East River wouldn't know if you asked them that they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, the security of their persons, their homes, and their property is my job. My job and the job of the 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm captain in command of the 21st.
It was 9:30 p.m. I returned to the precinct house from patrol and walked into the muster room, where Lieutenant Snyder was on duty as desk officer and Sergeant Burns was on the boxes.
Hello, Captain.
Sergeant.
How are you doing?
Nothing much. Lieutenant King's been wanting to talk to you.
Is he upstairs?
Yes, sir. I think so.
All right. Ring up there and tell him I'm back while I sign the blotter.
Yes, sir. Sergeant Burns on P.S. Would you tell Lieutenant King that Captain Kennelly's back in the house?
Yes, sir. He's on his way downstairs. T.T. order came through just after you left, Captain. It's on the 4 to 12th trace. Have McCarthy posted on the bulletin board.
I already told him, Captain.
Go ahead. Precinct, Sergeant Burns. I told you before, there's nothing we can do about that. We chase robbers. We're not plumbers.
Yes, I know, Lady Captain. What's doing?
Lady, ma'am, I thought you were in your office, Captain.
Sure. I've been in my office, Sergeant.
Yes, sir. I can't send a policeman over there for that, ladies. What have you got, Matt?
Go ahead. It's like we've got a cop. What's it all about?
Well, the commander of the 6th squad got up here about an hour ago. Two uniformed men jumped a burglar's house. He admitted he was in and up with things in it. Came out of the apartment. Far down there, started about 25th burglary.
What's that got to do with us?
A boy, his name is Riston. He said he came down the service entrance and walked out and put the money in his own pocket. Gave him back all the merchandise. Hit him on the can with his knife. Taken a train. Hasn't been back on the east side since.
What does it sound like to you?
Oh, uh, got a cigarette, Matt?
Yes, Philip Naland, 61 East 68th. Reported the apartment had been broken into. Three chairs, a diamond ring, risked $575 in cash for taking it.
That sounds like the same deal this morning we're talking about.
Yes, sir, it does.
You reported this on the 5th?
Yes, sir.
Well, when did the burglary happen?
The night of the 4th.
It could have been either the 2nd, 3rd, or 4th, Captain. It was a weekend. Mr. and Mrs. Naland left the city Friday afternoon to spend a week in the country. They discovered the burglary when they got back Monday morning.
What time of night did all this occur? Did you find that out?
No, sir, not yet. Lieutenant McInerney told me there was still a claim in the boy down there at the 6th to let me know what they were developing.
Yes. Sergeant, 761 East 68th Street is on what post?
All right, Sergeant, get out the telephone record and the post list for the 4 to 12 and the 12 to 8 tours for October 2nd, 3rd, 4th, and 5th.
Yes, sir. Bring them in here and bring the blotter.
Something's the matter. Get those records out and bring them in here.
Yes, sir.
For this and other purposes, the records of the precinct contain a detailed account of the movements of every member of the command. The blotter, for instance, shows for each tour in the handwriting of the desk officer the assignments of patrolmen to posts and motor patrol duty, the time each post is vacated for meal period, all post changes and movements during a tour of duty, and a notation of the nature, time, and location of duty performed by each member of the command.
Yes, sir.
From these records, Lieutenant King and I narrowed the possibilities down to four patrolmen who would work post number 9 on either the night or late tours October 2nd, 3rd, 4th, and 5th. In order to narrow the list still farther, we drove to the 6th Precinct at 135 Charles Street in Greenwich Village to interview the burglary suspect. There, I stopped at the desk to sign the blotter as a visiting captain. Then, with Lieutenant King, I went upstairs to the 6th Detective Squad.
I help you.
We're in the job. This is Captain Kennelly of the 21st Precinct. I'm Lieutenant King.
Oh, yes, sir. Well, we'll come to McInerney soon as well. Thanks.
Oh, come in, Matt. You want to close the door, Matt?
Yeah, sure.
Lieutenant McInerney, Squad Commander, Captain Kennelly.
All right, Captain. Well, I don't know.
Yes, sir. I get how you feel. You want to sit down?
No, thanks, boy. Well, he's a good boy, all right. He's done one bit and sing, sing for burglary. I think he's been in a 25 or 30 flat all over town. Maybe more. About the story he tells. Unfortunately, it sounds pretty straight, Captain. He checks with a squeal we've got. A cop had his hands in a good burglar. Nine chances out of 10, he was gotten a commendation and a promotion to detective. Pay raise for one year alone would have amounted to as much as he took off that boy. Cop is an idiot.
A little more than an idiot. An idiot with everything else, Captain.
Have you got him spotted?
We've got it narrowed down to four. The complainants were away Friday, Saturday, and Sunday nights. Could have happened on any of those nights on either the 4 to 12 or the 12 to 8 tour.
Six a time, any closer, Jed?
No, no. I thought I'd wait until you got down here at your squeal. Don't you want to talk to him about it?
No. Where is the boy?
In the detention room. I'll have him brought in.
Bring that Leroy in here.
You've got it down to four, huh?
Yeah, that's right. We've got one man who was working the 4 to 12 on Saturday and Sunday nights. He was swinging Friday night. Another man was working the 12 to 8 was swinging Saturday night. Those two men and the two who relieved him.
Well, if it could fix it either on the 4 to 12 or the 12 to 8, that would knock two of them out of the box, Matt.
Yeah. If we could get the right night from the boy, it would be gone to the man.
This Leroy was pretty vague about dates and times.
Yeah. He's been in so many flats, he doesn't know one from the other.
Yeah, who is it? Come in.
He woke me up.
No, Leroy, your time's not your own. Sit down there.
Yes.
Okay, Leroy, thanks. This is Captain Kennelly, Lieutenant King. They're from uptown, the 21st. They want to know something about that officer taking the money off him.
Oh, yeah. You told Lieutenant McInerney it was five or six hundred dollars.
That's right, yeah, five or six hundred.
You burglarized an apartment there. You took some suits, a gun, some jewelry, and the cash. When do you have time to stop and count the money?
Well, you know how human nature is. I found the cash in the drawer there. The first thing I was tempted to do was look at it. I saw a couple of hundreds, a couple of fifties, the tens, the twenties. I figured five to six hundred. I shoved it in my pocket.
What'd you do with the gun you got out of there?
Oh, I don't care for guns. I figured you have a gun on your hip, you're gonna shoot it. I never did go in for that kind of heavy stuff. I gave it to a very good friend of mine.
What's his name?
His name is Jack, Jack Truro, but he don't have it. He sold it, he told me. A lot of nerds. I give him the gun and he sold it to a stranger.
Where is it, Jack Truro? Can we locate him?
It's the easiest thing in the world, but he don't have the gun.
Oh, where is he, Leroy?
He's in the tomb. He got picked up last week on a deal.
Where'd he get picked up?
In Times Square. I told him a dozen times if he's gonna go in a public place like Times Square, he shouldn't wear a sports jacket that's three sizes too large for him. You know, a real fine sports jacket. Cashmere, what do you call it? Well, anyway, he got it out of some flat and he fell in love with the cloth. The cloth was fine, but in a million years it couldn't have been his jacket. Some detective stopped him on Broadway and said, hey, Broadway, did you get the cloth? That was that.
Well, that's what comes to being too much a clothes horse, you know?
Yeah, to get back to the night you got the gun and the money up on the 21st.
Oh, I don't know what's the 21st. I couldn't swear. It was.
You remember what night it was?
What night? What do you mean? I don't know. It had to be either Friday, Saturday, or Sunday.
No, I couldn't remember what night it was. I'd been awake almost every night. No, my memory doesn't serve me on that.
It was during the World Series, wasn't it?
Oh, yeah. You know, you're right. When you come to think of it, it was during the World Series. I remember I was in the flat. I was going around looking through drawers and in the closets and I found some rain checks for the game the day before. Box seats. I figured, boy, what a lucky guy I was in box seats. I wished it was me.
Who were you for? In the series?
Yeah, in the series. The Brooks. I had a $20 bet with Jack. Jack has died in the world for the axe.
Oh, yeah. I was feeling good because the Brooks win it after dropping the first two. It was the same day, I remember. Earth can stand 14, a new series record. You remember?
And it was Friday night you were in that flat on East 68th.
I don't know if it was Friday night. I don't know if it was East 68th. All I know was the day Earth can stand 14. That was Friday, October 2nd.
If you say so, okay.
What time of night was it, Leroy?
Time of the night? Yeah.
Well, that also would be kind of hard to say.
Well, let's start at midnight, huh? Would you say it was before or after midnight?
Does it make a difference?
Yeah. What'd you do before you went over and broke into that flat?
Let's see. I don't know. But I can tell you what I did after. I met Jack and he and I, we went to my place to drop the suits and it's gone like that.
Jack sure figures in your life a lot, doesn't he?
Well, he's my best friend.
And then from my place we went over to meet a girlfriend of his after she got off work.
Oh, yeah. Yeah, it must have been 10:30, 11 I hit the flat because this girlfriend of Jack's, she works in a cafeteria down here in the village over on 7th Avenue. She gets off at midnight.
You're not sure about that?
I'm sorry.
Well, that's pretty well set the time for you, Captain. Friday, October 2nd during the 4 to 12 tour.
Yeah. Leroy, you think you'd be able to identify the officer who took the money off you?
Well, to tell you the truth, I don't know about that.
What did he look like?
A cop with a blue suit.
Was he young? Was he tall? Why, look, Jack, I wasn't interested in what he looked like. Young, tall, short, I don't know. All I could see was the cop. I was nailed. When he took the money, slapped me with his stick and said, go, I win. I didn't turn around to see what color eyes he had.
Well, we're going to give you a chance to identify him. I told you about this, didn't I? If I didn't want to help you, I could have clammed. Cop catches me, takes me in, I got no beef against him. But if he turns out to be a bigger thief than me, I got no regrets, no regrets at all. Except maybe my good friend, Jack, is laying in the tomb.
Yeah, well, don't worry about that, Leroy. You'll be down there to keep him company.
Lieutenant King, Lieutenant McInerney of the 6th Squad, and I continue to interrogate the burglary suspect, Leroy Rustin. The officer he referred to was most likely Patrolman Philip Austin, who the record showed was assigned to post number 9 during the 4-12 tour on Friday, October 2nd. It was decided to continue the investigation at the 21st, and arrangements were made to transport the prisoner in the custody of Patrolman Nestico of the 6th Precinct, one of the arresting officers. Before we left, I phoned through CB to Lieutenant Snyder, the desk officer at the 21st, and gave him instructions to detain Patrolman Austin and all other members of his squad, which again was working the 4-12 tour for my arrival.
At 12:10, after having been relieved from his post, Patrolman Austin returned to the station house and walked through the front door into the muster room.
Austin?
Yes, Sergeant. Come here. 21st Precinct, Sergeant Burns. Lieutenant who? Lieutenant Gorman isn't due in here until 8 a.m.
That's all right. Captain wants to hold your platoon.
Yeah? He's on his way uptown. Wait for him in the back room.
Why?
Just wait.
Oh, listen, Sergeant. My wife's brother has a birthday party tonight. I told him I'd get over there as soon after 12 as I could.
He'll have another birthday next year.
What do you say, Sergeant? What's it all about?
Pardon me, Sergeant.
Yeah, wait in the back room with the captain. He'll be back in a minute.
Oh, what's the trouble?
There's no trouble. Just wait.
Okay, Sergeant.
And don't change from your uniforms or leave them on.
Listen, Sergeant, he's liable to be another hour.
Will you stop giving me an argument? Now, go ahead.
Sure, Sergeant. Come on, sir.
Yeah. Why do I have to get all the dirty details? Beats the living daylight out of me.
Oh, it's not that bad.
Hi, fellas.
Hi. Anybody know what this is all about?
Ah, beat me. Deal.
Come on, Austin. Sit down. No sense getting worked up about it.
I don't know if the captain wants to see us.
Where is he?
Look, we're all in the same boat.
Yeah, but you got no place to go except home and the bed. But he can think of some extra detail he'd think of us.
Don't get mad until you find out what it is.
Hi, Austin. What's going on?
You know, it's what we do. Grab a seat.
I've got the midnight snack on the table over there right now. And the beer is just flowing.
Stop aggravating yourself, will you?
Well, what do you expect me to do? I'm out walking a post for eight hours. When the tour's over, my time should be my own. There's something going to take up with the PPA delegate.
Watch it.
Keep it. I'll hold you, man.
Lieutenant King and I would like to have you stay around a few minutes to help us out on something. That all right with you?
Yes. How long will it take, Captain?
Oh, not very long. I have to go into my office. We'll be ready for you in a few minutes. Come on, Mac.
Okay. Haven't you met him before?
I've seen him around, yes.
Oh, Sergeant.
Yes, sir. You're getting the other men in here?
Yes, sir. The rest of them should be in right away.
All right, Sergeant. When they get here, you send them into the back room. Then let me know. I'll be in my office.
Yes, Sergeant. Would you ring upstairs? Have Novak come see me in the Captain's office.
Yes, sir.
For a record, I've often gotten the department, Captain.
Oh, just there. Good educational background. Two years in medical school. He's in the fire department first. Well, switch jobs. Nothing outstanding in this department. Up on charges once about three years ago for leaving his post without permission. Not in this precinct. Five days' pay. No trouble with him since. He isn't the best man I've got, but as far as I know, he's been doing his job.
Go ahead, Mac. Thanks, Mr. Eagle.
Well, what's gonna happen?
Don't get in a hurry, Leroy. You've got plenty of time.
I'm not getting in a hurry. I'm just getting hungry. That's all. Is there a delicatessen close I'd like to send out for a sandwich?
It was just my luck to get collared right before supper.
You'll get something to eat in a little while.
There's no time like the present. Leroy, you told us to burglarize the flat on your way out of police officer Collinger.
That's right. That's the honest to goodness truth. Now, we want you to identify that police officer.
Well, I told you I didn't know whether I could do that. You stood there like that, that's all. That's long enough to get a look.
Well, it was in the nighttime. It was dark.
Wait a minute, wait a minute. Let me get this straight. Where was this?
Right outside the service entrance of that apartment building?
Yeah, that's right. Right outside. As soon as you came out that door.
Yeah. It was like he was waiting there for me when I came out the door.
Listen, couldn't you send out for a sandwich for me soon, Leroy? I'd like a corned beef and rye with coleslaw and some pickles and some coffee.
Yeah, as soon as we get through here.
Yes, who is it?
No back. Come in.
Do you want me, Lieutenant?
Yeah, no back. I want you.
Yes, sir. Tell you what I want you to do.
All right, Tom, that's good. I'm entitled to get something to eat before you ship me down to this home. The bill of fare down there ain't nothing to write home about, you know. I saw this girl, of course, with my good friend Jack the other day. She was down there to stay, and he says the bill of fare hasn't improved any since the last year or so we've been. And Jack ain't hard to please when it comes to food. You're giving any old snob and he's happy.
All right, get going. No back, Captain.
All right, I guess we're about set, Captain.
Set for what?
To give you a look and see if you can identify that police officer.
I told you I didn't know whether I could do that. I couldn't tell him from Adam.
Well, we think we can, Leroy. We think we know who he is. I want you to give a look and see if you agree with us.
There are 20,000 members of the police department of the city of New York. With their families, the force comprises a community larger than all, but 94 of the most populous cities in the country. As in any group so large and from such varied background, occasional deviation of character is expected. And the police and the methods of dealing with it are provided for in the laws of the state, the rules and regulations of the department, and the manual of procedure. These provisions afford the same protection to an accused police officer as to any other suspect. In all criminal cases, identification is usually the most important criterion. In this one, we proceeded to determine whether the burglary suspect, Leroy Rustin, could identify the police officer he accused. In addition to the principal suspect, Patrolman Austin, a dozen other officers were waiting in the back room. When we were ready, they were formed into a line of fire and marched into the muster room.
What a date! What's the story?
All right, I'll tell you what the story is. We're conducting an investigation. We're holding a man who's made an accusation against a patrolman. I want to see right here and now if he can identify that patrolman. Farrell, would you go into my office and ask them to come in here?
You're not supposed to be accused of, Captain. Among other things, receiving stolen property and failing to take proper police action.
Come over here, Leroy. I'll come there, but I don't know what good it'll do.
Now, there's a squad of police officers here, Leroy. Take a group of them and have a good look at every one of them.
Yes.
Then you tell us if you see the man who took the money off you. And, Leroy.
Yes?
You say this police officer spoke to you. You want to hear the voice of any one of these men? Just ask him to talk.
I'll hear you to talk. State your rank, name, and shield number.
Go ahead, Leroy.
I'd like to hear this fellow state his name, rank, and shield number.
Norman John Farrell, 24381.
No.
Then let this one talk. Go ahead.
Norman Phillip, 31650.
Would you come again? I can't make him. I don't see him.
You want to take another try down the line?
I can't make him. It was too dark there. I told you that.
Austin, wait in the back room for a while. Sergeant, dismiss the squad.
Am I Leroy?
Yeah, I'm coming.
All right, let's go back in my office.
I'll go anyplace. Captain, how long do you think we'll be?
Not very long, Austin, I hope.
Captain, you look at me like that. What did you want me to do? Say it was somebody if I wasn't positively sure? What do you take me for? Did you think it was any of the men there?
Didn't I tell you it was dark? Go ahead, inside.
Lieutenant.
Yes, Lieutenant. Sit down over there, Leroy. What I want to know is when I'm going to get something to eat.
I went over there, Lieutenant. We'll get you something to eat, Leroy. If I could stop the dead around here. We wouldn't let you starve, Leroy.
Yeah. Leroy, there's something I'd like to get straight. You said you couldn't see the cop over there because it was pitch dark. Is that right?
Yeah, that's right. That's the service entrance?
Yeah, the side door, the service entrance.
Leroy.
Yes, Lieutenant.
You just came back from that apartment over there, right? Look at the service entrance where the cop was through collared, Leroy. It was a dark light over the door. The super told me it's never out at night. In addition, that door is right under a streetlight. Would you say it's light enough over there to see a man's face?
Lieutenant, it's light enough to read a newspaper.
Listen, maybe the electric was off there.
The electric wasn't off, Leroy. It's just the plane has been wasting our time all night.
No, I've been giving it to you straight.
You've been going around corners. We're not going to waste any more time. What about it? Did you see that cop or didn't you?
You don't want to waste any more time, huh?
No.
All right, I won't waste any more time. I didn't see any cop because there wasn't any cop.
Then why the story?
Well, it's very involved.
Oh, this has been very involved all night.
Yeah, Cap, you got a point. I told the story for two minutes. I told it before to my good friend, Jack. You see, he was in that flat with me. I didn't tell him about the money when I found it. Well, after we got out, we broke up and met later, just like I told you, at the cafeteria where his girl works. I figured this flat we made might belong to some celebrity and the papers would have the story and tell exactly how much cash was took. So I made up the little tale about the cop. He bought it because being a thief, he believes that's the logical thing for a cop to do. That's what he would think.
Yeah. When I got caught up tonight, I knew I was going to see Jack in the tombs again, so I stuck with the story because he's big. Boy, how big he is. In addition to which, if I played along and told the same story, maybe I'd get a break, you know? Then the newspapers and the DA and everybody go for that stuff. I thought I'd get a break out of it. But I was honest. I didn't identify any cop. I didn't get anybody no jam, not me.
Because you might have picked somebody who wasn't anywhere near that spot.
Well, that's the point. I'll grant you that.
I'll be right back, man. But you still got to give me credit, huh?
Yes, Sergeant. Is everything all right?
Yeah. Boy was lying. He pulled the whole story out of the air. I feel a little better.
I feel better too, Fred. Much better. There's nothing worse than doubt. I had to know one way or the other. He's in the clear. Definitely in the clear.
Austin and them are waiting. Shall I let them go, Captain?
No. I will. Thanks.
Yes, sir, Captain. You can get changed now and go home.
Yes, sir. Just a second, Austin.
Yes, sir. Good night. I'll see you tomorrow.
Night, Captain. How do you like that? We have to stay around here on our own time on some deal we got nothing to do with. We don't even get a word of things.
Oh, what can you do? It's a trouble. There's nothing you can do. Good job. E-77? Talk into the phone. Mr. Thorne? Are you there now?
And so it goes. All right. Week, every day, every year. Precinct in the city of New York is a flesh-and-blood merry-go-round. Anyone can catch the brass ring. Can catch anyone.
21st Precinct. A factual account of the way the police would lodge a city is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the Police Department's city of New York. Everett Sloan in the role of Captain Kennelly features Lieutenant King. Featured in tonight's cast were Larry Haines, Wendell Holmes, Chuck Webster, Frank Reddick, Bill Quinn, and Phil Sterling. And directed by Stanley Nist. For CBS Radio, by John Ives.
