The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read
21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein.
Who's dead? Who? He was killed. Where is it? Where? 88 East what? East 70th? Who is this calling?
You are in the muster room at the 21st Precinct, the nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct.
All right. Just stay right where you are. The officers will be there right away. Yes, right away. They'll take care of it. Yes, right away.
21st Precinct. It's just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the nine-tenths of a square mile between 5th Avenue and the East River wouldn't know if you asked them that they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, the security of their persons, their homes, and their property is my job. My job and the job of the 173,000 people, 60 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm captain in command of the 21st.
What makes a city? Not buildings, not subways, not business. People make a city. From dawn to midnight, from midnight to dawn, people pour their lives together and stir up the city, where even love can lead to death.
I was working my 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. tour. When I arrived at the station house, I signed the blotter and read over reports and communications. I came around from behind the desk where Lieutenant Gorman was on duty as desk officer and Sergeant Klein on the boxes and crossed to my office. Sergeant Burns was waiting inside.
Morning, Captain.
Hello, Sergeant. Well, what is it?
Lorley went sick this morning, Captain.
Yes, I noticed that. Listed on the roll call. What about it?
Well, he's been writing Inspector Carr, too, with warrants.
Yes, I know it. Listen, what's this UF61 here? It says a radio stolen from a parked car. What kind of radio? And where was the car parked? I can't sign a report like that and send it on to Division. Was that on my tour, Captain?
Yesterday, yes. Don't you look these things over before they're written up? Harder to get by you. Who's this? Parker. Take his memorandum book and see if he's got the facts himself. If he hasn't, get on his tail. All right. What about Boney?
Well, he's been writing his recorder and Inspector Carr, too, with warrants.
Yes. I noticed they hadn't been getting along so well together, always crapping about who's going to take what pinch and so forth. No complaints to me, but I could see this had been going on. I warned them that I'd split them up if they didn't knock off.
Well, it kept going on. After the tour yesterday, I told them I was going to put them both on six posts today.
And Boney went sick this morning?
Yes, sir.
How about warrants? He's swinging.
You think Boney's malingering?
He looked all right yesterday afternoon, Captain.
Did he? Yes. Sergeant, get me the reserve surgeon, will you?
It looks like we've got a bad homicide.
Where's that?
I don't know. The board's jammed up. That's all we know about it. Call came through CB.
I caught it on the air.
Okay.
I'm sorry, Captain.
That's all right. What have we got?
It came over the air as a Signal 32 ambulance responding. I rang down the CB and they told me a woman called in, the maid, apparently. She got to work this morning and found the lady's body.
Homicide for sure?
She was a little hysterical. That's what they gathered.
No name?
No, sir. Not yet.
Did you notify the detectives?
Yes, they're just now.
That's the press again. They've been running in here since the call was put out. 88 and 70. That's a good address.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein.
Let's take a ride over there, Marnie.
Look, you know as much about it as we do. Call didn't even come through here. The detectives are just now on the way.
I gave instructions to the desk officer to reach the surgeon on reserve by telephone with a request to visit the home of patrolman Boney who reported sick under circumstances which indicated he might be attempting to evade disagreeable duty.
Men with Sergeant Burns, I drove to 88 and 70. I saw on the street the scene of the reported homicide. The house was a four-story white stone mansion built early in the century and converted within the last ten years to an apartment building, one apartment on each floor. One of the sector men had been posted at the street door to keep the curious out of the entrance hall. He told us the occurrence did in fact appear to be homicide. We went inside and took the small self-service elevator to the third floor. The door to the apartment was standing wide open. The place was magnificently furnished. There were thick wall-to-wall carpets.
I went over to talk to the maid who sat on the living room couch. She still wore the hat she had on when she arrived at work.
Hold it, Peter. I'm Captain Kennelly.
It was so beautiful, so beautiful. To walk in the bedroom like that and find her, sprawled out, cold.
Did you call the police?
Yes, sir. I called the police. When I first opened the door of the apartment, I knew there was something the matter. I knew it. The television was on, the newspapers, glasses were all over the front room, and the ashtrays full up. You see, she never left anything like that. It looks pretty straightened up in here now.
Yes, sir. I turned off the television and picked up a little, and I walked back to the kitchen. That's when I saw her. The minute I saw her, I knew it. Lying on the floor there in the bedroom, just stretched out. That yellow hair she had all turned everywhere. Always had it so neat. So neat, sir.
What's your name, honey?
Yes. Dorothy, Dorothy Ramsey.
Ramsey?
No. With an O. My family spell it with an O.
Head bashed in like that. Who could do something like that to Miss Edith? She never hurt anybody in the world. Never. Anybody in the world. So kind and nice.
Where do you live, Dorothy?
134th Street.
Where on 134th Street?
4-6 West.
Poor Miss Edith. Poor sweet little thing.
Excuse me, Captain.
Never hurt nobody.
Yes. Anyway, cruises. Only cruises.
Oh, then you better keep them out in the car. The fewer people walking around in here, the better.
Her name was Edith Camden?
Yes. Edith Camden. Yes, sir.
Does she have any family?
No, sir. No family. At least not in New York. She comes from Texas. She's got brothers in Texas. Two, I think. Poor sweet little girl. So sweet.
Must have been pretty well off to live in an apartment like this. Did she live here alone?
Yes. All alone.
She wasn't married?
No, sir.
Was she ever married?
No, sir. Not that she told me.
Did she go to business? Wouldn't you know? Well, I mean, did she have a job or anything like that?
Oh, no, sir. Not Miss Edith.
Well, what did she do?
She had a friend, Captain.
Oh.
Hello, Captain.
Oh, hello, Matt. Doris, this is Lieutenant King. He's in charge of the detectives who take all of this case.
Yes, sir. You tell him everything he wants to know.
Yes, sir. Poor Miss Edith. I don't know what I'm going to do without her. I couldn't work for nobody else. Nobody else.
Where is it, Captain, in there?
Yeah. You sit here, Doris, all right?
Yes, sir. It's all right. I'm not doing nothing.
Do you think the rent is on this place, Captain? Four or five hundred a month?
Yeah, something like that, I guess. Pretty steep.
No, there's someone else. There's a...
In here, Matt.
No, it doesn't appear that way. She was hit with, I guess. What is it, do you think?
Oh, it looks like a fire tool to me.
Hmm. Who was she? What'd she do, do you know?
She didn't do anything. She had a friend.
The tabloids are going to have a field day with this one. Made to order for them.
It sure is. There's all the elements. The mystery of Blonde and Park Avenue.
Yes, sir. I bet she's not around to read about it.
All had come in at six minutes after 8 a.m. It was now 8:25. At the moment, little more was known about the case than what we could see. A striking blonde named Edith Camden was dead from a blow across the base of the skull in the bedroom. She was dead in the bedroom of her apartment just off Park Avenue. Within minutes, the apartment began to fill up with specialists and experts. Detectives from the Manhattan East Homicide Squad arrived to work with detectives from the 21st Squad. As required, the chief medical examiner and the New York County District Attorney were notified. Latent fingerprint experts and a photographer from the police laboratory were summoned. Superior officers of the detective division, who had been notified in accordance with the manual of procedure, began to arrive on the scene. At ten minutes before nine, when I left the apartment, the investigation was well underway. I instructed Sergeant Burns to have his men resume patrol as soon as possible. On the street, a considerable crowd had gathered. The press was out in force. I suggested they direct their questions to the chief of detectives, the commander of the Manhattan East Homicide Squad, and the district attorney's office. At five minutes after nine o'clock, I returned to the precinct house.
Hello, Captain.
Sergeant. Excuse me, this board has been humming. 21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein. Chief who? Oh, he's not here. I haven't seen him. Just a second. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir.
Did you see Deputy Chief Polk this morning? He was over at the scene of that homicide.
He was over at the scene of that homicide we had.
He was too late, Captain. He was there when Captain Kennelly left. I called his office. I'll tell him, yeah.
First precinct, Sergeant Klein. Listen, Coley, somebody called in here and said there was a bus stop standing in the second floor hall of a 622E64. Well, how should I know? Some drunk must have carried it in there during the night. Walk over there and take a look.
Is that him, Sergeant?
No, it's not yet. How does this homicide look?
It's pretty heavy, Sergeant.
Well, that's all we need around here now. Another All-American, at least.
What else is doing, Sergeant?
A car struck a pedestrian on Lexington Avenue in 60th.
Bad?
A man got up and walked away from it. Then he decided his back hurt and he went into Metropolitan.
Did we hold the driver?
No, sir. The man walked out from between two parked cars right into the side of the automobile. Just give him a summons to pull the brake.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein. The detectives are all out. Can I help you? Well, that's what the detectives are all out on, that homicide. No, I don't know. I ain't any more about it.
That old age, Sergeant. You might as well be ready for it.
I know. What's it look like, Captain?
What do you mean?
Any idea who killed him?
I just started looking into it when I left.
How was he killed?
With a fire tool, apparently.
Listen, what time have you got Farrell and Eisman down for their meals?
Uh, 12:30 to 1 for Eisman, 1 to 1:30 for Farrell.
Well, switch them around because I want the car at 1 to take me downtown to Division.
Yes, sir. Let Eisman take his meal at 1 and put him on post until Farrell gets back with the car.
She was supposed to be a pretty good-looking head, Captain.
Yeah, I imagine she was. And one of those fellows in the press told me she won a beauty contest in Texas seven or eight years ago. That's how she first happened to come to New York. Judges picked her unanimously.
Texas Venus, of course.
Did they? I wonder what the judges would have called her if they'd seen her this morning.
Homicide is, of course, the most serious crime on the books. But it's not very often that detectives are called upon to deal with a murder mystery typical of detective fiction in which the guilty party must be singled out from among a number of known suspects. Nearly all homicides fall into two other categories. Either they're crimes committed in the heat of passion with the killer readily identifiable and easily apprehended, perhaps within minutes after the act, or they're felony murders committed during the course of robbery, burglary, or rape, in which case the killer seldom had any previous connection with the victim. In the case at hand, there was an element of mystery.
At 20 minutes past 10 a.m., I had finished reading and signing reports and communications.
Captain Kennelly.
Yes, sir?
Captain Kennelly, you appear to be malingering. How long do you think you'll be out?
All right, doctor, thank you. Goodbye. Much obliged.
Captain Kennelly.
On board what?
You ought to talk to the detective. Tell him to come on in.
Sergeant, who's on post number six?
Come in. When he rings in, Sergeant, leave the door open, Joe. When he rings in, tell him I've got a written complaint from a citizen about a peddler selling fruits and vegetables from a wagon over there. And tell him if he runs across that peddler to check and see if his license is okay.
Yes.
Oh, sit down, sir. What are you doing up here today?
Well, I can't tell you anything about it, Joe. I don't know anything. I was only there for a few minutes this morning.
What did the apartment look like upstairs? Plush?
Yeah, it was plush, if you want to call it that. But you better talk to Lieutenant King or the chief of detectives or the homicide captain. They've got it all over there. We don't know anything here.
Oh, Captain, I got tired of waiting out on the street. I saw all the big brass going in and none of them coming out. And one foot in the... Who did it around?
Joe, I told you. Joe, I don't know anything. You're the captain of the precinct, aren't you?
Well, I still don't know anything.
What is it? Like a Wilhelm Strasser? Somebody's got to know something.
Oh, be patient, Joe. You've got a morning paper. You've got all day to get your story. You'll get it.
I'm embarrassed. I call my city editor.
Well, don't be embarrassed, Joe. He understands. You'll never know what to talk to him. Get your story out there, Joe. The chief of detectives.
The muster room was alive with activity. Lieutenant Matt King of the 21st Detective Squad had walked in the door with the chief of detectives and the acting captain in command of the Manhattan homicide squad. Close on their heels were reporters from all of the seven daily papers with general circulation in New York, the Associated Press, and a newsman from CBS Radio. Lugging on all sides were photographers from most of the papers and motion picture cameramen. It was apparent that these top officers had avoided talking to the press at the scene of the homicide, but now they were cornered. I walked out into the muster room where the questions were being fired at a rapid rate.
Think that the medical examiner picked the time at that?
Not yet, not definitely. Sometime during the night.
It's true. It is true. It is not a double lie.
All right. Here's what we'll do, boys. There's some things we know we can't tell you yet. Give us a couple of minutes to decide what we can tell you, and you'll have a start.
Okay? Okay, fair enough.
Here's the captain's office. Here's us. I'll make sure of that.
Hello, Frank.
Steve.
What's the deal, huh?
What?
Go ahead, help yourself. Come ahead, Frank.
All right. Close that door. They'll find a way, those guys.
How have you been, Frank?
Okay, fine. How's Ellen?
Good. I'll give her my best.
Well, I guess I'll let you take care of her. Tell those boys something, Matt. They're entitled to their story.
Yes, sir, but I'd like to keep quiet about the boyfriend for a while. I don't think there's any point putting him into it yet, Steve.
No, neither do I. We can tell them that Edith Camden isn't a real name. She's just been using it since she came to New York.
Yes, sir.
What else?
Well, she worked as a model.
Not a cover girl.
No, sir, for a fashion house and at a store, but I think they know that.
How about suspects? Who, Steve?
Well, supposing I say there's four or five people we want to talk to, but that we can't divulge any names at this point.
Yes, sir. That would be good. You might want to mention her address and phone book, that we're checking every one of her friends.
No, I'd better say acquaintances.
Yes, sir.
Yes, if that address and phone book ought to make them happy. Always does. Thirty detectives assigned to the case. How's that?
Fine.
They'll want to know if there's any evidence of her being killed by a burglar or someone who entered the apartment with criminal intent.
I think you can tell them that the place wasn't broken into, Chief.
Okay.
Want to let them talk to the maid, Matt?
I think all they'll want is pictures of her. We can go that far.
All right. I guess that about does it.
All right. Let's get together some night, huh?
Oh, I'd be glad to, Chief. I'll tell Mary to call Ellen and set it up, okay?
Fine.
Okay, Matt. You can show me to the walls.
Yes, sir.
All right, Chief.
Okay.
All right, boys. Give him a chance. Give him a chance.
Why, yes! Chief, one question first. My best wants to get a photographer into her apartment. When can we do that?
Sometime early this afternoon, just as soon as the technicians from the police laboratory get finished.
What time?
What time, Matt?
1:30. It's the latest.
Why, yes! Boys, this is the story. We've got... 30 men on the job. At this moment, we have no more idea than you do who the killer is. However, there are four or five people with whom we want to talk about this. Now, in addition to that, Miss Camden had a telephone and address book. A little black book.
What color is it, Matt?
Baby blue leather.
In addition to the four or five, we'll be in touch with every person listed in her phone book in order to get some idea of a movement yesterday and last night. As I told you before, the M.E.'s office has not yet reported...
So the press had their story. All that could be... But I can tell you this. Without hindrance, the investigation was given to them. In a few minutes, the reporters hurried out of the precinct house to find telephones. The chief of detectives and the acting captain of the homicide squad went upstairs to the 21st squad with Lieutenant King. Within an hour, both had left the precinct house. Now started the real work of the homicide investigation. Detectives of the homicide squad teamed off into pairs with men of the 21st squad to work as partners until the crime was cleared. At 1:30, the car came by the station house to take me to 6th Division Headquarters, 160 East 30th.
While I was out of the precinct, a well-dressed, graying man in his late 40s was brought in by Detectives Whitey Howard of the 21st squad and Edward McInerney of the Manhattan East Homicide Squad. They took him directly upstairs to the 21st.
This way, Mr. Newfield.
You don't think it will take long, do you?
I wouldn't know about that, sir.
You got Mr. Newfield here.
Come in, Mr. Newfield.
Oh, it's like a... It's like lightning.
Cigarette, Mr. Newfield?
Lieutenant King.
Mr. Newfield?
Full name, sir?
Walter Crane.
What is your business, Mr. Newfield?
Not every day?
Every weekday, yes.
Married, Mr. Newfield?
Children?
Were acquainted with Miss Camden?
Yes, I... I deal with this. I really don't feel like smoking.
No one at your house in Winslow Park beside you?
I was all alone.
Did you see anyone you knew on the train?
Your lieutenant?
Yes.
But the moment I have to think about that, about this whole thing is bound to get in the paper, but he says about me, but those two young girls of mine, this is going to be terrible on them.
Just have me worked on them, Mr. Newfield, to tell us lies.
I haven't told you any lies.
You didn't see Miss Camden last night.
That's a lie, isn't it?
No, it isn't.
Home in Winslow Park last night, that's also a lie. You know you never left New York?
You haven't had time to think. Nothing in the world but those two girls.
The investigation of Walter Crane, so did my conference at division headquarters. They broke up at 3 p.m. Farrell drove me uptown to his partner and resumed patrol. He drove away, and I walked up to him.
Just three things, Sergeant Klein.
Hello, Captain. What's doing, Sergeant?
There's nothing like this morning, sir.
That's good. Where's Lieutenant Gorman?
I'm filling in for him, Captain. The D.A.'s office called for him to come down in a hurry.
Yeah.
The case went to that. This afternoon, but she made the arrest when he was at court last winter. This is a fine time to let us know, isn't it?
Well, the boy was going to take a plea, but he decided to stand trial for the last time.
Oh. Stand right up to the body, book him in. Yes, homicide. Middle name is G-N-U-S-F-I-E-L-D.
When he finally told us, he said she was going to break it off. She had a guy she wanted to marry. Age? 47. He was so enraged, he tore her to the head.
What?
He said he killed her because he loved her.
That's as good a reason as any.
First, please, Sergeant Klein.
You're what? You're fake.
Where is it?
And so it goes. Around the clock. Every day, every year. This precinct in the city of New York is a flesh and blood merry-go-round. Anyone can catch a brass ring in the 21st precinct. A factual account of the way the police work in the world's largest city is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the Police Department, City of New York. Everett Sloane in the role of Captain Kennelly, Ken Lynch as Lieutenant King. Featured in tonight's cast were Lawson Zerbe, Wendell Holmes, George Petrie, Joseph Julian, Frank Reddick, Eric Dressler, and Rosetta Lanois. Directed by Stanley Nist, for CBS Radio, by John I. Art Hanna speaking.
