The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 19 min to read
21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein.
He's jumped or he's going to jump? Where is he, on a ledge? Where is he? He's 71? What floor?
You are in the muster room at the 21st Precinct, the nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct.
Yes, sir. I'll send assistance right away. Right away. You just stay there and wait for the officers. Yes, sir.
21st Precinct.
It's just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the nine-tenths of a square mile between Fifth Avenue and the East River wouldn't know if you asked them if they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, the security of their homes, their persons, and their property is the job of the men of the 21st Precinct. The 21st. 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm captain in command of the 21st.
I was working my day tour, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. When I returned from patrol of the Precinct at 2:20 p.m., the desk officer, Lieutenant Snyder, told me he had received word from the district attorney's office that nine of my men, Sergeant Collins and eight patrolmen, had been instructed to appear before the New York County Grand Jury at 10 the following morning. All had been at the scene when a gang of five safe burglars were apprehended three weeks earlier. I took the teletype communication concerning this matter and went upstairs to Lieutenant King's office and the 21st Detective Squad on the second floor.
Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir.
Hello, Matt. Come in, Captain. How are you, Captain?
Oh, all right, except for this communication we got.
What communication is that?
This. Matt, there were four safe and loft squad detectives there and four of your men when that collar was made. They don't need any of my men to make a case for the trial, maybe, if it goes to bat, but not before the Grand Jury.
I don't think so, Captain. All of those men are working the day tour tomorrow to take nine men away and really knock a hole in my platoon.
Well, it's a mistake, Captain. Some assistant down there probably told his clerk to get all the police witnesses to the Grand Jury, and he did. We'll get it straightened out.
Come in.
Captain, Sergeant Fine on CS calling you.
Oh, he's on one.
Checking out my desk, Captain. Thanks, Coleman.
Captain Kennelly, in a few minutes, I'll be right there.
I left the 21st squad and went downstairs through the back room where the attendant was sweeping up. He nodded at me, and I nodded back. I stepped out into the muster room. Lieutenant Snyder was talking to a couple of complainants who stood before the desk. I walked over to the telephone switchboard.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein. You take your meal now.
What is it, Sergeant?
He's got a piece of bad news, Captain.
Yes, what?
A woman called in here from Queens. She said she was a neighbor of Sergeant Burns and his wife.
Yes.
She said that Mrs. Burns just got a telegram from the Army. That boy was stationed at Fort Devens. He was killed in an accident this morning.
A neighbor said she was calling from his house. The doctor's there for Fred's wife. They think he ought to come home right away.
Where is he?
On patrol, Captain.
All right, you better call him. This is Sergeant Klein, the 21st. Would you have 651 call the 21st? Yes, sir.
How did it happen? Did they know?
No, sir. Just the telegram notifying him so far. The neighbor said he didn't say much.
Oh, God. He was the only child, wasn't he?
His name was Fred, too. Fred Jr. Always talking about that kid. They loved to fish together. That's all he used to do when he was swinging or working the night to go fishing with his wife.
That's what I say to him when he rings in, Captain. I'd rather not be the one to tell him. Have him come into the house. I'll talk to him.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein.
That was Lieutenant King, Captain. They don't need any of our men for the grand jury.
Oh, good.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein.
Hello, Fred. Come into the station house, will you? I want to talk to you.
Come in, will you?
A large part of a policeman's job is conveying bad news. Hardly a day goes by that we're not required to notify a wife or mother, a father or husband that someone close is dead or sick or in serious trouble. These notifications are difficult enough when total strangers are involved. Telling a man you've known and worked with that his only son is dead is twice as hard.
I waited in my office. I tried to read over a few of the reports that had accumulated, but my eyes turned automatically through the open door into the muster room. Finally, I saw Sergeant Burns walk in. He approached the desk, talked for a few seconds to Lieutenant Snyder. Sergeant Klein busied himself filing aided case cards. When Sergeant Burns crossed the muster room toward my office, my attention turned to the file of reports in front of me.
Captain?
Hi. Come in.
Yes, sir.
Shut the door, will you, Fred?
Lieutenant Snyder says you wanted to see me, Captain.
Yes, that's right. Sit down, Fred.
Yes, sir.
I've got some bad news for you, Fred.
What kind of bad news, Captain?
A neighbor of yours called in.
Nothing happened to Ruth. My wife's all right.
She's all right, yes. It's your boy.
What happened to him?
The army sent a wire. He was in an accident.
Yeah? Are you sure? Are you sure it was Freddy?
All we know is what your neighbor called in and told us, Fred.
How did this happen? What kind of an accident? Where?
I don't know, Fred.
Dear God. What am I going to do? Tell Ruth.
She knows, Fred. She knows.
Why I came to your home.
Oh, that's all. He's 19 years old. When he got out of the army, he was going to try and get on the cops. I told him all the time, you don't want that. Get into something where there's more money. It made me feel good that he wanted to get on the cops, like I was setting a good example.
Well, sit still, Fred. With a friend, she'll be all right.
Just besides me and him, that's all she's got, Captain. Just me and him. Just me now.
Can you stay in here, Fred? Or do you want me to stay with you?
No. No, no, sir. That's all right. You, you, you don't have to stay.
All right, Fred. Whatever you want.
What I want, I... I got to have.
I'll be outside.
Yes, sir.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein.
Somebody ought to stay in there with him, Captain.
He wanted to be alone.
Hello, Captain. Matt, is that my message? About your men not being needed at the grand jury tomorrow?
Yes, sir. I gave it to him. You know what happened? It's a laugh. Somebody down at the DA's office.
What's next?
Fred Burns just got word his son was killed.
We went fishing.
And don't you think somebody ought to be in there with him?
I don't know whether it's good to leave him in there.
You ought to have company.
This is one time a man doesn't need company. Not when he's crying.
In about 20 minutes, Sergeant Fred Burns came out of my office. He changed to civilian clothes. I offered to have a man accompany him home. He refused. The rest of the afternoon was quiet. I turned out the platoon for the night tour at 4. From 4:30 to 6, I completed my paperwork and dictated a special report regarding changed conditions in the precinct in connection with the reopening of the school. Shortly after 6 p.m., I signed the blotter and left the precinct to go off duty.
The following day, before I reported for my night tour, I drove to the home of Sergeant Burns in Queens. I found the street was a little difficult, but every house was alight, except for the numbers on the doors. I parked my car and headed up the flagstone walk. Number 72 was in the vestibule, on the door.
Excuse the way things look around here.
Oh, yeah, sure. All that's happened and Ruth hasn't been much chance to get things straightened up. Brought him home late last night.
Well, he's all right, Captain. We can't blame her. I feel that way myself.
He's thoughtful. He's thoughtful. He'll be 19.
Why don't you see him like this in your own living room? He just got made corporal, just for you. Army sent that flag along with him, for having two soldiers come over for the...
Army's been very nice about the whole thing. He called me up on that last night, and the whole thing happened.
Would you like a cup of coffee, Captain?
No. No, thanks, Frank. There's some on the fire in the kitchen.
No, never mind. I think I'll have some myself. I haven't had a thing hardly since I first found out.
I'm just going in the kitchen, Ruth. I'll be right back.
I'll get through this, you know.
You sure no coffee?
No.
19 years old. Just 19. A hit-and-run driver. He did it.
Yes, I know. Well, Lieutenant Gorman told me when I called the station house.
Oh, yes. He was here last night.
What's the best, Captain? He and everybody from my squad, everybody to a man. That makes you feel good.
The driver?
No. It was in town. You see, Freddy was made corporal, and the next night he got a pass, went into town to celebrate. You know how a kid is. Every fall's for a celebration.
Yeah, I know.
I had this other soldier with him, and they went out and celebrated. I guess they had a beer or two. I don't know. He wasn't much of a drinker, just a beer or two. That's all he'd ever touch. Anyway, they were walking back to get the bus for camp. I guess he stepped out into the street. This car came along fast around the corner. The other boy got out of the way, all right, but did the other boy get a look at the car?
Yeah, he got a look at it. He said it was a black two-door. That's all he could see. The only thing he did say is he thought it was a soldier who was driving it. He couldn't even be sure of that. They're working on it. The MPs, the state police up there in Massachusetts.
Hope they get the guy.
You sure no coffee, Captain?
No, thanks. Hope they get him. That kid from nothing to 19 years old. I put about half of me into what's laid out there in that living room. Whoever it is, I want him to. I wouldn't want him to do it to another man's son.
I talked to Sergeant Burns a few minutes more. Finally, his wife came into the kitchen. She was a little better. He stayed out until Monday. When he reported back on the job for the night tour, I talked to him in my office for several minutes. He seemed sadly composed considering the circumstances and told me his wife had overcome the initial shock. After I turned out the platoon, I met with a committee of three Lexington Avenue merchants who complained of high-pressure solicitation of funds by little-known charitable organizations. I referred them to the Department of Welfare and phoned for an appointment for them to see the Deputy Commissioner the next day. At 5:30, I went on patrol and returned to the precinct house at 7:10 p.m. and walked over to T.S.
A couple of messages for you, Captain.
Yeah?
And there's someone waiting for you.
Who's that?
Well, he said he was with the first call, Sergeant.
Yes.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Clarence. Where is that? Yes, ma'am. We got a call on that from someone else a few minutes ago. The officers are on the way over. They should be there any second. You're welcome.
What's that, Sergeant?
A family argument. Why, he's 67.
No.
Who is it that's waiting for me?
A Lieutenant Nalen, Captain. He says he's with the 1st Army Military Police Apprehension Unit.
Well, where is he?
I asked him to wait in your office. I told him you would be back in the house any minute. He's in there.
Okay, thanks. Yes. I'll be in my office.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Clarence.
Lieutenant Nalen.
I'm Captain Kennelly. How do you do, Captain?
Lieutenant Richard Nalen, 1st Army MP Apprehension Unit. I'm glad to know you.
Sit down.
Thank you, sir.
Well, what can I do for you, Lieutenant?
We've got an arrest to make in your precinct, Captain.
Oh? You need some assistance?
Yes, sir. I think we will. But that's not the problem right now.
What is?
This fellow is AWOL. We've had the house staked out since last night. His wife's apartment, that is.
Mm-hmm.
We're 90% sure he's up there, but nobody's thrown their head out of the place since we've been watching.
Yeah?
We thought either he or his wife would come out today. We'd like to wind it up, but we don't have a warrant. And being federal officers, we can't go in there without a warrant.
We can't go in there either, Lieutenant. Not under these circumstances. We've got to have reason to believe that there's evidence of a crime or a fugitive from a crime incident. And by crime, I mean a felony, not AWOL.
He also is a fugitive in connection with a felony.
Is he?
Yes, sir. The Massachusetts State Police got a warrant out for him on manslaughter. He's suspected of driving a hit-and-run car that struck another soldier and killed him.
What was the name of the victim?
We got the request to apprehend him from the MPs at Fort Devens. I didn't notice whether it was mentioned in the report or not. Oh, yes, sir. Here it is. Corporal Fred Burns, Jr.
I think we can be of assistance to you, Lieutenant.
Thanks, Captain. Anything you can do will be appreciated.
We're glad to do it. The victim's father is a sergeant of police in this precinct.
That's a strange coincidence.
It doesn't happen every day. It's funny.
The case was properly in the province of the detectives, and I took him upstairs to Lieutenant King's office. There, he said the suspected soldier's name was John Escher, private, first class, age 22. He said that Escher had a 24-hour pass on the same night Corporal Burns was run down. Escher borrowed a car from a friend. He returned it early the next morning. There was a large dent in the front right fender, and the headlight was smashed. Escher failed to report the duty to the police. He was arrested the following day and had been AWOL since. This information has been forwarded to the First Army Military Police by Fort Devens MPs with a request that Private Escher's listed residence be checked. The residence was a small flat on the third floor of an old law tenement building on East 76th Street. Lieutenant King and I sought all the available information from the MP officer.
How many men have you got planted over there now, Lieutenant?
Well, Captain, we got the request yesterday from Fort Devens. I sent two of my best men right to the address. We've staked the place out. We haven't seen either her or him since we've been there.
He hasn't come out.
Well, maybe he's not. There, she might have gone to meet him someplace.
There's somebody there, sir. I got a hold of the people who live downstairs from them. They've been hearing voices and people walking around up in your place.
People?
That's what they said. Two people at least.
Has Escher had any previous criminal record you know of, Lieutenant, before he went into the service?
No, Lieutenant, no record at all. He had gone AWOL once before. That was limited to company punishment. He overstayed a leave of 48 hours.
Well, Captain, I suppose we can have a look.
All right, Matt. But there's one thing.
Yes, sir?
Can I use your phone to PS?
Sure.
Thanks. Yes, Captain.
Lieutenant King, put out a radio call for Sergeant Burns. Tell him to come into the station house.
I think he'd like to go along.
I'm sure he would, Captain.
In five minutes, Sergeant Burns was in the station house. He appeared to accept his instructions as he would any other duty assigned. We left the precinct house for the East 76th Street address at 10 minutes to 8. It was just getting dark. Lieutenant Nalen spotted the two men he had planted watching the building. He signaled for them to join us. Lieutenant King gave his instructions. Lieutenant Nalen, Sergeant Burns, and myself would lead the way up the stairs to the fourth floor. An M.P. and a detective right behind us would proceed straight up the stairs to the roof of the building to block an escape that way. The other officers would remain on the third floor landing.
All right, you drop off here.
Yes, sir.
And the M.P.s handle it, Fred. We'll stay in the background.
Yes, sir. You keep away from the boy. I'll talk to you.
Open the door. I'm a police officer.
Where's John?
Open up or I'll kick it in.
Open up.
Where's John?
He's not here.
Shouldn't be?
All right. But please, he's scared. He's scared half to death. He told me about it. He actually did. He said he didn't see that soldier. It wasn't his fault. It really wasn't.
Why didn't they stop the car?
I don't know.
Where is he?
He don't know why either. He just didn't.
Where is he?
In the bedroom.
Is he armed? Does he have a gun?
No, he doesn't have a gun. Wait a minute, please. I don't know what's the matter with him. He's sick, I think. He used to come home and he wouldn't leave the house. He wouldn't let me leave. Not even for food. He had medicine to eat all day. He's sick. I know he's sick.
All right, you stand there. You, you take care of her.
All right. Push it in.
Okay, Lieutenant. Go on, Trent.
That window, boy. What are you trying to prove?
The street.
John, we've got all the time in the world.
I'll jump. I swear I will.
Yes, Dean and Ambulance. Tell them what we've got.
Okay, Kevin.
Come out of that window, boy. Get some sense. This isn't so bad. Not worth dying over.
Can I talk to him, Kevin?
Sure, Trent.
Listen, son.
I'm not listening. Don't try to con me.
All right, you're in a little trouble. Everybody's been in a little trouble.
Stay where you are. I'll go out, I swear.
That'd be a smart thing to do, wouldn't it? Trying to solve everybody's problems, huh? You'll solve mine? What about your wife? What about your folks?
Don't try to con me. Stay where you are now.
All right, now come on. Get out of there. Why make things worse than they are?
It's not that bad.
Plenty bad.
Not so bad. For other people, maybe.
Everybody knows you're sorry about running down that soldier. An AWOL isn't anything. It's nothing.
I'm telling you to stay away. I'll go out.
Do you know this? The soldier that you ran down?
No, I didn't know.
Well, then what are you worried about? Come on out of the window. You're throwing your life away over something that doesn't mean a thing to you. You'd probably get out of this whole thing anyway. But it was an accident. Kid stepped off the curb. Right in front of you. I had the light with me. It wasn't my fault. I didn't even see him. I just got a little excited. That's all. Just a little excited.
All right, now come on. Let's sit down and talk about it, John. Just tell us about it.
What did they do to me?
Nothing much. Take my word for it.
What's the matter? Is there a guarantee?
I don't have any guarantee. You'll have to take your chance. But look at the chance you're taking going out the window. Close the window. Sit down in that chair.
I did that.
You want to go out the window?
I didn't know what else to do about it. I'm just causing anything else to do.
I'm Lieutenant Nalen of the MPs. Your personal lieutenant.
Sergeant, you're still all right.
Are you still?
No.
What do you think, Sergeant Klein?
What's the matter there?
How do you know?
So it goes. Around the clock, through the week, every day, every year. It's a precinct. The precinct in the city of New York is a flesh-and-blood merry-go-round. Anyone can catch the brass ring. Or the brass ring can catch anyone. ...all account of the way the police work in the world's largest city. It's presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the Police Department City of New York. Everett Sloane in the role of Captain Kennelly. Ken Lynch as Lieutenant King. Featured in tonight's cast were Wendell Holmes, Lawson Derby, Ralph Camardo, George Petrie, Michael Dryden, and Elaine Ross. Written and directed by Stanley Nist. Produced for CBS Radio by John Ives. Gaylord Avery speaking.
