Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Barrie Craig, Confidential Investigator artwork

From the Barrie Craig, Confidential Investigator collection

Dead Bull in a China Shop

Episode 049December 19, 195427 min 59 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 21 min to read

William Gargan stars as Barrie Craig, confidential investigator.

Murder is a steady occupation. Has its handicaps. The hours are irregular, the conditions under which you work aren't always ideal, and there's no social security. Of course, the pay is high, but so are the gallows from which, sooner or later, they hang you.

The National Broadcasting Company presents William Gargan in another transcribed drama of mystery and adventure with America's number one detective, Barrie Craig, confidential investigator.

Barrie Craig speaking. If you're a confidential investigator, and if you're smart, you put yourself on a schedule. You get to the office at nine and get out of it at five. You eat a leisurely dinner and spend the rest of the evening with a book you hope is good. That is, if you're smart. If you're me, you get restless, and around midnight, you drop in at Willie's wagon.

You find Willie morosely staring at his coffee. A small but not underprivileged brunette with her head at the far end of the counter, sobbing. For a wild moment, you think that maybe Willie has wronged our little Nell. You then dismiss such happy fancies. You try to ignore the brunette who keeps right on sobbing, and you make a brilliant opening remark.

What's new, Willie?

Ha! Well, all right. How are the hamburgers?

Not new.

Think I should take a chance on one?

You got the pennies?

No.

I'll make you a hamburger.

Thanks. You better have a cup of coffee first.

Why?

You're dead in your stomach, Nell. I've tasted your hamburgers before.

Well, they ain't improved since then.

Willie. Huh? I know she didn't come with the place. I've never seen her here before. She's pretty, but does she have to make that noise?

She is suffering from grief.

She had the blue plate dinner here?

According to what she tells me, she had a great loss.

What did she lose?

Her bull fiddle.

Her what?

Her bull fiddle. You know, them bloated...

Bloated violins. I know. She plays the double bass.

What's that?

A Carnegie Hall for a bull fiddle.

Oh, yeah, yeah. Except nobody plays on a bull fiddle that she ain't got. It would be harder anyway. Come to think of it, losing one of those things is a little like misplacing the Empire State Building. It was swiped off her.

Here's your hamburger.

Thanks. Mr. Craig, maybe you can help Susie. She don't find a bull fiddle she's liable to be out of work. She is accustomed to eating, so I do not think this will be good for her.

Hey, Susie, come here.

Huh?

I want you to meet Mr. Craig.

Hi, Mr. Craig.

Hello, Susie. Mr. Craig ain't only a friend of mine, Susie. He is also a confidential investigator. You ought to tell him your trouble.

I only got one trouble.

You lost your double bass.

Uh-huh. Only the kind of music I play, it's a bull fiddle.

Where did you lose it?

At the club, the 4920 Club.

You're a part of the band that plays the club?

Uh-uh. I play solos. The customers like it because I'm so... I'm so small and the bull fiddle's so big. And besides, I'm cheaper than the band, so they like it.

A bull fiddle isn't the kind of a thing a man could slip into his coat pocket. There can't be many things harder to steal.

Whoever stole mine didn't worry about that.

When did you miss it?

About an hour ago. I done my number, went out for a walk, and when I got back...

No bull fiddle?

No bull fiddle.

Well, there must have been people around who...

Well, the club closed early tonight. There wasn't anybody around when I got back except Brinker.

Brinker? Who's Brinker?

Well, he's almost... He's almost as big as you are, but not so cute.

Well, I'd have trouble recognizing him from that.

Well, he's sort of a caretaker and club bouncer, you know?

I don't. I'm afraid I may find out, though. All right, Susie, let's go over to the club. Maybe I'll be able to come up with something that might help.

Gosh. Thanks, Mr. Craig.

Hey, wait a minute, Tom. Closing up anyways, I'll tag along.

Why?

Well, I'm intrigued. You know, I would like to meet a character who goes around swiping bull fiddles. I would also like to want him to lay off the Brooklyn Bridge. It's fastened down.

Willie closed up, then the three of us piled into my car, and we took off. Eventually, we arrived at the club.

The club is dark.

Well, I get a key to the stage door. It's just down the alley here.

Mr. Craig, why would anybody want to steal my bull fiddle?

I don't know.

There's a truck parked outside the stage door.

Hey, it's coming straight down the alley. It is! Susie, Willie, get up. Get up against the building. Flatten out.

Look out!

I'm coming! You all right?

It was so close, though. That truck didn't care much whether it ran us down or not.

Backup, it was open, and...

Susie, you had a case for the bull fiddle?

Uh-huh. It was on the truck.

Oh? With a fiddle in it?

Hey, we ought to be chasing it or something.

Had too big a jump on us. I got the license number, though. 4X354. Maybe it'll come in handy later on. Right now, uh, let's get into the club.

Okay. Let's go. Let's go. Let's go. Let's go. Let's go. Let's go.

You're gonna lock the stage door after the bull is stolen, huh?

Not a one like that, and I'll see to it you're forced to eat in your own lunch wagon.

Nobody could be that cruel.

Say, it's open. They had no chance to lock it.

Just a work light on over the dance floor.

Craig.

One large man lying down.

That's Brinker.

Well, he's alive. He was slugged and passed out, but I don't think there's any permanent damage.

Hey, Mr. Craig.

Yeah?

Over here at the edge of the floor.

On my way.

Pretty. It was a double bass, all right. Whoever had left it here had propped it up against the ringside table. A bull fiddle isn't a thing of beauty, usually, though I don't mind looking at one. This one I didn't like to look at. Think about it.

That's yours, Susie?

Yes, it is. The last time you saw it, uh, was it out here on the floor?

Oh, no. It was back at the little bandstand down there. It was brought out only when I did my number, and then it was taken...

Is there a phone in the place?

Give me a walk this way.

This may surprise you. The reason why I want a phone is to make a phone call.

We're surprised. But, uh, what are you going to call about? Susie's got her fiddle back.

Sure. She hasn't got the case, though.

Is that something to get excited about? A bull fiddle case?

I don't know. I hope not. You're worried about something, aren't you?

Lead me to the phone, Susie. I want to find a truck.

Maybe it was the empty club. Shadows huddling in the unlit corners. The floor pale and shining. And the silence that did the job on my nerves. Whatever it was, they were jumping.

Here's Homicide.

Trav, this is Barry.

Things are quiet down here at Homicide, Barry. Do you have to finish this call?

Now stop playing with your Phi Beta Kappa key. I want to know who owns a truck. License number 4X354.

What did the truck do? Run you over?

It came close. 4X354. Hang on. If I can wake anybody up over in motor vehicles, I'll have it for you in a minute.

Thanks, Trav.

I hung on. I thought of Susie playing that bull fiddle. I wondered if she was any good as a musician. I decided she wouldn't have to be very good as a musician.

Yeah?

Christopher Malone, address 74 Eastlake.

That's what I wanted.

Barry.

Yeah?

I don't think so, Trav. All I've got so far is a sort of hunch. Probably won't mean a thing. Come on back to that bridge game.

No one in the department plays bridge while on duty. They play pinochle.

So long, Barry.

So long. Come on, Susie. Let's go back and see if Brinker has come to.

What's wrong with you, Mr. Brinker?

I've got a headache.

In both heads?

Look, this here ain't my head. This here's a lump on my head.

Are you Brinker?

Yeah.

Well, what happened?

I was straightening out the place, and all of a sudden, I feel somebody breathing down the back of my neck. So I says, stop breathing down the back of my neck. So he stops breathing down the back of my neck, and he hits me on the head. I shouldn't have told him to stop breathing down the back of my neck.

Maybe not. Did you see who it was?

I didn't see nothing and nobody.

Too bad. Well, Susie, I'll take you home. Will, are you coming along?

Sure.

Brinker, can you lock it up somewhere?

Yeah, sure. One of the back rooms.

Fine. Let's go.

Someone stole your fiddle. You sure of that, Susie?

I'm sure of it, Mr. Craig.

Then the fiddle was returned, and the case was stolen.

I'll hop in. Anybody got any answers?

Well, maybe I'm asking the right questions, but none of the right people. We'll keep trying.

We dropped Susie off at her apartment. Swung around and headed downtown again. The 74 Eastlake and a truck driver named Christopher Malone.

Maybe I ought to take you home, Willie.

I ain't in no hurry.

But your wife...

That's why I ain't in no hurry.

All right, she's your wife. Don't rub it in. But I'm perfectly willing to share the truck driver with you.

Nice truck ain't out front.

No.

Name plated over the doorbell.

Yeah, Malone.

Maybe he's a hard sleeper.

Yeah, maybe.

Second open door tonight.

There's the light switch.

I got it.

You know, a guy could resent our barging in...

Not this one.

Well, according to the police, Christopher Malone lives at 74 Eastlake.

They're wrong. He's dead there.

Back to William Gargan starring as Barrie Craig in just a moment.

And now, back to William Gargan starring as Barrie Craig, confidential investigator.

Trav came out with a couple of the boys from Homicide. They all stood around and stared at the corpse of the late Mr. Malone. He paid no attention. Corpses rarely do. We'd had a head start. We'd seen him before they did, so we left earlier.

Guys don't look good when they're shot full of bullets. It's never been recommended as a beauty aid.

He was the truck driver who drove away with Susie's bull fiddle case, huh?

Yeah.

So what happened to his truck and the case?

I don't know. Why would anyone swipe a bull fiddle case without the bull fiddle in it anyways?

Maybe he didn't know the fiddle wasn't in the case.

Well, he's sure gonna be disappointed when he gets home and opens the case and reaches for the fiddle.

Somehow, I don't know. I don't think so. Don't ask me why, either.

I won't. You wouldn't answer. Like, if you was to ask me what goes into Willie's Irish stew, would I answer?

But, uh, this car ain't aimed at my house. Or yours. Neither of us live down on River Street.

Malone's garage is on River Street.

Kind of late for a visit in the guy's place of business.

Except there won't be transaction business there tonight. I hope.

River Street pitched sharply to the Hudson below. A murky light picked out a worn sign. Scorching. Swaying in the slight wind. The sign read, Christopher Malone. Licensed trucking. The large garage doors were shut. The smaller door, set in the panel of one of them, was locked. You couldn't look inside.

It's been warmer in Alaska.

Yeah, we've got to get in.

You figure the truck's inside, huh?

Yeah. When we was back in Malone's apartment, why didn't you swipe his keys off of them?

Because somebody else had already done so.

That ain't comforting.

Because whoever knocked off Malone is probably a murderer.

Probably. He is a murderer. The question is...

The question is...

Shh. Someone coming down the street. Willie, this doorway, quick.

What makes you think I'm going to be so lucky?

For the coffee I serve alone, I deserve it.

It's Brinker.

Yeah. Stopping at the garage.

Comfortable. Personally, I would rather lay down in the bed.

One nice thing is we can't have the rest of the truck back here. So Brinker won't spot us while he keeps going.

But, uh, what happens when he stops?

We'll worry about that later.

You got something better to worry about now?

Yeah. Tell me so I can worry about it, too.

Over to your left.

Hmm?

Oh, the bull fiddle case. Still where it was when we spotted it.

I should worry about the case?

Only about what's inside of it.

It was pretty clear, wasn't it?

Sure, I didn't know who he might be, but that he'd be there. That was a certainty. Joker driving this truck is heading out of town.

Come on. We'll try to get that case open.

Hey, give me one good reason.

Corpses aren't pretty. Remember what Malone looked like?

I'm willing to forget.

That's what murderers would like. Okay, we get the case open.

Snap lock on it. Hope we don't need a key.

No. Ought to open easy now.

Okay, you got it open and...

Grab him, Willie.

Okay, I got him.

Yeah, but I don't want him. He's dead.

Ease him down to the floor. I'll get the case down flat.

He's down.

Fine. Breast pocket. Paper's in it.

Uh-huh. On what?

His name's Gordon Bentley.

Bentley? Hey, that's the guy who owns the club where Susie works.

Interesting. Come on, let's put him back in the case.

Yeah, but he won't be able to breathe in it.

Forget I said anything. Okay, let's go.

Now. It'll do. Think of the trouble we would have had if Susie played the piccolo.

We wouldn't have been here if she hadn't.

The guy was shot. Just like Malone?

Yeah.

Which is interesting.

I don't think it's any more interesting than if the guy had been strangled or even poisoned.

You don't appreciate the finer points.

Yeah, what are they?

I'll let you know when I find out. Thanks. So do we jump off the truck now or five seconds from now?

We stay on. The truck's hitting at least 50. We jump now, we could get killed.

We stay on, we will get killed.

I doubt it. Why?

No one could ever get all three of us into that case. Slowing down. We may have a chance to jump for cover when it stops.

Surrounded. Maybe somebody's gonna spot us back here and then...

Maybe it'll be later.

How are things, Brinker?

They're fine, Mr. Walsh. We got a load ready for you to run in.

Okay, Mr. Walsh, that's why I'm here. Buddy's leaving.

Shh.

Hey, Strip, I got something special for you, Mr. Walsh.

You have? What?

I'll tell you about it when we start loading the truck.

We ain't popular. Everybody's gone away. We get out. House is set back from the highway. It's a big place.

Yeah, yeah, well, let's not wait.

We have to.

If I get out of this alive, I'll use meat in the hamburgers.

Don't say anything you'll be sorry for. Come on.

What are we gonna do? Knock on the door and tell them we're working our way through college?

This wouldn't work. They're still looking for me in the sixth grade.

The side of the house, Willie.

The servant's entrance?

A window. Any place we can see what's going on inside. That one.

This gets around, they'll be calling me peepin' Willie.

Lots of guys in there. Very sociable. Not to mention the cases of liquor all over the place. Looks like this would be a warehouse for Bentley's Club.

Yeah, kind of inconvenient. Must be 50 miles out of town.

Must be a reason.

Why Bentley keeps his liquor out here.

His doctor told him to stay away from liquor.

Another one like that and they'll hand you your head.

You can't. It's attached to me.

Something can be done about that.

Nice contortions you're going through. Why?

Trying to get a better look at the liquor cases. Imported stuff.

Yeah. No customs stamp on them. Smuggled, huh?

Yeah. Explains the location of this place.

The truck. Mr. Walsh and friends. The smugglers, I guess. And also...

The delivery boy, huh?

The delivery boy. What it doesn't explain is why Brinker is bringing Walsh a bull fiddle case complete with a recent corpse.

The men inside showed signs of moving. Willie and I moved first. Crossed the road from the truck to a clump of trees.

You said you had something special for me this trip, Brinker.

Oh, I nearly forgot, Mr. Walsh. What I got for you is a bull fiddle and its case.

You don't say. Bentley thinks I ought to study music, maybe?

All I know is you're studying music. You're supposed to keep me here for a while.

Okay. I'll have the boys unload it. But you know something? I'd be a lot happier if instead of a bull fiddle, Susie was in that case.

They unloaded the bull fiddle case, loaded the liquor, and the truck went away. Willie and I stuck it out for a while and also went away.

You know, Mr. Craig, feet are never going to replace the wheel.

Maybe we'll get a hitch soon.

We better. Also, we're in a hurry.

Well, where do we go from here if we ever get transportation?

Susie's apartment.

Duty, or you think it's a nice idea?

Willie, duty's always a nice idea.

We got a hitch to the nearest town. There I made a quick phone call to Mr. Walsh. I advised him to look inside the bull fiddle case. Then Willie and I grabbed a cab and headed for Susie. We got there.

Oh, oh, my, Mr. Craig. And Willie. May we come in?

Oh, of course you may. I was asleep.

I thought you might be, but this is important.

Something's happened?

Susie, how do you and Bentley get along?

Oh, we get along fine. He even wants me to marry him.

Well, how do you feel about that?

I haven't been able to make up my mind. But he's got so much money that... Anyway, I'm not sure I can trust him. A man who runs a nightclub. What kind of husband would he make?

I've never thought about it.

So Gordon, that's Mr. Bentley, said he was going to sell the club to prove he really loved me.

Did he sell it?

He was supposed to this afternoon. For cash?

Oh, sure. Oh, I don't think the man Gordon's selling the club to can write. Besides, I wouldn't want to have any records on account of income taxes, so... Well, that's one of the reasons I don't know if I should marry Gordon. That's Mr. Bentley.

Have you seen Gordon? That's Mr. Bentley. I mean Bentley today.

No. My bull fiddle was stolen, so I forgot all about him. And besides, I...

We found the bull fiddle case, Susie.

You're a darling. Where is it?

That's not important. What is important is, uh, why was just the case stolen the second time?

I don't know.

Susie, suppose I murder someone.

Why would you want to do such a terrible thing?

Well, just suppose I do. I murder him in a nightclub. I've got to hide his body until I can dispose of it safely. Now, where can I hide it?

Well, don't ask me. After all, I...

There's a girl who plays a bull fiddle in the club, which means there's a bull fiddle case around. The man I killed wasn't a big man, so I put him in.

My bull fiddle case?

Right.

Well, it's a very nasty... But you didn't kill anyone.

Somebody did. Put the corpse in your fiddle case.

The corpse of who, Mr. Craig?

Gordon Bentley. Here. You better sit down.

Oh. Oh, that's terrible. I'll never be able to use that case again.

Well, I suppose not. I'll never be able to marry Gordon. That's Mr. Bentley, either.

You don't really care about that, do you?

You mean because I never really loved him?

I mean because you already have all his money.

Hey, Mr. Craig, you're saying she...

It's what I'm saying. She killed Bentley.

Oh, for the cash she sold the club for.

Only she's such a small girl. She had help. That is Brinker's help.

Stop flapping your lips. You don't know a thing.

You, Brinker, and Susie killed Bentley. Lifted the cash, hid Bentley in the fiddle case. You arranged for the late Mr. Malone to pick it up and deliver it to Walsh out in the country.

You get around, Craig.

Thanks. But I spotted that case in the truck. So while I took Susie home, you killed Malone. Closing that road, you thought.

He went around thinking such nasty thoughts about me and I said he was cute.

Shut up, Susie. The plan was simple. You delivered the case with Bentley inside and asked Walsh to keep it. Susie went out and planted the stolen bull fiddle story with Willie and, as it happened, with me. Why? Tomorrow morning, Susie would yell to the cops, Bentley is missing. I'd remember the bull fiddle. Well, Brinker would remember Walsh and the country hideout. The cops would grab Walsh, the case, find the corpse in it, and Walsh would fry.

Thanks, Willie. I got a surprise for you. It's still gonna be that way. Because after you two jokers go away, you're dead someplace. The program goes on like scheduled.

Oh.

Don't answer that. We don't care who it is.

Sure you care. Because before coming here, I phoned your friend Walsh. I told him to look inside that fiddle case.

Spread around, boys. All right, we're off the pop gun, Brinker.

No!

Okay! You should have dropped it, Brinker. Your arm would feel a lot better. But cheer up. Maybe it'll be healed before they execute you.

That wasn't a nice thing to say, but then murderers aren't nice people.

I phoned the police, and by the time they arrived, Walsh had discreetly gone for a long walk. The cops would get him anyway. However, they took over Brinker and Susie.

I, uh, hate to ask, but, uh, something must have tipped you.

Susie did.

I didn't hear her.

Sure you did. It was a phony story, Willie. We were supposed to think someone had put Bentley in that fiddle case in the afternoon. Somebody did. Sure. But if they did, the bull fiddle would have been out in the open. It had to be. Yeah, Susie would have noticed that. Would have wondered who took it out. She would have checked, and... If she'd been telling the truth. She would have said the case was stolen, not the fiddle. But the truth wasn't what Susie was dealing in. It was murder.

Uh-huh. Well, thanks for taking me home. And, uh, after all this time, when I walk into that house where my wife is no doubt waiting up for me and her eyes light on me, it won't be joy, Mr. Craig.

Well, what will it be?

Murder.

You have been listening to William Gargan in another exciting transcribed mystery drama from the adventures of Barrie Craig, Confidential Investigator.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑