Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Blood Will Tell

Episode 555November 26, 197644 min 24 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 24 min to read

I'm E.G. Marshall. People say, like father, like son. People say, the apple does not fall far from the tree. People talk about the sins of the fathers. You listen to some people and you might logically ask yourself, why bother to try to do anything or to be anyone? After all, isn't it who and what your father was that will determine the course of your life? Well, if you spend the next 53 minutes right here. You might get an insight into an answer. How did you get in here? You just heard how I got in. Through the window. What do you want? I want to kill you. Kill me? I never hurt anybody. You killed my father. I never killed anybody. You killed his memory. The memory I had of him. The memory I could live with. Now I can't think about it anymore. You killed him for me. Please, please, don't. Mystery drama, Blood Will Tell.

was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dan. Starring Nathan Adams. Sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division. I'll be back shortly with Act One. Day in, day out, the same dreary old thing. Nothing ever happens. Really happens. Well, that's how it is for most people. And the fact of the matter is, that's how most people probably want it. Here we have Norman Claymore. A gentleman for whom life has always been well-ordered, regular, and uneventful. It is death where he works in the billing department of a mammoth corporal. All day he adds figures on a machine. Is this rewarding? Satisfying? It's the sort of thing most people do, isn't it? Take note of the date. It all begins here. And you are Mr. Norman Claymore. No middle initial. Social security number 089-03-0984. Well, yeah, that's me.

I'm Melisande Resnick of Personnel. I'm sorry to disturb you. Oh, well, just let me make this entry, please, and I'll put the figures down as soon as I get the total. I understand. I could have asked you to come over to Personnel. Oh, I wouldn't. All we need is the answer to a single question on your record. Oh? The original application for employment here, where it says parents, living or dead, you wrote father deceased. And where it says cause, you wrote died of illness. Do you recall? Yeah. Could you specify the illness? Could I specify the owner? Yes, what did he die of? I don't know. But you said... Well, actually, I don't remember. See, I was only three or four, I think. Well, forgive me if this sounds forward, but didn't you... Well, I'm not sure I wanted to know. Why do you want to know? Oh, I assure you, it isn't merely idle curiosity. We need this information for insurance purposes. It has to do with, oh, tables of probability.

Various technical computerized matters of that sort. Uh-huh. Do you need for full information these days? Oh, sure, sure, of course. Well, could you ascertain the answer? Yeah, I suppose. Well, it is vitally important, because until the item can be completed, the file will remain open. You can't have that. Forty and sober hard-working men from their duties to their mothers who have grown old and ill, making sacrifices for their ungrateful sons. Have some pie, Normie. I'm supposed to be on a diet. You know me. You shouldn't be a fanatic about anything. I do so wish you'd meet a pretty girl who'd take you off my hands. I'm lucky, Mommy. This is the music your daddy and I used to dance to. This was music. You're talking about daddy. So many other great band people today never heard of. I'll have to ask you a question. Oh, you tune in the radio at night and...

Heal wonderful bands from all over the country. Yeah, Mommy, a girl came up for personnel, and she told me that they had to know just exactly what kind of illness it was. Girl came up to? Talk to? Yeah, yeah, Mommy, it's about Daddy's death. Did it strike you as strange? I understand why they might want to know. Oh, I'm not discussing that. Your problem has always been that you could never follow the main line of the argument. All I'm saying is she told me why they wanted to know. Now, we'll address ourselves to that personally. First... Why did this girl come up to see me? Mommy, as I'm trying to tell you, she wanted to know. Well, if she wanted to know, why couldn't she have elicited that information on the telephone? You do have inter-office communication, do you not? Well, yes. Well, and the fact that she is with personnel only serves to prove my point. What point? Oh, Normie. There are, as you know, women who are desperate for marriage. I'm screwed.

Ridiculous women who will do anything to ensnare a man. Oh, but Melisande. Melisande, is it? Well, she had to tell me her name. Her first name? You see, my poor, naive little normie. She goes through her files of personnel. Stouts the unmarried men. And since you are obviously the most eligible of the lot, she made some pretext to meet you. But it did sound rather legitimate to me. Oh, no, me, no, me. You're such a babe in the woods. So unaccustomed to the wiles of women. Yeah, yeah, I guess you're right, Mommy. But what should I do about the question she asked me? Do? Well, just disregard it and disregard her and she'll get the message. That's Mommy. Is there a fella who has a wiser or more loving mother? She figures every animal. She catches on so quickly.

I guess I'm the luckiest guy in the world. Well, I went back to the office the following morning, and Miss Resnick did not contact me, nor did she the next day or the day after. Which led me to assume, naturally, that the request she had made was, in truth, a device to make my acquaintance. However, Miss Resnick, because on the following Monday... Mr. Claymore, you never did get back to me with that information. right, I didn't. Are you sure it's important? Well, certainly it's important. To whom? To me, of course. Why else would I ask? I have no idea. Mr. Claymore, I have been told to complete your record by the vice president in charge of personnel. Now, do you want me to tell him that you refuse to give us this information? Well, you may tell him anything you like. Mr. Claymore, have you considered the consequences? The consequences? An assumption will be made that you have something to hide.

Now, really, why should you create an unfavorable impression? The corporation from the chairman of the board down has filled out this form just as you're required to do. Well, just put down any disease, TB, whatever. I cannot put down what I know to be false. Mr. Kramer, can you obtain this information for me no later than tomorrow? It's ruthless. I'm screwed. and this woman appears to have upset you a great deal. Mommy, she seems to be very shy and quiet. Oh, they're the worst kind, but I have to give them an answer. What disease did Daddy die of? He didn't die of any disease. He was killed in a bus accident. Yes, yes. He was standing at the bus stop waiting. The bus came along. He stepped off the curb. The bus didn't stop. But, Mommy, you said... You see...

He thought it was the local, but it turned out to be the express. But you said that he took ill and died. Did I say that? Well, perhaps I did. But if it wasn't true... It may not have been true, but it was con. After all, being run down by a bus is an absolutely horrible way to be killed. And you were a little child. It could have done something to your psyche. You might have become terrified of buses for the rest of your life. And not being rich, we couldn't afford to travel everywhere by taxi cab. Isn't that so? Oh, yeah. Personally, you would have had bad dreams. Well, in four cars of death, I could tell Miss Resnick that Daddy died in a butt accident. Yes. And after you tell her that, you can tell her goodbye. Sorry to disturb you again. Well, what is it now? I did telephone the information to you, didn't I? Yes, you did, and I placed it in your record. Well, then what is the problem? The vice president in charge of personnel, he asked me to ascertain.

Why you lied. Lied? Lied about what? Lied about the cause of your father's death. He wants to know why, if your father was killed in a bus accident, you found it necessary to lie about it. Why did you say he died of sickness? Well, that is the story that my mother told me. She wanted to spare a little child's feelings. Well, we appreciate that, but we must know the exact circumstances. I have just given them to you. I'm afraid that will not be sufficient. If he was killed by a bus, there would be a police report. If he died of illness, I'm sure there was a death certificate. What does it really matter? Mr. Claymore, until the matter is resolved, your file will be incomplete. You want that to happen. I know I'm disobeying, Mommy, but I love you. I love you because you're so practical, so down-to-earth. I love you for your quiet strength, for the way you can just stick with me so much like Mommy. Melisande, we can't do very much about it now.

I can't marry anyone while Mommy's alive, but forever? After all, nobody lives forever. Oh, this band plays very much like the old Hal Kemp orchestra. Why can't we give them proof of how Daddy died? Because it's none of their business. Well, it's not an unreasonable request. I see. She's seduced you, hasn't she? Who? That Melisande Resnick with her blonde hair, her blue eyes. How do you know if he has blonde hair or blue eyes? With a clinging sweater and a tight shirt. Mommy, how do you know this? Don't you think I would find out at first hand what sort of Jezebel is trying to ensnare my son? Darling, I went downtown to your office building. I got a look at her. Oh, a very good look, let me assure you. Mommy, I've only seen her exactly three times. And all three times she was at my desk. And at no time did I feel for more than two or three minutes. It's all she requires. The idea of her, they said...

idea of her has been planted in your soul. Cleanse yourself, Normie. You have strength of character. Drive her from your mind. But, Normie, if I don't bring in proof of how Daddy died, I can be forced to quit my job. Perhaps that would be for the best. But I have seniority, an equity, and a pension plan. I'm 40 years old. I mean, where could I go to start all over again? Now, Normie, you have a great amount of ability. You could get a good job anywhere. Why won't you tell me what Daddy died of? I think I'll go to bed. Don't you understand? They're going to fire me. Well, dear, who knows? After all, it may just turn out to be for the best. Little acorns suddenly sprout into great big oaks. Tiny mole hills become huge mountains. Why is Mommy so set against giving Normie what, after all, should only be a piece of routine information? You already heard enough of our story to come up with a variety of interesting possibilities.

Think about them, and let's compare notes when I return shortly. The thing you can now accept to live in a world of forms, papers, documents, records. There are no secrets. There is no privacy. Soon there will be no mystery. All of us shall become open books. Mr. Congreve wrote a play in which a lady said to a gentleman, Oh, sir, you must not kiss and tell. It was almost 300 years ago. Today... You must not only tell if you kissed, but also if you didn't. And why. Mommy, I know you don't understand. I'll be fired if I don't bring in a certificate of one sort or another. I'll be fired. Darling, you weren't listening. I said it wouldn't be for the best. A job like mine, a good job like mine, how could losing a piece of the button for such a trivial reason? But it is not a trivial reason. All they want to know is a daddy.

I say that's none of their affair. What is involved here is the basic principle of privacy. I am not concerned with principles. I can see that. You don't understand. No, me dear. You're the one who doesn't understand. You're the one who doesn't sense the grave danger. It has a name. Miss Melisande Resnick. Oh, Marley. You're so innocent of the world. It's quite probably my fault. She has already seduced you. And that is why you must leave that place. Mommy! He must not be permitted to destroy your life. And that is your mommy's final word. She's always right. But Melisande, she's so nice. Is that the word? Yeah, yeah, yeah, nice. Surely she must be exactly what mommy would choose for me herself. I don't understand. Melisande hasn't said one word, made one suggestion that might even remotely be considered as improper.

Yet what does he know that I don't? Mr. Claymore, do you have the information for me? No, Miss Resnick, I do not. Oh, I'm at a loss to understand your reluctance. A most insignificant matter has been blown completely out of proportion. I do not agree that the matter is insignificant. The right to privacy. We're concerned here with the world of practicality. The world as it exists. All I can say is that failure to furnish us with the information can mean your job. I realize that. You realize that? And you still... I am prepared, as they say, to walk the last mile. I understand, Mr. Claymore. And please, this is off the record. In the ordinary way, the matter would be of no significance. However, the vice president in charge of personnel is the son of the founder. I didn't know that. Well, it was necessary to give him a title to keep him happy. And now he looks for things to justify his job. Well, he...

He found you. I can't do anything about that. You're an excellent employee. I would hate to see you lose your job. Well, sometimes a man must stand up... You have three weeks. Three weeks to do what? To complete the form. The vice president left for his vacation last night. His parting words to me were, if that record isn't filled in fully and accurately with documentation, Norman Claymore will be fired. Well, then I guess I'll be fired. Oh, no, you mustn't be.

Why won't you write down the cause of your father's death? Because I don't know it. But that's impossible. You must know. Is your mother living? Yeah, she's living with me. Oh, what did she tell you? It seems that every time I ask, she tells me a different story. Well, perhaps she's afraid of what's involved. Afraid? It's possible. I say possible, not probable or even likely, but possible. She doesn't want the circumstances of his death to be known. Mommy, she would tell me. She tells me everything. We're very close. Oh, Mr. Kramer, I know we would hate to lose you. Oh, please, try to resolve this very minor problem somehow. There's nothing personal in this. I'm just thinking of the good of the company. You are wooing one another. This is the earth. Do I know nothing at all about Daddy's death or even his life?

Why are there no pictures, no letters, no mementos? Why are there no stories, no family stories? Why is there no family? No aunts, uncles, cousins? Why are Mommy and I alone in the world? I must have... Troubling, you know me. Well, it's about your daddy, isn't it? How did you know? Because I'm your poor old Mommy, and I know everything about my little boy. Mommy, what did he... I don't want to talk about it. Just because some... No, I won't say anything disparaging about her morals, even though it's true. Let's say I don't want to talk about your daddy's death because I find it painful. Well, then walk about his life. I find that painful, too. But, Mommy, shouldn't I know something about my dad? Oh, please, Normie, don't be disobedient. Do you want me to feel pain? But, Mommy... Oh, goodness, this is my bridge night. Where am I playing this evening? Oh, admit to selling.

What a wonderful memory you have. Darling, are you sure you'll be all right tonight without me? Oh, yeah, yeah. Good boy. Usually, I kill the time till I had to pick her up in a movie. But tonight, I drove straight back home. There was something I had to know. I had to know it, or else all would be over between Melisande and me. I find it. Somewhere in Mommy's room is the answer. I know that. I know. I know the answer is in Mommy's desk. Or in her chest of drawers. Or in some of those cardboard boxes high up on the shelves of her closet. Must be in one of those places because Mommy made me promise on my honor, cross my heart and hope to die, that I would never go into her room unless she was there. Never. I must know about Daddy. Because unless I tell Melissa, she'll reject me. And I can't live with that. Look at Mommy's desk drawer. Books, receipts, bills, letters. I know about Daddy. I know that. Shelf of her closet. I will forgive me. I'll answer my wife.

Mommy calling me to pick her up. Her bridge game is over. Paper. The box. I rushed him. Say about the fury and the blood of the men in his line. Is he that enraged with his mother? With his adored mommy? That should go business we're involved with. He'll sort it all out in act three. In just a few moments. Qualified for one in a lifetime headlines. Our Norman Claymore has just discovered that his father was a murderer. Not just a murderer. A multiple killer. killer was finally brought to justice, he would never have endeavored to discover this fact about his father had he not been compelled to fill out a form at his place of work, which asked if either or both parents are deceased. I never did get into you this evening, Normie. Hi, Mommy. You know you must never make me wait for you at Mrs. Silver's ambassador game. I think you cannot tolerate the woman. Normie, are you sure you're all right? I said I was, didn't I? Oh, nothing of me again. Oh, I know.

That Melisande Resnick. Oh, now, really? She upsets you. She makes you think strange, unnatural thoughts. Natural for a man and a woman to want to... Natural? You're the one who's unnatural, Bobby. You're the one who treats me like a child, who finds fault with every girl. You, who are unnatural, an unnatural woman. What am I saying? Blood. Thing that's in my blood. That's why you watch me, why you... Keep me under your thumb. Thank you, Mommy. Darling, whatever you're mumbling about. What? What? Oh, oh, I'm sorry, Mom. Girl, this is even worse than I feared. That woman has completely captured your mind. To be from marriage, you must. You know what's in my blood. You know what I have inherited from my mother. I must never pass on to my own children. I must not have children. You could have told me about that because you love me.

You wanted me to have memories of you, Mommy. I love you. The family. I think I understand. Oh, Mr. Claymore, I... I cannot help but admire you. Where? You're protecting someone. Now, that's obvious. Oh, but at such a cost. You know, you're a hero. In the truth of the world... Ah, now, it's a good man. Can't deny it. I won't, but we are human. My father knew, but did he deny himself my mother? Never. I shall not deny myself you. Normie, there's something wrong. Wrong? What, no? Now, darling, I know you better than you know yourself. Something is burning inside of me. Please, everything's all right. What do you mean? You won't share this with your mommy? I don't know what she's talking about. Now, Normie, we must get to the bottom of this thing. Fighting the bad blood. Quick, meet up your wall. Age in my blood. This is a killing of Pennypack. Mommy, pull me.

Normie, we've always been able to talk out your troubles. I tell you, I have no troubles. Mommy knows better. Normie, where are you going at this hour? Out. Where? Nowhere. What are you going to do? Nothing. I broke your window, Mr. Pennypacker. How do you know my name? Everybody at the plant knows your name. What are you doing here? I intend to kill you. Why should anyone want to kill me? You killed my father.

I never killed anyone in my life. You killed his memory. Ask anyone. I'm the mildest person. But you tried to separate me from the woman I love. No. I've never done anything bad in my life. Lies won't save you. Please, don't kill me. I'm ready to complete the form to answer the open question on my record. I don't even know what you're talking about. The cause of father's death. I'll tell you. My father was hanged. I'm truly sorry to hear that. Oh, my. We all make mistakes. It was no mistake. It was in his blood. No, that's impossible. A thing like that? And it's in my blood. Maybe a psychiatrist. I can't help myself. I'm going to kill you. No, don't. Please. So overpowering, I could kill with my bare hands. I hit him again and again and again. I should have whispered. I looked at him. He was dead. He didn't need to feel for his pulse to listen for his heartbeat.

He was dead. You could tell by the sprawl of him. Such as finally found my identity. I was my father's son. Alvin Claymore. Have you read the news? What news? In this morning's paper, he was murdered last night. No. It was some homicidal mating act. Very sorry. To life, Mr. Nemore. Believe me, Miss Resnick, my job is not worth Mr. Pennypacker's life. Actually, if by giving it up, we could bring that poor man back. Who are you? I know that you're waiting for me. This is 398.

I thought this was the residence of Melisandre Rednick. Melisandre? Some short little guy looking for you, baby. I recognize you with your clothes on. I mean, with your overcoat and hat. I mean, the only times I ever saw you, you were sitting at that desk with the green eye stayed and in your shirt sleeve, banging away at that adding machine. Eight hours a day, punch, punch, punch on those teeth. Melisandre. Give him a drink, lad. It looks like he needs it. Melisandre, I thought... I thought that... Who's he? Oh, that's a good question. Les, who are you? Been hanging around together another couple of years. I guess I'll qualify as your husband. Melissa, I thought that you were in love with me. Hey, baby. You'd give her the eye to Chubbs again? She can't help it, Shorty. She tries to make every guy she meets. No. But it don't mean nothing. The only guy she'll ever go home with is me. I'm sorry, Shorty. My name is Norman. Nah, don't get it.

Get mad, Norman. See, Melisande? See what you've done? He's mad. Oh, come on, Norman. These things happen. You're a big boy. I'm going to kill you. Both of you. You and who else? This is what happens when I don't listen to Mommy. I'll write to you with a bucket. She calls you Jezebel. Norm, I think you better be leaving. You're a harlot. That's enough. Talk about it, Mr. Claymore. What's there to talk about, miss? I killed him. We know that. Why? Because I'm my father's son. What does that mean? Claymore. Norman Claymore. Does the name mean anything to you? Think. Think, miss. Many years ago, there was a murderer. Norman Claymore. I remember. He was my father. Murderer was in his blood, and he passed that blood to me, and that's why I killed him. Enoch Pennypacker, too. You say you also killed this Pennypacker man? Yes.

Yes, when my blood begins to raise the way my father did, then I have no control. Excuse me, is he all right? Oh, yes, Beck, I'll come out and talk to her. Mister, do you want to see your mother? Mommy? Oh, yeah, yeah. Just finish dictating your statement to the secretary, and I'll bring her in to see you. My son, can I see my son? Yes, Mrs. Claymore, he's just as human. He didn't kill those people. Couldn't kill them. We have witnesses, Mrs. Claymore. But why? Why? He said his father was a murderer. Is that true? Is it? Yes. He said his father claimed murder within the blood. Is that true? Yes. And so your son says he killed because he inherited that murderer's blood. You can't help it, sir. That's not true. It wasn't true about his father.

It was true about his father, yes, but it couldn't be true about Norman. It couldn't be. Why not Mrs. Claymore? Because Norman, Norman was adopted. Blood will tell, will it? The question is, will blood tell? Will blood tell it? If you want to reach into the heart of the matter, what is blood? We're not talking about serum and plasma and cells and platelets. What we have in mind is blood. As a mystique. All right. Enough questions. You want answers. Tricky business, this. About blood. And sometimes the blood you think you have may be more powerful than that which actually flows through your veins. Or less. And why do we say flows through the veins? Why not through the thoughts? The great mystery. The greatest mystery of our existence. Which is why you hear about it so often on Mystery Theater.

Our cast included Mason Adams, Bryna Rayburn, E.V. Juster, and Ken Harvey. The entire production was done at the direction of Hyman Brown. A preview of our next... ...anything in all my life. I remember it, Craig. Take a deep breath. Float right through the locked door as if it weren't there. I'm moving toward it, as if I were flying. The important thing is not to worry about it, Craig. I feel better if I could understand it.

explanation. And I'm...

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑