The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 22 min to read
Calling All Cars. A copyrighted program transcribed and dedicated to the prevention of crime. Calling All Cars, broadcast 202 at 127 West 42nd Street, 127 West 42nd Street. This is the fire department, Arson Squad. That is all.
The grief of many a peaceful citizen has been disturbed and his return to consciousness harrowed by hearing the cry of fire. Small fires may spread beyond control and result in a citywide disaster, accompanied by a horrible toll of life and property. The setting of fires is a peculiarly contemptible form of crime. It is rarely committed except for gain, collection of insurance. Though sometimes the arsonist is urged only by revenge or an attempt to cover up another crime.
Of course, the fire department of any city is responsible for the control and extinguishing of fires. But where arson is suspected as the genesis of the fire, there is a police department set by the police. This is the fire marshal. The arsonist is a cunning creature. He hopes that the fire will destroy the evidence which started it. To circumvent this, the police department and the fire department must and do work hand in hand. How well they do is shown in Sirens in the Night.
Engine Company 22, Acting Captain Mohler speaking.
You've got a fire at 127 West 42nd Street.
Okay. It's a go! 127 West 42nd Street, right. 127 West 42nd Street. Okay, 127 West 42nd Street, that's a go! Bring that chemical line.
Hey, Fred!
Yes, sir?
Get us that window over the driveway.
Yes, sir!
All right, all right. We'll have to get back, folks. We'll have to get back if there's any flies in here.
I turned in the alarm. I saw it start. There was an explosion. Hasn't been any kind of living in there, either.
All right, Joe. It's right up there. All right, all right. All right. Look out! Move on, now! Back off! Move on!
Joe, it's Captain Mohler.
Bright and early, I see. Well, I came over as soon as I got your call. Had a little trouble last night, I understand.
Yes. I don't understand. I've taken every precaution to keep that place free of fire hazards and still it caught fire.
Wiring all right?
As far as we can find out, everything was in order. I'll tell you what I think. I believe the place was set on fire.
Any idea who might have done it?
None. Wait a minute.
No?
Maybe the family that lived there before had something to do with it.
Where are they now?
Oh, I don't know. But I had a little trouble with them about the rent. And I wouldn't be surprised if they had something to do with this.
Better be careful, Mr. Barton. Arson's a serious charge and one practically impossible to prove.
Yeah? Why so?
Well, in the first place, usually all traces of evidence are destroyed. Unless a man is seen in the actual act of setting fire to a place, it's practically impossible to prove that he did it.
Well, I never realized that.
How you'd be surprised at the number of fires that are incendiary.
But isn't it risky?
Seldom for the man setting the place afire. Unless he uses explosives or some highly volatile substance like gasoline. But the greatest danger is to innocent persons living in the quarters or nearby buildings. They're the ones who usually suffer most.
That must cost you insurance companies a lot of money.
It does, but it costs you a lot, too.
What do you mean by that?
High insurance rates.
Why, I don't pay much for my insurance.
That's what you think. As a matter of fact, you pay some form of insurance premium with every purchase you make.
Hmm, I hadn't thought of that.
Oh, neither do these fellows who burn down their houses to collect insurance. They think they're getting by with something.
Well, I'd like to catch the bird who set fire to my place.
Well, we'll turn this over to our investigators and to the fire department arson squad. If he's still around, they'll catch him.
I hope so. I wouldn't want him coming back and finishing up the job.
Don't worry about that. We'll keep an eye on the place, and if he tries it again, we'll nab him.
Well, that'll be fine. Oh, uh, by the way, when do I get my check for this fire?
Oh, I'll, I'll send it over this afternoon. Just as soon as the adjusters look the place over.
Good. I've got some notes coming to you on some other property, and I want to be able to clear them up.
I'll get on that right away. We'll also get after your fire bug.
Though investigators worked for weeks on the case, no trace of the fire bug was found. The insurance check was duly paid as the property repaired, and new tenants found for the house on West 42nd Street.
Phew, what a job. What a job. This was the dustiest place I ever walked into.
What'd you expect? After being vacant six months?
Uh-huh, I know. Mrs. Thompson says this is a jinx house.
Who's Mrs. Thompson?
She lives next door. She said this place has been vacant ever since it was built.
She's crazy. It was rented early this year.
I know, but she says nobody would live here after that man set it afire.
What man?
Oh, that's just it. Nobody knows who did it. But they know somebody set it afire because he didn't like Mr. Barton.
As Lee settled as I did, I don't blame him. I think Mr. Barton's nice.
Like he wanted me to cancel my lease. I canceled my lease before I moved in. We aren't in yet.
No, not tomorrow morning. You know, Mrs. Thompson says Mr. Barton had a chance to rent the house for more than we're paying. Just yesterday.
So that's why he doesn't want us to move in.
Well, I'll fool him. I'll move in tonight.
Oh, but how can we? That window's not fixed and the place isn't clean and...
Yeah, never mind. I'll fix the window myself if I have to and we'll clean up the place later. I positively will not move into this place until it's clean.
I'll move in tonight. Mrs. Thompson said that...
Listen, for all I don't care what Mrs. Thompson said. We're moving in tonight. Barton will fix that window. At least he said he would. And if he doesn't, well, we move in tonight.
All right, but August, don't shout at me. I've heard so much about this jinx and Mrs. Thompson and fire. And I didn't mean it...
Stop it, will you? Let's go now. We've got to load the furniture and get back here before night.
All right, August. All right. I won't mention the fire again. But I tell you, there's something...
Mr. Barton, I'm talking.
Good afternoon, Mr. Barton.
How are you, Albert? How's things going?
Oh, six-two and even. Have a good Christmas?
Well, not very good. You know, being on the county and all...
Yes, I know. Things have been a little tight this year.
A little tight, huh? Been mowing a little tight for me. Honest. Looks like I never will be able to pay you back what you've done for me.
Oh, don't worry about it.
But I do.
Well, maybe you'll be able to do me a favor someday.
A favor?
Yes. Yes. Say, if I ever can, just let me know.
I'll do that, Albert. Well, what do you have today, Mr. Barton?
Well, let's see now. I think I'll have a glass of beer.
Glass of beer. Yes, sir. Anything to eat?
Well, maybe you'd better bring me a Swiss cheese sandwich and Russian rye.
Where's some Russian?
Right away. And there's your beer.
Oh, thanks. Quite a hit on it. Creamy.
I thought you liked it that way.
No, no, no. It's good beer.
Yeah. Yeah. How'd you like to make a little money, Albert?
Money?
That's what I said.
Well, it depends on what I have to do for it.
Well, I've got a job you could do for me.
Is that it?
Yeah. You could make $10 or $15 at it.
$10 or $15, please?
Right.
What doing?
What time do you get through work here?
Oh, in about a half hour.
A half hour, eh? I'll tell you what I'll do. I'll drive you out and show you the jobs.
Well?
If you want it, I'll make the necessary arrangements.
Sure. I'd like to look it over.
I think you can take care of it all right.
This is the place, Alan.
Yeah? Gee. Nice looking place.
Yeah. Been a jinx house, though.
A jinx house? Honest? How so?
Well, I can't seem to keep it rented. It's been vacant ever since I had that fire last year.
That long? Heh. Looks like the place had just been cleaned up.
Yeah. I rented it yesterday to a fellow named Dube. We got another offer of money less than an hour after that. But Dube wouldn't cancel his lease.
Is that the job you want me to do?
Well, part of it. Heh heh.
What am I supposed to do? Ooh, haunt your place?
No. Heh heh. Well, what is it? If I'm gonna do the job, we better get started.
Yeah, I guess we had. Well, you'll find a cane in the back there.
There in the car?
Yeah, in the luggage trunk.
Oh, back here?
Yeah, that's it. Bring that in, will ya?
Sure.
Gotta be careful with it.
Sure. I've got a hole plugged up with a match and a piece of rag.
Yeah, I'll watch it.
Oh, gosh. This is heavy.
Careful, don't spill it.
Oh, I won't. Where do you want me to put it?
Right on the back porch.
Okay. Just inside the door there.
Yeah, I see. We'll tend to it later.
Okay. Hey, what is it for?
Charmite?
Yeah, another pet. Heh heh heh.
Okay. Hey, hey, wait, wait now. Wait. I'll come back and help you with our rent in a minute. You go ahead and get everything fixed up. I'll do this job, and then I'll look over what you've got done.
Yeah. Do it just like I told you. I told you now.
Oh, sure, sure. I'll do a good job, all right.
That's what I want. A good job.
At 34 minutes past 7 o'clock on the evening of December 29th, 1934, August Dube walks into the fire station at 4352 South Main Street, asks to see the officer in charge.
I'm acting Captain Moeller. What can I do for you?
My name's Dube. I just rented a house at 127 West 42nd Street, and something suspicious has happened there.
What do you call suspicious?
Well, in the first place, that house is a jinx house. There's been fires there without any ordinary explanation. Now, the neighbors have been telling all sorts of stories about the place, but I never paid much attention to them. But this afternoon, when I went back to take a load of furniture, I noticed a very peculiar odor, like oil or kerosene or something.
In the house?
Yes, sir. I noticed that there were some oil stains on the walls up near the ceiling, like it had seeped through the plaster.
Were they there when you rented the place?
That's the funny part of it. The house was in good condition, except for the dirt. And you never noticed the odor or the stains before this evening?
No, sir. My wife and I worked in the place all morning, and when we left, the place was spotless. When we came back, the stains were there.
Do you know whether or not anybody was around the place after you left?
No, I don't. And say there's been a fire there before?
Yes, and no one seems to know what caused it.
I see. Well, Mr. Dube, I'll send a man over with you to look at the place over there and see what we can find out.
Oh, uh, Oliver?
Yes, sir?
Change your clothes. Get into some civilian clothes and go with Mr. Dube here and look his place over. Phone me if you find anything that looks suspicious.
Yes, sir. Now, Mr. Dube, you just go right ahead and act as though you hadn't noticed a thing. If we find the fire is planned for that address, well, you can take it from me. We'll take care of the bird who's planning it.
2022, Moeller. How's the layout? Seen anybody around there?
No.
Notify the chief. We'll take a job for the arson boys. When they get there, you can come on in.
Okay, Captain.
I want to speak to Chief Battalion Four.
One moment, please.
Chief Battalion Four.
Chief, this is Acting Captain Moeller, Engine Company 22. We've found what appears to be an arson plant at 127 West 42nd Street.
Who reported it?
The tenant who's moving in there. I've got a man watching the place now. He says there's a great deal of oil and kerosene around the place.
Well, I'll notify the investigators right away. You keep your men on the job till they get there. Have your company stand by in case anything happens.
We want to prevent a fire if possible, but be ready for a call in case the bug slips past our men.
All right, Chief. We'll stand by.
Battalion Chief Boone notified investigators Hare and Schubert of suspicious conditions at the address Moeller had given him. The two men make a thorough search of the place, finding a well-laid plant for a fire. Failing to find any igniting device and realizing that the fire bug plans to set the fire himself, Schubert leaves to get fire department photographers so as to obtain pictorial evidence. Hare calls Investigator Hayes.
Investigator Harris to assist him in staking out the house.
Schubert and I went over the joint with a fine-tooth comb, but we couldn't find anything that looked like an igniter.
Ooh. Coming back to do the job himself, is he?
Well, that's what we figured. Say, isn't this the same place we looked over last year?
Yes. We were sent out to check up an insurance claim, remember?
Sure I do. I thought that fire was set, too.
So did I, but we couldn't find anything to prove it.
Well, looks like we've got him with the goods on him this time.
Yes. Let's see if he shows up. There's that much oil in that place. We've got to get him before he sets it off.
You're telling me. Who owns that place?
A chap by the name of Barton.
Barton, hmm. Didn't we pick up a couple of birds who had a grudge against him while we were on that last fire?
Yes, yes. We couldn't get anything on them, though.
Oh, boy. He must have a flock of enemies. Looks like somebody's out to get even tonight.
Hey, wait a minute. Look there. There's a car stopping in front of the house.
Yeah. Maybe that's our man. Looks like he's having a little trouble parking that jalopy. Bit under the weather, if you ask me.
Yeah. He's our man. I'll bet on it. Now, he's going around the back. Hey, come on.
All right, now, you take that side. I'll go around to the right here.
See him anywhere?
No, don't. He went back to those palm trees, though, I think. I'll meet you in the back.
OK.
See anything?
No, not yet.
No, where he went? Maybe he didn't come in here at all.
Hey, wait a minute. Somebody just struck a match.
Where?
On the back porch there.
Oh, yeah. Yeah, I see it. I see. Two ladies set it off. And there he comes grabbing. I'll get him. You turn in the alarm.
Be careful, my friend.
All right. All right, stick him up. I said stick him up. Don't try to run when I tell you to stop.
I never done nothing wrong, mister. I had to do it. I had to do it.
All right, all right, all right. We'll find out about that later. Now, tell me, how much oil did you put in there?
Five gallons.
Five gallons?
Yeah.
Well, come on. Get away from here before more of it fills up.
Honest, mister. I didn't mean to do it. Honest, I'll tell you.
All right, never mind about that now, will you? Come on. There's that chemical line in here. All right, all right. Step back. Step back there, will you? All right, will you, boys? That's it. That's it. OK. Let her go. Be careful with the others, man. Don't disturb things more than necessary. Come on.
Everything under control, Captain?
Yep. We've got all the top fires out. But I'm leaving a man here to watch for fresh outbreaks.
How much damage did it do?
Oh, not much. Less than $1,000, I'd say.
Well, if this bird hadn't given us the slip tonight, we'd have prevented all of it.
Well, if we could catch them all before they got any further than this one, we'd be satisfied.
Yeah. I'll return in a report on this. I'll see you later.
Hey, hey. He made me.
Who's he?
I ain't going to tell you.
Oh, yes, you are.
Oh, no, I ain't.
Now, what's your name?
Albert.
Where do you work?
I got a part-time job in a saloon out on Lydia Boulevard.
What do you do with the rest of your time?
Whatever I can get to do.
Such as setting houses on fire?
No, no. This is the only job I have.
Yeah, but... Did somebody hire you to do this job?
Well, yes and no.
Yes and no. Just what do you mean by that?
Yes and no. I mean, well, I owe this fellow some money, and I thought I could sort of square myself with him if I done this.
Who is he?
I ain't going to tell you.
You realize, of course, don't you, that we can send you to jail for this?
Yeah, well, I don't care.
How much money owe this fellow?
Oh, a couple of hundred, maybe less, maybe more.
What do you owe him that much for?
Well, he's been letting me take five bucks every now and then.
Did he offer to cancel the debt if you did this job?
Well, he didn't say.
Does the guy who hired you to set fire to this house know the man who owns it?
Why, oh, yeah. Well, I guess he does.
Has he got a grudge against him?
Huh? I don't know.
Have you?
Me? No.
Now, listen, Albert, if you're trying to hide something to shield somebody, you're just wasting your time as well as ours. You're going to jail anyway. Now, come on, come on clean. Tell us who hired you.
I tell you, nobody hired me. I did it just to do a friend of mine a favor.
Well, how did you go about it?
Well, a friend of mine, he told me that he could get even with the fellow, make him do something he wanted him to do if this place caught on fire. And he told me he'd call things square if I'd do the job.
Oh, he did. Just where did you get the kerosene and the oil?
The kerosene and the oil? Oh, he bought it at a filling station down on the corner on Main. And we come up here, the people that had rented the place had just left, and I had a key to the back door. I don't know where he got it, but I went in and got it naveled up under this gutter hole there and climbed up in the attic. And he handed me the oil and the newspapers and I scattered them around.
Why didn't you do the job then?
It was daylight, Jane. We didn't want nobody to see it.
I see. And then what did you do?
We drove out to where I work and I hung around there a while.
And got drunk?
Well, just a little maybe.
Needed a little more courage, is that it?
Well, I guess so.
You say this man had lent you money over a long period of time?
Yeah.
How much?
Oh, maybe a couple of hundred bucks.
Were you going to get any more for doing this job?
Huh? Yeah. Fifteen dollars.
Mighty little money for the risk you took.
Yeah.
What's coming up here?
Why, Al, what are you doing here?
Why, I, uh...
Do you, uh, know this man?
Certainly I know this man. I've known him for years.
You've missed him, Barton, over a long period of time?
Yes, for probably two or three years now.
Just who are you, by the way?
Why, I'm the owner of this house. Barton's the name.
Oh?
Yes, Mr. Barton. I remember you now. You had a fire here last year, didn't you?
Why, yes, I did. How did you know?
I'm Investigator Hare. Fire Department Officer. Arson Squad.
Arson Squad? Why, what, who...
And I'm Captain Harris of the same department.
What are you doing here?
We caught this man setting fire to this house, Mr. Barton.
What?
Setting fire to your house, Mr. Barton.
Well, what's the meaning of this house?
Well, you see...
Have you, have you lent this man money?
Why, yes, but...
How much money have you lent him altogether, I mean?
Why, I'd say a hundred, maybe two hundred dollars.
Did he ever pay any of it back?
No.
Did you expect him to?
What?
Did you expect him to pay it back?
Why, why, yes, of course, certainly.
Well, how?
I beg your pardon?
How did you expect him to pay it back?
I, I don't follow you, I...
Perhaps I can make it plainer. How did you expect an unemployed man to repay a loan of two hundred dollars?
Well, it really wasn't two hundred dollars, it was...
Oh, whatever the amount, how did you expect him to pay you back?
Well, I, I haven't thought about it.
Are you in the habit of lending money that way?
I don't think I am, I...
Don't you know?
What, what? Wait, I know I'm not.
Rather warm tonight in here, isn't it, Mr. Barton?
Yes.
You've noticed it too, have you?
You know the penalty for burning property for insurance?
What's that?
I said, do you know the penalty... for burning insured property?
What's that to me?
This is your property, isn't it?
Certainly.
And it's insured, isn't it?
Naturally.
And it's been burned, hasn't it?
I still don't see...
Mr. Barton, I think we'd better explain to you... that you're under arrest for conspiring to create an incendiary fire.
Oh, this is preposterous. Do you know who I am?
Yes, Mr. Barton, we do now. You're a fellow that goes around burning his property... in order to collect the insurance. You tried that several times before this. We couldn't pin it on you. We've got you now, though, red-handed.
I'll have you dismissed from the department for this. You have no proof to connect me with this fire.
That's what I thought, too... until you got so warm a few moments ago... and pulled out your handkerchief.
Oh, what's my handkerchief got to do with it?
May I see it for a moment, please?
Certainly. Here.
Thank you. You see, we found a five-gallon can out on the back porch. It had been full of kerosene just recently. It had a little air hole in the top of the can, too. Somebody had plugged that air hole with a match wrapped with cloth. That piece of cloth, Mr. Barton... came from the corner of your handkerchief right here, do you see? Right. See. And that's why we're arresting you for burning insured property.
I didn't think about that. It's plugged.
Yeah, evidently not. Tell me, did you set fire to this house before?
I said, did you set fire to this house before?
Yes. Yes, I did.
Why?
Why? I'll tell you why. All my life I was... a home of my own for my family. And I couldn't afford one. But finally I saved enough money for my job and I bought a house. But it caught fire. The insurance company said I set it on fire... and they wouldn't pay me. But I didn't. I didn't, I tell you. Right then I made up my mind... I'd get another house. And I'd insure it for every dollar it would stand. And then I'd burn it. I'd show them. They'd pay me the next time. Well, I did it. I did it and it worked. I stood there watching the flames mount higher and higher. And I heard them roar. Those flames meant money to me. Plenty of money. I did it again and again and again. And I wanted to see those flames burn into the soul of the insurance company... as they feared mine when I watched my first house burn down. That's why I did it. And I'd do it again. I'd do it again, I tell you. I'd do it again.
The two men accused of the crime of arson in the case you have just heard... duly appeared for trial. They pleaded guilty... thus saving the authorities the cost and time of trial... and were then sentenced to prison terms. The shrewd, able, untiring investigators of this felony... Harris, Schubert and Hare... deserve a great deal of credit for their work. They did not lose sight of the fact that the defendants in this case had certain rights. But neither did they lose sight of the fact that a criminal... must be punished. It is their work which proves that crime does not pay.
