The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 22 min to read
21st Precinct.
Sergeant Waters. Notify the 6th Division plainclothesmen, whose job it is to enforce the laws relating to public morals in the 21st and the other precincts of the division. At five minutes after 9 p.m., four plainclothesmen arrived in the precinct to act on the information. With the assistance of Patrolman McGill, two men from Sector Car No. 2, and myself, the suspected premises were raided. A dice game was, in fact, in operation. Seventeen men were placed under arrest. The patrol wagon was summoned. They were brought to the station house for booking. The muster room was swarming with the suspects and police officers.
As Lieutenant Gorman took the pedigree of the first suspect and entered it into the arrest record, I stood behind the desk.
"All right, all right. Keep it quiet. Where do you think you are? All right. Next."
"Yeah, that's this one. Come on, step right up there. What's your name?"
"That's the traffic, huh, Captain?"
"Yeah, yeah. Joe, I was."
"First name is Joseph?"
"Joseph, yeah."
"What's your middle name?"
"Joseph C."
"Joseph Carl, I would. C-A-R-L?"
"That's right. C-A-R-L."
"How do you spell the last name?"
"E-R-W-O-O-G."
"Hey, look, I want to get this straight. I wasn't shooting crap. I was in the barbershop to get a haircut. You can ask anybody."
"How old are you?"
"Thirty-two. In March."
"Where do you live?"
"Thirty-four, 20 Florence Avenue."
"In the Bronx?"
"In the Bronx, yeah."
"All right, all right. I don't want to tell you too much. What's your occupation?"
"Quiet."
"Electrician. Electrical contractor."
When Mercado rings in, I want to talk to him, Sergeant.
Okay, Captain.
"Search him and go."
"Why, has he happened?"
"There's a bondsman coming. He's on his way."
"Okay, but I only know he had to get a haircut."
Let's see what that woman wants, Sergeant.
Yes, sir.
"Lady, over here, please. Everything."
"Excuse me. I didn't want to be any trouble."
"What can we do for you?"
"I want to talk to someone who's a policeman."
"What about?"
"Well, I don't know how to... Excuse me."
Yes, all right.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. Lieutenant Gorman is busy now. What did you find there? Yeah. All right. Wait just a second, will you?
"It'll be just a minute, lady. All right. Don't worry."
Captain.
Yes, sir.
"Would you mind handing me that 80 card on the desk there?"
"Oh, which one, sir?"
"That's it. Right there."
"Here you are."
"Thanks, Captain. He's in Roseville Hospital with a possible fractured leg. Right leg."
Take the call, Sergeant. I'll talk to the woman.
Yes, sir.
"I'm Captain Kennelly. How do you do?"
"Pretty busy here. Suppose you step into my office."
"All right. I don't mean to be any bother."
"Right in this way, please. Stand on your own two feet there."
"Is it like that all the time? So busy?"
"No, not all the time. Would you sit down, Mrs., uh..."
"Mrs. Deason. Mrs. Eva Deason."
"Would you sit down here, Mrs. Deason?"
"Thank you. Thank you very much. Oh, what can we do for you? Do you know how many times I walked past the police station? How many times before I came in?"
"What's the trouble, Mrs. Deason?"
"Trouble, all right. So much trouble, I don't sleep nights. I don't sleep nights for two weeks."
"What trouble? Better come in at the police station. Maybe I should have kept right on walking by. But... But... But..."
"You're in now."
"Yes, I'm in."
"Please, sit down."
"You want me to tell me about it? All right. But I'm married 15 years, going on 16. If I tell you, I might as well move out. If I don't move out, I'll get kicked out. 15 years."
"It's something about your husband?"
"Yes. And no, about his brother."
"What's the trouble with him?"
"Crazy, insane."
"Well, uh, Mrs. Deason, that's not our job here."
"He's got his wife. He killed her."
"Oh. Crazy. When did this happen?"
"Six, seven weeks ago. Oh. I don't know."
"Where?"
"At his home, Brooklyn. He came home one night and took a shotgun. A shotgun he used to hunt ducks. He shot her and she was dead."
"Why'd he shoot her?"
"No reason. Crazy."
"He must have thought he had a reason."
"He said she was running around. He said she ran around with all different men. He said it for years."
"What, she? Running around?"
"No, nothing. He stayed home all the time. A nice woman. Just scared all the time. Scared he was going to kill her. And he did."
"What's his name?"
"Who? My husband?"
"No. No, his brother."
"Just like my husband, Easton. My husband's John. He's Fred."
"Where is he now? Fred?"
"Yes."
"I don't know right now."
"Wasn't he arrested?"
"They didn't catch him yet."
"Are they looking for him?"
"Oh, sure, yeah. Oh. They knew right away it was him that killed him with his gun. The lady downstairs from them heard the shot. She came out in the hall. She was running down the stairs. He ran down the stairs and out on the street."
"And they haven't caught him yet?"
"No."
"This was in Brooklyn six or seven weeks ago?"
"Yes, Brooklyn. The police have been waiting. They've been working on it, haven't they?"
"Oh, sure, all the time. From the scene she was shot. The detective came to our house and told us about it. We went to Brooklyn with him. Some police station there. We went to the place where they had her laid out in a... What do you call it?"
"A morgue."
"Yes. They asked us a lot of questions."
"Who was that?"
"Me and my husband, John. They asked us all about him. They asked John if he knew where his brother could be and everything like that."
"Did he know?"
"How could he? We don't see Fred very often for a long time. He lived in Brooklyn, us in Manhattan. Maybe two or three times a year. You know?"
"Yes, yes. Does your husband have any other brothers or sisters?"
"No, just him, Fred."
"So a day or two goes by and he still isn't caught. We went to a funeral and everything like that. There were detectives at the funeral, too. Same detectives that talked to us. They said they thought maybe Fred would come, but he didn't. After the funeral, one of the detectives came to our house. He waited there. Then another detective came and also waited."
"Have they still got detectives planted at your house, Mrs. Deason?"
"Planted? What do you mean, planted?"
"Well, I mean, are they still waiting there?"
"No. After ten days, or maybe two weeks, one of them came in for a cup of coffee with John and me. He said the detectives, they thought Fred had gone away from town, Pennsylvania someplace. He said they wouldn't wait at our house anymore."
"Well, what's the problem now, Mrs. Deason?"
"The problem is, John heard from Fred. Fred called John on the telephone and he placed a visit. Two weeks ago."
"Didn't John call the detectives?"
"No."
"Why didn't you call?"
"I didn't know. I didn't know until the day before yesterday. I went to put money in the savings account. I saw $200 was taken out, $100 once, and $100 again. When John came home, I showed him the bank book. He told me his brother called him on the job and told him he needed money. He called him twice for money. Twice he went to the bank and got it out. $100 each time."
"Why didn't he get in touch with the detectives?"
"He wouldn't do anything against his brother."
"You, uh, you said he's out of his mind?"
"I say he's out of my mind, yes. The detective says he's out of his mind. Everybody says he's out of his mind. Everybody except John. John don't believe it. He sticks up. His brother could kill three wives and rob four banks. To John, he'll be all right. It's a loyalty. Stick up for the family."
"Yeah, but doesn't he realize his brother's liable to get violent with him?"
"How could he realize that if he don't realize he's crazy? I can't mention it around the house. One word that anything's wrong with Fred makes John mad. He thinks it's a reflection on him. He thinks people will say it runs in the family. He's insane, too. He should realize it. I asked him who's kidding who. Wasn't Fred in Harlem State Hospital for two years? I asked him, why did they send him there? He said to get a rest. What's he going to do with something like that? He can't even talk to him about it."
"Well, why didn't you come and see us before? Or call a Brooklyn detective?"
"Because before he had already seen Fred and the money was gone. So was Fred. What good would it do? He just gets me in a big argument with John, that's all."
"And now?"
"I noticed today the bank book was gone again. He took it when he went to work. Ah, I see."
"It was back after supper. Back where we keep it, all the time in the drawer with his socks. Another hundred dollars was drawn out."
"You think he saw his brother during the day?"
"No."
"Oh, why not?"
"Because also after dinner he went to paint the pipes under the sink, took off his good pants and put on his old pants. The hundred dollars was still in his good pants."
"Then you think, Mrs. Deason, that he hasn't seen his brother yet?"
"I don't think it, I know it."
"Maybe he's seeing him tonight?"
"No. Tonight, right now, he's playing seven-card rummy with a neighbor. The neighbor's flat downstairs."
"Where did you say you were going?"
"86th Street to the movies."
"That didn't make him suspicious?"
"Why? Whenever he plays rummy, I go to the movies."
"What time does he expect you home?"
"11:15, 11:30, when he finishes the rummy game."
"All right, Mrs. Deason. In the meantime, I'd like to take you upstairs to talk to the detective here."
"If you want, all right."
"Now?"
"Yes. Please."
"What?"
"Yes."
"I don't want you to think this is because John took $300 from the bank to give to his brother. I didn't say I thought that. $300 takes a long time to save. To give it to a maniac that goes around killing wives is not right. I'm loyal also. There's a time and place to do the right thing. That's what I made up my mind, and that's enough."
"I agree with you, Mrs. Deason. Enough is enough."
I took Mrs. Deason upstairs to the 21st Detective Squad and into the office of Lieutenant Matt King, commanding officer of the squad. There, she went through substantially the same story she told to me. As Lieutenant King and one of the detectives began to question the woman in greater detail, I left, walked down the worn stairs, and through the back room out into the muster room. The crapshooters were still being booked at the desk as I went to my office and closed the door. At my desk, I dug deeper into the pile of reports and communications to be signed in time for the precinct messenger to take them to division headquarters with the morning mail.
Yes?
"Come in, Matt."
"How am I at?"
"Well, what's going on out there? It's like a convention."
"It is. Convention of crapshooters."
"Well, how many of them's your bag?"
"Seventeen. Sit down."
"Okay."
"Is that all?"
"Looks like more. The others are plain clothes and from division."
"Oh. Lieutenant Gorman is going to have writer's cramp before he's finished with that haul."
"Yeah. Uh, what did you think of this Mrs. Deason story, Matt?"
"Looks pretty good, Captain. Huh? I called out to the 62nd Squad. Uh-huh. They had such case. Fred Deason, the husband of the dead woman, is still a fugitive. The squad commander wasn't there. His assistant is on the job. He told me they suspected the man might turn up with his brothers. As a matter of fact, I remember they spoke to me a month or so ago that they were going to put a plant on an apartment building here in this precinct."
"Uh, where are you going from here, Matt?"
"Well, it was their case. This acting squad commander I spoke to and the detective carrying the squealer are on the way over now."
"What are they going to do? Put a tail on the husband? See if he takes the money to Fred?"
"We thought we might do that at first, but we decided over the phone to pick him up tonight."
"Why?"
"Why? If this John Deason is anything like his wife says he is, he's taking a chance. He might just shut up. The other way, he'd probably leave you to Fred. We thought it out, pretty much. He might have had a date to meet his brother today and miss him. We could tail him around for two or three weeks before they make contact again."
"Yeah, well, maybe. Oh, uh, what I wanted to see about, Captain, is I sent a look at Novak over to the flat a little while ago to pick up Mr. Deason and bring him in. The wife's upstairs. Thought maybe I could talk to him in here for a few minutes before I took him up to the squad."
"You're not too busy."
"Oh, sure. It's all right, man. I told the sergeant on T.S. to ring in here when they get back to the house with him."
"Or I can wait out in the muster room."
"No, no. Stay right where you are."
"But you're back now. Mrs. Deason told you he was playing cards in the neighbor's flat?"
"Yes, she told me. I got the name and location from her."
"Oh. Oh, well, I got something I want to show you."
"Yes?"
"My recommendation for a departmental recognition of Sergeant Lyons and Patrolman Nelson. Connection with that gunfight they had with that stick-up man, Fort Chris."
"Oh, yeah. They ought to get commendations out of it, don't you think?"
"Well, I think a commendation from Nelson to Sergeant Lyons ought to do better. He ought to get honorable mention out of it, man. Wouldn't be surprised if he did."
Excuse me.
Yes?
21st Precinct, Captain Kennelly. Yes? Yes, right here. All right. Hold on.
"Matt, DeLuca, and Novak are out at the T.S."
"Well, ask them to come in, Captain, if it's all right."
"Sergeant, have them come in here."
Sergeant?
"Yes, sir?"
"How are you doing out there with the dice players?"
"All right. Come in. Come in, lads. All right, go ahead, Mr. Deason. Greg, somebody away from a peaceful rummy game. Novak, you better go on up and catch while Whitey takes his meal. Sit down. Sit down here, Mr. Deason."
"I know nothing. I told the detectives from Brooklyn I know nothing. I told this detective tonight I know nothing. I tell you, I know nothing."
"You don't have to know anything to sit down, Mr. Deason. This is Captain Kennelly. I'm Lieutenant King. How do you do?"
"Hello. Mr. Deason, I don't suppose there's any need for me to tell you how important it is for us to apprehend your brother?"
"Everybody has already told me."
"As important as it is for us, it's just as important for him. His safety is involved and his health."
"Nothing wrong with his health. Never anything wrong with his health. He's as healthy as a knock."
"Is he?"
"Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. He's a knock. Yeah. He looked well when you saw him, huh?"
"Yes. When I saw him a week before he, before his wife died."
"Do you think there's any doubt that he killed his wife?"
"I think nothing. I only know what I know."
"It's been established beyond all doubt that he killed his wife, Mr. Deason. You know that."
"I don't know that. I, I, I was not there."
"But he did."
"Were you there, Captain?"
"The evidence is quite conclusive."
"I don't give a dick for the, for the evidence."
"Is that why you've seen your brother on several occasions?"
"When?"
"Since he's been a fugitive."
"Who said I saw my brother?"
"Didn't you?"
"Eva. Eva has been talking to you. You saw him on two occasions. I know it was Eva."
"No, it was her because that's what I said to her. I saw him twice. Man can't even lie to his wife without the, the police becoming him."
"Why did you lie to your wife?"
"Was it a lie?"
"It was a lie because I had to tell her something she'd believe about what I did with the money. You know about the money, too."
"Yes. Sure. Tell a woman the secrecy. I took the money out of the bank for other personal reasons."
"What other personal reasons?"
"Pay somebody I owed it. Here we go. At my place. The business is. Shipping clerk takes bets on horses. I owed him. Two hundred dollars. Two hundred dollars."
"Then why did you draw it out of the bank a hundred dollars at a time? You owed him two hundred."
"Because I told him I would pay him a hundred at a time. Settle at two hundred, you owe him."
"That is right. One and one, that's two."
"And what was the other hundred drawn out today for?"
"I need to look at the bank book tonight, so."
"Where is she? I could give her a piece of my mind. Is she here?"
"What was the hundred today for, Mr. Deason?"
"Also for the bookmaker?"
"Yes."
"I thought you only owed him two hundred."
"I was trying to win back the two hundred, so I lost another hundred off. Three hundred altogether."
"Three hundred. That's what you paid him, is that right?"
"Three hundred, yes. Except I didn't pay him the last hundred yet. I still have it in my pocket. Do you want to see it?"
"No, no, it's all right. What's the name of the shipping clerk? Bookmaker?"
"Yeah, what's his name?"
"His name is Al."
"What's his last name?"
"I don't know."
"You work in the same place? You don't know his last name?"
"We're in different departments, a big place."
"All right, we'll find out. A woman who runs to the police with lies. Her husband tells her wife a lie about the money she runs to the police. You ever hear anything so ridiculous?"
"That's what's the matter with lying, Mr. Deason. It keeps getting people in trouble."
The interrogation of John Deason continued for some minutes. It was a difficult job for Lieutenant King. He needed information regarding the whereabouts of the killer. But he couldn't afford to press too hard for fear that the witness would stop talking entirely. He skirted the subject that would touch him, was John Deason. Kept going over and over the ground. In the hope that the witness would be caught in the tangle of his own lies. It didn't work. At 10:30, Lieutenant King and Detective DeLuca left my office with John Deason. Took him out into the muster room where the process of booking the gamblers was continuing. I stood in the doorway of my office, watched them go into the back room up the stairs to the second floor. On their way to the office of the 21st Detective Squad.
"All right, Mr. Deason, inside."
"When I have to be at work at 8 in the morning, I hope you realize. Eva. Family secret. Family secret. Family secrets about a wife killer? Family secrets. About a maniac?"
"The maniac part, that wife killer part, that don't bother you."
"All right, let's settle down."
"The money, the $300. You're crazier than he is."
"He is not crazy. Now you get that through your head."
"All right, Mrs. Deason. I got enough through my head already. He is not crazy. Now, Mr. Deason."
"Let me go now. I can talk to my own wife."
"Your wife, yes, but not for long."
"What do you mean, not for long?"
"I mean not for long. Only for as long as it takes me to pack my clothes and go to my sister."
"Ah, after 15 years."
"After 15 years. Why? Because I can't live with a man who don't know right from wrong. Even after 50 years."
"It's right. I know it's right."
"How do you know what he's doing? Maybe he's killing somebody else. Maybe right this minute."
"Oh, Eva, please. Sit down, Mrs. Deason, please."
"I'm not going to sit down. I'm leaving. I'm going. I'm through."
"Sit down. Please. No."
"I'll talk to him. I'll talk to him."
"All right. If you'll tell him, I'll sit down."
"I met him. Yes, twice. He called my place of business. He said, he needed some money. I went to the bank and I got it. And then he called again. More money."
"Where's he living?"
"I don't know. I didn't ask him."
"You have more money for him now, don't you?"
"Yeah. He called on the telephone yesterday. Here's another $100. I took that out of the bank today."
"When are you supposed to give him that?"
"Tonight at midnight."
"Where?"
"He told me to be on the subway platform, 77th Street Station. He said, get off the train and meet me at midnight."
"He'll be met."
"He's got a gun. I said, he'd shoot. He'd shoot anybody. He don't care. He said, if I didn't get him the money, he'd hold up places and shoot the people. That's why I got it. I didn't want anybody to get shot. That's why."
"John. Oh, John, I'm sorry."
"I'm sorry, too. Very sorry."
"You'll be on the subway platform, John. We'll all meet him."
"No, I'm not going. I'm me."
"We need you to point him out."
"Not me. I won't point out my own brother. Don't ask me to do that, please. Let me be that loyal."
"All right. We'll get him without you."
Arrangements were begun immediately to plant the 77th Street subway station of the Lexington Avenue line in order to apprehend the fugitive when he stepped off the train at midnight. Lieutenant King conferred with me and requested assistance in the form of members of my command to cover the stairs leading to the street of both the uptown and downtown sides of the station. Detectives were posted near the change booth at turnstiles and at frequent intervals along the 100-yard underground platform at which the train's puller was stopped. Other detectives were assigned to board each train as it stopped at the preceding station. We waited. Several locals stopped at the station, several express trains went through on the inside track. No one resembling the fugitive had gotten off a train by 12:10.
"Here comes another train, Captain."
"That looks like an express, sir."
"Yes, sir, it is an express."
"Well, the locals..."
"Huh?"
"Twelve minutes after 12."
"Yeah. Think he's got a show?"
"That beats me much. It would beat me worse if John wasn't telling the truth. He was supposed to meet his brother some other time in some other place. Here comes the locals."
"Yes, sir. Like everybody said, not many passengers, Captain."
"No. Way down there, the last car. Now, look."
"Yeah, that could have been him getting off. Listen. You better talk to him. Fine, out loud. One. Watch it. God, are you all right? One in the neck. Ring in for an ambulance. Come on, Captain. Ring in. Look out, jumping down, Captain. Watch the third rail. Oh, yeah, all right. Hold up there. Crossing over. Watch it. Hold it, Matt. I see him. Come on. Let's cross over, Matt."
"Yes, Captain. Downtown Express."
"Yes. Yes, see him? See him, Captain?"
"Yes, Captain. No. We want 10 feet. Back up above. Got it. Friend. Friend. It's okay. Well, at least one thing, Matt. Watch it. Do this brother a favor. Won't have to plead insanity in court."
21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. Why do you want a policeman? What's the trouble there? Yeah. Whose car is it, yours?
And so it goes. Around the clock, through the week, every day, every year. A police precinct in the city of New York is a flesh and blood place. A police precinct is a flesh and blood merry-go-round. Anyone can catch the bright ring. Or the bright ring can catch anyone.
21st Precinct transcribed. A factual account of the way the police work in the world's largest city is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the Police Department, City of New York. James Gregory in the role of Captain Kennelly. Ken Lynch as Lieutenant King. Harold Stone as Sergeant Waters. Featured in tonight's cast were Santos Ortega, Bill Zilkis, Abby Lewis, John Sylvester, and John Larkin. 21st Precinct is written and produced by Stanley Nist, Art Hannaf's teacher.
