The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 26 min to read
Thanks, Sergeant Klein. What do you mean you were robbed? Held up? So where'd this happen? Where? Did he have a gun? There were two men. When was this, just now?
You are in the muster room at the 21st Precinct, the nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct.
Where are you calling from? Well, from what floor is that? You take the elevator back downstairs. The officers will be right there. They'll be right there. You just wait. Yes, ma'am. 21st Precinct.
It's just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the nine-tenths of a square mile between Fifth Avenue and the East River wouldn't know if you asked them that they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, the security of their persons, their homes, and their property is my job. My job and the job of the 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm captain in command of the 21st.
What makes a city? Not buildings, not subways, not business. People make a city. From dawn to midnight, from midnight to dawn. As in the 21st. Sometime in a way you'd least expect.
I was working my 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. tour. It had started to rain during the night, and it was still raining at 1:15 p.m. when I came out of the luncheon meeting of the Lenox Hill Lions Club, at which I spoke on the problems of juvenile delinquency.
From the lobby of the hotel I rang in. Sergeant Klein on CS told me everything was quiet. I instructed him to send a car for me. When it came, I had the operator, Patrolman Farrell, drive me to the New Era Theater, a movie house on First Avenue. I went into the lobby and was told by the manager that Mr. Crows could be found at the back of the theater near the candy stand. I saw him in the dim light, and I walked over. A cartoon was on the screen.
Oh, Captain, how are you?
I had a report from Sergeant Collins on the night tour that you've been having some trouble over this way.
Yeah, that's right, Captain, but I told the sergeant what was on my mind last night. I appreciate you stopping by anyway.
Well, I'm getting instructions to remain on post and in the cars here to pay special attention to the conditions.
Oh, well, thanks. Oh, just a second. Here's that scene. I get the biggest kick out of these cartoons. I don't know why. You ever see anything so funny?
Sure, clever, all right. Look in there, Captain. A rainy afternoon. A rainy afternoon, and business is just fine. You know, I got the answer to what's wrong with the picture business. Have you?
Mm-hmm. If they make a good picture, you do business. Even on a day like this. It's simple. Make all good pictures.
Uh, how many kids does the rule hang out at that candy store at night, Mr. Crows?
Well, you know, it varies. Now, on a nice night or a Saturday, there's a whole gang of them. They yell and they make jokes at the people coming on their way to the theater at night. And that can scare them. I don't need my patrons scared away. The condition at the box office is bad enough. And it's not healthy. It's not healthy for the neighborhood.
All right, Mr. Crows. We'll see what we can do about it. Look at that rabbit. I like that. You know, I see a feature picture once, I'm through with it. But I can watch these cartoons four or five times a day.
Yeah, well, if the condition doesn't clear up, Mr. Crows, you just get in touch with me.
Oh, uh, is this the cop looking for you, Captain?
Oh, yeah. Excuse me, Captain.
Yes, Farrell?
Signal 30 just came over.
Yeah?
Hold up just around the corner at 340. I thought you might want to take a look.
Yes, I do. So long, Mr. Crows.
Thanks, Captain.
One man, no description put out yet.
All right. Let's go.
I left the theater with Patrolman Farrell. It was still raining. We got into the car, and he drove around the corner to 340, a loft building. The sector car and the sergeant's car were already there. Sergeant Burns had posted his operator at the front door of the building to keep the curious out of the lobby. He held the door open and nodded as I went in. The lobby was long and narrow, the building old and grimy. At the far end of the lobby was a single old-fashioned elevator. Sergeant Burns was talking to a woman dressed in a raincoat, a woman about 35. The sector men, the patrolmen on post, were questioning the elevator operator several feet away. I walked to Sergeant Burns.
Do you know how much was in the envelope exactly?
No, Sergeant. No.
Captain?
There was $1,362.25.
Exactly?
Yes.
How did you know that?
I just came from the back. It was the payroll.
Oh. Captain Kennelly, this is Mrs. Beatrice Parazoni.
How do you do?
Is that how you pronounce it, Parazoni?
Parazoni, yes, that's right.
She's a bookkeeper for a firm up on the sixth floor, Captain.
Mm-hmm. She's coming back from the bank with a payroll. A man followed her into the lobby and onto the elevator, pulled a gun, took the package. Then he forced the elevator operator to take them back down to the ground level. He got off, told him to go straight up to the top. Is that about right, Mrs. Parazoni?
Yes, that's right, exactly.
Did you get a description, Sergeant?
Yes, sir, as good as they could give me. I didn't remember much. I honestly didn't. I could only look at that gun. That's all I could see. The elevator operator is not so good with the English. I called TS, gave him the best description we could get.
Good. What kind of company is it you work for?
Well. It's a place that makes optical lenses, you know, for eyeglasses.
Yeah.
It's just a small company. It's about 14 to 15 men working in the shop and myself in the office with the boss. That's all.
That was the whole payroll, $1,352.25, the whole payroll for a week.
Where's your boss? Did you tell him about it?
I stopped up on the floor to call the police. He's not there. He's out selling. He's usually in the shop in the morning. He goes out seeing customers in the afternoon.
How long have you been employed there, Mrs. Parazoni?
Almost 10 years, between 9 and 10.
Oh. You never had anything like this happen before, did you?
Oh, no, nothing like this at all, never.
Well, it's five minutes after 3 now, Mrs. Parazoni. What time did you leave the office for the bank?
Well, it was just about 2 o'clock on payday. I usually work all morning until I get the payroll finished, and then I ran out to check, and the boss signs it before he leaves to call on customers. I had to check, and I went out to lunch. And then I was going to the bank right before it closed to come back here in time to make up the payroll for when the men go home.
Okay. You follow this? Pattern, pretty much, every week.
What do you mean?
Well, I mean, you pay on the same day every week.
Oh, yeah.
And do you go to the bank just about the same time?
Yes, usually right before it closes.
Oh, Sergeant, you ought to have the second target back on patrol. We don't need them here anymore.
Yes, sir, Captain. All right, Brian.
You really ought to be getting upstairs and back to work, Captain. I don't know what I'm going to do about the payroll today. I don't know where I can reach the boss. The bank is closed. It'll be a shame for the men to go home without their money. Can I go upstairs now and see if I can get it straightened out?
Well, look. The detectives will be here any minute, Mrs. Parazoni. They'll want to talk to you. I think you ought to wait down here until they come.
Oh, ring me up when you get back. Oh, gee, what, I have to wait for detectives before I told you everything I know? I told you and that sergeant and that police in there.
Yes, well, it's the detectives' case. It's up to them to conduct the investigation. Thank you. Out of all people, Captain, I don't know. Why did he pick on me? The funny thing, he picked on me.
Is it?
I guess he didn't pick on me. He just picked on the $1,300.
The essential duty of the uniformed force is patrol. When the criminal is unknown or has fled, it is the job of the detectives to investigate. In this, as in all similar cases, the 21st Detective Squad under the command of Lieutenant Matt King was notified by the desk officer immediately on the receipt of the report. Within a few minutes, Detectives Ben Novak and Whitey Howard were on the job. Sergeant Burns opened his memorandum book and from notes he had taken for his UF-61 and unusual occurrence report, gave them the facts as he had learned them. He introduced them to the victim and to the witness, then resumed patrol. I returned to the precinct house. It was still raining, but not nearly so hard. I walked to the telephone switchboard where Sergeant Klein was on the box seat.
Hello, Captain.
Any messages, Sergeant?
No telephone messages, no, sir. But there was a communication on the teletype addressed to all precinct, division, and borough commanders. I put it on your desk.
Good. Tell Glass I'll read and sign whatever report he's got ready now.
Yes, sir. I'll be in my office.
Yes, sir. 21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein. Yes, sir. Captain Kennelly. Hello.
Hi, Mr. Crows.
Oh, hello, Mr. Crows.
Captain, can I talk to you for a minute?
What's the matter? Are those boys at the candy store giving you trouble this early in the day?
No, no. I'd just like to talk to you, Captain, if I could.
Yeah, sure. Come into my office.
Thanks. Thanks a lot. Go ahead.
Well, Captain, I'm the curious type, you know. Like anybody else, I like a little excitement. When that cop came in and told you there was a Signal 30 around the corner, I got sort of interested. The Signal 30 is, it's an armed felony, right?
That's right.
Well, anyway, I figured I'd like to see what's going on. So when you left, I got my raincoat, and I walked around the corner. The cop was standing at the door of the loft building, so I couldn't get in. But I looked through the door, and I saw that girl you were talking to. And from the conversation around her, I found out that she was held up for a payroll. Is that right?
Yes, that's right. What about it?
Now, look, it's none of my business, maybe. I feel like an idiot.
Well, you came here to tell me, didn't you?
Yeah. Yeah, I did. And that girl, Captain, the one that was held up? She did an awful funny thing a little while before.
What do you mean?
About 2 o'clock, I was standing in the lobby there, in the lobby of the theater. It was raining outside, and I was still wondering how we were doing all the business we were doing so early in the day with the weather. But a good picture will bring you in. That's all you need.
Uh, what about the girl?
Yeah, well, I guess it was about 2 o'clock. I remember it because she had on a funny brown raincoat with a plaid pattern. You know, the one she was wearing.
Yeah?
Well, she bought a ticket, and she came in the theater.
Did she?
Yeah, she did. Now, I know that's not funny in itself. I wouldn't have noticed her except for that raincoat. But I stand in the lobby a few minutes, talk to the ticket taker, go to the box office, talk to the cashier, shake hands with a few patrons. Then it's about 2:10, maybe 2:15, and I see this raincoat walking out again. Well, I figure this is funny. So I stop in the lobby, and I say, what's the matter, lady? Did you see the picture before? If you saw the picture before, I'd be glad to give you your money back. We don't want any dissatisfied patrons.
Now, what'd she say?
She said, no, she didn't see the picture before.
Uh-huh.
So I told her, look, lady, if it's not the kind of picture you think it is, or you don't like it, let me give you a free pass. You can come back some other time. You know, we do these things for public relations. But she says, no, everything is all right. She doesn't want her money back or anything like that. Anyways, while I'm standing there talking to her, a man walks out of the theater, and he walks right past without saying a word. Well, she sort of looks at him like she was going to say something, like she knows him, but he walked out, and he didn't even turn to her.
Yeah?
Well, that's all.
Is it?
Yeah, except that she left.
Well, I see I shouldn't butt in anybody else's business.
Uh, sit down, Mr. Crows. You think there's something to it, Captain?
I thought there was something to it. That's why I came over here. But I can't figure out what.
What did the man look like?
Well, that's kind of hard to say.
Well, was he tall?
Oh, I couldn't say he was exactly tall, but I couldn't say short either. Medium, maybe.
You sure it was the same girl?
I'm positive. I never forget a face, and I never forget a raincoat. In the whole city of New York, there couldn't be two raincoats like that, at least in this neighborhood.
Listen, Captain, you think there's something to it? You think I hit on something?
Maybe.
Well, what? What?
Mr. Crows, it's just like... In your business, they're not all good pictures. Some of them we have to clear up.
The inconsistency of witnesses and their honest mistakes are a major problem for law enforcement officers. The whole truth is not an easy thing at which to arrive. In this case, the victim of the robbery, Mrs. B. Parazoni, made no mention of stopping at the movie theater en route to the bank. The theater manager said he saw her there. This discrepancy could be either a mistake of identity, a coincidence, or of great importance. I asked Mr. Crows if he would mind telling his story to the detectives. He agreed, and I took him upstairs to the 21st Detective Squad on the second floor. In my presence, he repeated the events as they occurred. Lieutenant King questioned him in great detail.
When you saw her in the lobby, do you remember what kind of hat she had on?
Well, it wasn't a hat exactly, but something with a bandana-like handkerchief over her head. It was raining. You know, lots of girls wear those things when it rains.
And you couldn't see what color hair she had?
No, but it was the same girl. Take my word for it. It was the same girl.
Was she carrying anything in the theater? What do you mean? You mean a package or a pocketbook, anything like that?
Yeah, she was carrying a package.
What do you mean? What do you mean? Yeah, she was carrying a pocketbook.
Anything else?
An umbrella. She had an umbrella.
What kind of umbrella?
What do you mean, what kind of umbrella? What color was it? What kind of handle did it have?
Well, I don't remember those things, Lieutenant. I didn't take that much notice of it.
When you looked through the door at the building and you saw her standing there talking to me, Mr. Crows, did she have the umbrella in her hand then?
Well, I don't remember seeing it, Captain. Maybe she put it down someplace. I don't remember. She might have had it.
Mm-hmm. All right, Mr. Crows. Thanks a lot.
Look, I don't know. Maybe I'm just shooting my mouth off. I don't even know what it all means. I'm probably just wasting your time and my time, too. What am I doing here? I should be over there thinking up ways to promote that stiff I've got opening on Monday.
You're not wasting our time, Mr. Crows. We've got to consider every angle.
Well, that's what I figured. Oh, thanks a lot, Mr. Crows.
That's all right. Oh, we'll keep an eye on that candy store.
I appreciate that, Captain.
No, thanks. Then no, thanks.
Yeah, Lieutenant.
Come in here a minute, William.
Yes, sir.
Ah, what do you think, Matt?
I don't know. She could have had a good reason for stopping at a movie.
It was her.
Yes, Lieutenant. Shut the door.
Hello, William. On this robbery this afternoon, Ben, how close did you question the girl with the...
Hello, Captain.
Ben.
Well, like I told you, she accounted for her time to the minute. She said she left the office about five minutes of two. She said she went down to the restaurant and had a sandwich. And then she went to the bank and started back to the office with the payroll.
Did she say anything about any stops in between?
No, sir.
She couldn't have forgotten about making a stop someplace, could she?
No, sir. I went over it with her three or four times.
She was pretty hazy on the description of the guy, wasn't she?
Nothing. Nothing definite. She said she was pretty scared. All she could see was the gun.
How about the elevator boy?
Well, I couldn't get much out of him. His English is pretty slim. Fernandez will be in at six o'clock. I'm going to see if I can get him to ride up there with me. The man lives on 106th Street. Fernandez can talk to him in Spanish. Maybe we can find out something that way.
That's a good idea. How'd you leave it with this girl?
Well, I told her we might want her to take a look through some mugs in the rogues' gallery. See if she could pick out the man.
Uh-huh. When did you say you might do this?
I said I might call her this afternoon. She said she'd be willing to ride downtown with me after she got finished work.
Did you talk to her boss, then?
Yes, sir.
What'd he say about her?
He said she's been there about 10 years. She's a good bookkeeper. He said she practically runs his business when he's away. She's 36 years old. She lives with a married sister up in Washington Heights.
What's the deal, Lieutenant? What's this all about?
He may not have told you a straight story about what happened after she left the office.
Why don't you call her, Ben, and get some of the mugs?
When? After she gets finished work?
Now.
Oh. Want to get it straight, right?
Now.
I left the detective squad and walked downstairs through the back room where Patrolman Glass, the 124 man, was posting the latest teletype alarm. I saw Sergeant Waters come in the front door as I walked into the muster room. I called him aside and told him of an order that had come through assigning to the precinct a patrolman who had just been flopped after eight years in the 10th Detective District. The man would be in Sergeant Waters' platoon. We conferred for a few minutes regarding the proper assignment of this man, whether he should be given a fixed post or made the operator in a sector. We looked over his departmental record and discussed the mental effect that the demotion might have on the performance of his duties as a patrolman. It was decided to put him on post number three. Sergeant Waters went into the locker room to change to his uniform. Other men of the night tour were coming into the station house. I walked over to TS.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein.
Yes, sir, Captain.
That's all right. Go ahead. Take the call.
Who? Somebody's kidding you, mister. It's the 21st Precinct of the Police Department.
Yes, Captain. Get me a division, will you, Sergeant?
Yes, sir. Now, hold it a minute. You're coming here. Just a second now, miss. I've got to call up this. I thought we were going downtown.
Look over here. We are, yeah, but I've got to check something here first about the car.
Sergeant, could you ring upstairs for me?
Yeah, sure, Ben.
Hello, Miss Parazoni.
Oh, hello.
Well, are you feeling better now?
Oh, yes, a lot.
Well, who do you want up there, Ben?
Lieutenant King.
Is Lieutenant King there? Is Sergeant Klein on TS?
Ben Novak wants to talk to him.
Do you have any idea yet who that hold-up man was?
Well, the detectives are handling it now, miss.
Oh.
Lieutenant King is on his way downstairs, sir.
Oh, good. Here he comes now.
I just called up for you, Lieutenant.
Ah, hello, Ben.
Lieutenant, this is Miss Beatrice Parazoni. She was the victim in that hold-up at the loft.
Oh, yes. How do you do, Miss Parazoni? We're on our way downtown to look over some mugs to see if we can identify the man.
How's the car? Is it tied up?
I sent Whitey up to the 23rd to pick up a holdup there. He'll be back in a minute. Can you wait?
Have you got time, Miss Parazoni?
Yes, I guess so. How long do you think it'll take downtown to look at the pictures?
Well, there's a lot of pictures, isn't there, Captain?
Well, plenty.
Well, I'll call my sister. She's expecting me home for dinner.
Oh, I think you'll be home for dinner, all right. Well, it's kind of early.
Now, according to Detective Novak, you said you went downstairs about 2 o'clock or 5 minutes after. You went to a restaurant, had a sandwich for lunch, then went to the bank. You got the payroll and started back to the office. That's what she said she told you. Was that right?
Yes, sir. That's what she said. That's what I did.
You just wanted to get it straight?
How long has your boss been in business there, Miss Parazoni?
He said just before the war.
Have you been with him all that time?
Well, practically, Captain. I came in 1943.
You lived with your sister, is that right?
That's right.
At Washington Heights.
She and her husband?
And their boy. They have a boy, six.
Are you six?
You ever married?
No. No, sir.
What do you do when you're not working, Miss Parazoni? [inaudible] personal question. Boyfriend?
Getting to resist it.
Well, when something like a robbery happens, he wants to know all about everything.
Do you have a boyfriend?
No, no, sir.
Captain, are you going to turn out the platoon?
Yes, right now. They've come marching right after me. Here, miss.
Captain, can we wait in your office for a minute?
Yeah, sure. Go ahead.
All right. My next way, Miss Parazoni.
The band, sir.
Yes, sir. I'll be in just a few minutes. Do them, Captain.
He wanted her brought into the station house, but without getting her unduly alarmed. Hence the excuse about the car and the interrogation in my office instead of upstairs in the detective squad. He had timed it perfectly, posted the platoon, and instructed the sector men and men on post to correct conditions which existed at the candy store near the New Era Theater and to watch for similar problems at other movie houses in the precinct. The alarm concerning the holdup man wanted... [inaudible] for the robbery in the precinct.
Sergeant, who's the platoon?
I'll be in my office, Sergeant.
Yes, sir. Come in, Captain.
I want to get at these reports here.
That's all right. We're just disturbing you here, Captain.
No, no. Go right ahead. In the car.
Okay, Lieutenant. Close the door, William.
What else do you do in your spare time, Miss Parazoni?
Well, I read and I sit with the baby when my sister and her husband go out. And I like to go to a concert once in a while. I like music.
What else?
Nothing much else.
Movies? Do you like movies?
Sure, once in a while.
When do you go? At night?
Yeah, at night. I work in the daytime, except Saturday and Sunday. The movies are usually too crowded on Saturdays and Sundays. There's other things to do.
Ever go in the daytime?
No.
Then why did you go today?
What do you mean, today?
Who said I went to the movies today?
Did you?
Well, [inaudible] I don't understand it.
When did you go to the movies?
When I left the office.
You mean at 2 o'clock?
Yes, that's right.
You didn't say anything about that to anybody before?
Why didn't you?
It was important. It's turning out to be important, isn't it?
Yes.
Then why didn't you?
Think of it. I thought it was important before. I don't know that far.
What was the name of the man you met there?
I didn't meet any man.
Supposing I told you you were seen with a man there?
You'd find out. He said you wouldn't, but I knew you'd find out.
Shut out everything, don't we, Captain?
Most of it.
I didn't want to do it. I really didn't. I was afraid, and it wasn't right, and I didn't want to do it. But he said it wouldn't hurt my boss or me, only the insurance company. Nobody would find out about it.
Wrong, wasn't it?
Yes, it was wrong.
Why did you meet him in the theater?
He wanted me to.
Tell him how much I love him. Tell him how much I love him. Tell him how much was in the payroll.
What's his name?
Jack.
Get fooled. I didn't get fooled. He sounded so nice when I first met him.
Where was that?
A place in the mountains.
A hotel?
Yes, that's right. I took my vacation, and I went away. I didn't expect to meet any man. I wanted to do a little camping, a little fun time. So we went boating, and we swam together. I didn't even go up there with any intent. Maybe I used to, but I got over that. He was very nice. I came back to the city, and he took my telephone number. I never said anything. You know, he'd come over, and we'd go to a movie, take a walk, something like that.
How long ago was it?
Well, I got back from my vacation three weeks ago. And last Sunday night, we took a bus ride. It was so hot, we just had to get out someplace. We went up to Fort Tryon Park, and we sat on a bench up there. See, he had something on his mind. I thought I'd really find out, tell him what it was. I couldn't say a word. I didn't know he was that kind of guy.
Well, then why did you go ahead with it?
Well, I wasn't. We were supposed to get married.
Is that why? Is that why you did it?
Well, I don't think I would have married him. I just did it because he wanted the money so bad. That's all. I wouldn't have married him, ever, believe me.
Weren't you still afraid, Bea?
Yes.
Well, then why did you go through with it?
I guess because he was so nice to me. I figured I owed him something, that's all.
Where does he live?
I don't know. He never would tell me. Some hotel, I think.
Is Jack Kelly his real name?
I don't know. I think so.
Where can we find him?
Well, he was supposed to meet me tonight.
Where?
In a bar on Broadway, way uptown, he said.
I got to thinking, he said all he wanted was the money from this. I think he made the date just so I'd go through with this today. I don't think he's going to show up. I don't think I'll ever see him again.
You'll see him again. Maybe not tonight.
First Precinct, John Klein. The 80s. What? The 70s.
This precinct in the city of New York is a flesh and blood merry-go-round. Anyone can catch the brass ring.
21st Precinct. A factual account of the way the police work of the world's largest city is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolmen's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the police department of the city of New York. Everett Sloane in the role of Captain Kennelly, with Lieutenant King. Featured in tonight's cast are Derek, Mandel Kramer, Wendell Holmes, Bill Smith, and Lawson Zerwick, directed by Stanley Nustal, produced for CBS Radio by John I. [inaudible] CBS Radio Network.
