The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 13 min to read
21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. Who, shot? Well, where? Just take it easy. Talk slower so I can understand you. Now, where is this? Where? In the muster room. All right, don't worry about that part of it. We'll take care of it. Yeah, we'll send the ambulance right away. That's right. Right away.
21st Precinct. It's just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people packed into the nine-tenths of a square mile between Fifth Avenue and the East River wouldn't know if you asked them if they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, the security of their homes, their persons, and their property is the job of the men of the 21st Precinct. And for the tenants of whom I'm the boss. I was doing night duty. For a foggy night and between dusk and midnight, I returned to the station house from patrol to turn out the platoon for the 12 to 8 tour. Home behind the desk to sign the blotter. Precinct, on post, and inspector cars for the next eight hours were being assembled for inspection in the back room. Then to the muster room in a military manner.
"Seriously injured."
"On Wednesday, we'll see you guys, Sergeant. The governor's relief hasn't had a chance to get over yet. Notify the detectives. Go ahead."
"See, yes. We've got a report of a police officer shot at 104th Street and Park Avenue. Callbox on a corner there. He told me there was a policeman. He was excited. Hung up. Couldn't get any more out of him."
"All right, I'll go on over. Go up and then back to the other station house."
But it was still foggy and visibility [inaudible]. He and I could make out two sector cars parked along the curb. Right on the side of a new housing project where old Lord Tenement, [inaudible] in the process of being wrecked, simply [inaudible] most was wrong.
"Captain, where's the light? Okay. Take a look at that pile of bricks over there. You, Vaccaro, Farron. What is it, Sergeant? Who shot?"
"We don't know yet, Captain. He's unidentified."
"Oh, he's not from the 21st?"
"No, sir. He wasn't a cop. Sergeant, not a thing."
"Well, look on the other side there. Well, who is it? Hey, Captain, he's pretty bad."
"All right. Just step on these loose stones. They're treacherous. Yeah. On a night like this, you can't see anything."
"We never did get over this far, Sergeant."
"All right, well, look the other way then. What is it, Sergeant? Let the Captain in there. All right. Let him in there."
"No, sir. He was unconscious when I got here. Vaccaro, Farron. When you go to the car, ring in and get to the ambulance. Yes, he's about 17, I'd say. How many shots did he fire at Ballard? Three, Captain, according to Ballard. Any identification on him? Yes, he had a wallet in his pocket. Says he's, uh, [inaudible], it looks like. That's all I could see. Over here. Yes, sir. Ballard, stick with him until the ambulance comes in. Ballard, come on over here. Come here. Captain wants to see you. Who was next on us? Operator and I, Underwood. Want balls? Ballard answers, and I come on back. He was over there trying to do something for the boy. Did he tell you what happened? Yes, sir. He said he jumped him trying to break into a parked car. Chased him back in there. There was some... And he fired back now, huh? Sergeant, is that you? Yeah, right here. How are you, Captain? You signed the gun? No, sir. You better go help him look for it, Sergeant. Yes, sir. Right away. And, uh, Sergeant. Yes, sir. Check on that ambulance again. Yes, sir. Is anyone taking a look over here?"
"What happened, Ballard? It's just about 12 o'clock. Almost exactly. I turned the corner on the park street. About... About 35 or 40 feet from the corner. I saw this fellow standing right at the door there. It looked to me like he was trying to pry open the vent window. 30 feet. How could you see that far ahead in this fog? Right under the street lamp. It was that one there, Captain. All right. And... I saw him, but he didn't see me. So I figured I'd [inaudible] up on him and catch his feet. So I started to him. Yeah. He spotted me when I got within 15 to 20 feet of him, and he took off. Yeah. I hollered at him to hold up, but he kept on going. He, uh, he cut right into here, into the rubble. Yeah. I came after him. Well, [inaudible] see exactly which way he went at first. Then again, he was hiding over and around here someplace. Uh, I called to him to stand up, all right. See, I had my gun out, and I fired at the flashes. The fog was so thick, that's all I could see. I started to come in on him, and then I saw him up on the top of that pile of bricks over there. And he took another shot at me from there. See, the third one. Oh. I [inaudible] looked at him, and then I heard him scream. So I examined him. He looked pretty bad. I looked down at his person, and on top of the pile of bricks. Wasn't anywhere around. Then I ran back out the street, and I stopped the first civilian I saw. I told him to go to the call box and ring in."
"Hey, that must be the ambulance."
"Yeah, must be. Ballard, when you spotted him working on the car window, didn't you see how young he was? Well, it was pretty [inaudible] odd to see anything, Captain. He was far enough to convince you he was trying to break into the car, didn't you? And you didn't see how young he was? No, sir. He chased them off the sidewalk and under here, over this rubble. Yes, sir. He turned, fired two shots. And it wasn't until after he fired the first two shots that you returned the fire. When he got to the top of that pile of bricks, he fired a shot again. Yes, sir. And you fired two more shots. That's right, Captain. There's no possibility you could be mistaken. There's no question about him firing. No, sir. It's not possible that what you thought were shots from a parking automobile on Park Avenue back there. Well, sir, I saw the flash. All right. Let's go over. Yes, sir. He was shooting at me, all right, Captain. Come on, Underwood, McCarroll, Barron, let's have a little help get him under there. Get his leg. All right, sir. He was shooting at me, Captain. There's no question about that. Now, watch the front. Watch it there. Move over. Is it clear up ahead there? Yeah, yeah. Now, watch the loose. I sure hope that kid makes it, Captain. Too [inaudible] balanced. You better hope we find that gun."
Listening to 21st Precinct. The way police work in [inaudible] the world. Well, frankly, it would be difficult to find a detective with more savoir-faire than that mystery-solving mastermind, Johnny Dollar. [inaudible] Along from clue to clue with an impressive amount. Now, yours truly, Johnny Dollar, is looking into a baffling little matter of, say, mischief. Listen for every thrilling episode in his current case. And make yours truly, Johnny Dollar, a Monday through Friday night habit on the same station.
To 21st Precinct and Captain [inaudible] downtown of Bellevue Hospital. Lieutenant Matt King is seen to take over the investigation. And the uniformed officers continue to search there for the gun with an emergency truck. When Detective William [inaudible] meant by Lieutenant King to the address found in the wounded suspect. 733 East 107th. The old run-down tenement building. Found the name Malenki on the mailbox. He tried the hall door. It was open. He walked up three flights of stairs.
"I'm a detective. Malenki lives here?"
"Yeah, I'm his mother. What is it? What's the matter? Did he do something? Oh, no. Why don't we sit down and talk about it? No. And he got hurt, too. Harry's asleep in there. In bed. Not asleep, just in bed. I heard him come in and go to his room. I'll show you. Not my Harry."
"Yeah, I'd like to see. He's asleep. I'll show you."
"What is it, Ma? What did I [inaudible] know? My son, my other son, George. Harry's hurt. Harry. Sit down. What happened to him? He's dead, isn't he?"
"No, he's not dead. He's hurt pretty bad, but he's not dead. Tell me what's going on here. You answer if you... Hey, Ma, cut it out, huh? You'll be all right. I knew it. Hey, Ma, cut it out."
"Oh, can I go to him?"
"Yes, you can go to him. [inaudible] Look in Jersey and live there. What are you doing here? I come here and stay once in a while. When I'm in New York late. Huh, Ma? Don't I? Don't you watch, George? Don't I stay here when I'm in New York? Yeah, yeah. You're taking George to come in. I thought it was Harry. I thought it was very bad. Yeah, yeah, I know that. But how? I'm breaking into a car. He ran and fired a couple of shots at the officer. Not my Harry. No, Harry wouldn't do that, would he, George? Oh, sure. Harry no more. How should I know what he'd do? He wouldn't. Not Harry. I'm sorry, Mrs. Malenke, but it looks like he did."
While the mother and her other son got dressed to go to [inaudible] medical condition and continued at the scene, the gun could not be found. The search was abandoned for the night. The guard over the scene. Until detectives could resume their search in the daylight.
Now it's [inaudible] with patrolman [inaudible] when we walked into the moment.
"You go talk to him."
"Not so good, Captain. [inaudible] I was right through the back and into the stomach. What about his family? He was home in bed. Turned out it was another son she heard come in. Lives in Jersey. And stays there once in a while. Inform."
"Oh, hello, Matt. I heard from the hospital he's not so good. I know. Oh, yeah. You wanted one of my own? No complaints on his 42? Made one good car a month ago. He got suspicious. It was stopped on a signal. Good mixer. Reason to think he'd be trigger happy? No. Today. What'd I think? That Malenke boy ever did have a gun. Yes, Captain. We can't find any evidence. The boy was trying to break open that car. Gave Lieutenant Snyder the information on the arrest, Captain. Three shots were fired. Gun. I don't know. It must be there. For his own protection of fugitives. He fired three shots. I mean, I was entitled to defend myself. We can't find the gun. I don't think you did. I did. I called Harry Malenke. Supposed to return to the detective at my desk. And 25 minutes before in the morning, the station house opened and Mrs. [inaudible] I think the mother just came in. Great thing, Captain [inaudible] Cronin. I'm not afraid here, so you could tell me what to do. What am I going to do? I don't know. Is that what a cop is for? To go around shooting boys? Is it? What am I going to do? I don't have any money to bury him, even. You tell me. A young boy like that. Why you get this taking pause? It's about time. It's about something like this. He's the only one left in our husband. It's only my Georgie. Oh, George? He lives in Jersey over with an aunt. Maybe he'll come home now. Won't you, George? Will you come home now? I'll think about it more. I told you, I'll think about it. Is this the cop that shot Harry? Nothing, I'll bet. How could you do it to my boy? Please. Cold blood, just like that. Yeah, I guess you ought to know about cold blood, huh, George? After I get a lesson from you, baby. George ran away, left your brother dying tonight. What are you talking about? You were with him, weren't you? Me? I know you were with him. I was not. You told me you were together. Listen. You thought you got rid of the gun, but we found it. You did not. I brought it. Oh, we didn't find it, George. Not yet. You were with Harry? You were with him. Yeah, well, I was with him. It's on him, Ballard. Why didn't you tell me? You come home and you didn't tell me. You didn't say a word. Harry was dying. You didn't say a word. He's clean, Captain. Okay. What happened, George? Not a word. It wasn't my fault. I [inaudible] hurried together. I said, come on, I'll show you how to make some money. My Harry, my poor boy. So I took him over there. I stood him on the lot there off the sidewalk where they were taking down the buildings. He had a gun. I told him to hold it. I said, watch me, and I went to open the car. Then this cop comes along, and I run into where Harry was. Oh, no, no, my boy. We lit out across the place together. The cop hollered. Harry turned and shot. I only saw one, Captain, just one. Cop shot back and hit Harry. He dropped, and I tried to see if he was all right. I picked up the gun and ran at the top of the [inaudible] aisle of bricks. [inaudible] Hollered again. Shot at him. He turned. I took a shot back. It missed me, but I hollered anyway, so he wouldn't shoot anymore. What am I going to do? I don't know. Then I ran out into the street. I had a lot to do. I went to Ma's house. I was going to tell her before I went back to Jersey, but I couldn't. I just couldn't. So I went to bed. You should have told me. You should have. Ma, please. I'm telling you now. Georgie, what am I going to do? What? I don't know, Ma. I got my own trouble. Thanks, Captain. Thanks for getting me off the hook. Cool. If he didn't, he saw only one. That's all. I'm entitled to know. Sure, George. Big guess."
21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. What kind of a ring? A diamond? Yeah. She's a thief.
[inaudible] account of the way the police work in the world's largest city [inaudible] with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association [inaudible] an organization of more than 20,000 members of the police department [inaudible] of the city of New York.
