The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 24 min to read
The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... Come in. I'm E.G. Marshall. From 1861 to 1865, the people of the United States were engaged in a murderous civil war. Those years of conflict were the most costly epoch in all American history. Not only in money and in hundreds of thousands of wasted lives, but in the complete breakdown of our society. It became, in many places, what was called a war between brothers, especially in some of the border states, where the sympathies of the citizens were sharply divided between the causes of the North and those of the South, and death was a constant companion.
Tomorrow morning, sir, when my neck is snapped by the tightened rope and I hang dangling in the air, I will still be alive, in pain, but alive. And one time, finally, what you called, dead, all it will mean is an end to that pain. Your conclusion? Why go to the trouble of causing me pain one moment, only to end it bountifully the next? Aren't they worth the trouble?
Our mystery drama, A Matter of Conscience, is chiefly based on the Ambrose Bierce classic short story, Parker Addison, Philosopher. It was especially adapted for the Mystery Theater by Arnold Moss and stars Christopher Tabori. It is sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and ARM. Allergy Relief Medicine. I'll be back shortly with Act One.
In the autumn of 1861, the American Civil War was only a few months old. To most Americans, the idea of hunting down and killing their own countrymen was still an unusually disturbing experience, and a little unreal. The thought that the enemy they were shooting at, and who was shooting at them, was not from another part of the world speaking a strange and alien tongue, but another American. It still took getting used to. But it wasn't long before that changed. Whatever compassion there might have been began to give way to the cold, unrelenting hatred.
Hey, cut! Corporal, have your men pick up the body of the prisoner. Convey it to the place which has been designated. Assign four men to dig the grave. Then bury the body immediately.
Care for another egg, Parker?
No, thank you, Mother.
You've hardly touched your breakfast, son. Not very hungry.
Well, Mother, you must stop fretting about me. Remember, I'm a big boy now.
You're the only son I have. And with your father going off to the war, you're the only man left in this big house.
That won't be for long, Mother.
What are you saying? You can't stay out of the war much longer. I need you, Parker. I need you desperately. So before you decide to do anything rash...
I'm going to have to leave you, Mother. I, too, am going off to war. I've already signed up.
When do you go?
This morning.
This morning? The Union regiments that arrived last night have taken the town. The southern troops were badly beaten. They're in retreat. It's the same. Waited? Obviously, there's nothing I could have done to stop you.
Thank you, Mother. The rest of the boys in gray will be very proud of you. I'm sure Lorinda will be the most proud.
I'm not so sure. Have you told her your decision?
Not yet, Mother. I wanted you to know first. She has the right to know. Lorinda's going to be your wife.
Mother, it's quite possible you all may not be so proud of me. Why do you say that? My deepest convictions, what I believe about this war, are not, I fear, exactly the same as yours and Father's or even Lorinda's.
We all have a right to our opinions. That's what we've always tried to teach you. And if your philosophy differs a little from ours...
My philosophy differs more than a little, Mother. I've signed up with the Union Army. I'm a sergeant in the Army of the North.
I waited for my mother to burst into a flood of uncontrollable tears. Instead, her jaws hardened into two iron bands. Her eyes, after a silence I thought would never end.
To believe what you have just told me. But you have joined. I've been struggling with my conscience for weeks. My sympathies, Mother, are with the North.
Then we'll just have to get along without you. Parker, you're a traitor to your country. And a traitor to your loved ones. You must do what you conceive to be your duty. But your father and I taught you. It's been our way of living, always. Never for a moment dreamed.
I'm not ashamed of my decision. Don't try to make me pleased. I'd be most grateful if you would leave this house.
Well, Mother.
I can't do that, Parker. Enemy of my country.
Mother's words lashed across my face like the sting of a whip to try to justify her eyes. Within an hour, I was standing at attention before Colonel Herman Brail of the 4th Indiana Infantry.
Mr. Addison. A correction, sir. With your permission.
I beg your pardon.
You signed up with us yesterday, did you not?
Yes, sir, I did.
I understand you're a local boy. You live right here in this town?
Correct, Colonel Brail.
And still you wish to fight on the side of the Union? Our side. What might be called the side of the enemy.
Yes, sir. Why? Call it a matter of conscience, Colonel. I've searched and examined the issues of this war carefully and most seriously. My sympathies are completely and unwaveringly with the side of the North.
If it were necessary, you are prepared to give your life?
With respect, Colonel. My side. I have a fairly well-developed sense of duty. Slightly above, I have to say.
Sergeant. Please be seated.
Thank you, sir.
Sergeant Addison. A couple of questions. Any thoughts on how you might be of the greatest service to the Union cause, to the Army of the United States, and more specifically to this regiment?
I'll leave that decision to my superior officers, sir.
I'm aware of that. Without intending to sound boastful, you can say that I'm a first-rate shot around rifles since I was eight years old.
I see. Well, it may be worse. I've had as much schooling as any boy my age. Very good. I've been riding since I was five. I know horses. And you surely in the country fairly well, would you say?
Much, much above average, I would say. There's hardly a foot of ground within 30, 40 miles of here I wouldn't recognize as well as I would my own fate.
I think my question has probably been answered, how you might be of greatest use to this Army. Sergeant Addison, we need certain information. We need certain information very badly and in a hurry. By sometime late tomorrow night, the hour is not yet set, we pursue our attack on the enemy. Everything we've got.
I follow you, sir. We give him no relief. After yesterday's battle, I'm sure how many of his troops he may be able to regroup forces he may have in reserve. He may be preparing to counterattack.
I understand, sir.
At the moment, we're not sure exactly who would be attacking specific regiments, the number, the disposition, the morale. We have only an approximation of all this intelligence. We must fill in the blanks as fully as possible before we dare move.
Yes, sir.
Sergeant Addison, do you think that you could get this information for us?
I could try, Colonel. I would do my best. I would not order you to do this, understand? Should you refuse or hesitate, I would not hold it against you.
I volunteer, sir, to try to get the intelligence. The intelligence you require.
Spoken like a brave soldier. Provide you with a Confederate uniform, rank of sergeant, I believe. You'll be supplied with false identity papers, a name other than your own. You'll represent yourself as having been separated from your own company and regiment in the confusion of yesterday's battle. Uh, maybe even that you were wounded.
Yes, wounded. Good idea. Then what, sir?
You will slip on the enemy lines under cover of darkness. Tonight. Once you have penetrated those lines, we'll give you twelve hours to gather your information and make a safe return.
And should I not return within twelve hours?
...that you're in fairly. If you should be so unfortunate as to be discovered to be taken prisoner as a spy, the only questions you're required to answer under the Articles of War are... Name, rank, army identification number. Nothing else. Oh, one more thing. If you're taken, there's nothing we can do about it. There's nothing we can do to help you. We won't even acknowledge you. You're as good as dead. Johnny Reb, though with no disrespect to your former friends and countrymen, is especially sensitive to being spied on.
You're right about that, sir. Particularly by a man they would regard as a turncoat. The lowest, vilest kind of traitor. Hardly worth the rope by which they'd hang him to the nearest tree.
I'm not unfamiliar, Colonel Braille. Either with the concept or that behavior. I promise to do my best to avoid such an uncomfortable and embarrassing end.
One slip and you're finished. Remember that. Here are your false papers. I knew I could depend on you. Thank you, sir.
Let's see now, who are you? Sergeant Shelby Worth of the 7th South Carolina...
I sure do appreciate them kind words, sir. Now be careful, Parker. Next time we meet, I do not wish to see you hanging from the limb of a sycamore, a rebel rope around your neck. That would not be very amusing.
No, sir. Death is not usually very amusing. Finally, I want you to know that we trust you with our lives. Completely and implicitly. As if you'd been one of us from the very start. Above all, dream is touched. Thank you, sir. Good luck, my boy.
Lieutenant Howard. The man who just left this room is Sergeant Parker Addison. You're to watch him like a hawk every minute that he's here. He is to suspect nothing. I don't trust him any further than I can throw him. A man who can turn his back on his friends, his family, and his country is a man with whom we may have small... At the same time, he is a man whose deep moral convictions many of us are compelled in some strange way. To admire.
This is the course young Parker Addison has chosen. Where will his courageous choice take him? Directly to...
As night began to fall, Parker Addison, in the uniform of a Confederate sergeant, slipped unnoticed through the southern lines. There was enough of the lingering daylight for him to see that the fighting of the previous night had been hard and murderous. The taste and smell of battle were still in the air. Among the splintered trees lay wrecks of... Stretcher-bearers hurried about, carrying away the few who showed some signs of life. The dead were piled up like so much cordwood, while trenches were being dug to receive them.
I raised my hand to my head, rudely bandaged to give the appearance of a serious wound. I limped, as though I had taken a shot of grape in the leg. Before long, an endless moving line of suffering men, their faces, drawn, their ragged uniforms, spattered with crimson.
An old soldier hobbled up to me. Hey, that were a pretty good fight last night, weren't it?
Yes. Yes, it was. Never seen our boys put up such a fine scrap. Never.
That they did. Even if we did take some of the ver licking.
Well, we can't win them all, old man, can we?
Well, ain't that the truth. Where were you hit?
Piece of shrapnel caught me here. Well, right here, over my right eye. Give you much pain?
Enough. Hoping I don't lose my eye. Oh, then I caught a little grape here in my leg. How about you?
Well, I took a big one here in the groin. Beats are pouring down into my boot. Where you from, Sergeant?
South Carolina. Got separated from my regiment. You?
Kentucky, 7th, Company C. You lads hurt bad?
Bad enough. If one out of ten of us is still a-living, we'll be doing pretty good.
How about the others? I mean, the other companies?
From what I hear, we're not in very good shape. Not good at all. Why do you think you boys be now?
We couldn't say. I mean, did you have any cavalry support or artillery?
Oh, we did, but...
Who is your Commander General?
Well, Commander General? Oh, just we hollered every minute, mister. You're asking a lot of questions. Questions that ain't really none of your dang business.
I didn't mean it. What makes you so dang nosy, anyway?
You're absolutely right. It is none of my business. Why, I was just hoping that things were not quite as bad for all of us as they seem.
Well, I can understand that. Back young fella come along out of nowhere, just started his smellin' and his company pushin's at us. What happened? Too many. Turned out to be a dang Yankee spy. But, uh... You did? We did see them flappin' around in the wind, strung up on the branch of an old oak tree. Funniest sight you ever did see.
Any idea where this column we're in is headed?
This, uh, column with a walkin' deck. Some kind of field hospital somewhere up ahead. Couple of miles more, maybe.
I see. Uh, the Army Surge hatches up. Good enough shape to get us back to fightin'. Long enough to get to ever see them, sir.
Strugglin' line of us. Suddenly, down near Whitewater Creek, we blundered onto a hastily thrown-together field hospital by the light of their crude lamps. The doctors were busy sweatin' over the wounded men. Three or four soldiers, rifles at the ready, stood about as guards before I could get out of sight. One of the officers...
Here next, Sergeant.
Thank you, sir. Now, if you don't mind, sir, I'd just as soon took care of my old friend here. Oh, I think he's in much worse shape than I am. Now, you sit down on this log. I'll bring the light a little closer.
No, no, please, please take care of that. Please, please take care of the old fella. I can wait. He's been hit in the groin, and he tells me that...
I will make the diagnosis, Sergeant. Now, sit down. Off your head and see what you've been hit and how. Just how badly.
Why, it really isn't all that bad.
When you stop being a hero, Sergeant, all the heroes we need piled up out there like so many fallen log. Now, you just sit still. The wound doesn't trouble me all that much.
Now, look, Sergeant. Some of these men are on the brink of death. Now, if your wound doesn't trouble you all that much, now, please tell me what in heaven's good name you're doing here. Now, why aren't you with your regiment, Sergeant, uh...
Worth, sir. Shelby Worth. See, I just got separated in the last night's little fracas.
Oh, how?
Can't really say. One minute I was with my boys, and the next, I just wasn't. Now, just hold these stinking rags off your... Now, I really would rather you didn't.
You'd rather... I didn't. I can do that, sir. Just as I became separated from my country. I became separated from my company. Well, somehow, in a way I can't explain, my papers got separated from me.
Who are you, Sergeant? Who are you? I was hit by shrapnel last night, sir.
Sergeant Worth, uh, whoever you are, you weren't hit by anything. There isn't so much as a scratch any place on your head. Now, you stay where you are. Hey, where do you think you're going?
I'm getting out of here.
But... You hold on there. Sentry! After that man! The one who's running! Over there!
That saved me. That and the fact I knew exactly where I was. In a trap. Frantically sniffing out the one opening that would mean freedom. I began to run in the direction of my home. My pounding heart ready to burst inside of me. Exhausted. Where... Where am... Where am I?
Who is that?
It's me.
What on earth are you doing here?
I have feelings. I understand how you found me. Well, anyway, one thing, sir. You gotta get out of here. I'm going with you, Park.
No, no, no. That's crazy. Right in the middle of the fiercest fighting of the war. You must... You must rest. And then you got to come back with me.
I can't do that, Lorinda. We're at war. I... I'm a soldier.
I can see that. You're... You don't understand. This is not my uniform.
Not yours? How can that be?
I can't talk about it now. We're in the gravest danger here. I'll leave, Lorinda. Not with... And I love you, but... Oh, but please... Please go back home. I'll take good care of myself. I promise.
I'll help you if you came with me. You'd be safer.
Well, I'm going. You'd be safer.
You're under arrest. Where'd you come from?
That's the man, Captain. He went away while I was examining him.
Thank you, Doctor. Where's Lorinda? The girl I'm going to marry.
What you talking about? Get your head on this rock and... ...on your feet. Keep moving straight. This rifle is as small as your back.
I was led into a walled tent about eight or ten feet lighted by a single tallow candle stuck into the hat of a bayonet. An old rag carpet covered the earthen floor. A tattered leather trunk, a chair, and a roll of blankets were at the further end. A silver-haired general sat at a pine table, busily writing. The captain who had arrested me was posted at the open... The rain was drumming down on the canvas.
Pardon, sir. I believe, General, you want to see me.
Prisoner, aye. Since I'm to lose that at daybreak tomorrow morning, along with everything else, I, too, will follow the rules of war. The name, sir, Parker Addison. A somewhat humble one. You see, commissioned officers are considered much too precious to...
Sergeant. A lowly sergeant. I did have hopes of promotion, had I been fortunate enough to succeed in my mission. From the point of view of the articles of war, the answer would give you a good idea of whose forces you were facing. I came into your line, sir... ...that you are... That you came into my camp disguised as you are in the uniform of a Confederate soldier.
Would the General permit me to ask a somewhat personal and perhaps irrelevant question? I notice that there's a large nail driven into the tent. Can you stand it on guard?
Yes. The trommet is suspended. Permit me to say so. ...and a long-bladed double-edged bowie knife. A military weapon, wouldn't you say?
My days as a civilian.
Sorry, sir. Any more questions?
Captain?
Yes, sir?
Please take this paper to the Adjutant General immediately, and then...
Yes, sir?
And, uh, the prisoner, General?
I'll take care of the prisoner, just do what you're told.
Yes, sir.
Sergeant Addison?
Yes, sir.
Bad night, isn't it?
It certainly is. I can only hope that things will be clear by morning. In times of war, an ordinarily gentle person, in almost no time at all, will often be transformed into a hardened, impenitent mechanism who can sleep soundly on a hill that trembles with the thunder of great guns, play cards among the dead faces of his closest without blinking an eye, calmly and coldly assign another man to...
To what?
I shall be back shortly with Act Three.
Stormy night in the autumn of 1860, somewhere in the south. One of the earliest battles of the Civil War has just been fought. The driving rain cascades in torrents upon the canvas of the Confederate General's tent. The elderly officer sits at his rough, fine table. He has just given a folded paper to a sentry with the order that if he delivered immediately to the Adjutant General, the General's young prisoner, a spy for the North, would stand at attention.
Are you aware that what you have done is a capital offense? A punishment is death?
I am, sir.
Can you guess what was written on the paper I've just handed the sentry?
I'm usually not very good at guessing, sir. It may be my immodesty, even my vanity, but I venture to suppose that I was mentioned in it.
Your assumption is correct. The memorandum to the Adjutant General is an order for the guidance of the elder that rather than spy falls into our hand and raised right here. I hope General Provost Marshall will arrange the article with pace. ...of your own that you might like to have carried out any messages to your friends you wish to see a chaplain.
A daybreak at five in the morning?
No, I couldn't think of being so inconsiderate of another man's sleep. Besides, I could hardly expect to secure a longer, more pleasant rest in heaven by depriving a chaplain of his rest.
Do you mean to go on to your death with nothing but these silly jokes?
Silly jokes about death? I would have no way of knowing about that. I've never been dead before. This is all very new to me.
Well, you ought to be serious. Isn't there anything more important you can say?
Isn't there anything more important you can say to me, sir? I know that death is supposed to be something one should not treat lightly, but I've never heard this from any of those who have acted. One thing I'm sure of, of all the dead men with whom you have strewn your path, I'm sure that few have shown any noticeable signs of either death, or pain.
Yes, yes, I admit I. I admit I've been the cause of many as you would blow the flame of a candle at me to your lord. You could order your men to release me. Procedure might be considered not reasonable.
One last point. Suppose I made an attempt to escape death. But if I did, what would you do?
No, no, no. Don't revolver. You are courteously concealing in your lap. You would file with several ounces of lead. I should be what? What is the point you're trying to make?
Tomorrow morning when I am hanged, when my neck is snapped by the tightened rope, and I hang dangling in the air, still alive, my pain is ending. I go to the trouble of causing me pain one moment only to end it bountifully the next. It would hardly be worthwhile to hang me at all.
Sat there impassive, as if his eyes were a mountain guard over me, while his mind concerned itself with other matters. The long breath shuddered, as if he had wakened from a dreadful dream, as though talking to himself, Captain of Peter.
General.
Send for me.
Captain Hesterlick, your provost marshal.
Thank you, sir. I got your message from the adjutant general.
Yes, of course. Captain Hesterlick, this is the Yankee spy who was captured inside our lines in a Confederate uniform. He has confessed.
Yes, sir. The storm has passed.
Yes, sir, it has. Clear night. Adjutant general, you're to take a file and conduct the pris firing squad and have him shot.
Yes, sir.
You can't mean what you're saying. I'm not to die until morning. I never said a word about your dying in the morning. Of course you did. Or a morning. That was an assumption of your own. You die tonight. Why are you doing this? General, I'm to hang. I'm not to be shot. It'll take at least two hours to erect the gallows. You wouldn't hang me, would you? And certainly not shoot me. What difference? Spies are hanged, not shot. I've my rights. Rights under military law. Captain Hesterlick, proceed with your orders.
Yes, sir.
Rittner, the opening of the tent. The point of my saber is quite sharp. Toward the tent, open it. Three short steps to the tent pole. I sprang toward it like a cat. I seized the handle of the long buoy knife that was hanging there. I thrust the captain aside, leaped upon the general, and with the fury of a madman hurled him to the ground. The tent was overturned, and the candle was extinguished.
Captain, help me!
The provost marshal pounced on me. In no time, the three of us, a welter of limbs and bodies, fought and clawed at one another in the pitch black dark. Get that knife away from my throat!
The tent collapsed upon the three of us, and beneath its heavy folds, the struggle went on. The captain, on guard outside the tent, had obviously fired his rifle to attract attention. Soon the drums began to beat the long rope. Bugles sounded the assembly. Swarms of half-clothed men, dressed as they ran, rushed into the moonlight, fell into line. When all was under control, the men stood at arms, while an officer and the men of his escort tried to bring order out of the chaos I had created. Someone lifted the canvas of the tent that had covered the three of us.
Here! Our prisoner!
Yes?
Stand up, if you can.
I can't, I can't say, sir. Captain Tasman? Dr. Tasman?
Uh, the general's buoy knife was stuck deep into his throat. And clenched in his hand. His own saber. Streaked with blood.
You! How'd this happen?
Look to the general.
General. Now, now, you. Let us help you. I think I... Now, one in the thigh, and the other in the shoulder. Good, you can. And shivering. Though a heavy white fog had settled on everything about me, I could not raise my right arm. It was broken from whatever help was offered me. Cowering on the ground, babbling a torrent of words. Words I could not understand myself. My face. The blows and sting of blood.
Felt as though it were still white. I heard a voice say, No, no, he's not insane. He's merely suffering from being taken out at once. And those whom I written to execute this detail. General, your order has been carried out. The prisoner Parker Addison is dead.
Prisoner's what? Where was that beast from the north? A Yankee? He was not. Who's the prisoner, sir? The man you have just shot to be placed next. General Addison. Thank you, Captain.
Having reaped what it saw as a harvest of perpetual peace, this one bloody trial of sharp war, the nation tended its wounds and did its best to soften the agony and torment of four long years. Years of a war that often pitted brother against brother. Or, as in this case, father against son.
The author of the short story on which this dramatization was based has been praised for being among the few American writers of the past hundred years with the uncanny ability to reveal man as a proud but helpless figure in the clutch of a ruthless destiny. Our cast included Christopher Tabori, Arnold Moss, E.V. Juster, Earl Hammond, and Robert Dryden. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by True Value Hardware Stores.
This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Till next time. Pleasant dreams.
