Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

The Man Who Couldn't Get Arrested

Episode 556November 29, 197644 min 51 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 27 min to read

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... Come in. Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. Anger is a branch and hate is a tree. And prejudice and bigotry are the undergrowth and the bramble. And they all form the forest. The unwholesome forest of intolerance. For this is a forest that has always flourished. How well has it been protected and preserved over the centuries?

Darling. Penelope. Of course it's Penelope. But you're dead. Who says so? It's all the papers. Really? Aren't you the one who says believe half of what you see, a quarter of what you read, and nothing of what you hear? But I went to your funeral. Well, if it really was my funeral, then obviously I didn't stay put. Our mystery drama, The Man Who Couldn't Get Arrested, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dan and stars Fred Gwynn. It is sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and True Value Hardware Stores. I'll be back shortly with Act One. Society endures, which is not to say it always will, but as of now, the work of the world goes on. Most people can be depended on to do their jobs. Most people accept.

Their responsibilities. Most people obey the law. And why? Is it morality? Is it citizenship? What keeps Mona straight and narrow? Our little drama may cast a ray of light on the subject. On the other hand, you may find yourself deeper in the dark than ever. It is night. Madam, your sign says... Ringing the bell at this hour. Your sign says rooms for rent, and I thought... You know what time it is. We apologize for the lateness of the hour. I run a respectable place. I'm convinced of it, ma'am. I wouldn't have rung your bell, but I saw the light on in your window. Well, come on in, come on in. Do I have to catch my desk tanning out here, jabbering? Room's at the end of the hall. Well, so what do you want? Tell us it ain't. That's a 25 a week. I'll take it or leave it. I'll take it. In advance. Oh, I'm paying all my bills by check. I'll bet you are. Listen, Buster. First thing in the morning, I'm at the bank. If this thing bounces, you bounce right out after it. And one thing I don't put up with here...

Women in the room are on a quiet, respectable house. Oh, yes, I approve. I'm actually a rather quiet person myself. Mrs., uh... Mumford. Mrs. Mumford. Yes. And my name is Carnahan. Hector Fremont Carnahan. Well, I'll bet it is. Where's your bags? Bags? Luggage. Your belongings. Your stuff. Oh. Are you on the lam? I beg your pardon? I ain't running a hideout. So if you're in wrong with the law, you... Oh, oh, I see what you mean. Oh, I assure you, it's nothing like that. Yeah? Well, what is it like? Um... Yeah, I miss America. No, no, no, it's true. I'm a stockbroker. Sure, sure. You're also a millionaire. Yes. Even with the depressed state of some of my holdings, my net worth... Yeah, well, so tell me, Buster. My name is Hector. Yeah, so what are you doing in a flea bag like this? Why, now, Mrs. Mumford, you underestimate the sheer...

beauty of this building. Oh, yeah? This is what's known as a Madison Brownstone. A what? Which means it's over 100 years old. You're not telling me. The last of them were built in the 1870s. None of which answers my first question. Question? Where's your belongings? Oh, well, you see, I don't intend to live here on a permanent basis. You don't? You see, there are times when I need solitude, intervals for meditation, contemplation, and I do not wish to be disturbed. my associates. Well, then, why don't you go on up to the woods? Millionaire like you, you're going to have one of them hunting lodges. That would not answer the purpose. You see, I must be available for various business decisions at a moment's notice. At address, I am not more than five minutes from my office by taxi cab. Teacher's owners this day. Good night. Yes, good night, Mrs. Mumford. I see you. Yes, yes, yes. Just a minute. Okay, now, what's happening? I don't know. Who's in this room with you? Nobody.

What do you mean you guessed nobody? Well, I don't see anybody, do you? Well, if there ain't nobody in the room, who are you yelling at? I heard somebody. We laid down the ground rules here. No women in the room. She was in the room before I got here. Oh, you're crazy. I heard her voice. Are you nuts or something? We'd better call the police. The cops? What for? She was calling for help. Who was calling for help? The woman in the room. Well, you said there was no woman. I said I didn't see her, but I heard her. Heard it distinctly. She's begging for help. Somebody's going to murder her. And when was this? It was just now. Yeah? Well, so why don't I hear her? Well, let's just be quiet and listen. I still don't hear her. But it was just as plain as... Are you sure you haven't been taking too much thought? I tell you I heard her. Her voice. She's pleading. She doesn't want to be killed. She's begging for help. Oh, all right. Let's put a stop to this. Is there anybody in this room? Any place?

It needs help. Now he's there. Speak up. Well, go ahead. Speak up. Let's hear from you. Well, you hear something, Mr. Hector Carnahan? I, uh... Yes or no? Well, I did just before. I mean right now. But, Mrs. Mumford, I distinctly heard... Oh, Mr. Carnahan, I don't rent to drunks. Mrs. Mumford, I swear to you, I'm absolutely sober. Oh, well, then it's worse than I thought. You might bear in mind I don't rent a nut either. Good night. But I heard it. I heard it. I heard a voice. A woman's voice. Somebody help me. It's my imagination. I never hurt anyone. I'm getting out of here. Well, if you have to ask, you don't have any business being in here. This is Harry's bar, pal. I'll have a drink. Sure you can handle it? You're the doctor. What are you talking about, buddy? I'm going to be killed. Don't you hear it?

Now, listen, friend. Answer me. Don't you hear her? Friend, you better not have her. A woman? Why don't you just go home? I don't want to. Sleep it off. Understand, we have to help her. Can we let a woman die? You're trying to humanize. Now, look, mister. You think I'm a nut. Well, okay, read this. Now, look, why don't you just... Just read my card. Yeah, just read my card, okay? Read the rest of it. D, D, and W. There's firms on the street. Yeah, sure, sure. You don't believe me. I believe you. I believe you, yeah. You can't treat Hector Fremont Carnahan as if he were some kind of nut who wandered in here. Look, all I'm saying, pal, is you better not have a drink. What are we going to do about her? The lady who is going to die if we don't help her? Look, friend, just take a walk, eh? You're going to let that woman die? A lot of women in the world. One less, is it really going to matter? All right, I'll go. But I...

Hope you can live with yourself. The recent... In the prices, precious metals should not tempt the prudent investor into thinking he can get in on the ground floor. Hector? Am I interrupting anything? Oh, certainly not, Dale. I'm just doing my... Where were you last night? Yes, you and Penelope were supposed to have dinner with us. Of course, don't you remember? How would I know? Penelope handles all the social engagements. Check with her. Well, Eleanor did. Yes, and what did Penelope say? I don't know. She couldn't reach her. She's been trying to phone Penelope all day. Do you know where she is? Well, it's strange. Where were you last night? Last night? Supposed to be at our house, and when you didn't show up, we kept calling and calling. Well, as far as I can tell, we went out to dinner. Supposed to be at your house, then signals were crossed. The matter? To tell you the truth, I... Hector, there's a... There's a woman in my office. Yes? And she told me a rather unbelievable story.

Yes, about what? About you. About me? Yes. Her name is Mumford. Mrs. Marguerite Mumford. Do you know her? Let me tell you what she said. Well, we know what she said, so this is as good a time as any to take our usual intermission. At any rate, we have presented you with two Hector Fremont Carnahans. One, the impressionable and frightened man who hears voices. The other, the hard-headed, no-nonsense man of business. Which one is he, really? He could be either. Neither. Or both. Very shortly. Starry still. Voices that whisper secrets. Voices that cannot be still. Sing. Voices that tell of love. Hector Fremont Carnahan is hearing voices. Then I'll send her on her way. Just a minute. What's this all about? Oh, no. It's probably a confidence racket of some kind.

Well, that beats me. Come into my office, Mrs. Mumford. Oh, well, good morning, Mr. Carnahan. Know me, madam? Well, sure. From where? Mr. Carnahan, you don't remember me? How could I remember you if we never met? Oh, it's worse than I thought. Madam, state your business. Well, I don't know where to begin. You came around to my rooming house on Hudson Street late last night. Whatever would I be doing on Hudson Street? Near the waterfront, especially late at night? Well, sir, that would be your affair. You rented a room. I can only tell you what you said. You said you needed it for intervals of meditation. Was it contemplation? And I guess it was communion. I said that? Yes, sir. And you paid me one week's rent in advance, $25. You wrote me a check.

I took it to the bank this morning, and I asked, is it good? And they said, well, as good as gold. Let me see that. It used to be your signature hack. Exactly. It's a very clever forgery. I'd better destroy this at once. Well, you... It was not me. Yes, sir. But I had to go along with the idea. It was you, you see. You was acting very strange. You were hearing voices. Voices? Yeah. A dame. A woman who was calling for help. Why? Well, because someone was fixing to kill her. Who? Well, I don't know. I didn't hear her. You're the one who claimed you heard her. But it wasn't me. Well, what do you want from me? Oh, 10 o'clock at night, a guy, he's an amateur here. He rings my bell. He rents a room and gives me a check for a week in advance. Then he starts screaming to hear some dame who's in trouble. Well, I figure this guy's got to be sick.

Well, I find out he's a big Wall Street businessman. I say, well, why don't I go to this guy's office? Oh, look, I ain't no angel of mercy. I had an angle. I figure maybe the guy's partners or somebody would flip me a couple of bills for my trouble. Well, well, well, it's worth it, ain't it? You did the right thing, Mrs. Mumford. Yes, thank you. Oh, I tell you, that guy used the spitting image of you. Just like he had a twin brother. Thank you for your trouble, Mrs. Mumford. And here's... that the man was supposed to have paid you, and... Around claiming to be you, Hector. What after do you suppose? I could see where someone might use my name to steal service at a luxury hotel, but for a dive on the waterfront... Oh, excuse me, Hector. I'll put her on. Oh, I just spoke to Hector. He doesn't know about the dinner date last night. Oh, he doesn't know where Penelope is either. Oh, dear, I'm sure there's an explanation. Well, all right. All right, goodbye. She's been trying to reach Penelope.

I'm sure there's some explanation. We'll get it all sorted out when I see Penelope tonight. The recent fall in the prices of precious metals should not... Hector, dear. Penelope! What is it? Why, you look as if you've seen a ghost. Is it you? I'd like to know who else it would be. I had a dream. Yes? A horrible dream. Oh, well, if it was a terrible dream, you'd better forget it. No, no, no, no, no. I have to tell it to you. Whatever for? I don't tell you my bad dreams. Well, that's because you never have any. Penelope. Oh, flattery, flattery. I love it. And how good you are. Well, about that. Did you do something wrong? I dreamed I did something wrong. Well, darling, you can't be held accountable for that. Well, I was jealous. Jealous? Of what? Ben Walston? Whatever for? Well, I thought you had fallen in love with him. With Ben Walston? And that you were having an affair with Ben Walston. With Ben Walston? That's impossible.

possible. Well, when you're jealous, anything's possible. Ben Walton. I was, I was so angry I decided to kill both of you. Oh, you're kidding. I'm telling it the way it happened. But Hector, dear, I've only known you to become passionate over stocks and bonds. I don't show it, Penelope, but I love you very deeply. I know that, darling. And the fact that you and Ben were having an affair. That's only in your dreams. It became too much for me. You had made an excuse that you had to visit a friend somewhere out of town. I knew that you and Ben were going up to the lake. And did we? Surprises in flagranti delicto, as they say in the tabloids? No, not exactly. But you were both up at the house, sneaked into the study where Ben was reading, heard the gun, and shot you. Oh, Hector, how could you? I told you, I was insane. I was crazy with jealousy. All right, darling, I forgive you. I went up to the country. I was able to get into Ben's apartment. I wrote a note on his typewriter. I'd love to read it. And as near as I can remember it, it was a suicide.

Dramatic, darling. Darling, word of this must not get around Wall Street. I left you and Ben and the note in the summer house. We had a dinner date with the Dales. Oh, I knew I had forgotten something. I was in a daze. I went back to the apartment. Well, too many memories of me, I suppose. It was dreadful. The voice kept begging for help, imploring someone to save her, save her from death. Oh, how dramatic. I ran out of the house. I ran and ran down the deserted streets. I suddenly found myself in a neighborhood near the docks. This would have been a good time to wake up. I saw a sign on the tumbledown building. I went in there. The landlady rented me a dress and followed me there, too. Poor darling. You knew a bar, but your voice wouldn't let me be. And I remembered. You were spending the night at your mother's. How is she? Oh, she sends you her love. The Dales will want to know why we didn't have dinner there last night. Oh, I wish I could come out with it and say they bore me. Please don't. Well, I shall make up a most delicious excuse. Well, shall we go home to dinner? Oh, you go, darling. I...

I have something, a committee meeting tonight, and we're having dinner at that inn. Oh, will you be home early? Oh, very early. Okay, then. I'll stay here a while and finish this. Good. And then we'll both get home about the same time, and you won't have a chance to miss me. Hector, I don't know if you're going to appreciate what Eleanor and I are doing, but friendship imposes certain obligations. Well, sit down. Drink. All this is better clear, cold, sober. Well, last night you didn't show up. Yes. Penelope didn't... Didn't what? Didn't remember? It's possible. You, uh... You know about Penelope and Ben Walston. Now, look, Dale... If not, you're the only one who doesn't. And that's what friends are for. I... I'm telling you. Why? Because the man who pretends not to see what's crystal clear to everyone else is laughed at as a fool. She went away with him last night. Yes?

And if she did? You found out about it. It almost drove you mad. Is that so? That woman in your office today, she wasn't lying. There's no imposter. You roamed the streets like a lost soul. I went into all of the neighborhood bars, and most of them remember a nut. Yes, that's what you were to them. A nut who tried to convince everyone that he heard a woman's voice. Victor. It's my affair. No. It's... Penelope and Ben's affair. Hector, would you take her back? Dale, there's something you should know. Eleanor's going up there now. To the lake house. She's going to try to convince Penelope to come back. She's driving up the country to ask Penelope to come back to me? Well, it's what you want, isn't it? She's going to have that long drive for nothing. You mean you know she won't come back? She's here. Here? Where? I spoke to her at the office around 6.30. Well, Everything's all right? She's at a committee meeting. She's due home any minute. Well, Eleanor and I have egg on our faces. There was never anything between Penelope and Ben. Well, it shook that way. Oh, you know Ben. We meant well. You must believe that. Will you have dinner with us tomorrow? Have Eleanor check with Penelope in the morning. Yes, of course. Good night, Hector. Good night, Dale. Sorry, the meeting ran a little later than we expected. Oh, that's okay.

Oh, I just want to get into my nightgown. Oh, I'm sleepy, too. Oh, I'm glad you woke me. It's a dream. Oh, another one? It was about Ben. Oh, go back to sleep, dear. He was so terrible. I have to tell him about it. Well, I'm sure he doesn't care. I must. I must. I must. I'll call him now. Darling, I'm sure he's asleep. All right, then you call him. Say, I have to tell him this dream. Tell him he must come over right away. To hear a dream? Yes, to hear a dream. Please, Penelope. We're dealing here with a dynamite dreamer. Now, before you put any of this down, remember, nobody really knows what a dream is. For all we know, the dream life may be the real one, and vice versa. Especially to those people who have learned how to develop the capacity to dream. What's this about a capacity to dream? Is there proof such a thing exists? It doesn't.

In the next few moments, I'll prove to you that we have a third act. Mr. Hector Fremont Carnahan keeps weaving in and out of a dream world and in and out of the world that we hold to be reality. And so far, no one can really tell which is which. Power for the course, because who really knows what's what about anything these days? What's this all about, Hector? Ben, we must make peace. Why are we at war? Yes, you and I are at war. It's the craziest thing I've ever heard of. Please, Ben, just listen to Hector. I felt so strongly, I was sure. Some of my emotions had to be communicated to you. Perhaps it was. I would dream violent dreams about it. Just this evening, I dreamed I was at your house and I was waiting there to kill you. What for? Jealousy. Then he had the same dream about me. I just want you to know how I felt then. We have nothing to be jealous about, Hector. I think hatred cannot be concealed, especially when it's so...

All-consuming. The one who is hated must be able to sense it. Did you? Well, most certainly. That is, if you think I have anything to forgive. Ben killed you. In my dream, I killed you. I want us to be friends, the three of us, the way we always were. Can we go back to that? Hector, I'm not aware that we ever left it. Oh, Ben. Lifted from my soul. Oh, that's beautifully put, Hector. Beautifully. I couldn't have said it better myself. You're not supposed to talk like that, you old... Stockbroker, you? Suddenly I feel tired. Oh, it's late. Very late. Well, I'd better be running along. Good night, folks. Oh, don't bother. I'll let myself out. Good night, then. Yes, darling, I'm tired. But for the first time in ever so long, I'm happily tired. The way it's supposed to be. Now, dearest, you just close your eyes and get to sleep. Yes, I'll do that. Darling, get to sleep. You self-filled... Who would I? Nonsense.

Now, dear. Right out loud, I hear you ringing. I'm coming. What kind of idiot would be at the door at this time? It's me, Dale. Dale. Hector. Yeah, it's me, Hector. Who did you expect? I have to talk to you. It's four o'clock in the morning, Dale. I know that. It's the thing you have to tell me at four o'clock in the morning to get away. Hector, I don't know how to say this, but I never had occasion to tell something like this to anyone before. Something like what? Come on, come on, come on. Out with it, man. I just got a call from Eleanor. She's up in the country. Told you she'd gone up there to see if she could affect a reconciliation between you and Penelope. Didn't I tell the two of you you were dead wrong? Well, she'd already left our house by then. So she had the trip for nothing. She's up there now. And she found Penelope. How could she find Penelope up there? Now, let me finish this, Hector. It's hard enough to say.

Penelope's crazy. I wish I were. Let me prove it. Penelope's here. I just spoke to Eleanor on the phone and she said... You were dreaming. Hector, please, get hold of yourself and listen. Come with me. Where? Into the bedroom. You'll see for yourself. What will I see for myself? Penelope. She's here. She's been in bed all night. Hector, you have to stop fighting. Will you please come? You have to accept it. What are you waiting for? Just come this way. In here. But no one in that bed. Should I get you a drink or something? So she must.

Penelope? Hector? Penelope? I know you're here. She isn't. But we were just in bed. Eleanor went up to the summer place. I don't care what Eleanor says. I know. She says she walked into the house. Deal. This is the strangest thing. The lights were on, and the first thing she saw, she saw Ben Walton. He was dead on the floor. Now, I know you're crazy. Ben was here in this room around midnight. How could he have been up to the... Summer, how... You can imagine what a shock it was for Eleanor. She phoned the sheriff and then she passed out. Is this your idea of a joke? Don't fight it, Hector. Please. Sooner or later, you have to accept it. Penelope. Dead? Why was I able to see her so clearly? To talk to her? To hold her in my arms? You know where we're going. We have to drive up to the country. Going to be very bad for you for a while, but this is the first step you have to take. Until you do this.

You'll never recover. Let me tell you what happened. They were carrying on, your missus and Ben Walston. I'm sorry I have to say that, Mr. Conahan, but it's a police record, you understand? I understand. Well, I guess they could see no future. People in a setup like that, they can get awful depressed. I've seen it happen. Well, anyhow, they must have made a suicide pact. He shot her, and he then turned the gun on himself. We got the note. Want to read the note? It isn't necessary. I know what it says. But anyhow, the thing's open and know what it says. How could you possibly know what it says? Sheriff, don't listen to him. He hasn't been right, and this thing is obvious. I understand, Mr. Dale. It's enough to disrupt anybody. I know what it says, and I know what happened, and you must listen to me. Sure, Mr. Conaghan. Just relax. Take it easy. Don't patronize me, Sheriff. I'm doing your work for you. Oh, yeah, I appreciate that, sir. And don't be sarcastic. Hector.

The sheriff's only trying to... And you keep out of it too, Dale. I'm not a fool. I knew what was happening behind my back. And it wasn't even behind my back. It was in front of my eyes. Hector, don't punish yourself. What does a man do in these things? Divorce her? What if you love her? It's propaganda we sell ourselves. Most of us go through life for half a loaf. Better than none. I believe I... And I could even see her point of view because I'm... For your true meaning. Yes. Well, the more I closed my eyes, the more I pretended not to notice. The more... The more flagrant they became. Pretend anymore.

I couldn't disregard it anymore. Yes, sir. I'm a stockbroker. I must maintain a certain amount of credibility. You're coming to scandal. So I said to them, just, you know what they did? Well, they laughed at me. Oh, Hector. I decided I would make it look like a lover's. I knew they'd be up there. I wrote that note. I shot him in such a way that it would look like he killed himself. I see. I didn't. After I did it, my more than remorse, I wanted to take it back. Do you understand? Yes. I refused to accept the fact that I had done this monstrous thing. I insisted to myself that they were still alive, and I heard her voice. It kept following me. Don't kill me. Please don't kill me. Help. I don't want to die. The voice wouldn't let me alone. I wanted to bring her back to life badly. I forced myself to be able to see her again alive, Penelope, and I made them come alive for me. Sheriff, can't you see how ridiculous that is? Of course it's ridiculous. Well, the coroner is satisfied with murder and suicide. What do you mean the coroner is satisfied? Everybody is satisfied.

But I'm telling the truth. I'm going to get you to a doctor. You need something that'll let you sleep, Mr. Conahan. I can prove it. I wrote the note. It was typed on his own typewriter. We established that. Because I sneaked into his apartment. Yeah, sure, sure. I fired those shots. He didn't. He couldn't. Look at his hand. Give them a paraffin test. It'll show he has no powder burns. When you fire a pistol, there have to be powder burns on your palm. Only in detective stories. Okay, okay. So he killed her. And then he killed himself. What you say.

How long did you say you waited between killings? You can't establish time of death with any accuracy within a quarter of an hour, maybe a half. All right. Maybe subconsciously I knew I wanted to get caught. He was found holding the pistol in his left hand. Was you telling the story? I inserted the gun. He's right-handed. That's a known fact. Everyone knows that, don't they, Dale? Ask Dale. He knows it. We all three played golf together, didn't we? All right, all right, even if it's true. The fact that a man is left-handed or right-handed don't mean a thing at a time like that. Killing yourself is an awkward thing to do. And so people do it awkwardly. You must listen to me. I've been listening. This gentleman here is my witness. I've been listening. I tell you, I did it. I'm guilty. What you got is a guilty conscience. You believe you drove her to it. So you feel you're as guilty as if you'd pulled the trigger yourself. But I did.

Twice. I'm guilty. Won't you believe I'm guilty? Do you believe it? No one else did. The louder he shouted, the more people smiled tolerantly. And of course, as happens in these affairs, people's patience wears a bit thin. And finally, the only way to handle a situation was to place Hector Fremont Carnahan in an institution where he insists, to this day, he is guilty. I shall return in just a few moments. It's one thing to hear people accused of murder insist on their innocence. It's quite another to hear people who are not even suspected insist on their guilt. Is he or isn't he? Did he or didn't he? Left enough clues in the story, but unfortunately, they couldn't support either point of view. The only people who know for sure are Penelope and Ben. And how can they possibly tell us?

Our cast included Fred Gwynn, Joan Shea, Bill Griffiths, and Cork Benson. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. A preview of our next take. Remember a few years ago when I come home after my chores and you found me flat on the bed? Mm-hmm. I told you I was tired and my stomach was upset. I didn't want to worry you, Emma. Heard the voice, Rob. Yeah. I didn't say nothing for fear people would say I was an old fool. I heard the voice. Mother, please let me in. Please, Mother. That's what I heard. Heaven have mercy on whoever it is. Amen. Who could it be? I don't know, Emma, but you couldn't pay me enough to walk past the sunset. Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by True Value Hardware Stores and Buick Motor Division.

This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Till next time, pleasant dreams.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑