The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 27 min to read
The 21st Precinct. It's just lines on the map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the nine-tenths of a square mile between 5th Avenue and the East River wouldn't know, if you asked them, that they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, the security of their homes, their persons, and their property is the job of the men of the 21st Precinct. The 21st. 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Cronin, Vincent P. Cronin. I'm captain in command of the 21st Precinct. I was doing day duty, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. Tours of duty vary like the weather. Some are quiet, others are stormy. This tour was a stormy one.
When I came on the job at 7:30 a.m., a three-alarm fire in an old brewery near the East River had just been brought under control. Two city firemen had been overcome and taken to Metropolitan Hospital. At 8:16 a.m., a bus and a taxi cab collided on 2nd Avenue. The driver of the cab and his two passengers were injured. Shortly after 9 o'clock, there was a call that a paint store on Lexington Avenue had been burglarized during the night. I was still at the scene of the accident when Patrolman Farrell, my operator, rang into T.S. from a call box and informed me of the burglary. We made the run to Lexington Avenue.
The men from Sector 4 and Sergeant Keeney were all ready on the job. Farrell parked between their cars in front of the paint store.
"All right, let's go."
"Hello, Captain."
"What do we got, Ross?"
"A safe job."
"Yeah. They hauled it away. They just rolled it out the front door, carried it away."
"All right. Don't touch the door, Captain. That's the way they got in and out."
"Okay. Sergeant Keeney says the detectives might want to try it for fingerprints."
"All right. Stay on the job here. Keep the sidewalk clear. What time do you usually open the door, Mr. Ristolis?"
"Same time, 9 o'clock. 9 o'clock every day."
"Hello, Sergeant."
"Captain. Mr. Ristolis, this is Captain. Captain Cronin."
"How do you do? Some mess to come to work to. Some mess, huh?"
"Mr. Ristolis is a proprietor, Captain. Mr. Peter Ristolis. He opened up this morning and found a place that had been burglarized during the night. The whole safe picked up."
"The whole safe. You'd think the safe would be safe. The whole safe."
"Did you notify the detective, Sergeant?"
"Yes, sir. I rang in as soon as I saw what it was. Sally was catching. He notified the safe and loft squad, and he's on his way over here himself."
"Oh, where was this safe, Mr. Ristolis?"
"Right back there. Right back there in plain view with a light on it. Light on it. Right, right here. In between brushes and water."
"What kind of a safe was it, Mr. Ristolis?"
"A black one."
"I mean, do you know the name of the manufacturer and the style number?"
"Oh, well, to tell you the truth, no. And when did you buy it? Well, let's see. I had it when I removed to this location. I had it about a year then. I've been here nine years, so I got the safe about ten."
"It's important the detectives have a description of the safe. Don't you have the manufacturer's name, the model number, written down, something?"
"Well, yes. Yes, I think I do. I think I got the original invoice from when I bought it."
"Good. That's all we need. Where is it in the safe? How was the entry made, Sergeant?"
"The door was jimmied. Neat job, Captain. They got a bar between the door and the frame and just snapped off the lock."
"Yeah. And when I walked up to the door, I could see something was screwy. I touched it and it opened. The lock is broken off."
"Listen, I got my insurance policies in the safe, too. How does that make me stand on the insurance?"
"Boy, you don't need your policies. Just get in touch with your broker. Do you have any cash in the safe?"
"Oh, yeah, sure. That's why I keep the safe."
"How much?"
"Oh, six, seven hundred dollars."
"Your receipt from yesterday?"
"Well, most of it. Four or four-fifty of the receipts yesterday. The rest is extra cash I just keep rotting."
"Of what?"
"Well, to tell you the truth, Captain, it's a couple of hundred dollars I had I didn't want my wife to know about. You know, mad money. She knows everything I'm doing and how much I got in the bank for the last nickel. You see, I'm the president and she's the secretary treasurer of this little corporation we got, the Solar Saints Corporation. And she takes the job serious. I figure I'm entitled to a couple of hundred dollars, you know."
"No, what is it? Six or seven hundred dollars?"
"Well, between, I don't know. I'd have to figure the register and so forth."
"What else did you have in there, Mr. Ristolis?"
"Oh, a couple of dollars in stamps. Oh. Oh, for crying out loud, my war bonds. My war bonds was in there."
"No, you won't lose anything there. You have a record of the serial numbers, don't you?"
"Yeah. Also, you sure had a lot of faith in that safe, Mr. Ristolis."
"Well, who'd have thought, you know? Listen, the government will make good on those war bonds, won't they? That's my hard-earned money in those bonds."
"What happened? You better get in touch with the Treasury Department as soon as you can, Mr. Ristolis."
"Oh, yeah, that's a good idea. Anything else in there, Mr. Ristolis?"
"Oh, my accounts receivable. Listen, how much chance is there of getting them back? I mean the bonds and the accounts receivable. I don't care about the cash. You know, this could develop into an expensive proposition. The Treasury might give me a hard time, and without the accounts receivable, well, to tell you the truth, I'm a dead duck. Accounts payable, who cares? The people I owe, if I don't pay them, will let me know, but the people that owe me aren't going to come around here and volunteer money. No, sir. You think I can get it back, the contents, besides the cash, I mean?"
"You probably will, Mr. Ristolis. It's all I want, the cash. The ledgers and war bonds won't do them any good."
"Oh, that's good news. If only it comes true. Oh, what'd they do, Sergeant? Roll it along here?"
"Yes, sir. You can see the track. Right down here and out the door. Must have had a pickup truck or a car waiting."
"A car? Oh, they couldn't get that safe into a car. You know how big it is? Well, it comes up to here. Up to here. There must have been nine guys to move it. Look, I haven't had it out of that corner for two years. It was so heavy. Look at the dust back there. You, uh... All alone? All alone in the store, Mr. Ristolis?"
"No, that's right. All alone. Except on Saturdays. My wife comes down to give me a hand and work on the books. She's got a job down on Wall Street. On Saturdays, she comes to help me out."
"You've always been alone in the store?"
"Well, yeah, for the last three or four years. I used to have help, but it got more than the traffic could dare. I couldn't keep them, and I always had their problems, plus my own. I figured it didn't pay. Twelve guys there must have been to roll that safe out of here. Believe me, it was this big. It was this big and heavy. Now, who could that be on the phone? It's a fine time to call."
"You better ask her, Mr. Ristolis. It's a fine time for business as usual. Some deal, huh, Captain?"
"Yeah. Had to roll the safe out, cross the sidewalk, up on with trucks. Where was the patrolman on post?"
"Beats me, Captain. What time do you think they broke in, Sergeant?"
"He closes the store at 6 o'clock. He didn't open up until 9 this morning. Could have been any time in between."
"Yeah, yeah. Sergeant, give me the names of the two men who were on post here for the night tour and for the late tour."
"Yes, sir."
"I want to know why they didn't see this burglar in progress, or at least discover that the door was jimmied."
"Hey, listen, Captain. That telephone's for you."
"For me?"
"Yeah, I answered it when somebody says, who's the cop in charge there? It was a dame, some dame. I said, there's a captain here. She said, let me talk to the captain."
"All right, where's the... It's back there on the counter, right next to the case, right here."
"You don't need all those men here, Sergeant. Get some of them back on patrol."
"Yes, sir."
"Captain Cronin. I... Oh, it's important if you want to talk to me. I want to talk about a proposition with you."
"You know I must, do you? Very nice of you. What's your proposition?"
"If you don't get it. Hold on a minute. Now, talk it over. We'll admit to restore it. No, I don't... Cronin, 25th Precinct. I thought it was a burglar."
"Burglar? Burglar on the phone? I'm sure he said it once. What does he want?"
"A combination to the safe."
"The what? Who does he think he is?"
"He can't get it open. He said if he gets the combination, you'll recover everything else in the safe, except the money. All he wants is the money. If he doesn't get it, he says, the whole thing goes to the bottom of the river."
"You mean I could get my accounts receivable and my war bonds back?"
"That's what he said."
"Well, who cares about the money? I'm covered by insurance for that. I'll go along with him. I'm inclined to do that."
"Well, I don't know whether I will, Mr. Ristolis. Now, look, who stops this? I've got a lot to lose. We'll talk it over with the detectives. They'll be here soon and see what they want to do about it."
"Well, I know what I want to do about it."
Within a few minutes, detectives of both the 21st Squad and the Safe and Loft Squad, the Central Office specialists who handle safe burglaries on a citywide basis, arrived at the scene. Sergeant Keeney gave them such information as he had collected, and I told them of a phone call from the man who was purported to be one of the burglars. The detectives took over the investigation, and Sergeant Keeney instructed his men to resume patrol. I returned to the station house where I signed the blotter, went into my office to read and sign reports and communications which had accumulated since I was last on duty.
At 20 minutes after 10, I'd almost finished the paperwork, when I looked up and saw Lieutenant Matt King, a man of the 21st Detective Squad, and another man standing in the doorway.
"Sergeant Keeney, this is Lieutenant Gordon Sawyer of the Safe and Loft Squad."
"I know you, Sergeant."
"Yes, sir. Sit down. Matt, sit down."
"Yes."
"Well, that was an odd one this morning, wasn't it?"
"It sure was. How do you figure, Sergeant? You fellas ever hear of anything like that before?"
"No, sir. It's new to us. Guy must be a psycho trying to swing a deal like that."
"Well, he didn't sound much like a psycho on the phone, Matt. How are you fellas going to figure, Sergeant?"
"Well, there are a couple of things, Captain. One, Mr. Ristolis said it was a woman on the phone when he answered, and you picked it up, and it was a man."
"That's right."
"Two, from the description Ristolis gave us of the box, it sounded like a certified 600. Now, a safe man who really knows his business wouldn't find much trouble getting into a box like that. He'd try ripping it, and if that didn't work, he'd use a cutting torch, get inside of it that way, especially since they carried it off and can work on it at their leisure. They aren't red-hot iron men, that's for sure. Whoever they are, I don't think they've been long in the trade."
"How many of them, you think?"
"Well, that box weighs 600 pounds. There must have been at least three of them, maybe four."
"And what about the girl on the phone?"
"I don't know, Captain. I think I've got an idea about that."
"Yes, sir?"
"If this burglar's going to put the proposition to someone, who'd be the logical person? Not the policeman on the job. The logical one would have been Ristolis. I don't think he wanted to talk to Ristolis. That's why he had the girl put in the call."
"You mean you think Ristolis might have recognized his voice?"
"Might have. Yes, sir. That's a good possibility."
"But why the girl? There must have been at least two other men in the deal. Why the girl?"
"I don't know. Maybe his friends didn't think it was a good idea. Maybe they gave up on the deal when they couldn't get the box open. No, any number of reasons. Boy, let's check out some of the people Ristolis has known."
"Okay, Lieutenant. He said he used to have help in the store, but not anymore. How about his former employees?"
"Yes, sir. There might be something there. You going to be around here all day, Captain?"
"Oh, I was going out on patrol again this afternoon. That's about all. Why?"
"Well, we figured this bum might call back here to see if the deal will go through. If he does, we've got the switchboard here. One of us will be right out there. We'll keep one line open to the telephone company to get the location of the phone he's calling from. As soon as we can get the location, we'll have a car go right over there. He won't stay on the phone long. He wouldn't this morning. He knows we're looking for his call."
"Well, he's got to stay on long enough for you to give him the combination. And you want to go along with it?"
"Well, part way. We'll give him a phony combination. That might give us a chance to get to him. If you take long enough to tell it to him, Captain."
"I'll take long enough. We'll be out at the board and start to work on every call that comes."
"Studio, Captain, if that's all right."
"Yeah, that's all right. If you'll just take a few seconds longer to get to the phone than you normally do, we might have a chance. If he calls again."
"Well, he's got the safe, and we've got the combination. If he had the nerve to carry that safe out across the sidewalk, he's certainly got nerve enough to make another telephone call."
You are listening to 21st Precinct, a factual account of the way police work in the world's largest city. This year, there's something brand new in campaign news coverage, an innovation by CBS News, which is always on the lookout for new ways to illuminate and enlarge its news reporting. It's the CBS News Campaign Cavalcade, a 12-man unit of top CBS newsmen which will be touring America in two specially designed and equipped station wagons, heading always for on-the-spot coverage wherever political news is breaking. Perhaps the cavalcade has already visited your locality. Perhaps it's on its way right now to cover the political situation there not only from the candidate's point of view, but yours. Be on the lookout for it, for the CBS News Campaign Cavalcade is on its way.
And now back to Captain Cronin and the 21st Precinct.
I remained at the station house for the balance of the morning. Detective Sawyer of the Safe and Loft Squad posted himself next to the telephone switchboard ready to use another line to trace any subsequent call from the safe burglar. He got head starts on two callers who had asked for me, but both of them turned out to be ordinary police business. At 11 o'clock, a Coleman White, who had worked the 12 to 8 on the post where the safe burglary occurred, came into the precinct house and stopped to talk to the desk officer. About the same time, I finished my paperwork and started out of the office into the muster room. I saw Patrolman White and asked him to come into my office.
"What are you doing back in the house, White? Weren't you off at 8 o'clock this morning?"
"Yes, sir, but I had to go to court on an old case and I left something here I wanted to pick up."
"Come on inside. You were assigned to post number 6 from midnight to 8 a.m., is that right?"
"Yes, sir, that's right."
"You're familiar with the paint store on Lexington Avenue run by Mr. Ristolis?"
"Yeah, that's on post number 6, Captain."
"Did you have occasion to notice anything unusual at the paint store during your tour or do?"
"No, sir."
"Did you try the front door at all during your tour?"
"Well, I did on my first time around."
"You saw nothing unusual during the balance of your trip?"
"No, sir."
"Did you notice any truck parked on your post near the store?"
"No, sir."
"White, sometime during the night, burglars jimmied the front door, got in the store, rolled out a 600-pound safe."
"They did? I'm telling you they did. Rolled it out the front door, crossed the sidewalk, into a truck. Where were you?"
"Well, I didn't see them."
"I know you didn't see them. I'm trying to find out why."
"Yes, sir. After your first time around, didn't you try the door again during the course of the tour?"
"No, sir."
"Well, why not? Can you explain why you didn't?"
"Yes, sir."
"Well? Go ahead, explain. It's what I'm waiting for."
"Well, a little after one o'clock, there was some trouble over in a bar on 3rd Avenue."
"What kind of trouble?"
"Oh, two of the patrons got in a fight, Captain. One of them hit the other over the head with a beer bottle. The man was unconscious, and I had to go to the hospital with him."
"And what time did you get back on post?"
"At 2:23, Captain."
"Did you start around again?"
"Yes, sir."
"Did you try any front doors?"
"Well, I started to, but it was long about that time that the alarm hit for this fire in the old brewery on the river."
"Yeah?"
"Well, Sergeant Collins drove by and instructed me to leave my post and go over to York Avenue."
"Well, why did you do that?"
"Well, the firemen had lines strung across York Avenue. There were about 30 pieces of apparatus there. I was instructed to reroute traffic off the road. York Avenue and on to 1st and 2nd."
"How long did you stay there?"
"Until I was relieved."
"What time was that?"
"20 minutes after 8 o'clock this morning. I came into the station house, changed into my civilian clothes, and I went down to court. That's where I was until I got back here."
"Okay, well, go on home."
"Yes, sir. Thank you, Captain. Bye, Captain."
"Oh, leave the door open."
"21st Precinct, Captain Cronin."
"Boy, I think it's awful."
"All right. If you'll hang up, I'll let it rip."
"Okay. 21st Precinct, Captain Cronin. You know who it is?"
"I think so. Well, what about... Look, first, I want your assurance that you're not going to throw that safe in the river. A man wants his property back."
"You can get it back."
"Well, I just want to make sure. Listen, I know what you're trying to do. You're telling me I'm not. Now, what... All right, just a second. Now, let me find it, huh? Take more than a second."
"I'll pound you a second."
"All right, all right. I'm getting it. Just a second. I'm pounding you. All right, hold it. Here it is."
"What?"
"Let's see. Two full turns to the right. Stop at 71."
"Stop at 71?"
"Mm-hmm. Now, back left past 71, stop at 6."
"Back left past 71. Look, you're going to keep your promise, aren't you?"
"I'll keep my promise, too. All right. And right, right to 98."
"Is that it?"
"Yep, that's it."
"Okay. I think we got a chance, Captain."
"Oh, I couldn't keep him on the phone any longer, Sawyer. He knew what we were up to."
"We made it. Good. The girl was with him again. At least she was standing right alongside him and taking down the combination as he repeated it. It was from a pay station. I'll tell you. A drugstore on Astoria Boulevard. A car from 114th is on the way."
"Good. Maybe they'll make it. I'll call the squad out there and ask them to take a look, too."
"Okay. I'll do it from the board."
"Oh, excuse me, Lieutenant."
"It's all right. Go ahead."
"We got the call, Lieutenant. You talked to them, Captain?"
"Yeah, Matt. I gave them the combination. They traced it to a pay station and a drugstore on Astoria Boulevard."
"Well, he's probably gone by now."
"Yeah. Well, a car's on the way. Sawyer's calling the 114th squad and having them take a look, too. Astoria, huh?"
"That's right. You know something, Captain? I had Vitale and Novak over there talking to that Mr. Ristolis for the better part of the morning."
"Yeah?"
"We've been going on the possibility that maybe your suggestion is correct. The man didn't want to talk to Ristolis on the phone because he might recognize the voice. They asked him all about his former employees and friends and relatives, anybody that he knew was familiar with the store or wasn't there. Did they get anywhere?"
"No, I don't place much, but one thing came up."
"What's that?"
"Ristolis' wife has a brother who's been in a little trouble."
"Oh, Ristolis."
"Yeah, he did one bit for Grand Larceny, I mean. He's been out for two and a half, three years. He hasn't got jammed up since. Ristolis said his brother-in-law used to call him. He used to work in the store on Saturdays once in a while. No, just to help him out a little bit in a rush. He said he wasn't much account as a clerk, though. He didn't know varnish from enamel. But he hasn't seen his brother-in-law in about seven or eight months. Doesn't think his wife has either."
"Well, it's nothing in itself. Ristolis would know his brother-in-law's voice over the telephone. His brother-in-law might think that Ristolis is a pretty good mark."
"Well, it's a possibility, Matt, but I still don't have much."
"Oh, do you know where he lives, the brother-in-law?"
"Astoria."
"Oh, I guess you want to know."
"Yes, sir. I guess we do."
In another minute or so, Detective Sawyer came into my office and told me that he had spoken to the acting lieutenant in command of the 114th Squad. Two detectives from there were en route to the drugstore on Astoria Boulevard to see if they could locate the caller. It was determined that Detective Sawyer, accompanied by Detective Vitale of the 21st Squad, would go to Astoria and talk to the brother-in-law of the victim. The fact that the brother-in-law lived in Astoria and had a criminal record was considered more than a coincidence.
After they left my office, I turned my attention to other business of the precinct. At 1 p.m., I went out on patrol and returned in time to turn out the platoon for the night tour at 4. The precinct was calmer than when I came on the job in the morning. The storm had abated. After the men marched out the door, a call came from upstairs that Lieutenant King would like to see me in the detective squad office. I walked through the back door where several of the men who had just come off duty were standing around talking, climbed the rickety stairs to the second floor, and walked into the 21st Squad. Detective Sawyer was sitting on the edge of a desk talking to a small blonde woman. I walked over to him.
"Well, I was just doing him a favor. That's all I was doing."
"Sawyer? Oh, hello, Captain. How are you? After all, all he asked me to do was make a telephone call for him. If a girl can't make a telephone call for a man, well, what's this world coming to? Captain, this is Eleanor Mulhall."
"How do you do?"
"I'm sure. I didn't have anything to do with breaking into that store. I wasn't anywhere near the place. I didn't know what it was all about. He asked me to do him a favor. That's all that I did. I didn't know what it was all about. He asked you to write the combination down, too. When he got it from the captain here, you knew what that was all about, didn't you?"
"Well, not exactly. He's not the kind that tells you everything."
"You got it about wrapped up, Sawyer?"
"Yes, pretty much. Vitale and I went to this house in Astoria. We found the brother-in-law out there and her."
"I told you. I was just visiting. That's all I was doing. I was just visiting. We took a look in the garage, and what do you think was there?"
"Right."
"Yes, sir, the safe."
"I didn't know it was in there. I don't look in garages. Why should I look in a garage? Why should I look in a garage? I was just visiting him, and he asked me to do him a favor. You can't tell somebody for doing a favor."
"Oh, where's the lieutenant? In his office?"
"Yes, sir. I didn't know what it was all about. That's the honest-to-goodness truth. He asked me to do him a favor. That's all."
"Got him. Got him. I wasn't feeling anything. I thought you'd like to meet this man, Captain. You talked to him over the phone, Lee Tangley."
"What are we waiting for? You got the state, you got me. Book me and get it over with, will you? I'm tired."
"Says you were up all last night."
"I was up all last night, Dad. It was a very smart thing you did, breaking into your brother-in-law's store, wasn't it?"
"Oh, that was smart enough. The stupid thing was leaving a safe in my garage. I should have found some place else."
"Did you find out who was with him on the deal last night, man?"
"Yes, sir. He told us."
"Sure I told you. I told you everything. Why should I keep anything back? They walked out on me. You think I want to be in and them out? Not me, brother. I'm weak and easy. When I go down for the third time, I take everybody with me."
"Why did you pick on your own brother-in-law?"
"I wanted to keep the money in the family. That was very thoughtful, wasn't it, Captain?"
"Very. We're sending a truck out after the safe, Captain."
"I'm kind of anxious to see it. Sawyer told me they clawed at it and hacked at it and burned it with a torch to try to knock the knob off. They couldn't make a dent in it. That must be a pre-war safe. Do they build them like that today?"
"I'll say they don't. Who's got a chance against one of those things? And it's work. You know that's work? To get it out of the store, onto the truck, and out to the garage. Then to have to go to work on it? You know we worked on that thing from 2:30 this morning till almost 8. We couldn't make a dent in it."
"Is that when you got the bright idea to call me?"
"Yeah, that's right. I came over to New York, walked down the other side of Lexington Avenue to see what kind of a rumble there was from the deal. When I saw all the cops parked out in front, I went in a candy store and called."
"Oh, which way? Just Eleanor?"
"That's right, just Eleanor. I had the idea out in the garage, but the other boys thought I was crazy. They wouldn't have any part of it. I said to them, look, I'm not two feet away from where all that money is. Not two feet, and I can't get my hands on it. If you don't want any part in it, get out. I said to myself, I'll do it myself, and they got out. All that work, not a dime out of it. That's what gets me. Back breaking work. Are you going to bring them in here, those boys? I'd like to see those boys. Look at the looks on their faces. They take a fall, don't get a dime out of it. I'm laughing. It's a big joke."
"All right. Come in, Mr. Ristolis."
"Yeah."
"I'm Lieutenant King. How are you? I'm pleased to know you. Lee, I don't know what to say."
"Say hello."
"I'm ashamed of you, Lee. I'm really ashamed of you. My wife's own brother to do such a thing to me. What do you want from me, Pete? I did it. What am I going to do, say I'm sorry? You would really throw the safe in the river? Your own brother-in-law's accounts receivable and bonds at the bottom of the riverbed? I can understand how you would do it to me, but your own flesh and blood is my wife. Don't knock yourself out, Pete, will you? Why didn't you do it, Lee? Why didn't you come to me if you needed money? I needed money, but who needed a song and dance along with it? Captain, do you understand that I don't? A grown man, look at him. In his trade, he can go out and make $25 a day. $25 a day, and he's got to go get himself in trouble like this again. What's the answer?"
"$25 a day. The answer, Mr. Ristolis, seems to be that he prefers night work."
"21st Precinct, Sergeant Keeney. Who's dead? Who? Where is this? Where? 8080's what? Yeah. Yeah, who is this?"
And so it goes. Around the clock, through the week, every day, every year. A police precinct in the city of New York is a flesh and blood merry-go-round. Anyone can catch the brass ring. Or the brass ring can catch anyone. 21st Precinct transcribed, a factual account of the way police work in the world's largest city, is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the Police Department of the City of New York. James Gregory in the role of Captain Cronin, Ken Lynch as Lieutenant King. Featured in tonight's cast were Joe DeSantis, John Sylvester, Miss Leslie Woods, Bill Quinn, Larry Haynes, and Eric Dressler. 21st Precinct is written, produced, and directed by Stanley Nist. Roger Foster speaking.
