The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 25 min to read
Out of there until they talk to him. Yeah, I'm sending him right now. Okay.
First Precinct, just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the nine-tenths of a square mile between Fifth Avenue and the East River wouldn't know if you asked them that they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, security of their homes is the job of the men of the 21st Precinct. The 21st. 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly. F. P. Kennelly. I'm captain in command of the 21st Precinct. I've been doing day duty, and at 6 p.m., I signed the blotter to go off the job, not scheduled to return until 4 p.m. the following day. The desk officer, Lieutenant Harry Snyder, was in charge of the patrol force of the Precinct. As opposed to the patrol force, whose essential duty is the prevention of crime, detectives are responsible for the investigation of crime. In the 21st, 18 detectives work out of the squad room on the second floor under the command of Lieutenant Matt King.
At 11:30, while detectives... Detective Dan Goldman sat at his desk, talking to one complainant. Two others, in different cases, waited their turn on the bench. All the other detectives on duty were out on patrol or investigations, and Lieutenant King was busy in his room with paperwork that always plagues the superior officer of the department.
You spell that E-L or L-E?
L-E.
Now, exactly where was the suitcase when you last saw it?
Well, I sat down in the restaurant, you know, in one of those booths, and I put it right alongside of me, and I thought it would be perfectly all right there. And then, when I got up, it was gone. And I didn't see anybody take it, and nobody else saw anybody, not the cashier or anybody.
All right, miss. Okay, we'll try to get it back for you. What did the suitcase look like?
Hey, listen, how long are we going to have to wait?
I'll get to you, too, in a minute. Just sit there.
Well, it was brown imitation leather, and it was about this big, with a lighter color brown strip of leather running all around it.
About how big?
Well, it was about this long, you know, about this wide, and it had genuine gold-silk snaps with little brass corners... Would you excuse me for just a second?
Yes, sure.
21st Squad, Detective Goldman. Sergeant. Listen, you fellas are going to have to keep quiet on that bench. I can't hear a word on this phone.
All right, all right.
All right, ma'am. Okay, that's better. Have you got a name, Sergeant? Okay. Yeah. But I really don't care about the suitcase. It's what's in it, Mr. Porter.
Yeah, we'll get to that in a minute. I've got to talk to the lieutenant in a second. You just sit right here.
All right, but I'm really very upset about all this.
We'll see what we can do. All right. Okay. All right. Okay. Okay. Now, he's not going to threaten you again with a knife while you're sitting in the police station. We'll take care of it all. Just sit down. Now, let me show you. We'll get trouble.
Yeah, Danny. From downstairs, Luke. They've got a robbery victim over in the Beth David admitting office.
What have you got outside?
I've got the lady with the suitcase, the fellow and his brother. They claim somebody's after them with a knife. And there's that Wilson fellow.
Where are DeLuca and Scanlon?
Well, they're over on 2nd Avenue. See if they could grab that bum they're looking for and when they catch it, have them come in. Let Scanlon catch them. You and Ludd take a ride over there to the hospital. If they don't, I'll take a ride over there myself as soon as Vitaly gets back here. Okay. Let me know if they haven't rung in in five minutes.
Okay, Luke.
Can't you two just sit there?
Oh, and I forgot to mention.
Yeah?
It has my initials on it. D-R-K.
What?
The suitcase. It has...
Oh. Oh, yeah, yeah. I'll just be one second more.
Well, all right. But really...
We'll see what we can do to find him. Sergeant Waters. Danny Goldman, Sergeant. Would you ring down at CB and put out a call to have 192 called in?
Yes, sir. Call the 21st Squad. Okay.
All right, now. It was a brown imitation leather suitcase with a light brown strip going all around. And the initials D-K.
D-R-K.
D-R-K. About this long and about this wide?
Yes. And inside, I had my Navy silk tan tongue dress and a pair of shoes to match with all of my life's gray and the high hats.
All right. Well, let me get down about the suitcase before you tell me what we can do next. All right.
The radio call for the cruising detectives was put out. They received it and pulled up to the nearest call box and rang in. But so until Lieutenant King's, the squadron was still on the move.
All right. All right. All right. All right. All right. All right.
The squad car came by the house. The janitor came upstairs and Detective Goldman joined Detective Louis DeLuca in the car. They drove to Beth David Hospital, 161 East Ninth Street and parked near the emergency admitting office. As they came through the double doors, they saw a young resident surgeon leaning against the counter talking on the telephone.
Let's see if he knows.
Yeah. Honey, look. They're the only aunt and uncle I've got. I know, but look. Honey. Norma. Honey. Oh, hi. What do you say, Doc? Honey, will you listen to me? I'll be with you a second. Okay. Look, sweetie, we'll get it worked out. Yeah, I'll see you tomorrow. Yeah, now don't worry. All right, goodbye, honey.
Doc, we're detectives. You got a man here, victim of a robbery?
Oh, yeah, he's got a nasty laceration across the base of the skull. It'll take six or seven stitches.
Were there any uniformed men around here?
Yes, there were. My name's Goldman, Doctor. This is Detective DeLuca.
Hi. Oh, how are you? I'm Dr. Samoy.
Where is he, Doc?
In the treatment room back there.
This fellow's all right, Doctor?
Oh, yeah, sure. There doesn't seem to be a concussion.
Yeah, I'm here. Go ahead.
Yeah. Hey, Doc, where you been? This happened to him before. I'm still carrying the squeal.
Well, I was busy.
Well, I want to get sewed up and get out of here. These detectives want to talk to you.
Well, listen, I'm...
Oh, hi. You remember me?
I remember you, yeah. This is Detective DeLuca.
What do you say? I'm all sewed up, but only as soon as I wash up.
All right, make it snappy, Hector.
What happened this time, Ham? Same as last time?
Glands, no. No, I learned my lesson with blondes. This one was a redhead, and this one didn't even wait until I fell asleep. She had some guy hit me on the head.
Hey, see? Boy, look at that. You ought to go back to blondes. It's safer.
Is that the truth? What's your full name again, Ham? Hamilton what? And you still live at the same place? 47.
All right. Sitting there minding my own business.
Sitting where?
In this bar and grill.
What bar and grill?
Over there, 3rd Avenue.
What's the name of the place?
I don't know. Has it got a name?
Where on 3rd Avenue is it?
Well, it's right over there by, uh, Frankie runs the place. You know, Frankie, what's his name? And his brother, Vince. Vince is the brother.
All right, we'll get to that later. Look, I better get him sewn up before that novocaine wears off, okay?
Sure, Doctor.
It's gonna hurt.
I'm in bed.
No, you'll hardly feel it. But you said last time you put the needle in there, it felt bad for you.
No, you said that you were in the bar minding your own business.
Yeah.
Well, well, the first thing you know I got talking to this girl.
The redhead?
Yeah.
Yeah, the redhead. And I buy her a drink or two, and one thing leads to another, and she says, uh, it's a pity to have to pay for drinks. She's come out to my place, I got a bottle there.
What was her name? You know her name?
Well, to tell you the truth, now that I think about it, she never did say her name.
What'd she look like?
She was nice looking at me.
All right, now hold still. Now you go right ahead, Doc, anytime you want. Besides being redheaded.
Well, you told us that. Most of the time she was down, and when she got up, I didn't see her. Oh, I just tell her, when she asked you to go to her place, you go out of the bar with her?
Yeah, sure. We went out, we walked down 3rd Avenue, and into one of the streets.
Yeah, I thought you said they wouldn't hurt.
Come on, now, they're not so bad.
Which one of them?
Well, she said, this lot where they tore down a building, and something grabbed me. It's a guy, and he shoved me into the lot with something, and poof, I am like a light for the redhead.
Oh, she helped him. Didn't I tell you?
Well, how do you know she helped him if you were, uh...
All right, all right, hold still. He made a fine. You know, what's that? What is that? Was that a crack?
How do you know she, uh, helped him?
Before he hit me, she pushed me.
Her name. You'll find her, do you think? What name he called her?
She had, uh, red hair.
In your pocket, how much money?
A lot, a lot. It was $33.48. Uh, two ten, five, one's a quarter, two dimes, three pennies.
Who'd you have along with you? Your accountant?
Hey, ho. Hey, no, stop twisting your head, ho. Ah, still. Make it easy, ho.
Now, look, what do you do for a living, Ham?
Me?
Yeah, yeah.
What's that?
Floors on the floor.
Well, somebody's got to take care of them, so I got my customers and I can went to the store at night after they close to wax the floors. It'll be nice and, nice in the morning. You see?
Yeah, yeah. He won't be long now. What are you doing back there? You, you could have sold me a new pair of pants by now.
A new head takes longer.
You ever see this redhead before tonight?
No, sir, never.
All right, all right, that was the last one. How many stitches I got?
Is there any chance you'll find a new redhead back to my $33.48?
Yeah, there's a chance of us finding it. In case that $33.48 could buy a hand.
Well, we'd spent that already.
Well, what do you find in it?
Well, we just want to tell her that the next time she sees you, it's a look at your stitches.
Goldman and DeLuca waited at the heart of the resident had completed dressing the robbery victim's wounds. Then they drove through 3rd Avenue and the victim pointed out the bar and grill where he'd met the redheaded woman and on to the station house. The robbery victim seated on a bench in the squad room and went back to 3rd Avenue to the bar, a small, narrow store. 1:10 a.m. Business was bad. One patron sat by the bar sipping a glass of beer. The bartender looked up from his tabloid newspaper as the detectives walked through the door.
What do you say?
Detectives, we want to talk to you.
Yeah? What's your name?
Henning. Frank Henning.
You play Frank?
Yeah, me and my brother, Vince.
Oh, there's no trouble. You're Goldman?
This is Detective DeLuca. A little information.
Well, if I got it, I'll tell you.
A fellow named Hamilton Bayfield.
Hamilton Bayfield, 47, 48. He's around the neighborhood a lot. They call him Hamilton.
Hamilton Bayfield, 47, 48.
Hamilton Bayfield, 47, 48.
Hamilton Bayfield, a ham.
Yeah, yeah, sure. I know him. Yeah, he polished his floors at night. Yeah, that man. What happened to him?
Around the night.
Well, I was pretty busy in here before, you know.
Well, did you see him or didn't you?
Like I said, it was busy, you know.
He told us he was in here for almost two hours. You served him.
Well, then I guess he was in, huh?
You guess he was or?
He was in. About, like you said.
That's what Ham said. He knew about how long he was in here. Look, Mac, I don't have the people punch a time clock about two hours, you know.
What time was he left?
I couldn't tell you that. I don't know. Come around here shooting questions at me for. I don't keep records on every bum that sticks his head in here.
We're trying to get you to help us out on something.
Well, I don't know nothing to help you out about.
What?
Oh, look, Mac. Just a second. Now, let me go wait on a paying customer. That's what keeps me in business.
This guy's a lot of help.
Yeah. You think we're asking him for something.
Now, look, if you don't like the service, go buy your cents right there across the street. Who needs you in here slopping up this joint?
Good sales promotion, too.
Yeah, that's why the house is packed, hanging from the rafters.
Yeah. You knew Ham was in here.
Yeah, sure he did. Buy a glass of beer. They want the world with it, you know.
You know, well, like I told you, so busy in here before, I don't know who was in and who wasn't.
Where'd everybody go? The store club in a lump?
Were you behind the bar all night?
Yeah. I worked nights. My brother worked days. I was all alone.
You got no idea what time Ham left?
No, but we had the ball game on. Might have been after the ball game was over.
It just might have been?
Well, it was a tight game. You know, a lot of them stuck around to see the finish, and then they cleared out. He might have been one of them.
Was he all alone?
Who should I know?
Was he sitting at the bar with anybody?
People on both sides of him, if he was in here. The place was jumping.
What was the name of the redhead he was talking to?
What redhead?
Ham was in here for two hours talking to a redheaded woman at the bar and buying a drink.
Well, I don't remember any redheads. Now, look, Frankie, the joint's not that big, and you weren't that busy. He bought her drinks, and they left together.
Did he tell you that?
That's what I'm telling you. Now, what's the name of that redhead?
I don't know there was such a guy. You got a lot of nerve coming around here fixing questions with me.
All right, come out from behind here. Let's go talk to the lieutenant.
What, now?
Come on, let's go.
You're going to take me over there for nothing?
Now, cut it out, Frank. You know who that redhead is, and you know where we can find her. You don't want to tell us, you can tell the lieutenant.
I didn't see no redhead.
Get your hat.
What do you want me to do, lock up the store?
Your brother lives upstairs in the building, right?
Yeah, but he works days.
You want to keep the joint open? Get him down here. You're coming with us.
The pursuit and behavior of the bar and grill operator, Frank Henning, pressed itself upon both detectives. It's apparent to them that he knew a lot more than he'd said, which is robbery and assault, a procedure to continue the interrogation at the station house. While Detective DeLuca went upstairs into the building with Frank Henning to get his brother, Detective Goldman telephoned Lieutenant King and gave him such information as they had obtained. At 1:35 a.m., detectives and their witness walked in the front door of the station house, through the muster room, and up the stairs to the 21st Detective Squad on the second floor.
How long is this going to take?
It's up to you, Frank.
What do you mean, it's up to me? What's up to me, anyway? You just take this over and tell us who that babe is.
In there. Go ahead.
You're barking up the wrong tree now.
Over there, Lieutenant. Trump.
There you are. Frank, hi. Hey, do you hear what happened to me? Why don't you stay out of my store? What are you coming around making trouble for?
Trump?
Yeah, just keep your face out of there. Who needs you? I got slugged around.
I don't care what you got. That's an attitude, huh?
Now, look, listen, detectives. I'm sleepy. Can't I go home and go to sleep?
A little while. Just sit there, Henry.
Well, I want to go to bed, so I...
It would have been all right with me if you stayed in bed tonight. Okay, Frank. Give me that. Bombs. Pack of bombs I can get in here?
Yeah.
Goldman and DeLuca, Lieutenant.
Lieutenant, it's Mr. Henning.
Lieutenant King is in charge of the squad here. I want to know what they dragged me over here for.
Have a seat there, Mr. Henning. We'll talk about it.
Look, there's nothing to talk about.
Just sit down, anyway.
He didn't tell you anything more than what you said on the phone, right, Henning?
No. Nothing, Lieutenant.
Now, Mr. Henning, the patron of your place was the victim of a serious crime tonight.
I know that.
He got robbed and assaulted not two minutes after he left. These detectives came over to you, wanted to get some information. All you gave them was a hard time.
What do they want from me?
They want the name of that redhead that was sitting there drinking with ham. That's what they want.
Well, I don't even know that there was a redhead.
Well, they were there to get it for two hours. Haven't you got eyes? I was busy. It was a busy night.
It wasn't that busy.
You listen to me, Mr. Henning. We verified what this ham fellow had to say. He was sitting at your bar for nearly two hours with his redhead.
Well, I don't remember seeing any redheads. He was buying a drink. I was busy. It was a busy night. I was pending bar, and I was interested in a ball game. The Yanks was a run behind going into the ninth. It was a tight game. It was a tough situation. He blew a two-run lead, and everybody had their mind on the game. Except this ham. His mind was on a redhead.
I didn't see no redheads.
You were up and down the bar serving out drinks, weren't you?
Yeah, sure.
Well, don't you look at the people when you give them a drink?
What do I have to look at them for? I was interested in a game. The Yanks was a run behind. I had a couple of bets riding.
Oh, you're a bookmaker, too.
Oh, I'm not a bookmaker.
Well, who'd you bet with?
Some of the fellas there.
And the fellas were making bets with each other, too?
I don't know. Some of them may have. I don't know.
All right, you were running up and down the bar, taking bets and serving out drinks. Who won the game?
The Yanks win it. They got two in a ninth.
How many bets did you take there?
I don't take bets. What do you mean? It was just some small change to make it kind of interesting.
What is small change?
A couple of bucks.
How much is a couple of bucks?
Well, I had two bucks spent with one guy. And three bucks with the other. And three with another.
That's not small change. You bet with a redhead?
I don't know if there was a redhead.
Look, Frank, we've had our eye on that joint of yours a long time. A couple of weeks ago, we had a complaint from a guy who was rolled in there.
Oh, that guy was out of his mind. He didn't have a nickel when he come in.
You've had women picking up men in there and vice versa. You're loaded with bums.
Well, can I control who comes in at the public place?
You had a couple of fights in there, and you got a reputation of running a lousy joint. Now, this happens tonight with a guy getting robbed and assaulted. He could have been killed. You running up and down the bar, making book on the ball game.
That's not making book.
Danny, is he prepared to serve food over there?
Didn't look like it to me, Lieutenant.
Let me tell you something, Frank. We're going to come over there, and we're going to flout that guy.
Oh, now, now, Lieutenant, wait a minute, will you?
Hang out in there. You got rollings and robberies and fights. Now, listen to me. You're not prepared to serve food like the law says.
I got a kitchen there.
You call it a kitchen.
Danny, write this down. Get up a report to send to the State Liquor Authority, and let them send an inspector over there.
Wait, wait a minute. Everything there that's wrong with the way he runs the place. Frank, right now, I wouldn't give you two cents for your license.
Oh, listen, I do my best. I don't want that element, but they come in. I can't lock the doors.
And, Danny, put down there that this is a pretty troublesome spot in the precinct. The owner has refused to give the police cooperation in connection with a crime.
I didn't refuse nothing.
Frank, why don't you get some sense? Why don't you tell the lieutenant exactly what you know about this?
Yeah, you better do that.
I'm telling you, I run a clean place. I try to keep that element out of there, but what am I going to do?
Who is the redhead that Ham picked up? You know her, don't you?
Yeah. Yeah, I know who she is.
Who?
Her name is Melba.
Melba what?
Melba, I don't know.
This is not being much help, Frank. Look, what? What can I do?
I'll tell you what you can do. You can buy yourself a lot of trouble if you don't cut out this stuff and stop wasting our time. That's what you can do. Now, who is she?
All right, Danny.
You're going to tell us exactly what happened, aren't you, Frank?
Yeah, sure. Why not?
What did happen?
Well, all right. You see, there's this fella I know, Joey, Joey Deason. I know him a long time.
What's he got to do with this?
I'm going to tell you now, all right?
All right. Name down there, Danny. How do you spell it?
Deason. D-E-E-S-O-N.
Joey Deason. All right. What about this Joey Deason?
Well, like I said, I know him a long time.
Yeah?
As a matter of fact, I got a financial interest in him, so to speak.
What do you mean, financial interest in him?
Well, he's owed me $142 since about a year. Well, I don't have that kind of money just to write it off for nothing, so I've been pressing him.
What does he owe you money from?
Tom, I sold him something, and he said he'd pay me the next week. Did you pay me? That's how he paid me.
Where'd you sell him?
Well, uh, it was, uh, it was, uh, the encyclopedia.
Oh, now, come on.
No, that's the truth.
What's the matter? You see, there was this fella. He's dead now. God bless him. He's a real scholar. But he was also a lush, and he had these encyclopedia botanicas. It cost him over 400 bucks with genuine leather covers, you know? It was a Sunday. He come in and said he needed the last 20, and all he had was the encyclopedia, you see? So, well, I, I lent him 20 bucks on it. I didn't figure it was bad security, a dollar a book. How could you beat it? It wasn't a week later, this fella was dead, and there I was, stuck with the books. Well, at first, I figured it wouldn't be a bad feature to have on a joint, you know, on a back bar, kind of. Guys get into arguments about a fact or something. It settled right away. You take down the right book, well, there it is. Got called on the daily news, beat a dozen ways. Anyhow, come in one day, and he said he wants them. I said, well, all right, all right, and we settled on them for 100 bucks.
You said 142.
Yeah, that's right, sure. What was the 42?
Well, he didn't have the cash to pay me right away, so that, that, that was interest.
Yeah, yeah, sure. So, he took the books and gave me the money, and I've been trying to collect it this day.
What did he want with the encyclopedia?
Well, I had to admire him. He's a hustler. He's been out for the last 10 years a couple times.
For what?
One time for breaking into somebody's flat, the other times out on the home.
Anyway, I had to admire him. He was a fellow that wanted to do better himself. That's why I let him take the books on credit, you know.
How does he connect up with this redhead, Melba?
Well, Melba is his girl, Joey Deason's.
Yeah, so to make a long story short, Joey and Melba, I haven't seen him for a couple months, come into the store tonight. And he promised me that next time... And he promised me that next time... And he promised me that next time... And he promised me that next time... Next week, I would get my money, and I was glad of that. Anyhow, things did get a little busy, like I said, and the first thing I knew, Joey was gone, and this Melba was sitting at the bar with this ham fella. Well, I didn't think nothing of it. If he wanted to buy her a drink or two, that was okay with me. Then they're gone, too. Well, I didn't think nothing of that until a little later, some guy from the neighborhood comes in and asks that we hear what happened. And he told the whole story about ham getting slugged and robbed. Well, you see, I put two and two together there.
He came up with Joey Deason.
Yeah, that's it.
Why don't you tell us this in the beginning?
He... Of course, he's into me for 142 bucks. What chance would I have to get it with him doing another bit?
Where can we get hold of this fella?
Joey?
Yeah.
Well, he's got a place over there on 2nd Avenue, a flat. You know where that Fairland Furniture Store is, 69th, 70th, something like that?
Yeah, I know.
Well, it's in that building. It's upstairs.
What about the redhead?
My guess is you find him, you find her.
You didn't see them tonight after this happened?
No, no, no. Neither of them?
No, no, no, I swear.
All right, Danny, you and Lud take a ride over there, see if you can locate this fella. And the redhead.
Okay.
Listen, fellas, uh...
Yeah?
Could you drop me by to join on the way?
Just sit right down there, Frank. I want to talk to you some more.
Go on, Danny.
I gotta get back there!
You got the car keys?
Uh, yeah, I got them.
Hey, listen, fellas, I want to tell you men, my head hurts and I'm tired. What do you say? Can I go home?
Oh, you better wait here a while, man.
No, we think maybe we'll have that redhead and the guy that slugged you in here in about a half an hour. We want you to look at them, huh?
No kidding. We think so.
Hey, listen, maybe I'll get my $33.48 back?
Well, I don't know about that, but, uh, you might want... You might end up with a set of the Encyclopedia Britannica.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. Who shot?
[inaudible]
...of the way the police work in the world's largest city is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the police department, seen in the Columbia picture Nightfall in the role of Captain Kennelly, Lieutenant King, and Sergeant Waters. Featured in tonight's cast were Bill Quinn, Eileen Palmer, Frank Moss, Bill Zuckert, Frank Behrens, and William Redfield. 21st Precinct is written, produced, and directed by Stanley Nitz.
