Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
21st Precinct artwork

From the 21st Precinct collection

The Slugger

Episode 117December 30, 195527 min 24 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 26 min to read

21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters.

You smell what? Gas? Where is this? C-71. On what floor?

You are in the muster room at the 21st Precinct, the nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct.

You will have assistance right away. Yes, sir. Right away. No, just stay where you are. The officers will be right there. 21st Precinct.

It's just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the nine-tenths of a square mile between Fifth Avenue and the East River wouldn't know if you asked them that they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, the security of their homes, their persons, and their property is the job of the men of the 21st Precinct. The 21st. 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Cronin, Vincent P. Cronin. I am captain in command of the 21st. I was doing day duty, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. Immediately after I turned out the platoon, I went down to the 6th Division office at the 17th Precinct, 163 East 51st Street, where Inspector McBride had called a conference of all precinct commanders in the division in connection with the enforcement of certain new regulations of the State Liquor Authority. After the conference, I got into sector car number two, the Coleman Daniel Mercado operator, and we started back uptown toward the station house, where the paperwork had piled up. Because of my days off, when we got within the boundaries of the precinct, I instructed Mercado to go uptown on 1st Avenue, so that I could check on some complaints that some new construction was unduly blocking traffic.

And I had a lot of trick questions, Captain. You know, that could be answered logically either way, on the true and false, especially. Like, um, an automobile accident occurring in a public garage and resulting in personal injury shall be recorded as a vehicular accident [inaudible].

Why'd you put that on for them?

I put that on false, because it didn't happen on the street. Only if it happens on the street between building lines is it recorded as a vehicular accident. Otherwise, it's a straight-80 case.

That's right. How do you think you met Mercado?

Well, pretty good, I think, Captain. I can tell you more when the answers come out. I'm sure glad it's over, though. All that studying's rough.

Yeah, yeah, it takes a lot of studying. That's the biggest jump, a tall number of sergeants. There's lots of competition.

I don't, I know it. Do you know how many [ropes] he's having? Over 7,000.

It's gonna be some list, yeah.

Yeah, well, they'll have to make a lot of sergeants with all those men coming in as a job. Justin, if I'm in the first three or four hundred, I figure I ought to get made within a couple of years. My wife was helping me with the studying. She knows the rules in the manual as well as I do. She can recite articles, section, and paragraph.

Mine was the same way. I told her she ought to write the examination.

I don't know if she'll make it in. There are only two years left. I'll have to tell the math teacher. You've gotta have no luck with those two. Or maybe you'll make it. The last thing you need to do on the first day of the exam is practice the observe. You need to read your homework. You need to know where you're at. You need to be a good teacher. You need to be a good student. And you need to be a good teacher. You need to get it right.

So, in the end, you did better than your teacher?

I think so.

Then, you were lucky.

Sure, you're lucky. You're lucky. It wasn't your teacher who told you how you could get out. It wasn't your teacher did what you did. He told you exactly what it was, you messed with the station.

The ESD car 618 was a five-story tenement building. A few passersby and neighbors were beginning to gather around the sidewalk.

Let's go right with you, Captain.

That's either ESD or the ambulance coming now.

Yeah, keep the sidewalk clean, Mercado. Keep them off the stoop.

Yes, sir. All right, folks, let's get through here. You come on, let's get back off the stoop.

I'm a carter.

Yes, sir. Uh, keep the people away from those doorbells, okay, Captain?

Now look, I told you about your water. Stop the toilet.

All right, come in there. Open up, this is the police.

What is it, Sergeant?

Speak to me, Captain. We haven't been able to locate it. You can smell it?

Yes, sir.

Open up in there.

Well, I guess nobody's home here, Captain. We've been hitting every door. I sent a man up to the third, notice the fifth floor. We're telling everybody else. I don't think it's on this floor.

Holly, get it located down the floor.

Floor, Captain? The whole hall smells of gas. There's no telling where it comes. Who put in the car? Stupid kind of smell gas in the hole if you rang in.

How about the main feed line?

I sent a man into the basement with the soup to turn up the [virus].

Good. Come on, don't stand there and talk about it. Out on the street. I'll get on the sidewalk. You folks open your windows, open your doors, out of the building. Come on.

Yes, sir.

Anybody covering the third floor yet?

No, I told these people to clear out. It's not them. Let's try that one. It's pretty strong.

Officers, open up in there! Police officers, open up!

This could be it, Captain.

Holly, come on down here. This is it, I'm sure.

What do you want to do, Captain? Put the door in?

Huh? Yeah, yeah. All right, let's go, huh? Together. All right, again now. Is this it, Sergeant?

We think so, yeah.

Let me see if I can kick it in.

All right, go ahead. Try it again. Once again. You know. All right, keep it off by the floor. Holly, hit that window, I'll get this one.

Yes, Sergeant.

Let's go, get them off.

Good. How's the other window?

Pretty bad, Captain. Here, every burner would stand down in the oven. I wonder how long she's been out.

Holly, get the [horse] left.

Yes, sir.

Looks like she's really gone, yeah. Open them up. Get her tongue out of the way. Yeah, that's it. We're gonna watch it now. I'm gonna loosen the neck band. Now that's done again. Let's go. Okay. All right, roll it over that way and I'll turn ahead. How's this?

The gas is clearing out all right, yeah. Now get her around there. Got some artificial respiration until the [interlaker] gets here?

Yes, go ahead. That's the [yesterday]. Get out of the street. Tell them we need the [interlator].

Feels long, yeah, yeah. Keep it up. Let's see if I can get a [poke]. You can't find anything?

No, it might have been just long enough. Watch it there, your head clear.

Okay, it's getting kind of cold in here, Captain. My legs ought to be covered at least. How about my coat?

Now you keep working, I'll use mine. I'm not getting anything. Keep it up. All right, you ready? Here you go. Now watch it there. You go. All right, bring it on. All right, come on, come on. It's been a bit out too long. It's warm, but couldn't find a [poke].

Okay, all set. Come on ahead. Slap the mask on. Yeah, okay. Let's have some oxygen, huh? Good, hold the mask in. That's telling [super] the building. Captain Cronin.

Mrs. Amaro, how are you doing? [Tomorrow] is she going to be all right?

Okay, you're gonna have to. Can't tell. I want your name. Hampton. Uh, Mrs. Amaro, look, we... we better step inside right now. All right, make a little [ritual], will you, [bargain]? Oh, it's a sweet size and very [guess] it's clear. I'd better shut the windows. Okay, Captain.

21 and she lived here alone with her husband. Why did he had work?

Well, I don't know if he worked. Did you see him this morning?

No, I didn't see him. What's his name?

Mr. [Campton]. I was [born]. I didn't, I don't know about anybody else.

Well, what happened? How'd you find out about this?

Well, I was in my apartment downstairs in the basement. I was down there and one of the tenants, I thought they were away and I was sure that they were going to be home and I was there anyway. I was in the basement and I told him Mrs. [Ramon] said tell you what, what's going on? And I went on the other side and I looked at the other room and I said Mrs. [Thompson], she came down and knocked on the door. She said, Mrs. Amaro, you better come upstairs, there's something the matter. I smelled gas in the hall. So I came upstairs and I smelled the gas too, but I couldn't find it. I didn't know where it was coming from. I looked on the third floor, I looked on—

You don't know where the husband works, Mrs. [Merrill], where he can be located now?

No, I don't know. How should I know? All I know is he pays the rent, and that's it.

Do you have any other family?

Well, I never saw nobody.

How long have they lived here?

Oh, three, four months, that's all. In the fall, they moved in. September, October. I could check for you. I could check on it. I've got my rent receipt book down there.

No, no, it'll be all right.

Captain, do you want to look at this?

Huh?

There was a note on the sideboard over there.

Oh, yeah. Oh, it's here. It sure eliminates any possibility of an accident.

Yeah. There sure wasn't much possibility of an accident, not with all four burners and the oven on. No, sir, no. Just a wet night. All right. Save it for the detective, hmm?

Yes, sir.

Oh, a pretty young thing like that. How could she do it? Could she do it to herself? There must be something wrong with her in the head. I always figured it was something like that. She don't talk to nobody. She just goes in and out and doesn't even say hello. Never talk to anybody.

Captain.

Oh, yeah.

We're getting some response.

Nice, kid.

Yes, sir. She's going to be all right?

Breathing naturally. I got some pulse.

Oh, that's good.

I don't know how good it is. Both the breathing and the pulse are pretty weak.

Aren't you going to keep up the oxygen?

Yes, sir. I want to change the mixture.

That's the ambulance. I hope there's a surgeon aboard. A shot of stimulant wouldn't hurt.

She's not conscious, is she?

No, sir, not yet. But she's liable to come around any minute.

Good work. We're just in time, I think. She's lucky.

Yeah. But I don't know. I don't know whether she'll think so.

You are listening to 21st Precinct, a factual account of the way police work in the world's largest city. If you're enjoying the holidays during this between Christmas and... Don't be careless when you're driving. Roads may be slippery. The days are shortest and the nights longest at this time of year. Death takes no holiday when he comes upon the careless driver. This has been a public service message from CBS Radio. Now back to 21st Precinct.

The ambulance fortunately did have a doctor aboard. As the emergency service patrolmen continue to administer oxygen, the gas victim, Mrs. Louise [Campton], the surgeon made a preliminary examination. Under his supervision, the inhalator treatment was continued for another 40 minutes before it was felt she was strong enough to be moved to Beth David, the nearest hospital. Meanwhile, detectives DeLuca and Goldman of the 21st Squad arrived to take charge of the investigation. I returned to the station house where I completed my paperwork. Then I signed the blotter and left for my meal, after which I went on patrol to the precinct. When I returned, it was nearly 3 p.m. I walked into the muster room where Lieutenant Dorman was standing, and Sergeant Waters was now on telephone switchboard.

Captain, sir, just as soon as I signed the blotter, Sergeant—

Yes, sir.

21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. What is it you want to know?

Yeah, they have examinations for police department candidates all the time.

Well, sure, there'll be lots of jobs. They're supposed to increase the authorized force by 5,000 a year.

Well, I'll tell you. Why don't you call the Department of Personnel? That's Corp. on 7-8880. 8880. Or better yet, why don't you go down there? Well, that's 29... 99 Broadway, Dwayne Street. Broadway and Dwayne. Okay. All mentioned.

Ah, yes, Sergeant. Uh, that woman over there is waiting to see you, Captain.

Yeah? Who is she?

She's the mother of the one that took gas this morning, Mrs. [Canton].

Ah. How's she doing, did you hear?

She'll recover all right. Lieutenant Dorman just talked to the hospital again a little while ago. She'll be okay.

Oh, good. All right, I'll be in my office.

Yes, sir.

You want to see me, ma'am?

Are you the captain here?

That's right, I'm Captain [Dorman].

Well, maybe you can give me a little satisfaction.

So, what's the trouble? What's your name?

Mrs. Binning, Mrs. Edna Binning.

Are you the mother of Mrs. [Canton]?

Yes, that's right. What's the trouble, Mrs. Binning?

I want to register a complaint about the way I've been treated. Here? Upstairs, by the detectives, or they call themselves detectives. They're making a report that my daughter attempted suicide. It was murder, attempted murder at least. That's what it was.

Ah, now, I was there, Mrs. Binning.

I don't care what you were. You don't know the circumstances. Maybe you'd better come into my office.

Oh, I'd be glad to. And I hope... You're more considerate than that lieutenant upstairs. May I go right ahead?

Thank you. I remember his name, Lieutenant King, Lieutenant Matt King. I'm going to write a letter to the police chief, or whoever it is. That's what I'm going to do.

Yeah, well, I'm supposing you sit down here, Mrs. Binning.

I don't get any satisfaction. That's exactly what I'm going to do.

Mrs. Binning, I know you're upset, but it's quite obvious what happened. She, well, she wrote out a note.

Yes, I saw that. Turned on all four burners of the stove, turned on the oven, and bolted the door from the inside.

Oh, she did. Then how can you say she didn't attempt suicide?

Who drove her to it? Mr. Blaine, just the same as if he held a gun to her head and pulled the trigger.

Who's Mr. Blaine? Who's that?

Her husband.

Oh. I warned her. I warned her when she first started to go with him. I told her what would happen, how things would wind up. But do you think she'd listen to me? It was like talking to a stone wall.

Well, you see what happened, don't you? You see where she is. Well, I want to have him arrested.

There's nothing he can be arrested for. He's ruined her life. It cost me two years of aggravation. And why doesn't she leave him? She'll never hold on to him. You see that? The death of him. She's so afraid of him. She'd rather do away with herself. I warned him. He'd never amount to anything. I warned her what he'd do to her.

All right. I want him arrested.

Now, Mrs. [Benham], if you want to make a complaint against Lieutenant King because he wouldn't arrest your son-in-law, you'll have to make the same complaint against me.

My complaint goes deeper than that. I told the detective I wanted to prevent him from seeing her in the hospital. I want him to be kept out. And I want him to be kept out of their apartment so she can get her feelings away from there.

He's his wife, Mrs. [Benham]. There's nothing we can do to keep him from visiting her.

Oh, is he fair? And it's his apartment as much as it is hers.

I demand that she be protected against him.

Mrs. [Benham], if he wants protection, all she has to do is ask for it herself.

He's in no condition to ask for anything thanks to him.

Has he been over there to the hospital?

Of course he has. So concerned for her and carrying on and asking. It's nothing but a lie to make people believe that he cares about what happens. He doesn't care. There's only one thing about her. That's all that he was doing when I got there. There's another thing I'd like to know. Why did you have to go out of your way to find him? And I had to find out about his roundabout. I'm her mother, after all.

Well, if the detectives hadn't been able to get in touch with Mr. [Campton], they'd probably notified you.

I'm the one who should have been notified in the first place. The husband is... You get that information? I never heard of it. You know what he did? Instead of calling me himself on the telephone, he had some girl in his office call, a stranger, calling me to tell me my baby was in the hospital. Probably wanted to get right over there himself. The man should have had the decency to call me himself.

Well, I'll tell you, Mrs. [Benham], it seems to me the detectives handled everything in a correct manner. I can tell you not to make a complaint, but I think you'll only be wasting your time and theirs and, well, a lot of other people's time if you do.

All right. Is that all the satisfaction I'm going to get?

I don't think you'll get more anyplace else. I'll be at the hospital in case you change your mind.

I've nothing to change my mind about, Mrs. [Benham].

Well, we'll see about that. Goodbye.

Goodbye, Mrs. [Benham].

Sergeant, I'm going upstairs to the detectives.

Oh, Captain.

Yeah.

My father came in with the husband of that Mrs. [Canton] a few minutes ago.

Did he?

Yes, but he took him upstairs. From what I understand, it's lucky he and his mother-in-law miss each other around here.

Yes. Yes, it is.

Skipper.

My son.

Hello, Captain. Hi, sir.

Cronin.

Hi.

Lieutenant King, this office?

Delta Adrian, there.

Captain Cronin.

Captain.

Captain Cronin, Mr. William [Canton].

Mr. [Canton]? Hello.

This is [Don], Captain. Hi. I just met your mother-in-law, Mr. [Canton].

Oh, yeah? Then you can understand what's been going on. I met her, too, Captain.

So she told me, ma'am. We had quite a session.

Doesn't seem very fond of you, Bill.

Oh, that's the understatement of the year. She thinks I'm the worst thing that ever came into her life. When Louise and I got married, it was the tragedy of the century.

Well, what's the story, Bill?

Oh, there's no story. You've got an idea what made her turn on the gas, haven't you?

Well, she's been threatening to do it for a year. I never believed her. I didn't think she meant it.

Nope. Sounds like she meant it.

Bill, darling, I'm sorry. I love you too much. I can't be without you. Please forgive me.

Can I see that, please?

That's her writing, isn't it?

Yeah, yeah. It's her writing.

What does she mean, I can't be without you?

Well, we had a fight last night.

What about?

What do you think about? About her mother.

Some fight?

Yeah, it was. You told her you were going to leave her.

Yeah. Look, Lieutenant, I'm nuts about her. I really am. You can see that, can't you? Can't you, Captain?

Well, then why did you say you wanted to leave her?

You've got no idea what I've been through the last two years. That old lady has been making our lives miserable. She keeps telling Louise that she's got no business being married to a guy like me. She says I'm nothing. A lousy salesman that just barely got through high school. She says Louise is entitled to a lot more. The old lady kept interfering in our lives. She was always wanting to give her things. Furniture and money and clothes.

That sounds pretty generous.

Oh, there wasn't anything generous about it. She just did it to show me up. Every time she gave Louise something, there was a moral that went with it. Now, your husband should be doing this for you, she'd say. But look, your mother has to do it. Now, what kind of a husband is that? She was just trying to break us up, that's all. I don't call that generous.

Well, what did she do specifically to try to break you up?

Everything. Everything she could think of. I'd tell Louise not to take anything from her. And then she'd come around and give Louise $20 or $50 or whatever it was. And she'd say, don't tell Bill about this. Go out and spend it. Have a good time. Have lunch at a nice place. Take one of your girlfriends. Go buy something for yourself. Well, this went on and on and on. And I was getting pretty sore about it. I was getting sore because the old lady was becoming like a, like a stone wall between Louise and me. You know, she'd tell Louise to lie to me. You know, lie to me about where she got a new dress or a new sweater or something. And finally, I said, look, honey, you've got to make a choice. Either be a wife to me or go home to Mama.

So she said. She'd be a wife to me.

That was good, wasn't it?

Well, I thought it was going to be all right until I got out of the army.

Well, when was that?

In September. The old lady wanted to set us up in class.

Well, I didn't want to be set up in class. I wanted to make my own way. So I said to Louise, look, baby, we've got to look around for a place we can afford.

Well, you saw what we could afford.

Yeah, I saw. I mean, Louise was okay about it. I mean, she wasn't tickled to death that we had to move into a place like that. But she knew it was within the limits. And things would get better. Louise understands that. But her mother, she thought it was a rat hole. Now, she couldn't see her daughter living there. So things got worse with her whispering into Louise's ear. They got worse and worse and worse. And Louise and I were having a fight almost every night. It got so I hated to come home.

What happened last night?

That was a payoff. I got home and Louise told me she'd been with her mother that day. So right away, I smelled something was cooking. I said, what does she want? And Louise told me, her mother said, that we should come live with her. She said, she's got a big apartment. She's got plenty of room. And that her daughter has no business living in a rat hole like this.

Was that the cause of the big fight?

No, that was only part of it. Her mother is leaving for Florida for a month. See? So she wants Louise to come with her.

Yeah, leave me here in New York and go to Florida. All expenses paid.

I said, honey, nothing doing. I mean, this has been going on for almost two years, almost since we were married. Things like this. And once I went to the old lady. And I said, please, leave Louise alone. You're running her nuts. And you know what the old lady said?

No, what?

The old lady said that she would pay for the psychiatrist.

Now, how do you like that? It's all right for her daughter to go nuts as long as she goes to a Park Avenue psychiatrist.

You had this fight last night.

Yeah, but we patched things up as good as they could be patched up before we went to bed. She said she'd do whatever I wanted her to do. And then she started again this morning. And as soon as she started, I said, honey. I've had it. I mean, I love you, but I can't take this anymore. I'm through. This is it. Goodbye. And I went out the door.

Well, I guess that was a mistake. I should have realized the mental condition she's been in. You know, she's really had it rough getting pulled from both ends like that. I made it a little bit too final. I went a little bit too far, I guess.

Sure looks like you did, Bill.

I'm sorry. You don't know how sorry I am. If there's anything I can do to make it up to her, I'm going to do it. You can count on that.

Well, you're just lucky we got there in time.

Don't I know it, and I appreciate it. You know, the doctor over at the hospital told me she wouldn't have had a chance if it weren't for the emergency squad. Not only the emergency squad, but all you fellas. It was really great, and I appreciate it.

What are you going to do when she gets out of the hospital? Start fighting all over again?

Well, not if I can help it, but I've just got to get this settled. I don't know how I'm going to do it, but I've got to get it settled.

You got any idea?

No, not me. Hey. Specialty is Steve. Others will law a little bit out of my line.

After Bill [Campton] left to return to the hospital for another visit with his wife, I remained in Lieutenant King's office for a while. We went over several applications for pistol license renewals in the precinct, each of which must be investigated by both the precinct commander and the detective squad commander. We discussed our independent findings in each case. When I returned downstairs, it was nearly time to turn out the platoon for the 4 to 12 tour. As I came into the back room, Sergeant Lyons, who had supervised patrol during the tour, had the men lined up for inspection. As I walked out into the muster room, I saw the front door of the station house open. Inside came the crew of sector car number two. With Mercado was Bill [Campton]. A few steps in back was his mother-in-law, Mrs. Binning, with [Colt].

I want him locked up. I want him locked up, but he'll never do a thing like that again.

Look, it'd be a pleasure if it would keep you away from him.

All right, [Colt]. Step up to the desk, will you?

Mercado.

Yes, Captain.

What have you got here? I thought you were trying to kill me. We answered the call, Captain. The disturbance at the main reception desk.

That's David Hospital.

That's what I saw him with. He's bound to kill me.

Let the officer tell me the story, lady.

She's making the arrest, Sergeant. We didn't see it.

Do you want him arrested, lady?

I certainly do.

He's his mother-in-law, Captain.

Yes, Captain.

Well, Captain, I told you he was a murderer. You didn't take my word for it. He struck me with his fist.

Is that right, Bill?

Yep, that's right. Said you wanted to get it settled. Do you think this settles it?

Captain, I saw Louise again. Her mother had been there talking to her.

Of course I've been there. Talking to her. She's my daughter, isn't she?

She's my wife.

All right, folks. Take it easy.

Florida isn't far enough. She wants to take her to Europe now. And Louise wants to go. It will do her good.

That's not what she told me.

It's what we decided.

No, it's what you decided. And I decided that she wants to stay here and she agrees with me.

Mrs. [Brennan], are you sure you want to have him arrested?

I most certainly do.

What effect do you think it will have on your daughter? Arresting her husband. Bad mental state right now.

Well, he has me offered to apologize. I don't offer to be unreasonable.

Well, I don't see why not. It's a perfectly natural condition.

Well.

Oh, it's all right, Captain. Let her arrest me. It's worth it. I haven't felt this good in a year. Go ahead, Sergeant. Book him.

21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. Hey, what? How old is he? He beat up badly?

And so it goes. Around the clock, through the week, every day, every year. A police precinct in the city of New York is a flesh and blood merry-go-round. Anyone can catch the brass ring. Or the brass ring can catch anyone.

21st Precinct. A factual investigation. An account of the way the police work in the world's largest city is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the Police Department, City of New York. James Gregory in the role of Captain Cronin, Ken Lynch as Lieutenant King, Harold Stone as Sergeant Waters. Featured in tonight's cast were Martha Greenhouse, William Redfield, Abby Lewis, Bill Quinn, and Ralph Camargo. 21st Precinct is written and produced by Stanley Nist. I'm [Hannah] speaking.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑