The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 16 min to read
21st Precinct.
A stick-up? East what? Do both of them have guns? Where is this, in the liquor store? All right, I'll send the officers right over.
You're in the muster room at the 21st Precinct, the nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct.
Hello, CB. Sergeant Burns at the 21st. At the liquor store, 192-77. There's a robbery in progress. That's right, a robbery in progress. Two armed men. Okay.
Y'all. The 23rd. 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm captain in command of the 21st.
It happened at 10:55 p.m. Sector car number four of the 21st was on patrol on Lexington Avenue in the 70s, with patrolman Daniel Mercado as operator and patrolman Horace Nelson as recorder. It had been a quiet tour.
And what did he say?
Oh, he didn't say much, Dan. Said if I wasn't satisfied with the views, they'd give me something else. I told him I was satisfied, all right. It's just they were ripping on the heel.
It's almost 55, Nellie. We better ring in.
They gave me a new pair.
I got them.
That was nice of them.
Yeah, I thought so.
Four, box 11. They had one at Lexington in the 73rd. Okay.
It's enough to see him. There he goes, upstairs, to the roof. That's it.
The 6th Division was at the emergency ward at Metropolitan Hospital interviewing the patrolmen who had been injured in the 17th.
17. Lieutenant Snyder, the desk officer at the 21st, reached me on the telephone at the hospital to inform me of the occurrence and the shooting. He reported that detectives of the 21st Squad under the command of Lieutenant Matt King were on the job, that the second hold-up man had run to 3rd Avenue and escaped, and that the ambulance was en route to Metropolitan Hospital with the wounded suspect. I walked outside the emergency room door to await the ambulance. I heard it approach up to the door.
It was Lieutenant King.
Get over on the lot and come on inside.
I was here. I was heard down on the 17th. I'm tired to make the investigation.
Sure, it doesn't look too bad. He's got a broken stem. Don't even try to...
The doctor says that's about all. What have you got?
One of your men made a good collar.
Nelson.
Yeah.
How bad is this boy's shot?
Not too bad, I hope. Well, I want to find out from him. If he's part of it, get away from him. He better know where he is.
Did he tell you anything over there, man?
I think it wouldn't be me at the right time of day.
All right. You'll be with him now.
I was there. Take my jacket. Don't forget my jacket.
All right. I got this then. Go on.
Easy there, Watson. I left it high.
Nelson.
Nice job.
Thanks. Okay. Go ahead. Easy, will you?
Okay, back here. Go ahead.
Want to come inside, Captain?
Yeah, sure, man. Watch it going through the door. This kid might be able to clear a whole string of robbery swans. Watch it now. Take it easy, will you? We're crying out loud.
Doctor, I'll see you for a minute.
Hello, Captain Kennelly. How are you?
How are you, Doctor? Can I talk to him while you examine him?
Well, I... His buddy got away from us. We'd like to be there waiting when he likes.
Just take it easy now, will you? Everybody says I'm so lucky. Seriously, you're not going to cut the shirt. How are we going to get it off?
We'll get a cutter.
No. Where's my jacket?
I've got it. There's a bullet hole in that, too.
Take it easy, Doc. What are you doing? I still...
Wasting your time. Listen to me, boy. You're in a big jam. You tried a couple of shots with a police gun yourself. You've troubled for a long time being a wise guy.
What are you trying to kill me?
I'm trying to kill you longer, but we'll get him anyway. How good is it doing you? Him walking around and you find the guy.
Don't worry about that. All we're asking you to do is save us a little.
What are you to me? I should save you. I don't care anything about saving you. I mean, you want me to save you time.
All right, hold... Cut it out. This is what I cut.
Well, it's in there pretty deep. I don't think it's in too bad shape. It's going to be a while before there's any help here, man. There's a surgeon in here. Do some deep cutting.
Doc, come here.
Why are you leaving me alone?
Lay back there.
Sure. He's not going to be much help. Looks like we're going to have a busy time when I'm kept.
I bet you'd be a lot busier, man, if he were round loose.
And detectives under his command continue to question...
He was taken upstairs to the operating room. I returned to the 70... to enter the report of my investigation... concerning the injured police officer and the blotter. It wasn't until after 1 a.m. that I got back to the 21st. I saw Lieutenant King. He told me that Arthur Rollins had not given him any further information... before he underwent surgery for the removal of the bullet. He was still under anesthesia being guarded by a patrolman... detailed...
By then, the case had taken a new turn. Another holdup had occurred in the 28th Precinct... on the Upper West Side of Manhattan. One man. He had entered a bar and grill... and stuck up the bartender and two customers. One of the customers put up... a fight. He was shot and killed. Described as about the same age, weight, and height... and in the same kind of clothing as the man who escaped on the 21st. It appeared to be the same man. I signed the blotter and left the precinct to go off duty for 24 hours. Detectives had still not been able to talk to Arthur Rollins. It was later in the morning before his condition permitted an interview.
Too hard yet, Lieutenant. He's not completely out of it.
All right, Doctor. Do you want to stand by while I talk to him?
No, no, that's all right.
I'm Lieutenant King.
Yes.
How's he doing? I need to talk to him. Make an entry in your memorandum book that I...
Okay, Lieutenant.
How you doing, Arthur?
It's trouble, you know that.
Yeah, I'm... I've got plenty of it to waste, Arthur. I decided that one close call wasn't enough for him last night. Went up to the 25th, held up a bar, and killed a customer.
The man had wanted for murder.
Some guy I just met.
Listen to me, Arthur. We want help from you. There's a lot more involved now than just another stick-up. There's a homicide involved. You know who the guy is. We're here to talk to you today.
The homicide detective and detectives from the 25th... and somebody from the DA's office.
I can't tell you what I don't know.
Oh, and I don't know a thing. Not a thing.
Went during the whole day. Detectives from the various commands involved... talked to Arthur for as long as the medical authorities would permit. They got no help. In the meantime, other detectives attempted to trace him out... through his present address, his friends, and the people he did business with. More about him than he had already revealed. Investigation had moved forward hardly an inch.
7:30 a.m., I went into the muster room... where Lieutenant Snyder was desk officer... and Sergeant Burns was on telephone switchboard.
I have a few messages for you.
All right, I'll get them as soon as that's on the block.
Yes, sir. 21st Precinct, Sergeant Burns. Tristan Connor is taking a prisoner to court. You put out his school stanchions before you're relieved, okay?
Yes, sir.
Messages, Sergeant?
Yes, sir. And that young woman is waiting to see you, Captain.
Missy, do you know?
She says her name is Mrs. Rollins.
Arthur Rollins, sober metropolitan.
Didn't ask her, Captain.
I haven't been moved in the Bellevue of every platoon. Lieutenant Snyder spoke to the doctor during the night, Captain. He moved, Jack.
Let me know when they're ready to see me, Mrs. Rollins.
Are you the commanding officer?
That's right, I'm Captain Kennelly. He told me I'd have to get permission from the command... of the officer to visit my husband in the hospital.
Is your husband, Arthur Rollins, coming to my office, please?
Yes, thank you. Thank you very much.
Well, this is Wednesday morning. Your husband has been in the hospital since Monday night. Haven't you been able to see him since then?
Well, no. I didn't even know about it. You see, we haven't been living together, not for quite... Hmm? I live over in Jersey, Newark. Been living there ever since we separated. It just happened that a friend of mine brought home a New York paper last night... and I saw it in there. Just an accident, but I know about it.
How did you find it? How did you find out that you have to get my permission?
Well, you see, after I found out last night, I called the hospital on the telephone. I asked if I could visit Arthur. He told me he was a prisoner and I'd have to get permission... of the commanding officer of the 21st Precinct.
Who told you?
I don't know. Whoever answers the phone there does. Which board operator, I guess.
Mm-hmm. Then I called here on the phone. They told me you wouldn't be able to work till 8 o'clock this morning. I couldn't see any youth coming until now.
Is he in very bad trouble? Well, I mean, is it serious?
It's robbery, assault, and violation of the gun law.
Oh. I don't understand how he could do anything like that. He's not bad. He really isn't. He's all right.
Apparently, you didn't think so. You broke up with him.
That was over something else altogether. It wasn't his fault. I guess it was just as much mine.
Could I get permission to see him? That's what the rules say, isn't it? You can give me permission.
Well, the rules also say that in felony cases... where an investigation is being conducted... the commanding officer must consult... the detective squad commander... before giving any such authorization.
Oh.
Have any detectives talked to you about Arthur?
No. I wouldn't know anything about what he was supposed to have done. I haven't seen him in months. He didn't even know where I was.
Well, then why do you want to see him now?
Well, after all, I'm his wife.
All right, Miss Rollins. You just wait here. I'll go talk to Lieutenant King about it.
Who's Lieutenant King?
He's in charge of detectives in the 21st Squad.
Why did there have to be so many people? Oh, just so many people.
You'll have to take that up with Arthur. Maybe he's got the answer. I'll be back in a few minutes.
...the muster room to the desk... where I instructed both Lieutenant Snyder and Sergeant Burns... to keep an eye on the young woman in my office... and to detain her as she attempted to leave. Sergeant Burns told me that Lieutenant King was on the job upstairs... so I walked through the back room... where the men of the day tour were going over the alarms... preparatory to the turnoff. Went up the warren stairs to the second floor... and into the 21st Squad office.
All right, Whitey. Go check it out. You too, Fox.
Yes, sir, Captain.
How are you doing with that Arthur Rollins, man?
Well, he's still in Metropolitan. He'll probably be able to move him to Bellevue today... what the doctor said.
Has he been any help to you?
Help to nothing. I was there myself three times to talk to him. Men from the 25th, the Homicide Squad... and the DA's office were there almost all day yesterday. He didn't say who the second man was. He won't say anything.
The girl who claims to be his wife is downstairs.
Hey, Vice Squad. Oh, that's him?
Yeah. See you. I'll be down in the Captain's office.
All right, Lieutenant.
Holding back for him. He helped with Clear Homicide. He had nothing to do with it. He deserved some kind of break. Maybe he'll still help you.
Here. Her answer is no.
Wait a minute.
So you didn't even know he was married.
Hey.
Good morning, Captain.
Where he's living now, nobody doesn't do much talking anyplace he goes.
Miss Rollins? This is Lieutenant King.
Can I get to see Arthur?
This boy came all the way over here for it. I don't see why I have to go through so much red tape just to see my own husband.
He's being held on a charge of robbery.
I know that. And he hasn't been very helpful. We're still investigating to find out who was with him. When he held up that liquor store, would you know who it might be?
No. What would I know? I haven't seen Arthur in months.
How long has it been since you were living with him?
I don't know. Four or five months.
Where did you live? In New York?
Yes, I tried in New York. In Washington Heights.
Why did you break up?
It's an awfully long story.
We'd like to know why.
Well, you see, he was in service in the Army. He got married when he first went in, and then he went away, first to Texas, and then he went to Korea. He wasn't any hero or anything. But he was bitter. He was in for two years.
Where were you, meanwhile, in Washington Heights?
No, no, I was home, living with my folks. When he got out, they found this apartment in Washington Heights, just three rooms for that reason.
When was that?
About a year ago. Late last summer, I guess, a little more than a year ago.
Did he have a job?
Yes, so did I. I got it out in the post office. No, delivering special deliveries. It was just temporary, and he didn't like it, so he tried to get into building, construction work.
Yeah. I thought the post office was much better, for him, at least, but he wanted to work with his brother. His brother's in construction work. He works in, what do you call it, the excavation, when they have to dig a foundation for a new building. That's what he does.
Where does his brother live, in New York?
In Brooklyn. He told me how much more money he's making and everything like that, but I said, maybe your brother makes more when he's working, but there's time between jobs and all that, and you're better off in the post office. You're sure of it every week.
Was that... the cause of the breakup?
No. The only thing about it was that he always wanted to do everything his brother did. Joe. That's his brother. Joe's in some Joe's ass. That's all I ever heard. Every time we had to make a move, we couldn't do it without consulting Joe. I just got fed up with it, you know. But one day, he said, well, you married to me, you're Joe. Didn't last long after that. One night, I said, Garth, I'm leaving. He said, okay. That was that. It was mutual. After all, he was in the army with a married man and didn't have to go to his big brother anymore for every little thing.
Has Arthur ever been arrested before?
No. Not before we broke up.
Has Joe? His brother?
Yes.
I don't know. I don't care anything about Joe. I think for Joe, it's a couple of nights. I don't know.
Did Arthur go to work on a construction job?
Yes, I think so. At least I know he quit the post office.
Is Joe married?
Really?
Not much. It was very recent.
Listen. Can I go over to see Arthur?
All right with me, Captain.
21st Precinct, Captain Kennelly. Authorization. Turn out the platoon. Turn out the platoon. I get the men who are working the next shift on the Johnson. Oh, something, isn't it? Yes.
Turn out the platoon for the day tour and return to my office where Lieutenant King and Mrs. Rollins were waiting. Patrolman Fallon, the 124 man, came in and I instructed him to write up the authorization for Mrs. Rollins to visit her husband. In the company of myself, Lieutenant King, and Detective Whitey Howard of the 21st Squad, she went to Metro. As there's no prison ward at Metropolitan, a patrolman from the 21st had been assigned to guard Arthur Rollins. As we walked down the long corridor, I could see through the open door of the room he occupied. Patrolman Nelson was inside, sitting in a chair beside the bed.
Is he good? The doctor, I mean?
Very good.
Doctor?
Hello, Captain. Lieutenant.
Doctor. Well, how's the patient?
This is Mrs. Rollins.
I've got three men tied up here on guard duty. I'd like to get them back on the job.
Perhaps this afternoon.
Doctor, there won't be anything coming. Damage to him.
Well, excuse me. I want to talk to the officer on guard duty.
Go right in, Captain.
You? It'd be too bad if there was. He's always been so helpful.
He's not giving you any trouble, is he?
Arthur? You were shooting at the officer. He didn't have time to stand around. I understand you haven't been much help to the officers who've been around to talk to you.
You see me like this? I didn't want you to come. I didn't want anybody. I saw it in the paper. I... Oh, go on. Get out. I don't want you here.
Arthur, I don't. I told you yesterday I'm not staying in time for me to do a little talk.
What would I know? I didn't tell them anything, Arthur.
You didn't have to, boy. Just make a claim.
Oh, you're not telling me. Where is Joe?
Look, you know who it was. Isn't that enough for you?
We have to get him. That'll be enough.
How'd he talk you into this, Arthur? Where is he now?
You'll have to find that out for yourself.
Oh, them wouldn't have been so bad, Arthur. Put your knife on the burglar?
On the clock through the week, every day, every year. This precinct in the city of New York is a flesh and blood merry-go-round. Catch the brass ring.
