The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 17 min to read
The grim stone structure on the Thames, which houses Scotland Yard, is a warehouse of homicide, where everyday objects, a picture frame, a wicker chair, a telephone directory, all...
A most efficient bit of Sheffield, isn't it, Sergeant?
Yes, Inspector, for its original purpose as well as the other. Matter of fact, I use one exactly like it every morning.
A grim thought, Sergeant, a very grim thought.
...panels of the Criminal Investigation Department of the London Police. We bring you the dramatic stories of the crimes recorded by the objects in Scotland Yard's gallery of death, the Black Museum. In just a moment, you will hear the Black Museum starring Orson Welles. Black Museum starring Orson Welles.
...for each day of the week. You should talk to me like this, Mr. Wilson. After all, you are my employer.
Very good, darling. My name is Larry. And what if you are my barmaid in my establishment? If you'll only say yes, you shall be my wife.
Oh, well, Larry. Oh, you can't mean that. A man like you would...
But apparently, he did want the likes of her. To all appearances, Larry Wilson had fallen head over heels in love with Mabel Dill.
Mabel, you've got to marry me. I can't see you waiting on the customers, drawing ale, working with me every day. I can't. And not have you for my wife.
An interesting accent, hmm? Intriguing. To a susceptible young woman, that voice and that...
Father, there's a letter from Mabel.
Is there now? I should think it about time our daughter wrote to us.
Oh, my goodness. Something wrong?
Oh, yes and no.
Ridiculous. How can a thing be wrong, yes and no?
Mabel's wanted to be married. And to her employer.
What? There it is in the letter. And a note from him, too. Telling her how much he loved her. Telling her how much he loved her. Hmm. Won't do very well if he means it. How do we know?
Oh, perhaps it would be best if we went to find out.
Excellent. Write to Mabel at once. Tell her she's to do nothing, absolutely nothing, until she's had the chance to talk with us.
Simple people, the Dills, and eager to protect their daughter's future. So off they went, bag and baggage to the Statue Tavern, backed on by Larry Wilson, where Mabel was standing by.
My word. It's a party, isn't it?
It looks like a wedding party to me.
Oh, must be there's a bride somewhere. Oh, oh, there she is. It's Mabel.
Here now, my girl. What's the meaning of this?
Oh, Dad. Oh, Dad. Oh, I'm so happy your mother got here today.
Oh, Mabel, darling. Oh, didn't you get my letter?
Of course there was no letter.
Come along and meet my Larry. You'll be as happy with him as I will.
Not much the Dills could do about it, was there?
Mr. and Mrs. Larry Wilson. Proposal. Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Mr. and Mrs. Larry Wilson, proprietors of the Statue of Public House. And happy over it too, both of them.
Of course, things do happen sometimes in the most well-ordered of homes.
There we are, Mrs. Wilson. I'm sure you'll be all right.
Oh, doctor. I'm so sick. I can't keep anything in my stomach. Oh. Oh, doctor. She is so ill, Dr. Grant. What is it, do you think?
Probably something she ate. This tonic will fix her up.
The Welsh rabbit, that's what it was. If it wasn't for that, I'd...
Tasted a bit funny to me. I didn't finish it, remember, Mabel?
Oh, I like rabbits so. You're right, I suppose, for being so greedy. Well, you've learned your lesson, little lady. From now on, more care. Fill the prescription, Wilson, and I'll look in on her again this evening. Right. Mind now, less indulgence.
An upset stomach, that was all, nothing serious. Except Mabel just didn't seem to get better. Mother Dill came to visit and decided to stay.
I'm staying on, Larry. You've got your pub to tend to. I'll tend to Mabel.
Mother Dill, there's nothing to be alarmed about.
I'm staying, and I'm asking Dr. Marshall to look at Mabel.
Who's he?
My family doctor. Known Mabel for ten years.
Are you suggesting, Mother, that I'm not providing properly for my wife or giving her the best of care?
I'm not suggesting anything, Larry. Except that you have to worry about so many things, and I have nothing to do but take care of my daughter.
I cannot allow it. A man's first duty is to take care of his wife. More, I'm properly qualified. I can take care of her far better than...
Larry, I will not be put off. As for your qualifications, well, really, a barber is no doctor, even though some people permit barbers to bleed them.
Are you trying to insult me and drive me away from my wife?
The truth can be insulting, I suppose. However, from what Mr. Dill and I know, your care of your first two wives didn't work out so well, what with both of them dead and buried these three years.
There was no arguing with Mrs. Dill. Her child was suffering, and she intended to have her way, and she did. Dr. Marshall came in consultation with Dr. Grant.
It puzzles me. It does, really. You can see my position, Marshall. I've done everything the symptoms seem to call for. Nothing helps.
Well, we'll see. Meanwhile, if we can get her to take some nourishment, the poor child's just wasting away. I've no doubt...
Of course, this was 1896, remember. There are no methods yet, such as a series of gastrointestinal tests or a basic metabolism test or any other of the modern means to determine the cause of death.
I don't know. I don't know.
To determine the cause of intestinal ailments, the doctors had to work by observation and an occasional chemical reaction. In the case of Mabel Dill Wilson, it was tragic indeed.
Oh, Larry. He's downstairs, darling. Mother's here.
I want Larry.
I'll call him, dear. Larry! Will you leave the bar and come upstairs? Larry!
Larry Wilson came upstairs and quickly, two at a time, he raced up the stairs and entered his wife's room.
The doctor doesn't know him.
Is that you, Larry?
Yes, sweetheart, it is.
I waited for you, Larry.
Mabel, darling.
Of her mother, Dill. Excellent care, I must say. Your daughter, my wife, is dead.
Oh, no.
Angry sorrow. The two doctors.
What did she die of, gentlemen?
What?
My diagnosis is exhaustion. Exhaustion. Following inflammation of the intestines.
I do not know. As yet.
You do not know. You do not know. Are you a doctor or aren't you?
I take offense at your tone, Mr. Wilson. For your information, I have refused to approve the death certificate.
What?
Dr. Grant wishes to certify cause of death. I agree that his idea of inflammation of the intestines is probably correct.
Then why are you...
But I do not know, as yet, what caused the inflammation. When I do know, I shall be glad to sign the certificate. Whatever caused the inflammation, caused the death.
How do you expect to determine this?
By a post-mortem, Mr. Wilson. I shall do it myself, with Dr. Grant as a witness.
I shall not permit...
Ah, but you will permit it, Mr. Wilson. Because if you don't, I shall have to report the whole matter to the police and the coroner.
The stage is set. The actors are in their place and the drama has begun. And yet there is something missing. An item of evidence, which was to provide the whole affair with by far its most horrifying aspect. It was a case of razors. Which can be seen today in the Black Museum.
In just a moment, we will continue with the Black Museum starring Orson Welles. Oh, we continue with the Black Museum starring Orson Welles.
Doctors and the mortician, Marshall Surgery. There they did what was considered necessary and made their analysis. Shortly after, Dr. Marshall wrote out his report.
And as a result of my analysis, it is my opinion that there is definitely...
...a suspicion of arsenical poisoning.
With that report and Dr. Grant's concurrence, there is nothing to be done but report the matter to the coroner and to the police.
How certain are you, Dr. Marshall, that there is a large quantity of arsenic in the body?
As certain as I can be, Inspector, without being a specialist in criminal toxicology.
Have you preserved the necessary items, Doctor, contents of the stomach and so on?
I have. In sealed jars, initialed by both Dr. Grant and myself.
Very well. If you will deliver them to me, I will see to it that proper tests are made at once. In the meanwhile, it might be wise to have Mr. Wilson...
In the meanwhile? Well, of course, there was only one thing to do. A certain pub owner had to be questioned.
Mr. Wilson?
Yes?
My name's Baker, Sergeant Baker. Er, my credentials.
I see. How can I help you, Sergeant?
If you'd come to the station with me, sir, Inspector Waters would like to have a chat with you.
Larry Wilson went along, and quietly. I let him wait a little while before the Inspector was ready to see him. Not long, just a little while. Inspector had a job to assign to the Sergeant first.
I have a warrant, Baker. Take a squad, go back to the Statue and search it from top to bottom. Bring back anything which looks at all suspicious.
Yes, sir. Quick as we can.
All right, Mr. Wilson. Inspector Waters will see you now.
Thank you, Sergeant. How do you do, Inspector?
Sit down, Mr. Wilson. Make yourself comfortable.
Two gentlemen meeting each other in the quiet. Might be a business deal.
Mr. Wilson, as you may know, we are in the position of having to investigate certain...
...details of your wife's unfortunate and untimely death.
I understand that, Inspector.
Do you have any reason to suspect foul play?
Of course not. Mabel was the sweetest, nicest, most gentle...
And quite poor, wasn't she?
I really couldn't say. I didn't check up on that. I was in love.
Yes, yes, of course. In any case, she had no will and left no estate.
Exactly. Unlike your first wife, whom you married while you were still a barber. I mean, with whose estate you bought a tavern.
You're very thorough, Inspector. What you tell me is quite true.
Certainly very thorough. Very thorough indeed. Inspector knows a lot about you, Larry Wilson. Your second wife, Mr. Wilson, she also left you some money. You moved over to the Statue Tavern after her death, didn't you?
Yes, that's right. Couldn't abide the old place with Belle passed on.
You are sentimental, Mr. Wilson. You left the trade of barber after the other one. What was her name?
Daisy was her name.
Yes, I did leave the trade.
May I ask when you came to this country, Mr. Wilson?
In 1888. Why?
Oh, routine check. We found a record of your passport in 1890 for a trip to America. You came back within a year and...
Of course it had been noted that you were not born in the British Isles.
That's right.
Then your name is not Wilson, is it?
I wasn't born Wilson. My father's name in the old country was Wilmets. I anglicized it.
An interesting idea, Mr. Wilson.
There was more, much more. Two hours of it. When they were about finished, the inspector had a detailed life history of Mr. Larry Wilson. Of course there were a few open areas.
1889? Do you know, Inspector, I have practically no memory of that year. I was learning my craft. I was learning my trade then, I guess. No time for the kind of events which make memories.
And then there was 1891. I had to reestablish myself after I came back from the States. Took some time. It was in 92 I married Daisy. And stayed married to her until she died in 94. And then married Belle, who passed along in 95.
Well, we found one thing. Oh, excuse me. I didn't know you were still here, Mr. Wilson.
That's perfectly all right, Sergeant. I was just about to go.
What have you there, Sergeant?
A case of razors, sir.
What? But those are mine.
Yes, they are. I dare say the Sergeant found them in your bathroom. He's been busy with a search warrant, you see.
Yes, I begin to see a lot of things, including the reasons behind my being kept here. Is my mother-in-law in on this?
On the contrary, she knows nothing yet.
Where did you find those razors, Sergeant?
Hidden, sir. Hidden in the bin on top of a spare bedroom closet, sir.
Thank you, Sergeant. Very well, Inspector. While you're on your way, Sergeant, will you escort Mr. Wilson to his room?
Of course.
What's the idea? Are you arresting me?
Not at all, Mr. Wilson. Not yet, at any rate. We're detaining you temporarily on suspicion, sir.
Suspicion of what?
I'll let you know in 24 hours, Mr. Wilson. That's the limit the law allows. After that, of course, I shall have to prepare charges of some sort. But by then, the toxicologist will have reported. Won't he, Sergeant?
The Inspector was puzzled. Here was a possible case involving poison. And the suspect had hidden his razors where only an unreasonably thorough search might turn them up. It didn't fit. The Inspector filed the fact in the back of his mind. Turned to other things.
The toxicologist's report is in, Sergeant. The girl was poisoned all right, but not with arsenic. Her body was full of antimony.
Ah, we'd better charge Wilson or he'll be out of our clutches before we know it.
So, they entered a charge against Larry Wilson.
Larry Wilson, you are under arrest on a charge of willful murder. I must warn you, anything you say may...
And then they proceeded to do a little more digging, both figuratively and literally.
I want an exhumation order, Sergeant, for the bodies of the first and second Mrs. Wilsons.
Of course they found it there, too.
The laboratory reports, sir. Both the women were poisoned with antimony.
They called in Dr. Grant.
Dr. Grant, you attended all three of Mr. Wilson's wives, did you not?
Yes, I did.
And you made out the death certificates in the first two instances.
I did.
And in both cases, you stated that the cause of death was exhaustion following severe retching brought on by intensive inflammation of the intestines.
I did.
But you didn't consider these facts at all suspicious.
Why should I have? I've seen many such cases.
Fatal cases?
No, not fatal. However, with the symptoms in all the cases so remarkably alike, they were alike, weren't they?
Definitely. Oh, most definitely.
Now that you mention it, Inspector, the whole thing does seem a trifle too coincidental, doesn't it?
Now it is a matter of routine. Three women dead of the same poison. Three women all married to the same man. All treated by the same elderly doctor. They didn't seem to be much more necessary to be done except to trace the poison to the thrice bereaved husband.
The police canvassed all the drugstores, the chemist shops in the neighborhood where Larry Wilson had owned his barbershop and his taverns.
What can I do for you, sir?
Good morning. My name is Baker. My credentials.
I see. CID. How can I help you, Sergeant?
We'd like to know if you've ever had a customer named Wilson. Larry Wilson. One time barber and tavern keeper.
Oh, that Wilson. Yes, of course. Used to buy his supplies here.
Did he? What, for instance?
All brushes and combs, soaps as he needed them and so on.
Did he ever buy any strong antiseptics?
Not that I remember.
Any poison for hair dye or such?
I think, yes, I think. He once bought some tartar emetic. Yes, I'm sure of that. I remember now. He told me he was experimenting with a new type of dandruff remover. He had the idea that antimony might work very well.
Dandruff remover?
This was up to a jury to decide. There was small doubt what a jury would decide when the chemist showed Sergeant Baker the poison book.
You're certain?
Yes, here it is. Day and date, amount, July the 5th, 1894. Tartar emetic. Signed, L. Wilson.
Hmm, it's almost two years now. I have a pretty fair memory, haven't I, Sergeant?
They had him. Bit by bit, piece by piece, the story was filled in. The saga of this man with a fascinating little accent and the women he'd married. Daisy Allister, five years older than Wilson, owner of a small dress shop with 350 pounds saved painstakingly over the years. Belle Davis, owner of a flower shop with 275 pounds to her credit in the merchant's bank. And, of course, little Mabel Dill. Three wives, three deaths. The poison.
Well, the inspector was puzzled.
Can you send for me, Inspector?
Yes. Sergeant, where do those razors you found fit into this pattern? The man was a barber, wasn't he?
You do mean Wilson, don't you?
Yes, yes. But why did he hide them? Says he was afraid somebody would cut himself. Nonsense. There were no children. Sergeant, I may have hit on an angle. I sent over to criminal records for this file. Look at it.
Hmm, I see, sir.
The description of this man fits Wilson perfectly.
Of course, this man was seen only once.
True enough, but it's the identical coloring, height, weight, even the brief sound of his voice.
It proves nothing, sir.
I know, but there's more. The cases in this file began in 88. Wilson came to Whitechapel in 88. The cases stopped in 90 when Wilson went to America. But in that year, it's noted here, there were three identical cases in New Jersey. They stopped in 91 when Wilson came back here.
As Dr. Grant would say, it's too remarkable a coincidence.
Too remarkable a coincidence, Inspector. Would you, Sergeant, in this room and having seen this record and knowing about those razors, hazard that Larry Wilson is Jack the Ripper?
I'd hazard it, sir. I couldn't prove it.
Neither could I, but I'm convinced all the same. Perhaps he... Ah, well, we've got him on other matters. We can hang him only once in any case.
I'd handle that razor with care, sir. It's mighty sharp.
The most efficient bit of Sheffield, isn't it, Sergeant?
Yes, Inspector, for its original purpose as well as the other. Matter of fact, I use one exactly like it every morning.
A grim thought, Sergeant, a very grim thought. We shall never know the full story, but most people would agree with the Inspector there was more than a reasonable chance that justice had finally caught up with Jack the Ripper. Certainly, that case of razors deserves its place of honor.
Orson Welles will be back with you in just a moment.
Orson Welles. But the additional fact remains that never again from the date of Wilson's arrest was there a murder in the technique of Jack the Ripper. Not in London, not in America. His terrible signature never appeared again on the body of any murdered woman. The case of razors remains in its count. Do we meet next time? Do we meet in the same place? I'll tell you another story about the Black Museum.
Black Museum starring Orson Welles. Orson Welles is presented by arrangement with Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Radio Attractions. The program is written by Ira Marion with original music composed and conducted by Sydney Torch. Produced by Harry Alan Towers.
