The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read
This is Orson Welles, speaking from London. The Black Museum, a repository of death, a museum of murder. Yes, here in the grim stone structure on the Thames, which houses Scotland Yard's, is a warehouse of homicides. Where everyday objects, a portable typewriter, a jack for an automobile, an ice pick, all are touched by murder. Here's a pair of spectacles. It's a familiar object, neat, not too large, tortoiseshell with gold top. You've seen them a hundred times on girls who obviously have decided that they must wear glasses. They'll make the glasses as decorative as possible. But this pair, women's glasses, right on top in the suitcase. And pretty thoroughly smashed.
What a... Something, whatever it was, must have hit her awfully hard to smash her spectacles like this.
Today. Now today, no spectacles can be seen in the Black Museum. From the annals of the Criminal Investigation Department of the London Police, we bring you the dramatic stories of the crimes recorded by the objects in Scotland Yard's gallery of death, the Black Museum.
In just a moment, you will hear the Black Museum starring Orson Welles. The Black Museum starring Orson Welles.
Now here we are, the Black Museum. Scotland Yard's Museum of Murder. He allows death. Who died by these objects? The dead, named here on the white labels of the black lettering. Or the killers, named in equal place in equal size. Wherever they are known. A mandolin string, made for music, a mandolin string. Stretch it across the top of a stairway. See it blend and dissipate. Be under the dark carpet background. Stretch it ankle high and listen in the dark. Here's a French novel. Romance. With a blackened perforation in the center of the pages with a bullet past. Which ended romance.
Now here we are, the spectacles. Rather pathetic spectacles. The lenses are cracked, the frame twisted and bent. The gilt tarnished. Many other things were tarnished, including a man's reputation. A chain of events which began. That morning when Mrs. Oliver came to see Inspector Caswell, the Yard.
I understand, Mrs. Oliver. Perhaps your daughter thought she'd let you know, but didn't after all.
I wish I could believe that, Inspector. But I can't. Daisy was so determined when she left that night. And since she went to the train, you've heard nothing?
I wired Ron. I never liked him. Something, I don't know. I thought my Daisy'd do better for herself than a chicken farmer. Anyway, I wired. Asked him if Daisy was there. I received this in reply, Inspector. "Thought Daisy coming Saturday, not Friday. Went to meet her. Not there. Letter follows. Ron Smith." This was last Saturday?
Yes. I wired on Monday. Then this answer came back the same day. The letter came in yesterday, Wednesday.
Thank you. "Dear Mrs. Oliver, you do not know how shocked I am. Daisy missing since Friday afternoon. This is really terrible. She wrote asking me to meet her Saturday." The heart-sick words of a worried man, the tone and feeling of the letter, plus the fear and the tears of the mother, sent Inspector Caswell to Larkspur in Sussex, the nearest town to Ron Smith's chicken farm, the railway terminal for the area. He turned first to that prime source of all rural information, the local pub.
Evening, landlord.
Good morning, Lord.
A pint of beer, please.
Yes, sir. Of course. Haven't I seen you someplace before, my good man?
What? Oh, Jack Sheen. You have seen me someplace before. Drink up, man. It's good to see a familiar face.
Familiar face drawn by a familiar scent. You're not down here on business.
I am. And so are you.
No, I wanted to keep this quiet for a while.
Oh. With that crown, over at the dartboard, your old-time friend, Jack Sheen, Caswell, Morton of the Times, Alsop of the Guardian, Durr of the News, and yours truly. You fellows have the sense of smell of a ferret.
We have to. It's our living. Do you think the girl is dead, Caswell?
Words of one syllable. Literally one syllable. Do you think the girl is dead?
Inspector Caswell shrugged and turned to his drink. Without apparent effort, he drifted into conversation with the landlord while Jack Sheen stood by. Quiet. Then, non-obtrusively. Quiet.
Has there been any talk hereabouts recently about a girl who's missing?
Some. Oh. Well, girls get silly ideas sometimes, especially the young ones. Only silly thing about this girl was the man she went for.
Huh?
They get that way sometimes, even the best of them. Oh, I know what you mean. Anything wrong with the man in this?
May I do well? Owes for feed. Everything in sight. Lives in a hut on his farm. Not even a proper house. Oh, that's so? This Oliver girl now. Bright, sweet as they come. Real pert in them fancy glasses she always wore. Then, off the deep end over this Smith fella. Never know why they do it. Whereabouts is his chicken farm?
Right fork east. Second right after the fork. You thinking of going up there?
Oh, I might drop over. Tell the girl's mother I'd look around. Maybe talk to Smith. From his letters, he's pretty well upset himself.
Uh, him? Upset over that girl? Not much.
What's happened to your friend?
My friend? Oh, he was just... Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha. Five will get you ten, landlord. My friend is halfway there by now.
Inspector Caswell was absolutely right. Jack Sheen was well up the right fork and turning into the lane that led to Ron Smith's chicken farm.
Who's there? I said, who's there?
I'm Jack Sheen of the London Daily Post. I'd like to talk to you.
Ah. What makes you think I want to talk to you?
Oh, most people talk to me. If they don't, I, uh... I usually write what I think they might have said. Very simple.
Smart, aren't you?
I know my business, I hope. Fellows down in the village suggest you don't.
Yeah, they like to talk. Don't you?
Not about things that ain't my business.
Daisy Oliver is your business.
She was.
Meaning?
Daisy said she was coming down last Friday. I left my gate unlocked, like you found it tonight. She was always touchy about that. She never came, though. That's right. Now, all this talk. I'm more worried about her than I ought to be. Nancy's gonna make a fuss about that pretty soon.
Nancy?
Well... A girl, Nancy Noble, lives up the road a piece. Her and me have been walking out lately. Daisy knew. Figured she'd be coming down, but she wrote on the counter... Apparently, Mr. Ron Smith, chicken farmer, was as garrulous in his way as his hands were in theirs. He clucked on at great rate. Finally, Jack Sheen got away. Scribbled a bit in his notebook, and then off to sleep.
The next morning, quite early...
Hello, there.
What? Oh! You startled me.
You don't look as if you'd scare easy.
I don't? Who are you, walking into a barn like this, behind a busy girl's back?
A fellow who thinks you'd make a better wife for Ron Smith than some frail little girl from the city.
Ho, ho, ho! You know your way around, don't you?
There was banter and introductions. Nancy was quite flattered, of course, over the visit of a reporter. She talked.
Sure, sure, I met Daisy. Like her? All right. If you go for milk sops.
I see. I heard Ron was going to marry her, right after Christmas.
Not if he could break the engagement, he wasn't. He's all set to marry me.
Oh, so... So that's the way the wind blows, huh?
It sure does. Or did. Now, with all the fuss over Daisy's disappearance. Well, Ron's too upset even to think, I guess.
Upset, is he?
He told me, night before last. He's afraid she's killed herself.
So Daisy may be dead. And Ron is afraid she may have committed suicide. Well, Jack Sheen has turned up a factor, too, hasn't he?
Of course, Inspector Caswell hasn't been inactive.
Mr. Jeffery, I'm told by our host, the landlord, that you think you saw the Oliver girl last Friday night.
I think so. I was coming up the road, out past the fork. My place is out past, Smith's. There was a girl ahead of me. She turned to look back. I thought I saw her wearing spectacles.
Is that all?
Well, she must have turned in at Smith's. She didn't pass my place. Reed here saw her real close.
Did you, Mr. Reed?
Yes, sir. I met Jeffery on the road. I was coming down to the ward of the village after fixing this empty tank out to Jeffery's place. The girl passed real close. The Oliver girl, all right. She was wearing specs and a suitcase.
Ah, that's right. She had a suitcase like she walked out from the train. Why, the Smith fellow didn't go in and meet her.
Then there was the routine visit to the cottage where Daisy usually stayed when she was in Larkspur.
Did you hear from Miss Oliver, ma'am, that she was coming down here this past Friday?
She didn't. And she always stayed with me. If she'd planned to come down, well, you never know what with young girls being so free nowadays. And she had spent all her savings on these trips. She told me that last time she was here.
When was that?
Oh, about, let me see, about two months ago. She seemed so nervous, poor thing. Even then, you know, jumpy. Always a little scared, like a rabbit sort of. Oh, I don't know. I wish I didn't keep thinking.
And finally, there was Edith Staple. Miss Staple had a friend in the outlying area, and Miss Staple had been crossing a field near the chicken farm, a kind of shortcut.
Yes, Inspector. I'm positive I saw her. I saw two men on the road too. One passed her. The men met, talked a little, and went on. By the time I passed the lane to Smith's place, she was in as far as the first shed.
You saw quite a bit, didn't you?
The road is on a little rise just there. I was coming up to it, and everyone was, well, sort of outlined against the sky.
Well, thank you, Miss Staple. Thank you very much.
There must have been a girl. I tracked this out of tannery with Daisy Oliver. But how to prove it? Where had she disappeared to?
Inspector Caswell and Jack Sheen compared notes. They stayed around Luxborough. That fact alone started the talk, which had impetus enough in any case.
People don't just disappear, I tell you. She must be somewhere. She turned into Smith's place. Want to bet she never came out?
Nice girls don't take chances going alone to men's homes, even when they're more decent than the up he lives in. I'll get him, you'll see. He did the girl in. Want to bet?
The talk reached Smith, of course. On the heels of the talk came Jack Sheen.
Nice lot of chickens you've got here, Smith.
We didn't come out here to talk about chickens.
No? What then?
They're trying to get more on Daisy and me.
The town has plenty on you, they think.
They're long tongues. They wag too much. You can stop them, you know, quite easily.
Oh, I'd like to know.
Oh, just ask Inspector Caswell to bring his crew out here to dig up your farm. They'll find nothing. That'll stop the talk.
I'll do it. They can dig any place they want. Except I wouldn't want them to disturb my chickens.
The remarks were duly reported to the inspector. His comment was, "We'll be glad not to disturb his chickens."
I should think that's exactly what you would do.
Oh, I don't know a thing about chickens, except roasted.
Look, he was rather pointed about it, you know. Don't disturb my chickens. You know, if I were you, Caswell, I'd do some digging around that chicken run. Might save you a lot of extra trouble. You catch on, Inspector?
The inspector caught on to the extent of asking Ron Smith to drop in at the police station while Jeffery and Reed and a few of the others with Jack Sheen began their digging.
Uh, not much good this ground.
Good enough for chickens.
Got something?
No, just a rotten stick. Nothing suspicious like. Oh, there's something here.
Yes. I'd say you had something there. Lift out your shovel, Jeffery.
Okay. Now, look, I'm going to open it. I want you to witness that I neither take out nor put in any object. Ready?
Yeah, all right. All right? Okay, now just watch this.
It's the girl's suitcase, all right? I'd know those specs anyplace.
Well, today those spectacles can be found in the Black Museum.
In just a moment, we will continue with the Black Museum starring Orson Welles.
Now, we continue with the Black Museum starring Orson Welles.
It was her suitcase. Yes, there it was, the earth of the chicken run clinging to its freight hand with shabby sides. Jack Sheen stopped the digging, sent Reed pell-mell to the inspector.
Women's glasses. Right on top in the suitcase. And pretty thoroughly smashed.
Poor Daisy. Something, whatever it was, must have hit her. Just smash her spectacles like this.
Shall we go on, inspector? Digging?
Oh, of course. But, um, carefully. We don't want the edges of the spades to disfigure anything.
The first thing they found was part of the torso and the limbs wrapped in sacking. Finally, the head in a tin box. Buried shallowly in the chicken run.
I've had enough. Are we, are we through?
Sorry, I didn't have a regular police crew for this. You can go along. And thanks. You too, Mr. Reed. Where's Smith?
At your local police station. Where Mr. Sheen and I will be interviewing him in a very short while.
They interviewed him. It was quite simple at first.
I gave him the facts. We've found her, Smith. Thanks to Mr. Sheen here and the strong arms of some of your neighbors. Well? Well, what have you to say?
First, I must warn you that anything you may say may be taken down in writing and used as evidence. Now, go ahead.
I, I didn't kill her. I didn't.
That's only a beginning. She came down on Friday to have it out with me. She was so nervous. She was all twitchy. She said she wouldn't leave my place until, until we'd set a date for the wedding. But she knew about Nancy. She knew that. She had a row, a real hard row. I guess I gave in. I said the 27th of December, right after Christmas. Then I promised I'd tell Nancy that night. Daisy wasn't satisfied until I'd gone right out looking for Nancy. I couldn't find her. I came back and Daisy was hanging from the beam in my hat. She, she, she must have jumped from the table. It was awful.
What did you do? Why didn't you go for help, a doctor?
Well, I, I cut her down first. I thought there might be some life left.
Did you try artificial respiration?
As soon as I got her on the bed, I saw it was no use.
But you still didn't call anybody.
I was afraid. I, I panicked. I thought they wouldn't believe me. They'd, they'd all think I'd killed her and tried to make it look like suicide.
So you buried her?
Yes. In the morning.
But you cut her up first. You deliberately dismembered the body.
Have you ever tried to dispose of a body? True, a body is 76% water. But have you ever tried to get rid of one? It's almost impossible to burn without special apparatus. Burying it leaves it intact. What do you do? Find a lime pit? Even that isn't foolproof. What do you do?
After you knew she was dead, you still wrote letters to her home.
I couldn't stop doing that. If people were to believe that I hadn't killed her myself.
May I, Inspector?
Of course, Jerry.
What about these? The glasses. You, you, you found them too. How did they get this way?
They, they must have fallen off when I cut her down. I suppose I stepped on them or something. Her head hit the table as I was carrying her to the bed. I, I couldn't believe Daisy was gone. I couldn't...
Smith couldn't believe she was dead. Jack Sheen and Inspector Caswell couldn't believe other items.
It doesn't fit, Caswell. It doesn't.
What's bothering you about it?
Look, a girl who's just been told her wedding date doesn't hang herself in the next half hour.
Oh, I saw that. I sent his shoes down to London to the laboratory. If he did step on those glasses, there'll be bits of glass on the soles or heels.
I'm no Dr. Caswell, but did you notice any rope marks on the neck?
I didn't. I have sent for one of the medical examiners. We'll know all about that very soon.
They held Smith on an open charge. The least would be an illegal burial and failure to notify the proper authorities. Meanwhile, Sir Harold Hubert, one of the Yard's best medical men, came to Larkspur. He worked. He made his report.
The girl did it. The girl did not die of strangulation, gentlemen.
What was that? She didn't?
There's a slight discoloration of the throat, but that was probably caused after death.
What did she die from, then?
Shock. Caused by the multiple bruises all over her body. That girl was beaten to death.
Now the questions descended on Sir Harold's head in a deluge.
No sign of strangulation at all?
She may have been partially hung. There was congestion of the blood vessels of the throat. But she didn't die up there. If she was hung at all, she was alive when she was cut down.
What else could have caused the congestion in the throat?
Manual strangulation. Or she could have been knocked down. That is a logical assumption.
Did you knock her down and step on her throat, Smith?
Of course not. How could I have when she was hanging as I entered the building?
You're certain she was hanging and dead?
I know she was hanging. I'm as sure as I can be that she was dead.
All right. Take him back to the cell.
The expert said no. The expert said no hanging. The man accused contradicted that statement at every turn. Once again, the inspector and Jack Sheen went out to the chicken farm.
What are you up to?
Give me a boost. Up onto the table.
Okay. Now what?
I'm not going to hang myself. Come on up. I think it will hold both of us.
All right. Here I come.
Not the safest perch in the world. Okay. Now what?
Look here. Along the beam.
What up?
Filthy animal. Didn't Smith ever clean his place?
Maybe it's just as well he never did. Look, I don't get it. He said a dozen times he found her hanging. If a rope passed over this beam as Smith maintains...
The dust up here would show the marks. You see any marks, old boy?
Not a thing. Not even a bit of rope fiber.
Sir Harold is right. No death by strangulation. Not by any rope which passed over this beam. I wonder how friend Smith...
Smith did his best to explain the matter. In fact, he did a trifle better than his best.
That's possible. The rope must have caught in the joists. She didn't weigh very much. By the way, where is the rope?
I burned it. It gave me the willies.
What kind of rope was it?
Ordinary hemp rope.
Not sash cord?
No, hemp.
What did you intend it for?
Oh, no special purpose. You always have rope around a farm.
Inspector Caswell will remind you, Mr. Smith. Quite tersely. Hemp rope leaves its fibers caught in rough wood when it's passed over the wood. There is no sign of fibers or any mark in the dust.
Well, then the dust settled back after I took her down.
How did you take her down?
Well, lifted her with one arm and freed the rope with the other.
Now let's go back to the beginning, Smith. When did you first see her that night?
She came to the gate. It was locked. She called. I let her in. We argued, then we made up, and I went to tell Nancy. When I came back...
Hadn't you better keep the story straight, Smith? That is the story.
You said before you cut her down. You told Mr. Sheen you left the gate open because finding it closed upset her always.
Then I made a mistake.
Oh, you made a mistake, all right. You made your story much too involved. You see, the laboratory has reported on your shoes. Not only are there no bits of glass in them, proving you did not step on them, but there are traces of lipstick on one and traces of contact with human skin on both. I submit, and I shall so state to the jury at your trial, that you attacked the girl with force and violence, that you smashed her glasses on the table, that you beat and kicked her into insensibility and death. Your story tripped you and the laboratory did the rest. I'd say, Smith, next time, keep it simple. But I doubt if there'll be any next time for you.
Well, today. Today, those spectacles can be seen in the Black Museum. Orson Welles will be back with you in just a moment.
Now, here in person is Orson Welles.
Exactly how Daisy Oliver met her death was never brought out, not even at the trial. Whether Ron Smith beat her to death or whether she fell to her death, no one knows. But she was murdered, and by Ron Smith. There's no reasonable doubt about that. Nor was there any doubt about this man's character. Not only did he kill her, but he killed her. Not only did he write of his concern over her disappearance to Daisy's mother, not only did he write long-enduring love letters to a girl he knew was dead, but from his cell, as he awaited trial, he sent a wreath to her funeral, palm leaves and one lily, with the phrase attached, until we meet again. I wonder if they ever did meet again.
Until next time, till we meet in the same place, and I tell you another story about the Black Museum, I remain, as always, obediently yours.
