Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
21st Precinct artwork

From the 21st Precinct collection

The Pair

Episode 095July 30, 195527 min 34 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 18 min to read

25th Precinct, Sergeant Waters. Yeah, Colby. How many prisoners you got there? Yeah. Yeah. Where is it? Inside the bar there? Yeah. Yeah.

You are by transcription in the muster room at the 21st Precinct. The nerve center. Call is coming through. You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct.

All right. I'll send a call around to a circuit. Yeah, right away. And then come on in.

Lines on a map of the city of New York. With 73,000 people wedged into the nine-tenths of a square mile between Fifth Avenue and the East River, wouldn't know if you asked them if they lived or worked in the 21st. But whether they know it or not, the security of their homes, their persons, and their property is the job of the men of the 21st Precinct. The 21st. 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm Captain in Command. I'm the 21st.

I was working my night tour, 4 p.m. to 8 a.m. It was raining hard when I came on the job, and the 62 men of the 4 to 12 platoon wore their black rubber raincoats and cap covers at the turnout. By 6 p.m., however, the rain had stopped. And when I went out for my meal, the skies were clear. At 8, I instructed Sergeant Waters on telephone switchboard duty to have a car come by the station house to take me on patrol. Then, for the next two and a half hours, with Patrolman William P. Coley as operator, I rode the streets of the precinct.

The 490 radio motor patrol cars of the Police Department of the City of New York are, for obvious reasons, conspicuous appearing vehicles. They are Ford, Chevrolet, and Plymouth Club Coupes. Lower part of the bodies are painted dark green and black, the upper part white. Third police is lettered in several places large enough to be read a block away. At night, a red and white lighted sign, also reading police, shines from the roof of each car. Consequently, I rode the streets of the precinct. A citizen in need of assistance can see a radio motor patrol car coming from some distance away. And as we drove downtown on Lexington Avenue on route back to the station house, that was the case, exactly.

What's this, Captain?

All right, pull in.

Hey, am I glad I saw you. What's the trouble?

You see that bar there? Well, I was in there having a beer, see? I was just minding my own business, having a beer. And for no reason at all, I looked around, you know, I just turned around. I'm sitting at the bar, you know. The police just fell on the school. Hey, I thought he looked familiar to me. So I took him. Another look. Yeah. Yeah, who he is? He's the guy who held me up three weeks ago. How do you like that?

How's your blab? I'm the job. I'm the station agent for the Independence Subway. He come in and stuck me up. And he sure as was him. Same identical fellow, I swear.

Is he still on the bar?

Oh, yeah. Yeah, he's been there. Before he recognized me. On the street or something, I didn't know what to do. I thought I went to perform someplace. He'd get out, get away, you know. So I had to wait outside until somebody came along. He came out meantime. I was going to follow him, you know. Am I glad to see you. I didn't want to go following him. When he robbed me, he had a gun this long. Suppose I followed him and he still had it on him, huh?

What's your name? Where is this subway station where you were robbed?

116, 168, that's your line. And when was it? We'll breathe easier tonight. Know how many of us got stuck up the last couple weeks already?

Yes, I know. 11 of us. Think about me. You've got this girl with him. I recognize him right away.

Right. Be careful with him. It's way right here. You watch him now. All right, Tony. You'll be good. Keep your eyes open. I'm going for him. Okay, Captain.

Captain. I want to see you in a minute, Joe. Good morning. Joe, stand up a minute, will you?

What's the idea?

Stand up, stand up. All right. Make it a minute. Lean up against there.

Why?

Go on, lean up against there. Yeah, all right. Take him, Tony.

I'd like to know what the idea is.

So would I. Oh, all right. Sit down. But what's the matter anyway? What's your name?

Paul Creedy. Keep your hands on the tape.

I was just going to get my wallet to show you.

All right. Just keep your hands on the tape.

What's the idea? What's the idea? We didn't do anything. We were just sitting here.

Where do you live, Paul?

Why? Because I asked you, where do you live?

762 East 89th Street. I'd like to know what this is all about.

Would I, after all?

Got some trouble here, Captain?

No, no. We'll handle it, Joe.

What's the matter? Look, you better just get back behind the bar.

Okay, if you say so.

I'd like to know what this is all about. We've got some rights in this country, too, you know.

Okay, honey. It's all right.

Tony, go outside and get him. Get her right away.

Get who?

You working, Paul?

Working? Sure, I'm working. Where do you work?

At a leather goods factory downtown.

What's the name of the company?

Ravenscroft. Ravenscroft Leather Goods. Now, listen now. Fun is fun. What's this all about?

You ever been arrested, Paul?

Of course he hasn't. Have you?

No, I haven't. What's your name?

Her name is Louise Bonella. She's a friend of mine. We go out together. She lives across the street from me. Is there anything else you want to know?

All right, Paul. Take it easy.

Why should I take it easy? You come around here throwing a lot of questions at me. Why should I take it easy?

Because you're liable to have a lot more questions thrown at you. That's him. That's the guy.

I'm the guy who what?

You're the guy that stuck me up.

Get out of your mind. It wasn't me all night. It wasn't tonight. I didn't.

All right, all right. You're lying about it.

Okay, cut it out. He's crazy.

All right, quiet now. He stuck everybody up.

Listen, when was this supposed to have happened?

About three weeks ago. In the 116th Street Station of the 8th Avenue line.

Get out of it. Mine. Yeah, well, we'll see if I have to.

Listen, let's go get this straightened out. I want it straightened out.

That's what we're going to do, Paul. Right now.

Patrolman Coley rang in, and an additional car was sent to assist, and we took all three to the station house. At the house, Coley and I took them upstairs to the office of the 21st Detective Squad, where the situation was explained to Detective John Bender, who was catching, and Lieutenant Matt King, commander of the squad. As required, Patrolman Coley, who would be the arresting officer of record, remained with his prisoner. I went downstairs to my office. After talking for a few minutes to the complainant, Roy Purford, Lieutenant King brought the suspect into his office, where he questioned him in the presence of Patrolman Coley and Detective Bender.

Well, you've got to grant this, Paul. The man walked into the bar. He saw you sitting there. He said you're the boy that stuck him up. Must be something to it.

Well, he said it. There's something to that. Maybe he believes it. I don't know, but it wasn't me.

Paul, in the last month, there have been 11 station agents held up in Manhattan alone.

That doesn't make me the guy.

I know it doesn't. I want you to listen to this. What?

One of the robberies was in this precinct, the 77th Street station of the Lexington Avenue line on Friday, June 24th. This was in a squeal made out by the detective investigating the case. At 11.18, a lone man walked up to the change booth and asked directions as to how to get to Times Square. The station agent told him. The man then pulled a nickel-plated revolver from his pocket and robbed the station agent of $53.40.

What's that got to do with me?

The station agent described the man like this. 24 years old, 5 feet 9 inches, 50 to 60. Light complexion, blue eyes, medium build, and red hair. This sounds like he was talking about you, doesn't it, Paul?

Well, I'm not the only guy in New York with red hair.

He was one. Far from that. He gave the detectives up there in the 28th squad almost an identical description. He identified you in person.

Well, that doesn't mean a thing.

It means a lot to me, Paul. From the description, it appears the same man was involved in the other nine cases.

Well, why don't you find it?

The opinion appears to be pretty widespread that we've got him.

It's not true. I didn't do it.

All right. Well, maybe we'll find out if you didn't. But I'm telling you, if you did, you might as well let me know about it right now. You'd just be wasting a lot of your time and a lot of mine.

I didn't. Now, you told Captain Kennelly that you were employed by the Ravenscroft Leather Goods Company.

Well, it's standing. It works steady?

Yeah.

How long you been there?

Since around February.

What do you make a week?

Well, that depends on the overtime. On the average, right? Oh, around $80, $75.

What time do you get in in the morning?

Like 8 o'clock.

What time you through?

Well, unless it's overtime.

You live at 762 East 39th Street. What do you live there with?

My mother, my brother, and my kids.

Where's your father?

That's what we'd like to know.

Bender, move that ass for your sister, guys. He works for the city. Brother's in high school still. He works a little bit. You know, odd jobs.

How old is he? What color hair does he have? Red, too?

No. He's down to brown like yours.

Who's this girl you were with tonight?

I know that. I mean, you see her much?

I see her a lot. We're talking about getting married. We don't know yet. We've got a few problems. We've got to...

Yeah, don't we all? How long have you been going with her? Ever been in trouble?

Never had any trouble with a cop, not even when you were a kid. Kids don't know and have a... with them for a minute.

I don't know anything about any of this. I mean, us. We here. We know about the one in the 116th Street Station of the 8th Avenue line because Mr. Pierce would sell you in the bar and identify you. You're crazy about that.

Yeah, but he identified you. That was on Thursday night. We know about the one that was here in this precinct. That was on June 24th, Friday night.

Not at the moment. I have to think about it. I remember back when I wasn't doing anything in particular. I know, huh? Could have been with your girl, couldn't you?

Louise? Oh, yeah, sure. I could have. I might have, but I don't know. How should I know? I can't remember specifically.

All right. Could have been home.

Oh, I don't remember that far back. How do you expect me to remember where I was a month ago almost? I had no reason to remember. You know, I could have been putting a gun on those station agents. Oh, that I wasn't. You'd have remembered that.

If I did them, I would have remembered. I didn't do them. There's lots of redheads in New York.

And I'll agree with you. There's lots of redheads in New York. The pair from the 16th Street Station might have been mistaken. I've got mine. Let's get the victim from the 77th Street Station, the one in this precinct. See what he has. And just sit him down here and say, Well, I said I was the guy. Oh, nothing like that. Oh, sure. And I'm the only redhead. How can he miss? We'll be looking for him now.

To the stairs, Captain.

Outside the squad room. You sit in there, Paul.

Yes, sir. Come on, Bender. I'm not going to be here all night.

Hold that, Paul. What's up, Bender?

Yes, sir. Two things I want you to do. I want you to check his name for BC or any previous record. See? And I want you to see if you can locate the victim of the robbery in this precinct.

Yes, sir.

Wait around here. Do you know, I'm going down for a paper, and I stopped in for that B, and my wife will have a fit telephone letter. No, you're here. We don't have any phones. We could have the desk officer send a policeman around to notify us. No, no. Don't do that. You'll have to think. She's got some vivid imagination.

Come back. Is that B all right? The detectives from the 28th Squad are on the way down here to see you. Bender's quite poor, yeah?

No, not yet. What's taking him so long? He didn't do anything. You know he didn't do anything.

That's a trouble. I don't know it.

Well, anyone who's been in. I don't know that either. Go home if you want.

No. It's all right. I'll stay. But you may have a long wait.

I don't care. They're coming up, Captain. Continuous. And I, he's the one. Yeah.

I'm getting the victim from the robbery in this precinct over here. We'll have a lineup.

Good. I'm helping the lineup, Captain. We'll get to it about midnight. You'll be able to dig up that money between both platoons.

Yes, I think so. You would be. Benjamin is on the job, too. Thank you.

Captain, I've got a personal opinion. Second victim gets a look at him. I think he's going to walk right out of here. He's anywhere near those subway stations. Largest city.

Lieutenant Gorman, the desk officer. I rang upstairs and told Lieutenant King we had five patrolmen, all red-haired, approximated the same general physical description as the suspect. I suggested that the proposed lineup be held as close to midnight as possible in order that those men who were on the job would lose as little time from patrol. And those men off duty would be required to spend a minimum, their own time, provided, of course, that the victim could be located and brought to the station house by then.

In a criminal case, identification by the victim of the suspect is generally the most important piece of evidence. Consequently, procedure calls for exactitude in conducting a lineup. The process of identification is usually the prime target of attack by the defense attorney. And any irregularities that can be shown makes a deep impression on the jury in favor of the defendants.

At 1125 p.m., Lieutenant King informed me, me that Detective Bender had located the victim at his home in Washington Heights and was driving him to the station house. The men from the patrol force who were to participate in the lineup were instructed to report to Lieutenant King in their civilian clothes.

At midnight, I turned out the platoon and after the men marched out the front door to take over their post, I started to cross the muscle room toward my office.

Captain?

Oh, hello Bender. Captain, this is Mr. Lewis Wolfsmith, Captain Kennelly.

Captain.

How do you do, Mr. Wolfsmith?

He's the victim in that robbery we had in this precinct. I never thought you'd catch him. I never thought you would.

Well, we don't know that it came, yes, Mr. Wolfsmith. You're the one who's going to have to tell us that.

Oh, don't you worry about that. I know him. I don't. I wonder if we could wait in your office until they're ready for Mr. Wolfsmith upstairs, Captain.

Sure, Bender. Help yourself. I'll go up and see how they're making out.

Yes, sir. In here, Mr. Wolfsmith.

How long will it take?

Yes, Sergeant. Just upstairs, sir. I'll take some reports on your desk, Captain. You get a chance to look at them?

No, not yet. I'll leave them during the night.

Yes, sir. Unusual in them?

Just in that one I was telling you about, Captain. The manager, we had another complaint about the entertainer fraternizing with the patrons. He said he'd watch it.

You make the stop in there tomorrow night, too, Sergeant.

Yes, sir. Make sure he is watching it.

All right, keep it down, you men. What do you think this is? Where's Lieutenant King?

He's at the office, Captain.

Oh, haven't you gone home yet?

No, I'm waiting for Paul. Could have a long wait.

That's all right. I don't mind.

Captain Kennelly. Good night, Captain.

Then they brought the other victim in, Matt. He's waiting in my office.

Yeah, I know. He rang up here, Captain. I told him to come up and sit with him outside in the hall. Got set, Paul?

Yes, I'm set. Let's get it over with.

All right. I see you found a few redheads.

Paul, are you all right?

Why don't you go home, honey? I don't want to. You'll either have to sit down on the bench or go home. Go sit down, Louise, please. I'll be over soon. I hope so. I just hope so.

All right, Captain. Sure. Get them lined up over there, will you? This is your party, Vickers. Anywhere? On the end, in the middle, anywhere you like.

All right, Captain. I'll be right back. Sure, go ahead. You better take that jacket off, Ken.

Hello, Bender. Lieutenant, this is Mr. Lewis Wolfschmidt, Lieutenant King. If you can identify the man.

It's like yesterday that night. When we get in there, I'll tell you how we work it. Now, I got to tap him on the shoulder.

All right, Detective Bender. You want me to take another look?

I'd like to hear that blue talk. Which one? Take your name and address.

That's him. He's the one. No frame-up. No frame-up. Nobody told me nothing. That's a few manner excuses. Thank you very much. The whole thing is a lousy frame-up.

You're the one I can't help. I'm beginning to end.

Join my office, Paul.

Hey, Captain. Right with you, Matt. Wait a minute, Mr. Wolfschmidt. Yeah, sure.

Lieutenant?

Go ahead, then. It's a lousy frame-up. That's what it is.

Yes, Bender. Uh, listen, Lieutenant, can I talk to you?

All right, sit down, Paul.

I didn't rob anybody. What do I have to do to prove it?

I don't know, Paul. That was it, huh? That was nothing. It was a frame-up. You got to hang it on somebody so you pick me, that's all.

Did I? Did I pick you to serve two years in Elmira Reformatory for grand larceny and polonius assault?

I don't know about that. You could lie about this. Stick up anybody. Criminal identification call back and put the case back to me. I'm out of the armed robbery.

Why did you lie about doing time?

Do I do? I'll talk my way out of it, but I guess there's no use. A weapon of them?

Where's the gun, Paul?

In the basement of my house. I never did keep it upstairs. I thought my ma and my brother might find it when I was in there.

Exactly where in the basement? Describe it exactly.

I have to show you. Listen, I didn't hurt anybody. I didn't hurt a soul. You said you worked at this leather goods place. Why didn't you get another job? Station agent. Nothing. Nothing else. I swear.

He doesn't know a thing. Big mistake. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Right there for the officers. Flesh and blood merry-go-round. That's the brass ring. World's largest city. Settled with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑