The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read
Well, who got bitten? Owl? Or? Where's the dog?
You are in the muster room. The nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow the issuance of that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st precinct.
You just wait right there in the emergency room.
Yes, right there.
Yes, right away.
73,000 people wedged into the 9 tenths of a square mile between 5th Avenue and the East River wouldn't know if you asked them if they lived or worked in the 21st. The security of their homes, Eversons, and their property is the job of the men of the 21st precinct. 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and 4 lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm captain in command of the 21st.
It was 3:55 p.m. when I came into the precinct house for my night tour, which would keep me on the job until 8 the following morning. As I signed the blotter, Sergeant Burns, who was filling in as desk officer, told me that acting superintendent of buildings of the department was in the house making a routine inspection. After I turned out the platoon, I went upstairs and found the acting superintendent of buildings on the third floor. I called his attention to the cracked plaster in the hall ceiling on that floor, and to the fact that during the last winter the radiators failed to heat the floor comfortably. On the way down, I showed him the worn condition of the stairs from the second floor to the back room, and as we came out into the muster room, I told him about the plumbing difficulties in the cells.
Captain? Captain? Do you have any idea when these repairs will be made?
There's a lot of work to do, Captain. There's nearly a hundred buildings in the department, and most of them need work, lots of work.
Oh, yes, I understand that, but some need attention sooner than others, don't you think?
Oh, yes, yes, some do. That's why I make an inspection. The muster room, for instance, it hasn't been painted since 1941. Did you realize that?
Hey, Captain, you know I'd like to do everything, and I'd like to do it right away, but there's been only so much money appropriated.
Well, it's been a pleasure, Captain. Sign the blotter and get out. A little bit, then. It's a fine schedule. I still visit the 23rd this afternoon.
Oh, uh, Mr. Balney wants to sign the blotter, Sergeant Burns. Step back to the desk, Mr. Balney.
Who is he, do you know?
He says his name is Weald. Harold, he said he'd wait. He's Captain. I'll try to get something done, I promise you that.
Oh, what, ma'am? It's absolutely necessary, Mr. Balney, that we get sufficient heat up on the 3rd.
What?
Listen, madam.
Oh, it's a long time until winter.
Please, madam.
Yes, it was a long time since last winter, too. That's when I reported.
Madam, you have my word, Captain. There'll be someone here within two weeks.
All right. That's a civil action matter. If we lose your money, we can't collect it. You better see your lawyer.
Oh, uh, I'll talk to that fellow that's waiting, Sergeant. If you can't afford a lawyer, go legal aid, because I...
Mr. Weald?
Yes, that's right.
Captain Connelly?
Kennelly.
Oh, I'm sorry.
That's all right. What can I do for you?
Well, listen, Captain, I'm sorry to bother you, but I got an awful problem with my kid.
Well, she got bit by a dog.
When was this?
Friday morning. In the playground there, you know, 66th Street, your cabin.
Division cabin, it's called.
Oh, all right. Thanks, Sergeant. I'll take it in my office.
Yes. Thanks.
My mother takes you to the playground almost every day. Have a seat there. I didn't think there was anything to it. Let me look at my chart. Yeah. Yeah, I'm working Monday. How'd you happen to get bitten, Mr. Weald?
Yeah, personally, I was working. I should be on the job now, but I thought I'd better take off the afternoon, get this straightened out.
How bad was the bite?
Bad enough, I guess. He got her in the thigh, you know. He really dug in.
Did she get medical treatment?
Oh, yeah. Yeah, my wife said the lady with the dog was very nice. Janet, that's my wife. She got kind of excited at first, but got upset. Nothing serious. It's a whole thing, you know. Until I got a call from my wife this afternoon.
What happened then?
Well, my wife was all excited. She called my dispatcher, left word for me to call her. When I did, she said somebody had been around from the board. Told her they couldn't. They didn't, but tomorrow morning, she'd have to bring the kid down for rabies shots. There's 22 shots. It takes 22 days.
She's a woman with a dog. Live in this precinct?
Well, it's in this precinct. It's Mrs. Charles Whitney, 190 Sutton Place North.
That's in this precinct?
Yeah. So I had to walk over there. It's a big apartment. It's very expensive. I started to go in. The doorman asked me who I wanted, so I told him the whole story. He buzzed up the apartment. There wasn't any answer. He told me a policeman had been around two or three times today and the day before. The policeman couldn't find anybody there either.
Is he from here, that policeman?
In a dog bite. In most cases, there's a 480V notice to be served on the owner. A notice to deliver the dog to the ASPCA for observation.
Well, anyway, I got to talking to the doorman, and he said he thought, sure, somebody was home because the elevator man heard the dog barking in the apartment when he went up there on the floor for something else this afternoon.
Oh, is that so?
Well, I'm only going by what the doorman said the elevator man said. He was very nice, but I don't want my kid to go through any 22 shots.
What's more important, the dog or the kid? What do you think, Mr. Weald?
Well, I know what I think. The important thing is what you think.
That Mrs. Whitney, her husband, is a big shot judge. The doorman told me, well, I'll sit here, but is that any action? What I want is action.
That's what you're going to get. 480V on the dog bite case. You see? Captain, he just said it was still hanging. They haven't been able to serve it.
That's Judge Charles. Now, listen, the father of the child the dog bit is in my office. He's been told to bring the child down to start a series of 22 rabies injections beginning tomorrow morning unless that dog is delivered today. There doesn't seem to be anybody there.
There's somebody home, Captain.
Well, the father says the doorman told him there was somebody home. Now, get on it.
I went back into my office and told Mr. Weald, the father of the dog bite victim, that we would make a further effort to serve the 480V notice on the owner of the dog. I advised him to return to his home and promised that we would notify him later concerning any results we obtained.
Doorman Singleton rang in and reported that he again went to 190 Sutton Place North and attempted to reach the occupants of the Whitney apartment by the house phone. There was no answer. He left a copy of the notice with the doorman. He was instructed to go upstairs and knock on the door. In the meantime, I read and signed such reports as had accumulated since I was last on duty and placed them in the box to be sent by messenger to division headquarters.
At ten minutes to five, I went back out into the muster room and walked over to the desk.
I tried to reach the judge at his office, Captain.
Good. Sergeant Klein, did Singleton ring in again?
No, sir.
Judge Charles Whitney's office, please.
I thought this might be the quickest way to get some information, Captain.
It might be, yes.
Sergeant Burns at the 21st Precinct. Can you go with me?
Yes, sir, Captain.
Do you have a copy of him?
The American Fire Association's defense expects him back tonight. He's flying in.
Did Mrs. Whitney go with him?
No, sir. As far as his secretary knows, Mrs. Whitney's at home. Look up the telephone number of their apartment and call. It'll be listed, though.
Is that Singleton, Sergeant?
Who can't?
This is Singleton.
Oh, wouldn't she open the door?
No, sir. I heard that the Department of Health just has to examine the dog, that they won't molest or mistreat the animal.
Yes, sir, Captain. For a car to come by the house for me.
Yes, sir, Captain.
Open the door.
Yes, sir, Captain.
No headline. This is the 21st precinct and Captain Frank Kennelly. The disease of rabies is almost [inaudible]. This is due almost entirely to the cooperation between police and public health authorities and the strict enforcement of the laws relating to dog bite cases. These laws call for observation of dogs and other animals who are carriers of the disease after they have bitten and for compulsory treatment of human victims bitten by an animal that has escaped. The fact that the disease is now rare does not lessen the strictness of enforcement. The idea is to keep it. It is rare.
At 5:05 p.m., the car came by the station house and drove me to 190 Sutton Place North, a new apartment building in a high rent classification. As we drove up, I saw Patrolman Singleton on the sidewalk in front of the building. The man was standing there talking to him.
Wait for me here.
Mr. Tedburn is the superintendent of the building. The resident manager.
Mr. Tedburn, how do you do?
You've been waiting down here since you rang in, Singleton?
Yes, sir. I really don't see what's all the excitement, Captain.
Don't you? The Whitneys are respectable people. He's an important judge. To have policemen running through the halls over something like this is ridiculous.
Mr. Tedburn, I've just been talking to the father of the girl who was bitten by that dog. If that dog isn't delivered for observation, that four-year-old girl will have to start a series of 22 injections. Is that ridiculous?
Well, I just want to say the embarrassment is all.
There's no embarrassment on our account. If she'd accept service and the notice, everything would be very quiet and simple.
What kind of dog is it, Singleton?
The doorman told me a boxer cat.
That is right. They box.
Big fella, huh?
Yes, sir.
All right, let's go up.
Yes, sir.
Do you mind if I come along also?
I'd be glad to have you, Mr. Tedburn. You can see that we don't embarrass anyone.
The doorman held the door open for us and we walked into the foyer of the building. It was decorated in black and white. On the elevator, Singleton directed the operator to take us to the 14th floor. When we got off, Mr. Tedburn led the way to apartment 14B. No one was in the hall. The officers on the floor didn't know what was going on or they didn't care.
Ah, this is it.
Go ahead. Try again.
Yes, sir.
We're police officers. We want to talk to you.
But the neighbors haven't complained. He certainly does raise the roof, doesn't he?
Mrs. Whitney!
You know, Captain, I'm beginning to more and more see this thing from your point of view.
Are you? Under these circumstances, I think I have a right to use my pass.
Mrs. Whitney!
You can't leave!
What is she doing?
I want to put the dog in the other room. I want you to shut the door and let me alone.
You don't seem to understand the seriousness of this, Mrs. Whitney. You want to take Jeff away.
I don't want to take him away. He's all we've got. Jeff's all we've got. We have no family. Just Jeff. That's all.
I'm not going to take him away. I just have to give you this notice.
Singleton.
Oh, yes, sir. Here it is.
I want you to take this, Mrs. Whitney.
No. No, I won't. It's a notice to deliver your dog to the ASPCA by 10 o'clock tomorrow morning.
Well, I'll take it, but I won't deliver it. I won't. You can't have him. He's the only thing I've got left. The only thing.
All right. Shut the door.
Thank you, Mrs. Whitney.
I won't.
Do you think she will bring that dog down there?
I don't. She's been served with the notice.
Okay, Singleton. Get back on the job.
Yes, sir. People can live in a building 20 years, and you never know they ever exist for 20 years.
Hit that elevator bell with it, Singleton.
Yes, sir.
Then a little thing like this can cause so much trouble.
What's the trouble, Mr. Tedburn?
People seem to manage the big ones.
You rode down on the elevator. I thanked Mr. Tedburn. I thanked him for his assistance and came out of the building with Singleton. He resumed walking his post, and I got into the car and went back to the precinct house. There, as the officer who served the 480V form on Mrs. Whitney, I filled in the lower half and delivered it to the desk officer to be forwarded to the Bureau of Preventable Diseases, Department of Health.
Sergeant Burns told me that Patrolman Mercado had come upon a boy, 17, in the act of turning in a false alarm. He chased him up the stairs of a tenement and over the roofs of three adjacent buildings before he was apprehended. The boy admitted turning in at least five false alarms. I went on patrol of the precinct, during which I stopped on post number two, saw Patrolman Mercado, and congratulated him on the arrest.
I was still on patrol. There was a radio signal to call in. He stopped at the nearest box, and I was told by Sergeant Klein that a visitor was waiting for me, Judge Charles Whitney. I had my operator drive me around to the precinct house. When I got out of the car, I instructed him to pick up his partner, who had been taking his meal period, and resume patrol. As the car drove away, I crossed the sidewalk and walked up into the muster room.
I was there for about a month.
Captain, 21st precinct.
Where's the Judge?
I suggested the Judge wait in your office.
How's he doing, Sergeant?
Poor.
Judge Whitney?
We've met before, haven't we?
Yes, I think so. At some dinner.
Yes, sir, I know. Captain.
Yes, that's right. We were there.
I'm sorry if we found it necessary to be a little insistent with Mrs. Whitney, but I don't have to tell you the law in these dog bite cases, Judge. If I wasn't able to effect service the way I did, I would have been required to get a warrant and break the door down. I hope you were able to explain that to Mrs. Whitney.
Captain, I haven't been able to explain anything to Mrs. Whitney. She wouldn't open the door for me.
No.
I came home from the airport and went upstairs and tried my key. She had the chain on the door. Wouldn't open it. Wouldn't even talk to me. Building manager came upstairs and told me what had happened.
Well, I'm sorry, John.
Well, it's not your fault, Captain. I don't blame you. I should have seen it coming. That's why I even knew it was coming, and I couldn't bring myself to believe it.
What's that, sir?
A breakdown. I should have seen it the night I left for Boston. It was the same night that Jeff bit the child. He's a boxer, you know, so we named him James J. Jeffrey. Jeff for short. I told her before I left that she would probably be called upon to deliver the dog for observation. And I should have seen from my attitude then that this was going to happen. I was in a hurry to catch the plane. All right, until then, I understand. When the dog bit the child, took the mother and the child to the emergency room, paid the bill, so forth.
Yes, that's the report we got, too. But the minute I mentioned the possibility she might have to turn Jeff over for observation, she changed.
What was the reason for the change, you know, Judge?
Yes, I do. I think I do. See, Captain, we had two sons, Richards and Charles Jr. They were a year and a half apart, 19 and 20. They were in school at Yale. Last June, they were driving down to New York after a car turned over on America. You have children of your own. You can imagine what it did to us. But that didn't help. Nothing helped. Myself, I found escaping my work a judge can work hard, you know, and I did. But Nora didn't have anything like work. I suppose she turned to the dog. Jeff was the boy's dog. She thought the possibility that she'd lose the dog, that's the answer.
It probably is, yes, sir.
Wouldn't even open the door. She doesn't even trust me. If I'd have known what the circumstances were, perhaps we could have used some other means.
Any way for you to know, Captain, I'm not worried about that now. He's locked up in there alone. That's what I'm worried about. I don't know what's prior.
Well, if you want to go into the apartment, Judge, I can. Call the emergency squad to give us a hand. They have a way with doors now.
Yeah, but it's only as a last resort.
No, I'd like to try persuasion. I had the door open this wide, the same as you did. I called to her. She wouldn't answer. I couldn't think of anything else to say or do. I came over here. Do you have any ideas, Captain, besides the emergency squad?
Well, perhaps I have one, just one. It might work. I don't know.
Anything, Captain. I'm willing to try anything.
Judge Whitney was a forlorn-looking man as I left him sitting in my office. I walked out into the muster room. I gave Sergeant Klein instructions to have a car drive around to the precinct house to pick us up. Also, I told him to have Sector Car No. 1 go to the home of Harold Weald, the father of the dog bite victim. They were instructed to locate Mr. Weald and ask if he would accompany them to 190 Sutton Place North.
The car came by to drive Judge Whitney and myself to his apartment house. We rode the elevator to the 14th floor in silence.
This way, Captain.
Yes, I know.
You're trying your key again, Jeremy. I was calling the dog. He comes to the door. Maybe she will, too. That's a good idea.
Yeah, boy. Hey, Jeff. Hey, Jeff. Hey, Jeff. Come on, Jeff.
She has him in the back with the door closed. That's where she had him before.
Nora. Please. Please come to the door, Nora. Please.
Nora.
Let me try.
This is Whitney.
This is Whitney.
Hello, Captain.
Judge Whitney and Mr. Weald.
Judge.
Patrolman Singleton. How do you do?
Please do nice. He told me about all the trouble. You've been having, Judge. I don't like to cause any trouble, but after all, my little girl...
I think it's the other way around. The trouble being caused is concerned, Mr. Weald. Now, don't worry about that.
Well, I think you'd better call him. This isn't going to do any good.
Try again, Judge. Once more.
Nora. Please come to the door, Nora.
Nora.
I think she's coming.
Please.
Close the door, Charles. Let me in, Nora. You've got to.
Close the door and go away, Charles.
Sweetheart. Sweetheart. Now, please.
I'm not going to let you in. You're a part of the law, too. You're on there.
Mrs. Whitney.
Close the door, please.
This is Mr. Weald. He's the father of the little girl.
Oh. How is she?
She's all right, I think, ma'am. I'm sorry. I'm terribly sorry. Jeff never'd bitten anyone before. I think it was an accident. I think he was just trying to get that red ball she was playing with. Just the red ball. He's a very good dog, really.
Yes, ma'am.
Are you sure she's all right?
We hope she'll be all right. She has to take 22 injections.
22 injections? Why?
Because we can't get Jeff to see that he doesn't have rabies.
Oh, Jeff doesn't have rabies. You know it, Doug.
We have to make sure, ma'am. That's the law.
I don't want to hear about the law. That's all I ever hear about.
You don't want that little four-year-old girl to go through 22 injections, do you, Mrs. Whitney?
Oh, no. That would be a shame.
Well, it's up to you.
It's not up to me. Jeff doesn't have rabies. Anybody can see that. Anybody.
When were you told to bring your little girl to the Department of Health, Mr. Weald?
Tomorrow morning.
Tomorrow morning.
Tomorrow morning. 10 o'clock.
Oh, 22 at once?
No, ma'am. It takes 22 days.
Oh, no. Poor little girl.
Now, nothing will happen to Jeff, Mrs. Whitney. Believe me. They'll take good care of him. You'll have him back.
They'll keep him. They'll take him away from me, just like everything else.
22 injections.
That's right.
And she's such a little girl. How old is she?
Four.
Yes, four. That's right. She was crying and her legs hurt. That's right. But those little curls were the ribbons. I remember those little curls were the ribbons. I never had a little girl. I always wanted one.
Not 22 injections.
Yes, ma'am. 22.
Please close the door.
Mrs. Whitney.
Please close the door. I can't get the chain off if you don't close the door.
Yes, ma'am. Take it easy.
There's a lot to be sorry about, isn't there?
So much.
Thank you, Mrs. Whitney.
Nothing to thank me for. Just in there, in the bedroom.
I'll see that he gets where he has to go, Captain.
Good.
Young man?
Me?
Yes.
Yes, ma'am, Mrs. Whitney.
Watch her. Watch her every minute. Every minute of your life.
Yes, ma'am.
Because without her, you won't have any life.
First brief, thanks, Sergeant.
He jumped? Or he's going to jump? Where is he? On a ledge? Where is he? He's 71?
And so it goes. Around the clock, through the week, every day, every year. Precinct in the city of New York is a flesh-and-blood merry-go-round. Anyone can catch the brass ring. The brass ring can catch anyone.
21st Precinct. A factual account of the way the police work in the world's largest city is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the Police Department, City of New York. Everett Sloan and Captain Kennelly. Featured in tonight's cast were Lawson Zerbe, Wendell Holt, and the police department. Holmes, Barbara Weeks, Bill Lipton, and Donald Bain. Written and directed by Stanley Ness. Gaylord Avery speaking.
