The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 23 min to read
Soon for the day tour. Captain? Yes? Could I talk to you, Captain, please? Well, uh, you're Mrs. Rostek, aren't you? Yes, Mrs. Rostek. Well, it's been a long time. You still got the store? Oh, yeah. Sure I got it. When Joe died, I thought maybe I'd sell it, but I couldn't get nothing for a little store like that. I got the store. How much did five cents candy, ten cents photos mean in newspapers? Well, what can I do for you, Mrs. Rostek? Well, it's my boy, George. You remember my boy, George? Yeah. He got arrested. Where? Yeah, upstairs with the detectives. What for?
Captain? Yes? They're about to turn out. Do you want to talk to them? Yes, I'll be right there. Oh, you're busy, Captain. Oh, you sit right down here, Mrs. Rostek. I'll be back. Oh, yes. Sure, Captain. Sure.
I walked out into the muster room and stood behind the desk. The bell rang. In marched the platoon for the day tour. Patrol sergeant brought them to a halt. He reported the platoon inspected. The desk officer ordered the roll call. Martin, Rifkin, Rose, Shaw, Sutton, Thompson, Savicino, Zollett, Captain Kennelly. Well, a couple of things, men. We've had an alarm from the Harlem Valley State Hospital. An escaped mental case. His name is Lester C. Trey, age 58, 5 feet, 10 and a half inches, 165 pounds. Gray hair, blue eyes, light complexion. Medium build, and he walks with a slight limp in his right leg. They say this fellow used to hang out in bar and grills on 2nd Avenue in the 70s before he was confined. You sector men and you men on post there, keep your eyes out for him. Now, I don't like to talk about this. I'm not going to mention any names because I don't want to embarrass anybody. But get your house tax paid up. Those of you who are delinquent will have forthwith sent to your home. All right, sergeant. Coach the platoon. Platoon, halt!
The men who would patrol the precinct on foot and in cars for the next eight hours walked out the door and onto the street. I looked over entries in the blotter, and I walked back around the desk toward my office where Mrs. Rostek was waiting.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein. All right, 671.
All right, Mrs. Rostek. I don't want to take up your time, Captain. That's what I'm here for. What was your boy arrested for? I don't know. Robbery. Tell me what happened. I was asleep two or three o'clock this morning. I don't know. Somebody was knocking on the door. I thought George. I thought he forgot his keys. It was two men, not policemen, detectives. They said, where's George? I said, I don't know. He isn't home yet. He sleeps on the couch. He isn't home. They said, could we wait? I didn't want them there, but I said, all right. Then they wanted to look at George's face. I don't know. I told them I got no right to show them. Ask George. All right, then. Pretty soon, George come home. Maybe 3.30, 4 o'clock. There wasn't any trouble. No trouble. George told the misdeems, and they said it would be better to come here and talk. George said, go back to sleep, and I'll be home right away. I thought they just wanted to talk, so I went back to sleep. Who told you he was being held for robbery? I woke up, and he wasn't there, so I came here and asked. The man out there, he said. The desk lieutenant? Yeah, the lieutenant. He said, go upstairs to the detective. Oh, was George upstairs? Yeah, in a little office with one of the detectives who came last night. They were still talking. I went in, and I said, what did you do, George? He told me, go home, Ma. Get out of here. What was the name of the detective who arrested him? Oh, it told me to do something. I don't know. How old is George? 17, 17 in January. He was 17, or he will be 17? He was in January. I don't know. Captain, they came, they took him. He's a good boy. He goes to school. He works, Captain.
Let me see what I can find out. Get me Lieutenant King upstairs, will you? Yes. He's a good boy. He wouldn't do anything like robbing.
This is Captain Kennelly. Is Lieutenant King around? No, sir. I don't know. Listen, Tully, who squealed that George Rostek being held for robbery? It's my squeal, Captain. Oh. Well, what's it look like? We've got a maid in the tree about 1 o'clock this morning. Definitely him? Yeah, the man's watered it. Watered? What does George say? He's about to meet. What are you going to do with him? Well, his mother's here. He wouldn't even say hello. Yeah. Well, thanks, Tully.
I mean, yes, he's charged with robbery, Mrs. Rostek. I don't believe it. I don't. I say he mugged three people. Mugged? What's mugged? Beat them up and robbed them on the street. One last night. He's still in the hospital. Not my George. I don't believe it. He's been in trouble before, hasn't he? He's a good boy, Captain. A very good boy. What are they going to do? What happens now? I don't know. They'll take him down to court this morning. Not court trial? No, to felony court for a hearing to set bonds. You need a lawyer? Wouldn't be a bad idea. Oh, I don't know a lawyer. Do you know somebody, Captain? I can't recommend anyone, Mrs. Rostek. Oh, Mrs. DiPronio from the hardware store. Her oldest boy is a lawyer. I'll ask her. What time in court? Where? Well, I've got to get through here first, but they'll go to felony court, 100 Center Street, in the criminal courts building. You're sure it's not the trial? They won't send him away? All it's for is to set. Bail. Oh, how much does bail cost? You'd better get your lawyer, Mrs. Rostek. You can ask him all about that. Oh, all right. I don't know, Captain. I've raised him good. I sent him to school and to church. It's been hard since I buried his father, but I sent him. He's a good boy. You get your lawyer. I know you're very busy, Captain. Just one more thing. You know me. You know Joe a long time. 10, 12 years. I don't know. I do my best for him, Captain. My best. Yes? I'm sure you do. Please, one favor. If I can. Go upstairs. Talk to him. Say something to George. Ask him why. I want to know why he did this. I can't ask him. I can't. He needed money. I don't know. Well, that case is not in my hands, Mrs. Rostek. Please, Captain. Please. All right. I'll talk to him.
Come in. Captain. Yes? Patrolman Farrell has your car outside, Captain. He wants to know whether you're going to patrol in this morning. If not, he'll take it down. He'll drive down to Motor Maintenance, have him look at a sticky belt. Well, excuse me, Captain. Yes. Thanks for stopping in, Mrs. Rostek. Just talk to George. You'll see. He's a good boy. He's a very good boy. That's all right. Bye.
Oh, what did you say about my car, Sergeant? Farrell's got it outside, sir. If you're not going to patrol this morning, he'll drive down to Motor Maintenance Service Station No. 1 at 16th Street and Avenue C and get the valve repaired. Well, I was off all day yesterday. Why didn't you take it down then? Beats me, Captain. Well, you tell him to... Just a second. Yes. 21st Precinct, Captain Kennelly. Who? Who? Oh, hello, Eddie. Yeah, sure. I've got it down on my calendar. Wednesday, 4 p.m., Clinton Playground, softball field, Comets versus Eagles. The roof doesn't fall in on us. I'll be there to see at least part of the game. I'd sure like to. Thanks for calling to remind me, Eddie. Okay. Tell Farrell to come in here and talk to me about the car. Yes. Oh, and there's a communication from the chief inspector's office. Yes. We're getting three brand new rookies for the night tour today. Tell McCarty I want Sergeant Burns to put him on the list. Put him on fixed post tonight. Put them someplace he can keep an eye on them. Yes, sir. Right away.
My operator, Patrolman Johnny Farrell, came inside, and I told him to drive down to Motor Maintenance Service Station No. 1 at 16th Street and Avenue C and get the valve repaired. I finished up the morning's paperwork and looked over the departmental records of the three new rookies who would report at 4 p.m. for the night tour. At 10 o'clock, I walked upstairs to the 21st Detective Squad to keep my promise to Mrs. Lostick. Most of the men were out, as they should have been, making investigations on squeals assigned to them. The on-duty detective sat at his desk, typing out a UF-61 report. A woman, obviously a narcotics addict, was on the bench in a corner waiting for detectives of the narcotics squad to come and talk to her. The door to Lieutenant King's office stood half open. Detective Jim Tully, who was inside, saw me come into the room and walked out to greet me.
Hello, Captain. How are you, Tully? Dragging. No sleep. I promised the mother I'd talk to that Lostick boy. I've known him for years. You can talk to him, Captain, but he won't say anything to you. I know kids. I like kids. I got one of my own, his age, but this one, brother. Well, uh, what does he say about these deals? He's not even sorry. He'd do it again. You can figure him, Captain. You win the prize. He tried to pull away from me. I had to put the cuffs on him.
Oh, hello, Matt. I didn't think you were here. Just got back, Captain. Close this, Lieutenant. Yeah, go ahead. His, uh, mother asked me to talk to him. Sure.
Hello, George. If you're another cop, I don't want to talk to you. I've talked to enough cops. I'll listen to you. You're not in here to do what you want to do. Okay, Jim. I'm not in here because I want to be, either. George, this is Captain Kennelly. He's the commanding officer of this precinct. So? And I'm a friend of your mother's. Well, what's that supposed to get you? Listen, boy, you're looking at a rough deal. There's no sense making it any rougher. Well, what else could I make of it? What do you want, mister? I told you I'd talk to enough cops. I've known your mother for ten years, George. And I knew your father. Good, hard-working people. That's the trouble with him. Slob. Nothing but slobs. Not a brain in their heads. He's dead, and he's just as smart now as he was before. You think you're so smart? The three of you are standing around trying to find out something from me, aren't you? We don't have to find out anything from you, boy. We've got you right. You mugged three people on the street in this precinct alone. We found that one man's wallet in your pocket. I picked it up on the subway. He lost it. Did he? Well, tell me how you got the property that belonged to the other two. How did that wind up in your drawer? How should I know? This guy put it there to get something on me. No, listen. You weren't happy enough taking the money from them. You had to knock them down and kick them all over the sidewalk. You're the one kind of man. The guy we don't want around here, George. We're bringing every mugging victim in from the 19th and 23rd to have a look at you, boy. And if what I think is true, we'll just about clear the books. Yeah, clear them all up. 17 years, and you've already done more damage than the average guy we get in here. We're doing 70. We're no juvenile anymore. You can get the books thrown at you, George, and I'm going to help do the throwing. See, Captain, you can get back and tell my mother how nice they treat me around here. Give her a written report. Why don't you be sensible about this thing, George? Get it straightened out. Be a little helpful. Helpful.
Come in. Whitey's back with a victim. The woman, too? Yes, sir. She's here. All right, let's have a lineup. Who've we got? There's a couple of fellas, 18 or 19, down in the cell. There's car thieves. All right, get them up here. Give them a hand getting it set up, Ken. Yeah, Lieutenant, you bet. Where's Whitey? What happened, son? What gives now? Look, Captain, if you're a friend of my mother's, tell him to take these bracelets off, huh? Look at this. They got me chained to the chair like an animal. Look at this. Would you rather they locked up? They'll come off when you're settled on. We can take them off now, Captain. What is this, a new deal? The people you picked around and robbed are here, George. We're going to have a party. Yeah? You're the guest of honor.
The purpose of a criminal investigation is to arrive at the truth through the accumulation of evidence. Because a police officer is at the scene of a crime only in rare instances, he cannot depend upon his own direct knowledge for the truth. In cases of robbery and assault, the greatest amount of help in arriving at the truth comes from victims and witnesses who can usually identify the assailant on sight. The process of identification is very exact and painstaking for two reasons. First, to protect the suspect against erroneous identification if he is innocent. And second, to establish the fact beyond all question if he is guilty.
Come in. You're all set for the lineup, Lieutenant. Where are the witnesses, Jim? Close the hall. Hold them there for a minute, I'll tell you. Yes, sir. Would you like to stay around for this, Captain? Yeah, sure. Thanks, man. All right, George. On your feet. All right. Get up. We're going out in the squad room. There's a couple more fellows we're holding out there. They and you and two young detectives are going to line up. And this woman, this Mrs. Brown, and the man, Mr. Clayman, are going to come in one at a time. They were both mugged on the street. What we want to see is, can they pick out the one who mugged them? Get this frame up. It's all fixed. Is it? I guess it was all fixed, but you had Mrs. Brown's pocketbook and Mr. Clayman's wallet in your house. Well, that's possible, isn't it? Look, George, the truth has to come out. Why don't you save everybody a lot of time and trouble? Why don't you save your advice? All right. Come on.
Okay, let's have the lineup. Yes, sir. All right, you boys, step over here. Over here. Come on. Now, what do you say, George? You can't duck it if you're the boy. Come on, George. All right, get lined up over there like I told you. Yes, sir. Come in. Well, sir, Lieutenant, there's one or two more men to stand up there. I don't want any mistake about this. Whitey, Max, give us a hand with this, will you? Fine. One of you on each end. All right, all right. Keep it quiet. Okay, George, this is your party. Get wherever you like. I don't know what difference this makes. Go on, pick your spots. It's all a put-up job, anyway. Great kid, Captain. Yeah, I know what you mean. Well, if I stand up straight and don't jabber.
Hold on. Captain Kennelly, phone for you. All right. Excuse me, man. Yes, sir. What about you, Lieutenant? Okay.
Captain Kennelly. Sergeant Klein, Captain. All right, Whitey. This is Mr. Brown here. Brent's still in line there. ...about a woman who fell down the subway stairs on April 6th and has a claim against the city, Captain. Well, did you get out the aided case, Klein? Yes, sir. I wanted to talk to the officer who was on the job and the... Isn't that door open? Oh, well, who was the patrolman? I went to her last night. All right, Sergeant. Tell Mr. Osneal to wait in my office. I'll be downstairs in a few minutes. Yes, sir.
All right, come in, Mrs. Brown. Yes, sir. Come off this way, please. Oh, go on, Millie. I have an appointment. No, I don't think so. This is Captain Kennelly, Mrs. Brown. How do you do? Hello. I'm Lieutenant King. Hello. You see those men standing over there, Mrs. Brown? Yes. Could you identify any of them as the man who robbed him? Well, I don't know. That's an awful thing. I want you to be sure. I don't want any mistakes. Oh, there won't be any mistakes. I'll be sure. Look them all over good, every one of them. Look them over twice, you have to. Be quiet. You see the one? Tap him on the shoulder. Now? Yes, now. Tap him on the shoulder. He's the one over there. All right, hold him. The other victim is here, too. All right, the rest of you. All right, what do you think this is? Quiet down. You ought to be ashamed of yourself, young man. Do you know that? I had a cut in my par in my back which took for a week. What do you want me to do, break down and cry? That wouldn't be a bad idea, George. I'd think a lot more of you if you did.
After the second victim, I've identified George Rostek as Mr. Salen. I left the detective squad and walked down the stairs through the back room to my office. Mr. Rostneil of the Corporation Counsel's Office of the City of New York was waiting. He explained to me that a woman who slept on the subway stairs was making what appeared to be an unfounded claim for damages against the city. I arranged for the patrolman who answered the original call to give his immediate and full cooperation with the Corporation. Meanwhile, the robbery suspect, George Rostek, had been taken by detectives to New York Hospital, where he was also identified by his latest victim. I was still at my desk when Detective Tully returned from the hospital with George Rostek with instructions to book the suspect on three charges of robbery and assault. The act of booking is the first step in the judicial process leading to trial. The charges and the circumstances of the arrest are entered in the arrest record by the desk officer in the muster room. I sat at my desk and watched the procedure through the open door of my office.
Mr. Rostek, R-O-S-T-E-K, George. Any middle initial? No. No middle initial. Age? 17. Occupation? What are you, a student, George? When I work at it. Student. Robbery and assault, three times. He's going down to 240 to be mugged and printed and then to felony court. Yeah. Let's see what you got on you, George. Thank you, sir. Calm. 70. 78. Let me go! Hey! Watch it!
After the mix and be told, a citizen, a woman, had opened the front door leading to the street, apparently to make some inquiry or register a complaint. He held the door open while talking to a friend who remained on the sidewalk. The 17-year-old suspect saw his chance and made a break for the door. We were all out the door and onto the crowded street a few feet behind him, but he was young and fast and he knew the neighborhood. He ran across the street, down the block, and disappeared between buildings. Within minutes, there were over 30 uniformed officers and detectives on the job. The search continued late into the afternoon. No luck. An alarm was put out by C.B. to every precinct in the city of New York. The store owned by his mother and the flat in which they lived were both put under surveillance. Detectives were sent to talk to all his known friends. By 6.15, when I signed the blotter and left the precinct to go off duty, there was still no sign of him. Nor was there when I called in twice that night and three times the next morning. When I came back on the job at 3.45 in the afternoon, Lieutenant King was waiting in the muster room for me.
Hello, Captain. Matt, you look deep. I am. No sign of him, huh? Nothing. I want to talk to you about it, Captain. Yeah, sure. We think the mother knows where he is. Yeah?
Hello, Sergeant. Captain. 21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein. Yeah. 9-8. Oh, what's he doing, Sergeant? Nothing much, sir. A few messages. I left them on your desk. Thanks. We're sure he knows where he is. Did you talk to him? Yes, sir. He's a pretty bad liar, but he keeps on lying. He's not in the house or the store? I've had men watching both ever since. A lot of people go in. He went out of that store. That's the point, Captain. Somebody that went in knows where George is and told her. What do you want me to do? Talk to her? Yes. You've known her a long time. Maybe she'll open up with you. Sure, Matt. I'll talk to her. There's nothing to lose. Nothing, Captain. Nothing except sleep. We've all lost plenty of that already.
I signed the blotter, read the communications and reports, and turned out the platoon for the night tour. At 445, I had Patrolman Farrell drive me over to 2nd Avenue to the small candy store run by Mrs. Rostek. I got out of the car. I got out of the car and told him to wait. As I crossed the sidewalk, I spotted Detective Jim Tully standing in the doorway, 100 feet or so down the block. He'd been on the job 48 hours straight. It was his prisoner. He wanted him back.
Hello, Mrs. Rostek. Captain. Hello. Well, it looks like George is in more trouble. He's a good boy, Captain. I tried. I did my best. It's not my fault. Nobody's blaming you? Stoner, would you like a soda? No. No, thanks. I'll take one. It's hot out. Where is he, Mrs. Rostek? I don't know. Not even a glass of water? No. Oh, I'll have something myself. Chocolate's nice, the way I make it. George. Oh, I don't know. Maybe I didn't raise him right. Maybe I don't give him what he needs. When Joe was alive, maybe I spent too much time in the store with Joe and not enough raising George. Now, since I buried Joe, I have not even as much time for George. Well, he was in trouble, too. Kid trouble. Just kids fooling around. But I tried. I tried. I tried. I tried. I tried. You can't say I don't try. And I love him. He's a good boy. Lieutenant King tells me he thinks you know where he is. No. I don't know. Don't ask me. I don't know. It's in the neighborhood someplace, isn't it? I don't know.
Hello, Mrs. Rostek. Have you got movie glamour magazine? Right in back of you. Top shelf movie glamour. Where? Top shelf, you see. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Can I have two dimes and a nickel and change, Mrs. Rostek? Please tell us all. Yes, ma'am. Thank you. They find George? No, not yet. Oh, excuse me. That's all right. Well, I'll need to tell us something. Don't you worry about him, Mrs. Rostek. He's smart. They won't get here. Yes. Very smart. Me too. I'm very smart. I just feel no soda, Captain. Positive. And ice cream, then? No. You tell me, Captain. You tell me what's best. If we don't get him soon, Mrs. Rostek, he's finished. He's young and he's got a chance to get straightened out. A good chance. He's got a chance to get straightened out. If we don't get him, he can't do anything but get worse and worse. But, boy, it's very good. Worse and worse. So bad he'll never get straightened out. There'll be more mugging. He'll get a gun. He'll kill somebody or get killed himself. Mr. Rostek, no. That's the way it'll be. The next charge will be murder. The line was given. So wait and try again. I'll stay on the phone all the time once you leave. Now, thank you, Mrs. Rostek. I don't know. You want him to get straightened out, don't you? I don't know. But... He does. Bill me. Yeah? He's been coming in for money to buy him food. He's in a club room someplace. A club room that the boys have got. I put the money in the magazine. Five dollars. Thanks, Mrs. Rostek. Captain. Yes? He's a good boy, Gil. A good boy. I hope he turns out to be.
I looked both ways on the street. I saw that the girl had turned north and was walking slowly away from the store. I followed her until I got to the point where Detective Jim Tully was waiting in the vestibule. Jim. Hello, Captain. That girl in yellow dress and blonde hair? Yes, sir. George is hiding in the club room. Stay with her. She'll need you there. Thanks. Who told you, the mother? Yeah. I don't get it. She was a clam with R-2. Because George is a good boy. You're going. You're a loser. Yes, sir.
And so it goes on. Around the clock, through the week, every day, every year. A police precinct in the city of New York is a flesh and blood merry-go-round. Anyone can catch the brass ring. Or the brass ring can catch anything. Anyone.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein. Yes, sir. And what's the address? 205-209. Inside? In front of the queue makers. What's the trouble there? What did the man have? What kind of a gun?
Incidents portrayed on tonight's 21st Precinct occurred last year. Names were changed to protect the interests of persons involved. 21st Precinct is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 19,000 members of the Police Department, City of New York. Everett Sloan in the role of Captain Kennelly. Ken Lynch as Lieutenant King. Featured in tonight's cast were Barbara Wheat, Elaine Ross, Linda Watkins, Lawson Zerbe, Bob Reddick, and George Petrie. Written and directed by Stanley Nist. Produced for CBS Radio by John Ives. Art Hanna speaking.
