Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

The Orphaned Heart

Episode 1230August 5, 198144 min 19 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 28 min to read

welcome i'm e.g marshall asking an age-old question in this flawed world can good ever come from evil there are those of you who will answer yes others a resounding no still others astride a moral fence cannot make up their mind in the story i bring you let us seek the answer in an individual case you will be the jury and at the story's end bring in your verdict can good ever come from evil

now stop susan just stop i won't be part of such a wicked scheme

please aunt tim please i know how to do it but i can't do it without you

no it is wrong it's evil

it's not please aunt tim no

and that is final don't mention such an abomination again

our mystery drama the orphaned heart was written especially for the mystery theater by nancy moore and stars roberta maxwell susan martin

in the operating room of mercy hospital was there not as a nurse but as a patient paralyzed from a crushed spine dr levy chief surgeon leans above her kind old eyes trying to disguise they both knew what she wondered was david hurt too in the automobile accident dead she tries to say his name only a dry sound struggles from her throat

before the ether when she returns to consciousness like any romantic girl into the church wedding it's made and all the music the bride in satin and lace or a court hospital gown instead of standing at a flowering altar i lay flat on a hospital bed i david take thee david till death us do part who vows the navy's voice david clark's mind was only on medicine called susan martin

dr levy spoke on that subject doctor work and no play eventually makes a bungling surgeon you will take time off every week

i don't need or want any time off dr levy

i'll make the diagnosis here time off that's an order nurse martin see that dr clark obeys

how do i do that dr levy

well david how does she martin

i'm not sure i remember how to play but if you're willing to be my assistant off duty as well as on i'll give it a try

the cardiogram right then would have shown my heart gone crazy that night david took me to dinner really had forgotten how to play but two cocktails loosened him a little after that he took me out once a week a pattern set a few drinks to relax him laughter companionship a kiss good night each time i loved him more

the only person i could talk to about david

anything wrong with trying to make him love me

there's a good deal wrong with how you're going about it

all i do is try to be good company

but seeing to it that he drinks more than he should is being good company liquor breaks down barriers no doubt but liquor won't make him love you

oh aunt tim he'll love me and he'll marry me wait and see

david and i went to the beach after a moonlight swim we lay close on the warm sand and forgot to eat our picnic supper he kissed me longer and sweeter than he ever had and called me susan always before i was martin

i love you so

martin what's happened between us doesn't mean i i

love me i know it doesn't i've always known forget that i said that nonsense it was the martini talking

it's forgotten come let's go for a drive

we drove with the top down under a full moon i didn't care that david was driving much too fast and i didn't see the sharp turn at the moment we hurtled over a steep grade i was wishing on a shooting star that david would love me and marry me one day

hospital after the long operation when i came back to consciousness david unhurt sat beside my bed pale and stricken

lord susan what have i done to you how can i make up for this

marry me susan marry me

later the nurse told me that in my delirium i had cried out over and over david love me marry me and david heard

why did i allow such a mockery of marriage because i believed what everyone believed that i was dying and i could face death with part of my life's dreams come true

i david take thee susan till death do us part

after that pitiful ceremony dr levy said susan must rest now david

mrs david clark lay waiting to die mrs david clark like another shooting star the marvel of that name shot through me nerve and cell sprang to life strength flowing in me by all the rules i should have died i prayed to live to be david's wife i did live a thousand times i wish i could have died

you and the good lord have wrought a miracle

the miracle doesn't include making me whole letting me walk

susan perhaps with time

no dr levy is certain i can never even use crutches david is married to a woman he doesn't love husband of a wife tied to a wheelchair i know what i have to do aunt tim quickly now i wouldn't have the moral strength ever to do it at all

get the divorce neither of us will get a divorce susan

now you're not going to hold me to a marriage i hardly knew was happening you know very well i was too sick to know what i was doing

i don't know any such thing i know what you're doing now why only because you feel guilty about me

i am guilty

no what happened was an accident it could have happened to anyone

an accident that i drank too much and drove like a maniac let me do the little i can do to make up for what i've done to you don't take that chance away from me susan don't make me any more guilty than i already am

nothing will change his mind before i left the hospital he bought a lovely house all on one floor with a garden where i could paint not very good pictures of the flowers he hired a living nurse but was so exacting about my care that she soon departed two more came and left then david went to aunt timothy

aunt tim i'm here to apologize

what in heaven's name for

refusing your offer to take care of susan i still think it's too much to ask but now i'm asking in fact begging

you know you don't have to beg susan is an rn the best she'll know when something more is needed than you can manage will you come

aunt tim a thousand thanks for coming it'll be lovely to see you again thank you thank you thank you thank you

isn't it lovely to have you here

well if ever it isn't lovely if i get on your nerves or david's nerves or the cat's nerves i want your solemn vow that you'll tell me

i solemnly vow and i vow once you say the word i will vanish out gone no hard feelings

i wish david would vanish just because i say the word out gone no hard feelings i've lost count of how many times i've asked him for a divorce and nothing's changed he doesn't seem restive if he is he doesn't let it show no wife ever had a more kind and thoughtful husband

i'm so glad for you

well don't be glad can't you see his wretched goodness and sweetness make me love him more

i see but i don't i don't want to love him i know i know if he were rotten to me i could say get out leave me alone i don't want you anywhere near me and mean that so he'd believe me and go one day i will say it i plan how i i rehearse it i i scream it so the lie will have the ring of truth i've never yelled at david he'll believe me if i yell he'll it can't wreck his life any longer i'm sick of the charade david bored into the grave with it it's an empty act and i hate it get out just get out i just don't want you anywhere near me anymore

no he could read my eyes

the months of mock marriage became three years where would it end in my orphaned heart i knew it had to end but who would dream it would end the way it did

a few miles from our city flowed a wide river where i liked best to paint aunt tim would drive me there settle me on the bank with easel and paints then leave to do her shopping in spring the waters fed by mountain streams ran wild and high threatening to overflow and in march of the fourth year

david oh dear are you sure you don't mind staying alone when the river is like this

i like it best this way fascinates me

well i don't like it a bit i'm afraid of it what if there's a flash flood now i'm putting your chair far from the bank and i want you to promise you won't wheel any closer

that was the spring david fell in love but not with me he was not less kind but his eyes sometimes had a faraway look and once while gardening

like the spring david fell in love

oh david you're talking to me like a

love is not all left for me oh get up why don't you tell your parents you don't like them

yes because they don't love david at all

guanabara i'm z repetitively starting to break milk it's me добавl電 numbers at this house flores will have the right number just know they say otherwise cruyff no paradise at all

i can refuse to give him a divorce can't i

yes you can just because i'm a paraplegic isn't grounds for divorce

no but those aren't the grounds are they susan

saying if i really love him i'd want his happiness i will give him a divorce but david's request never came our arid life went on as before only his haunted eyes spoke but he meant to continue doing his duty i would have had to ask him for divorce myself and this time his answer would be different

susan please we agreed not to talk about divorce again

you've paid your debt to me david a debt never owed three years of paying now you've another debt to pay

what debt

the debt you owe to love and love's name is laura

how did you know

the florist's cards were mixed up sorry you had to find out because it's over i'm not seeing laura at all please believe me it's true something began between us but we stopped it i swear there's nothing now

except love i want you to have your love david do you think we could have any happiness knowing it was stolen from you happiness can't be built on selfishness there'll be no divorce ever

did i love david without selfishness i believe that i did what could i do that i hadn't done to set him free

the next day at the river i knew the spring thaw in distant mountains sending down angry waters straining to leap the river's banks susan sits painting the dark swirling water sits far back where aunt tim had anchored her chair she feels compelled to paint not what she sees but what she imagines the dangerous river at full flood covering the very spot where she sits and the ominous painting carries a message death by drowning

i will return with act two shortly

what have we now a painting that seems to speak to the painter death by drowning but your death will not look as if you chose it it will seem an accident and this time your beloved need feel no guilt once another accident bound him to you this one it will set him free

when the message came to me i shouted no no and flung the painting to the ground thou shalt not kill it was murder self-murder a sin believing that why did i keep thinking of it my mind thrashed like the river and by the time aunt tim came back i had to tell her the awful thoughts that wouldn't go away

i knew i shouldn't have left you in this dreadful place it's made you morbid you can be sure i won't bring you back till the danger of flood has passed oh how i wish we didn't live near this awful river

susan but now what are thinking you've just given me an idea

let's move away aunt tim

but you see you're talking more nonsense you know as well as i do david can't be asked to move his practice

i don't mean david should go with us i see exactly what we can do and how one day after the spring rains from the river really is that flood i'll come here to paint while you're gone i'll disappear or seem to all the evidence will say i drowned and david will believe the flood swept me away

susan your story will be that when you came back from shopping poor susan and her chair were gone he'll think i wheeled it too close or the brakes didn't hold

susan just stop i won't be part of such a wicked scheme

please aunt tim please i know how to do it all but i can't do it without you

no even if i agreed it wouldn't work you're not thinking of all the problems the obstacles

I am, I am. And it's clearer every minute. I know where we'll go and what we'll do.

We're not going anywhere.

Do you love David?

Oh, Susan, you know I do.

Then prove it. Together, we can give him back his life and give him Laura.

There. Now that shows how addled you are. Even if David believes you're dead, he can't marry Laura. There's a law that if a body isn't found, seven years have to pass before a missing person is legally dead.

Oh.

The body of Susan Martin Clark won't be found, and David can't marry anything.

No, he can be with his Laura, be free to love her, and the seven years will pass. Years of love, not duty because he's tied to me.

Oh, Susan. We can live on Uncle George's life insurance.

It's not a problem.

It's more than enough. He didn't leave it to me for this. Our whole life's hiding? What kind of life is that?

When it's safe, after a few months, we can go to Europe. You love Europe. Live in a charming, obscure village in Portugal or France where tourists never come.

And Tim?

No. All right. If you won't help me, then I... I really will drown myself. I will.

Yes. And Tim knew I wouldn't carry out that shameless threat. But how could she be sure? We sat still till twilight planning. When we reached home, the plan was set in motion.

David, Susan will go and paint by the river, and the place scares me. It's so wild and dangerous this time of year.

Well, then stay with her the whole time.

Now, that's just silly, you two. I like being alone, and I paint better alone. Once more, I have this odd feeling that the river has answers to all my questions.

But Aunt Tim had been right. Problems and obstacles were so endless, I sometimes grow discouraged, sometimes depressed. How could I live in a world without David? Other times I had grave doubts. Was what I planned wrong? Could only evil come from living a lie? We went right on planning. First essential was finding a place to stay in the mountain.

And, well, it certainly can't be a hotel or a motel.

Oh, no. Absolute privacy. A remote, furnished cottage with no close neighbors. But near enough to a village where I can buy supplies. Most important, near enough to this city.

So on the day Susan Clark died...

Don't say that.

So on that day, you can drive me to our hideaway and get back home the same day to tell David the sad story of the river stretcher.

Susan, Susan, I don't... I don't think I can go through with this.

You can. You will. Now, we've got to look ahead, not back. Plan, plan a thousand things. Buy me a wig, Aunt Tim.

A what?

After I've drowned, there'll be publicity, bound to be. My picture will be all over the papers, I'm sure. When we go house hunting, I mustn't be recognized. A little black bobbed wig, Aunt Tim.

Oh, your beautiful long blonde hair all hidden. Susan, let me tell you something. Finding a place where two women can live alone won't be as easy as buying a wig.

I know that. But we'll find that place.

Don't be too sure. And I'll tell you something else. If we look at house after house in the mountains, cottage after cottage, and not one is right or even possible, then it will most surely be a sign that we are not meant to do this unnatural thing. Not meant to, Susan Clark. And the Lord will be seeing to it that we can't.

Aunt Tim's sign theory. The Lord was highly in favor. Very soon, we were led to an almost perfect hideaway. A pretty isolated cottage, 60 miles from the city. The sign out front told us part of what we needed to know.

Furnished cottage for rent, monthly or yearly.

Aunt Tim, we are supposed to do this. The little house is telling us so.

In the village three miles away, we got the key from the owner, Mr. Allen.

We got the key from the owner, Mr. Allen. Albie. Luckily, he was too busy in his hardware store to go through the house with us, or I'd have had to stay in the car faking a sprained ankle. The cottage inside suited exactly. Aunt Tim, to her own disgust, was developing into a marvelous liar.

Mr. Albie, my niece's name is Mrs. Clayton, and I'm Mrs. Timmons. We're both widows, and both love the mountains. We'd like to rent your cottage for at least six months.

Well, now, ladies, it looks like it was just meant for the two of you.

I want to believe that, Mr. Albie. When will you be moving in?

Why, uh, we're not sure yet. Problems to solve first. Anyhow, the rainy season begins soon. I think we should come after the rains. Don't you think we should, Aunt Tim?

Yes, afterwards, absolutely.

Ma'am, you ought to come before the rains. They didn't see the stream alongside your cottage. It's thundering down the mountain. It's a sight to behold.

I, uh, well, yes, I'm sure it is. We'll try, Mr. Albie, but we just can't promise.

Well, any time suits me, ladies.

We'll pay the first month's rental now. Is that satisfactory?

Well, it's fine and dandy. And I hope you'll be happy up here. Uh, kind of a long holiday, I take it?

Very long. Longer than we've ever had.

We brought it off, Aunt Tim. Weren't we clever every step?

Full of lies, that's what we were. And wasn't I foxy saying I walked through the woods around the cottage?

Yes, that was a good red herring. Now, if Mr. Albie reads in the city paper that Mrs. David Clark, who drowned, was a victim of paralysis, he won't associate that name with Mrs. Clayton, who tramped through the woods.

Oh, the stage is all set, Mrs. Timmons. The die is cast.

Well, I wish I could be cheerful about it like you. I shouldn't tell you this, but sometimes, when I look at David and know that soon I won't ever see him again, I wish the rains would never, never, never come.

Come three days of drenching downpour. While the rains poured down, there were my tears. I pretended to David that I was annoyed because I couldn't go to my river. And overplayed my hand a little.

Susie! Susie, you've got a kind of obsession about that river. Do you realize how much you talk about it?

Do I? It's, uh, well, it's just that I feel boxed in when I can't go. The first day the sun shines, I'm going.

Fourth day dawned clear. On our last morning, David sat across from me at breakfast. My husband. I felt my resolve weakening and wished he wouldn't sit on over his coffee. Go, I thought. Please, go. So I can go, too. But in spite of inner torment, I said what had to be said.

It's a lovely blue-eyed spring morning, David. I can go to the river.

My wife and her love affair with a river. It, well, it does have something to do with a love affair. Can a husband be jealous of a river?

You're teasing me.

Complimenting you, really? You're a marvel, Susie. Have I told you that lately?

Probably not.

All right, I'm off. Have a fine day. Have a blue-eyed day.

Dr. David Clark came around the table to his wife, standing beside her wheelchair. Usually, in farewell, he only touched her cheek with his hand. If he kisses me, Susan thought, a kiss would be a sign that he loves me a little. And I will not go through with it. He holds herself rigid. We must wait for act three. Never to see David again would be Susan's true death. She longed for the kiss. It would hold her to him. His hand touched her cheek. He did not kiss her. She said only two words, final and terrible.

Goodbye, David.

As he turned to go, she even managed to smile. He would remember her smiling on that fatal morning, would believe in the accident. Now, she sits on alone, waiting for act three.

The moment I woke up, the sun told me you'd say today is the day. I lay there planning how I'd argue with you, plead, beg, even cry. And then I told myself nothing would change your mind.

It's too late for that.

So this is the day, Susan.

Yes, this is the day. It's begun, Aunt Tim. The die is cast.

Yes. I'm clocking how long it takes to get to our cottage, so you'll know exactly for the other time.

Yes. I've seen my house for the last time. David, for the last time. It isn't real. I don't believe it. It's as if I will not talk like this, think like this. The die is cast. Aunt Tim.

Yes. I know what you have to do is harder in some ways than what I have to do. I'll just sit up there in the mountains and wait.

Well, you don't belittle what you have to do. Manage alone. You've never had to do that since your accident. But I can. I've practiced enough.

Poor dear Aunt Tim. You have to go back and tell David the endless lies.

I should never have left Susan alone, David. The river had flood like that. I told her I wanted to stay. Several times I told her. I said I was afraid of that river. I remember I used the word ominous. Now it's as if I had a premonition.

Susan, not listening. Laughing at your fears. Liking to be alone. That's exactly how it was. Exactly. And then, then the river she loved. Taking her. Taking her like a lover for its own.

You could say that.

Damn the river. She loved it and it killed her. Have you any idea what it does to me to know that if I'd given her a better life, this wouldn't have happened? She'd never have felt the need to go to that place.

No, no, no. That's not true, David. Her paper. She went there to paint the wild beauty of the water.

It is true. Her life would have been full. Instead, it was empty because of me. It was barren.

David, don't talk like that. Now, it would break her heart if she knew you felt any guilt at all. You were always good to her. You've nothing to regret.

Good. She was good. Brave. Gallant. Never the martyr. Never accusing. She never felt there was anything to accuse you of. She loved you. And heaven forgive me, I could never love her the way she needed and deserved. But I loved her, Aunt Tim. I loved her.

One worry for me was that friendly Mr. Albie might come to call. He did just that. Fortunately, I was not in my chair. Tired from painting, I was lying on the couch when he knocked. My easel close by. Quickly, I took the afghan covering. And threw it over my chair. Then, with my hands lifted, my legs to the floor so I could sit up.

Where's Albie? There, Albie. The door's off the latch.

Good day to you, ma'am. Just come by to see if everything's all right.

Everything's fine. Forgive me for not getting up. I've been painting for hours. It's made me tired and lazy.

Now, there's no call for fancy manners. So, you're a painter.

Yes, of course. There on my easel is the view.

Oh, from that front window. Bless my soul. The spitting image of them trees out there. The stream behind them rips snorting down the mountain. It's real beauty. I never saw the like.

Thank you. See you, Mr. Albie.

Well, no, I can't stay but a minute. I've got to get back to the store. I'm awfully sorry I can't offer you something cool to drink. We haven't been very efficient about supplies. My aunt's gone to remedy that.

Oh, is that so? I didn't see your car in the village.

She's gone to the city. We need other things from there.

You don't mind being out here in the woods by your own?

Not a bit. I paint better alone. My late husband never understood that.

Oh, here I am bothering you. Well, I'll go along. Uh, ma'am, I hope you'll be happy here. I surely do.

Happy? That was not part of the plan. Only David was mad. And Tim came back for a few hours the day after Mrs. David Clark's memorial service. It had been another painful ordeal, but in a way, laughable.

All the lovely, sad things the Reverend Harris said about you. I kept wanting to shout, Stop! Please, stop! Darling Susan is alive and well and living in the mountains.

Well, what have you had? But someone else might say it. If we don't make more plans fast. Who on earth?

Mr. Albie. He was here yesterday, inside. Your chair, did he see it?

I had time to cover it up. Then pretended I was too tired to get up from the couch. But if he makes a habit of coming...

Aunt Tim, as soon as you're here for good, we've got to tell him I had some kind of accident and I have to be in a wheelchair.

More lies. That isn't a lie, is it? Well, the lies aren't near finished with David.

I can't keep on leaving. You're here alone. That was too close a call yesterday. And what if someone notices when I come here? I never stay overnight. You have business in the city. That won't wash after a while. If I had that much business, I wouldn't take a house in the mountains. Next week, I'm going to tell David the last pack of lies.

David, tell me I'm a busybody if you want to, but I just have to ask you a question.

Any question, ask.

Laura. Well, that's my question. Nothing about her. You're not planning to see her? Is she married?

Well, no. I'd have heard about it.

Oh. Oh, I'm glad, David, because Susan would want you to be with her.

She told you that.

And out of some wrong feeling of guilt, if you plan not ever to see Laura, then you're being faithless to Susan's memory.

Thank you for saying that, Aunt Tim. Thank you.

A week later... Tim told David what she called her last pack of lies.

David, I came to live in this house to take care of Susan. I can't bear it here now that she's gone. I thought it would get easier, but it gets worse.

It's the same with me. I see her everywhere. I hear her voice. I keep remembering her at the breakfast table that last morning, smiling. I'm glad I can remember her that way, but I can't stand the house. I'll sell it and buy another.

Can you bear with it just a little longer?

But, David, it's not just the house. It's the city. It's her city, the river. Her river. I want to leave all the memories. So I'm going to travel, David. I have friends to visit abroad, and eventually I'll find the place I want to live. And you'll find a new life, too. I hope, and I know I speak for Susan. I hope. It's with Laura.

Susan and I live in a village in France. Seven years have passed. Mrs. David Clark is legally dead. Yesterday, from America, came copies of the newspaper we subscribe to. In one of them, a picture of a young woman. A pretty, sweet face.

Susan, this picture of Miss Laura Stewart.

David's Laura. Let me see. Read the caption.

Miss Laura Stewart. Married today. To Dr. David Clark.

Tim. What you wanted has come to be. At long, long last. Now that it's happened. Really happened. How do I feel? I don't know. Glad for David, of course. But how do I feel for me? And, Tim, I'll tell you something I've never confessed before. To this day, I don't know if what I did, I'm still doing, is wrong or right.

Dear, you always said it was right. Always.

I had to say that. But I do know lies are wrong. I know laws are meant to be obeyed. My entire life is a lie. And because of me, David has two wives. Breaking a law of God and man. As long as I live, I'll ask myself if what I've done is good or evil. And I'll ask myself, is it right? I will never know the answer. Never.

On sleepless, haunted nights, Susan seems to hear a voice whisper. It was wrong. An act of betrayal. Go back. What's done can be undone. She closes her ears. She will not hurt David anymore. What is now is forever.

On better nights, she hears, What you've done is good, is healing. An act of love. David is happy. Be happy, too. And she is.

I will return shortly.

Quaker State. Quaker State's new lifetime engine lubricant. Check out this amazing low-brow.

The death of Susan Clark was a lie. But no one who hears her story can deny that she died a thousand deaths. Now I ask again the question we began with. Can good come of evil? In the case of Susan Clark, I personally answer an unqualified yes. What do you answer? How finds the jury?

Our cast included Roberta Maxwell, Terry Keene, Gordon Gould, and Robert Dryden. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.

A preview of this tale. You must understand I do not willingly cause you pain. You forced it upon me. Yesterday you gave us to understand. And no one in Doremi or anywhere else conspires with you. And now perhaps today you remember it differently. I have nothing to add. We have sworn evidence that you are a courier for the French underground. Courier? What is that? Do you deny that you have carried messages from Doremi to Paris, the contents of which are to sabotage the German offensive? Whatever I have done has been at the bidding of the holy voices. Ah, sir. Young woman, this is the 20th century. There are no voices other than humans. You have withstood some pain by refusing to tell us who is in this plot with you. However... There are voices. I tell you, there are.

This is E.G. Marshall, inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.

Thursday night, CBS Radio Mystery Theater, 806 on 1160 AM. 1160 AM.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑