The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 35 min to read
Come in. Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. New York is a city of subways, old, new, in construction and projected, and of the masses of people who ride them daily, commuting to and from work. This is the story of an old and battle-scarred subway user and a new spur line, opened at last and, as usual, too late to achieve its objective: relieve congestion. But it did bring Alvin Freiberg a strange and wonderful freedom from the grinding daily tragedy of a life not worth living.
What's the matter? You got an itch or something?
We're getting near 35th and Neely.
I'm not passing it again.
This subway doesn't stop at that station.
Why? How do I know? There's got to be a reason.
So how come the conductor doesn't know? It's a brand new line. Call the Transit Authority.
I didn't get a chance. I got to know the truth about it just the same.
Here it comes. 35th and Neely. This time I gotta know.
What are you gonna do, stop the train?
I'm gonna get off.
Are you crazy or something, Alvin? Stay away from that emergency—
Our mystery drama, The Phantom Stop, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Ian Martin and stars Norman Rose. It is sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division. I'll be back shortly with Act One.
Al Freiberg and Marvin Schreiber shared the same treadmill. They both worked for Goldman Incorporated. Al is a pattern maker. Marv is a cutter. They both rode the subway morning and night. They both shared the same two-family house in Flushing, owned by Marvin. But of the two, Marv was the lucky one. When he came home, he came back to love and affection. What Al came home to was, uh... well, that was something else again.
Is that you, Schatzie?
Yes, Esther, I'm home.
You're late.
I'm late. That's all you got to say?
What else should I say? I was making hanky-panky with one of the models.
Who'd give you even a look? Models I don't worry about. But you and that mob downstairs could have stopped maybe for a beer. Let me smell your breath.
I wouldn't advise it. I had a garlic pickle with lunch.
A comedian I married. So why are you late?
I said, have a heart. We're behind the fall deadline. We've got to get out the garments.
Don't give me a story that fink Goldman's running you into overtime. He'd have a heart attack if he had to pay a dime over take-home pay.
Give a little, take a little. A few minutes overtime isn't going to make me run to the shop steward.
Give a little, sure. That's the story of your life. When did you take?
A person makes his own choices. I want to sit down. I've been on my feet all day.
It was just the subway was late.
Now the subway don't run on time.
I mean me and Marv, we missed the regular train.
Oh, he was working overtime too, huh?
No, no. He, um... he stopped to buy a present for his wife.
It's a pity you couldn't have the same excuse.
It's her birthday.
You had yours.
Don't talk about birthdays. And don't sit down. I want you to fix Rebecca's hair dryer.
What's the matter with it?
Would I ask you if I knew? It doesn't work.
Couldn't she let her hair dry with God's own air for once?
What, in curlers? She don't mind in the morning. Every time I eat a shredded wheat, I look up at her and think, what am I doing eating one of your sister's?
Sister's curlers. Hey, how come she don't wear her hair straight all the time?
Eh, nothing helps. Tonight is special. She's going to the community center.
She's wasting her time. There isn't a nice boy who isn't already taken.
Essie, is that Alvin at last?
Yeah, he just walked in.
Well, tell him to run down to the store and get me some gloat prunes.
Couldn't she go down and get it herself? All day all she does is sit.
A lumbago is bothering her.
Maybe she's just waking up to what she is. A big pain in the—
Is he going?
I run out of hate that night. I'm only half—
Boiled is more like it.
Is that any way to talk about your own flesh and blood? She's your sister.
Are you going down to the drugstore or not?
Yes. Yes. Gloat prune, right?
Yeah, you might as well get the giant can. Then you can fix the hair dryer.
I should have been a barber. The things I could do with a razor.
Come on, come on. Rebecca's waiting.
When I get home, can we eat?
Oh, just like a man. The only thing on his mind is his stomach.
To tell the truth, limping down to the drugstore, the only thing on my mind was my sister-in-law. Except maybe my wife. And the razor. The things that go through a man's mind, it would frighten you. But you could settle with one simple stroke. All day long at the shop, the boss screams at me. And then at night and weekends, I got my wife and her sister yelling at me. Oh, it's not like it used to be in the old days. With Sarah, my first wife. With Sarah, when I got home, it was altogether different.
Hello, Schatzie.
Hello, sweetheart. Come into the living room and sit down. I got your slippers and the paper and a nice glass of tea with a little you-know-what. Come on, rest up a little before dinner.
Oh, you're such a good wife, Sarah.
Oh, what's so hard? I got a good man. Here, darling, sit. Oh, give me your shirt. Here's your shoes. How's business?
Well, we'll talk later after we eat.
What's for dinner?
A favorite.
Yes. Ah, what's the difference? Anything you cook is my favorite.
I never really realized how much Sarah meant to me until she died and I married Esther. If Sarah had lived, it would have been... well, it would have been just like Marvin and Rachel downstairs. Love, warmth, kids, a real family. I made more money, but he was the one with the life. Oh, Marv was a lucky guy with his Rachel.
Say goodnight to the kids, Marv.
Yeah. They're growing like weeds. Thank God they both look like you.
Oh, go on. Well, sit already and drink your coffee.
Where's yours?
Right over here.
Well, bring it to the sofa and sit with me.
I gotta do the dishes.
Come on. The dishes can wait. I'll help later.
You got anything in mind, Marvin? The kids are not that much asleep. I mean...
Anytime I look at you, I got something in mind. But don't worry. It's not that. It's something else.
What's the matter? You didn't get laid off?
No, no, no. Don't you? No, no. That's just for love.
What did I do to deserve that, huh?
Just for being you. What a lucky guy I am.
All right. I wouldn't deny it. But how come you know it?
The way we are and the way Alvin and Sarah used to be before.
Why do some guys get all the breaks and the rest get a kick in the pants?
I don't know. I don't kick in the pants. It was a terrible thing that happened to Sarah. Bad enough to lose your first child. Or a wife as well. Remember how it used to be with the four of us when we first moved into this house?
Sure. It was a whole family. Two-family house, but one family living in it.
Yeah. You, me, Sarah, Alvin. Dinner every Sunday. One week their turn. Next one ours. Times were good.
Remember the picnics at Jones Beach?
Oh, do I. Sarah's potato salad. Nobody could make potato salad like Sarah.
I remember. I remember. I remember. I remember. Oh, boy. And your pot roast? The best. And what a cut-up that Al used to be. He could have been on the stage. What laughs we had. Especially that last time I remember, with Sarah and me both out here with our kids, and you wanted to take a picture.
Oh, I miss Sarah. You know, I try to get on with Esther. Ah, that loud mouth. She'd burn your ear off with nothing good to say about anybody. And the sister's worse.
Well, she can't help it if she's got a face that'd stop a horse.
Keep a big nose out of everybody's business.
What's the matter, Marvin? There's no heat in the house. You want us all to get pneumonia?
She's always sick with something. If it wasn't for Al, I'd find some way to kick him out and get new tenants.
Oh, you couldn't do that to Al.
No, no. He's the one who ought to get rid of them. God forgive me for saying it.
Well, why shouldn't he? I mean, they deserve it.
Not what I was thinking.
And what sometimes I think lately Al could have on his mind.
What do you mean?
You know. Knocking off either one of those two old crows ought to be justifiable homicide.
Marvin, what are you saying? There never was a kinder or more gentle person than Alvin Freyberg.
But you put a mouse in a bowl with a lid on and let him run around trapped. He ever gets that lid off, out comes a raging tiger.
I don't know. Maybe it's all the violence, but Al worries me these days.
How come?
He daydreams a lot. He gets up in the morning and he's behind on his work. He drives Goldman frantic. And every so often, I'll see him pick up my cutting shears and just, you know, kind of weigh them in his hand like they were, I don't know, like, like, like, like a weapon.
What are you suggesting? He's going to turn into a murderer or something? Al Freyberg? Ah, don't make me laugh.
But it wasn't something to laugh at. If only Rachel could have known. And Marv was right, though I didn't know he'd said it. These last years, like a hamster in a cage, that was me. Running around and around, going nowhere. I wouldn't mind so much, but Esther wouldn't have children. Not even a son to carry my name. There are times lately, like when Abe Goldman is trying to chisel on the patterns, when I, I, I find myself grabbing up Marv's shears and, oh, I, I get such a, a pain in my chest. Everything goes black. By the time I see straight again, I'm, I'm worried what I might have done.
Or like mornings. I shave with a, with a straight razor, which was my father's. And sometimes, like the morning after Rebecca needed her hair dressing.
Uh, yeah?
You plan to spare?
I'm shaving.
How come you're up so early?
The noise you make getting out of bed, who could sleep? Listen, could you spare the powder room a moment?
Well, can't you wait till I'm finished?
It's Rebecca. Ah, what's with Rebecca?
She's sick to her stomach.
Okay, okay, I'll shave in the kitchen.
How come you're up so early?
Well, today, today Marv and I are trying the new subway, which just opened. Just to be on the safe side, we're leaving early.
I bet you come home early one of these evenings.
Ah, what's in it for me?
All right, all right, Esther, don't get mad. Can't I make a joke?
Uh, look, you, you want to have a cup of coffee with me before I leave?
What for? As soon as I get Rebecca straightened out, I need my beauty sleep. Have your coffee at the office.
You used to make it for me when we were first married.
I used to do a lot of things before I discovered what a nothing I married. Go into the kitchen, shave, will you, and let Rebecca use the ladies' room.
The ladies' room. That's what it comes down to now. I'm a stranger in my own house.
I finished shaving, nicking myself twice without a mirror. Then I cleaned the razor and I, I thought about it. How quick it would be. And as long as it was sharp enough, how painless. And then, with a... gasp, I thought to myself, for whom? What am I thinking? Me? Them? All three of us? And then all of a sudden, I, all of a sudden, I, I had the pain in my chest and I, I wondered. Indigestion. Gas? Ah, take a Bromo-Seltzer. Finish shaving and get to work, Alvin.
How do you like it?
What?
The new subway.
Ah, who knows yet. Same sardines packed in a new can.
Ah, here you got more room to breathe.
It's still the same air, if you want to call it that. You know, I thought maybe there'd be less people.
If a guy could have one wish.
What'd you say?
I said, if a guy could have one wish, it would be not to travel Queens to New York and back in the rush hour.
Eh, it's not so bad. Count everything else in.
For you, maybe. What else have I got to look forward to either end?
Al, I've been meaning to talk to you.
No, look, not here. You couldn't hear yourself, but everybody else could.
Hey.
What?
Hey, here's a station we're passing. 35th and Neely Avenue.
Hey, how come the train doesn't stop?
Express, I guess.
I didn't see the station.
Clear as the nose on your face.
I wasn't looking.
What's the difference? What could it matter in your life anyways?
What could it matter in Alvin Freiberg's life? Not a thing. Just another subway station passed by an express train that didn't stop there. 35th and Neely. From the first moment he read the designation, he knew that sometime he had to get off the subway there.
I'll return with Act Two shortly.
It wasn't a good day in Alvin Freiberg's life. The patterns for the new styles were hard to work out. Seventy yards of cloth on a bolt. You have to lay out the patterns so that you waste the least amount of material. If you're a first-rate firm, you don't cut corners. But if you're just an ordinary firm, and times are hard, there's a little temptation to short change.
I can't do it, Mr. Goldman.
Are you telling me? I brought you up in the business. So we'll be a little tight with the seams. We'll still make up.
A little tight? Look here under the arms and on the sides. A woman buys the wrong size so she takes a deep breath and the seams go...
That's her problem. She should buy the right size to begin with. You know women.
Women? That's what always made our line. They could breathe a little buying undersized.
Are you telling me how to merchandise? Look, I make patterns. That's all I know. I made them before you were out of public school. I asked you to cut a few corners and you have to give me an argument.
I want only the best for us, Mr. Goldman.
The same for me, but we got to go with the times.
I don't like to cheat.
Who's cheating? We cut a corner here and there. What are you? A conscience for the world? You think you're better than anyone else?
Ah, maybe he was right. What was I? I sat there piecing the jigsaw patterns on a bolt of cloth and I wondered myself, let some customer lift her arm and split a seam or eat too much and have the zipper split. Why should I care? What did I have left? No pride at home? Why try to have any at work?
Even Marv couldn't shake me while we waited for the subway home.
Why did you knock, Alvin?
Ah, what's the difference, Marv? He wants to cut short. How can I stop him?
He'd never cut short. How can I stop him? It never pays off. And what you lay out, I gotta cut. You know, once you'd have made me mad saying that. But now, what's to fight for? These days we're lucky to have a job.
That's all the business means to you?
Tell you the truth, nothing means much to me.
Well, you've got something to protect.
There's a seat. Grab it.
Come on.
Ah, I'll stand.
You need it more than me. Now sit down, will you?
Ah, okay. Maybe I do. But I, I wanted to ask the conductor or one of the guards about that station.
What station?
The one we don't stop at. The, uh, 35th and Neely.
Ah, who cares?
Me? Why?
I don't know. Just, just something crazy. You wouldn't remember.
What wouldn't I remember?
Well, I could tell you, but what do I want to do? Broadcast a secret at the top of my lungs? Wait till we're home.
Okay, okay. It's hard to hear you anyway. Read your paper.
I sat a little while with my eyes closed. The pain was in my chest again. Right through the back. The racket of the subway seemed very far away. And then I, I glanced at the paper in my lap. Just to skip over the headlines.
General Charles de Gaulle takes over premiership of France.
Ah, so let him. What do I care? De Gaulle. But he's dead. He's long dead.
I look again at the newspaper. The date. June 1st, 1958. I, I started to get Marvin's attention, but just then I realized that we were slowing down, ready to stop. I, I twisted to look out the window. Thirty-fifth and Neely. I, I had to push and shove to get off. I was the only one. I went through the gate. Long flight of steps to the street. But my pain was gone. My legs, they felt twenty years younger. So did all of me. I could feel my heart lift. Reach out, expecting something. And I was right. I came out to the street. And, well, it was, it was... It was just before sunset. Everything was bathed in a rosy glow. A color you couldn't forget. And waiting for me was...
Alvin, the subway's I waited. I thought maybe you'd missed your train.
You know the rush hours, Sarah. But why should you wait for me?
Why does any woman wait for her man? Love. Besides, I was shopping near here at the market, so why not give you a surprise? Here, let me have the bag.
Yes, sir. Hey, this is, this is the old neighborhood. Why so surprised?
Thirty-fifth, all right. But, uh, Neely? That's not near us.
Oh, it's a new subway. So it's a little longer walk than the old stop. What's the difference when a person is young? The way I feel. So, why do we have to stand talking so much? Come on, let's go home.
Yeah, home. Yeah, uh, give me your hand. Let's just walk like we used to. You know, I don't know what's so good tonight. It seems so special, huh?
It is special.
What's for dinner?
I shouldn't tell you. I should just surprise you.
So? Surprise me.
Um, maybe I won't if you sound so indifferent.
Who's indifferent? Oh, well, you'll find out anyway. It's strawberry blintzes with sour cream.
You want to leave me for another woman? I want to take you in my arms right here on 33rd Street.
Oh, you gotta call the cops.
No, darling, just wait till we get home. You want coffee or a glass of tea?
I just want you. Come on, sit by me on the couch.
I'm not sure I could trust you.
There's more than one kind of love, Sarah. This is just old people, quiet, just to touch, to know, to feel that you're there. And I'm next to you. Come on, sit.
Maybe just a little. Because you have to go.
What do you mean? How come I have to go?
Don't ask questions, Alvin. Just take what we got.
But this is my home. I'm not leaving.
You have to leave. Answer me one thing first.
Anything.
You won't let whatever happens change you? You'll stay the way you are?
Why should I change? Supposing I wasn't alive.
Oh, Sarah, then I wouldn't be alive either.
It isn't always that easy to die.
Sarah? Sarah? What are you talking about?
Just promise me, darling, if anything happens, just keep on being my same loving, kind, gentle Alvin.
What crazy talk is this? I'm Alvin Freiberg. I'm 30 years old. If I don't know what I am now, I'm in sad condition.
I'm only thinking of the future.
The devil with the future. We're living now.
That's just the trouble, my darling. We're not. And I beg you, whatever happens, don't let anything change you between now and...
Wake up, Alvin. Stop. Get off the subway.
But I already did. I mean when we stopped at 35th.
Come on, Alvin. You've been sound asleep since we left Manhattan. Let's get it out of the sling and on the way.
What are you talking about, you got off the subway on the way home?
I did. At 35th and Neely.
You got a hole in your head. You were asleep by 57th Street Manhattan and you never woke up till we hit Flushing.
I didn't... I didn't get off and see Sarah.
Sarah? My wife. She... It was a dream. It was a dream.
You were tired. You went to sleep and you had a dream.
Oh, such a dream, Marv. You know, it was so real. Just like it used to be. But... Hey, listen. I didn't get off at that station.
The train doesn't stop there, Al.
It did. In my dream. If it could only be like that.
Uh-huh. Uh, could I say something to you which is none of my business?
What, a friend like you? You could say anything.
I'm worried about you.
Yeah. That makes the two of us. I think you should see a doctor.
What, could a head-shrinker tell me that I don't know already?
I didn't mean a psychiatrist. I meant a doctor-doctor.
Who needs him? I'm healthy.
I could be if I had the chance. I was thinking about, you should excuse the expression, your home life.
Yeah, you should excuse the expression, all right.
Alvin, you ever hear of the French proverb? You ever hear of the French painter called Gauguin?
Yeah, sure. You know what he did? Uh, he went to Tahiti or somewhere and he, well, he painted pictures.
Yeah, but first off, he was a banker and he was unhappy. So he separated from his wife and just took off.
Are you trying to tell me something?
Yeah. Who likes Esther? Do you?
I'm married to her.
You were married to Sarah.
Yeah. I was different.
Sure it was. Everybody loved Sarah. But Esther... Esther? Who likes Esther? You gotta say it out loud.
Not even me. I wish she was dead.
You don't have to go that far. Why don't you just walk out on her?
What would happen to Rebecca?
That's your problem? They're driving you crazy, the two of them. Rachel and me, we only live downstairs and they're driving us around the corner. Why don't we all get her up from under?
You're not gonna renew our lease.
Al, Al, I ain't talking as a landlord, but as a friend. Rachel and me, we can make out. But we want to save you.
From what?
We're almost home now. Take a good look at yourself. Do a little thinking. You got a ding-a-ling hung around your neck. I'm your buddy. What else can I say?
I don't know what to answer you.
I don't blame you. I don't know how I had the guts to say all I said to you. I'll see you at 7:30 in the morning and we'll walk to the subway.
After Marv went in, I waited a moment in the dark. Sarah, or was it a dream? I had a crazy notion that grew more real as the pain in my chest started up again. That I could go back there. All I had to do was stop the train and get off at 35th and Neely. Except, except, I had to fix everything right to leave behind. A man can't just walk out on everything like that fellow Gauguin. He was a genius. I'm just a schlep.
Yeah?
Ben, you in there?
I'm shaving.
Ten o'clock in the night and you're shaving?
I'm coming in.
So come in. The door's open.
Why are you shaving this time of night?
Well, uh, the morning traffic gets so heavy I thought maybe I'd take a load off of it.
I don't understand you, Alvin Freiberg.
Well, say something. What am I to say?
I don't think you ever did.
What?
You asked me to say something, I said it. I didn't ask to be insulted.
Who insulted? You said I didn't understand you.
Well?
You think you do?
Oh, I certainly don't understand a man shaving ten o'clock at night and tying up the only bathroom in the house. I shave in the morning. I'm in the way, too. What should I do? Shave at the garment house?
You don't have to make a thing.
Who is making a thing? You are. I was just trying to make things easy.
Don't give me that, Alvin. You just try to make things a problem because me and Rebecca haven't ever been good enough for you.
Did, did I ever say that?
Well, it's what you think. Sarah, she was so great, your first wife, nobody could live up to her.
You leave Sarah out of this.
Who brought her in? I didn't. Don't try to fool me. Ever since we were married, you compared the two of us.
Esther, that honestly is not true.
Don't try to pull the wool over my eyes. I know what I know. And let me tell you something, Alvin Freiberg, your first wife was a nothing. If you had stayed with her, you'd still be a gopher for Mr. Goldman, running errands, getting coffee, pushing dress racks, a forty-year-old office boy without my connections and my family, so don't you ever forget it.
That isn't true. I was a cutter before you...
Don't make me laugh. With that Sarah soft in the head about how great you'd be, she couldn't see a future in any dress cut...
Alvin, Alvin, don't hold that razor like that. Alvin, what are you thinking about? Don't you ever mention Sarah's name to me again. Don't you ever...
Alvin, are you crazy or something? I was just trying to bring you to your senses. Now don't take offense about it. Don't take offense about Sarah. Sarah's been dead for sixteen years.
Get out. Get out. Get out! You, you leave me alone. You and Rebecca, you leave me alone. I don't know what I'm gonna do. What are you, are you a crazy man or something?
Right at the moment I'm yes, yes.
Well, so what made you like me?
You, you, you, you and your nagging sister, you get out!
For the first time in her life, Esther knuckled under to me. She fled from the bathroom in terror. And as she slammed the door shut behind her, I, I, in terror at myself because I realized that I had advanced on her with the razor in my hand, held like a weapon. I couldn't kid myself that I didn't want to use it against her and her sister. And suddenly, all alone, I, I started to, to shake from head to foot. What had I become? Because I knew that... Because I knew that I, I knew that I was near the end of control.
And if something didn't happen, I would lose my mind, my mind and destroy both of these women as surely as they had been destroying me day by day for the last fifteen years. Two selfish women driving against a quiet and simple man. The day by day deterioration of what had once been a human relationship is as devastating as the Chinese water torture, and as inescapable without violent reaction or some miracle to end it. Which is the deciding factor? I'll be back with that solution shortly when I return with act three.
The dictionary definition of tragedy is the downfall or destruction of some great or noble figure because of some flaw or fatal weakness. But surely the fate of a simple man living a life of quiet and utter despair, misunderstood, unappreciated and starved for a kind of love he had once known is just as tragic. And when he finds himself with his back to the wall, how desperate might he become? Let's watch Alvin Fryberg, who might be you or I, or any of us who sees no hope of escape. Let's watch him face his problem and find its solution.
The next day I woke up early. Even earlier than usual. With a gut feeling that I'd reached the end of my rope. Just like any other morning. Esther snoring like a walrus beside me. Same heavy feeling in my chest. Why should it surprise me? My heart was dead already fifteen years. I turned off the alarm clock, checked the time automatically, and went into the bathroom. Half an hour early. I reached for my razor. All of a sudden, I'm thinking, what kind of a fool are you? You shaved already last night. Then I said to myself, Alvin, you know that. So what are you doing with a razor in your hand? I knew I didn't have to ask that question. I was desperate. Who was I kidding? I couldn't face another day the way I lived. Even without hearing the master's snores sounding in my ears, I could hear Rebecca's whine. What would she have today? An ulcer? Arthritis? Indigestion? Something which wouldn't have a name? Anything to drive her to a doctor so he could reassure her, or try to. The razor. The razor would end all this. I was like a man walking in his sleep. With a razor in my hand, I walked into the bedroom.
"Alvin, it's six o'clock. What are you doing up?"
"I couldn't sleep."
"What's the razor for? You got five o'clock shadow in the morning? You know, that's the first joke you ever made."
"Who cares about jokes this hour?"
"What's the razor for?"
"I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I forgot. I shaved last night, I guess."
"Put it away and come back to bed, huh?"
"Yeah. Yeah. Yes. Yes. Yes, Esther. I don't know. I don't know what came over me all of a sudden."
"Just come back to bed and don't wake up the whole house."
"I don't feel sleepy. Maybe I'll make a cup of coffee."
"I don't understand you. But do what you want. As long as you don't wake up Rebecca and me, I couldn't care less."
I don't understand you. It was all there in those two sentences. And the coffee was bitter. No matter how much sugar I dumped in, and so was my life. It's the way a good half of the world, maybe more, live. An hour and a half later, walking to the subway, how different could I feel? Except that Marv was a friend, and with him I could talk a little.
"Hey, nice brisk morning, huh?"
"Well, that's a good word. You should know me by now. I wonder you even bothered to walk to the subway with me. What have you given me, Al Freyberg? Twenty-five years we're friends. Why would I walk out on you, huh?"
"I ain't the same man I once was."
"Look, when was the last time you saw a doctor?"
"I don't know, three, maybe four years."
"You ought to have a checkup."
"What for? Who cares? Anyway, my regular doctor died a couple of years ago."
"A person our age should have a checkup once a year."
"Stay alive? What else? Supposing you get to the point where you don't care, huh?"
"Oh, that pins it. I'm going to make an appointment with my doctor to see you."
"Don't waste the time."
"I'm ready to waste more than that. You'll see him if I have to drag you there. We'll go at lunchtime. Don't give me any arguments. I'll pay, just for my own peace of mind."
"Look, Marv. Marv, you're a good friend, okay? Okay. I'll see your doctor, but, you know, he can't help me. And we got one thing straight. I pay. I pay."
"Come on."
Tomorrow we're at the subway.
"Would you get the ants out of your pants, Al?"
So we changed at Raleigh Plaza to a local.
"What are you going to do when you get to 35th and Neely?"
"I'm going to get off and go upstairs."
"We get off, we could be late for work."
"You don't have to come."
"Listen, there's something. The way you're acting, as a friend, I wouldn't leave you for a minute."
"I ain't got enough moxie to argue. Anyway, here it comes."
"How do you know? I can't see."
"I know. There. There, you see? We're coming into the station."
"Yeah, okay, but we're not slowing down."
"What? We've got to slow down. This is a local."
"Some train has got to stop here."
"Maybe there's some other local, but this one isn't going to stop."
"Marv, there is a station there, isn't there?"
"Sure, sure. It says, it says 35th and Neely, don't it?"
"Yeah, that's what it says. Or said. Or said. We're already past it. For some reason, trains just don't stop there."
"But I told you last night."
"That was a dream, Alvin. I was standing right over you, and we'd pass right through as usual. You didn't get off, nobody got off. Whatever this station is, there just isn't a train that stops here."
I didn't feel well that morning. My mind wasn't working properly, or I might have thought of calling the transit authority. But everything I did was automatic. I laid out my patterns, and then at lunch, I went to the doctor with Marv. I went to the doctor with Marvin leading me by the hand like I was a baby. It was nearly quitting time before I got back from the doctor, and Goldman was fit to be tied.
"So, what are you going to claim now, Alvin? Seniority? You take almost the whole afternoon off without a word?"
"Well, I was to the doctor."
"Doctor! You couldn't see him on your own time? Maybe it was your head that needed examining. Look what you did here, and your friend Marv already cut. So, what can we do? I'm in the factor's hands already."
"But what is it? Mr. Goldman expected three more dresses out of these bolts of cloth. Didn't I tell you to skimp on the patterns?"
"Oh, I forgot."
"You forgot? How could you forget with that? Look, I'm sorry. I went to the doctor, and I... I don't need a doctor. You'll give me heart failure. The poor line is a disaster before we even cut one dress. I might as well end up in bankruptcy. Freiburg, I don't want to see you again. You're lucky I don't fire your friend Freiburg."
"Mr. Goldman..."
"Don't give me any arguments. All right. It's quitting time. I'm in enough trouble with the union to begin with, so let's close up. Maybe tomorrow, maybe next week, we won't open again. That's the way things are here."
Marv. Marv, I'm sorry.
"Forget it. Forget it. Let's have a fling. Heaven knows we need a lift. Come on. I'll buy you a drink at Levin's before we take the subway home."
"L'chaim. L'chaim. L'chaim. I don't know what I'm wishing you good luck for, the way it goes."
"That don't matter. I'll get the severance pay, some pension. And the beauty part, the insurance."
"What insurance?"
"The life insurance. That should take care of Esther and Rebecca."
"What are you talking about, life insurance? You made me see the doctor, huh?"
"So? What did he say?"
"Well, I got a, uh, a something I ain't sure I know how to tell you. Ventricular fibrillation."
"Uh-huh. The doctor wanted I should go in the hospital right away."
"So why didn't you?"
"Well, I ate up all the money in hospital bills. I'll go home. I'll rest."
"I haven't got a job anymore."
"Rest? With Esther and Rebecca? I'll give it a try. Thanks for the drink. You wouldn't believe, Marv, and a glass of whiskey could make me feel so good. Come on. Let's go home."
Over Marv's protests, we got into the subway. I did feel good. Like I was young again. Like I didn't care. And I had this crazy idea I was gonna try. Because the possibility to find out would never come around again.
"I'm not gonna pass it ever again."
"The subway don't stop at this station."
"Why not?"
"What do I know why not? There's gotta be a reason."
"So how come the conductor doesn't know?"
"It's a brand-new subway, Al. Call the transit system."
"I never had the chance. Just the same. Here it comes. Thirty-fifth and Neely. This time, I gotta know."
"Alvin, wait."
"I gotta know! Gotta find out!"
"Why don't the doors open?"
"You can't open these."
"I'll get out between the cars."
"No, wait, wait. Wait, Alvin, wait!"
"Just a minute, mister. What's going on here? You pull the emergency brake."
"No, no. It was my friend. He wanted to get off here."
"Why?"
"I... I don't exactly know. Why doesn't the train stop anyway?"
"Well, there's nothing up there but mud."
"I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I know. Yeah, there's nothing up there but mudflats and an old city dump."
"Then what's the point of this station?"
"The city is filling in the dump. There's a big housing project gonna go up there. Won't be finished for a couple of years, but they'll need the stop then. Come on. We got to pick up your kooky friend. He can't get out of here. It's all blocked up."
"You gonna arrest him?"
"Sure. He could have caused a panic or got a lot of people hurt. What's the matter with him anyway?"
"I think I could explain to you, officer, except it's his heart."
"Hello, Alvin."
"Sarah, you were waiting again."
"Well, this time I knew what subway you'd be on."
"Oh, my darling, let's go home."
"That's all I want."
"That's what you got. This time for good. See, I told you there was no way out."
"Oh, what's he lying there for? He get fits or something?"
"No, no. He just hasn't been well lately."
"What? You ain't just whistling Dixie. I'm sorry to tell you, mister, but your friend is dead."
"Heart attack, huh?"
"Yeah, something like that. I wonder."
"What do you mean?"
"Just, I hope he found what he wanted. And for the record, guard, there's no doubt it was his heart. Tragedy or something nearer to all of our lives? Escape. Death, of course, is always tragic. But if you have belief in something beyond, Alvin Freiberg, slippers on his feet, Sarah by his side, and something too delectable to name cooking in the kitchen for dinner, is a happier man dead than alive? I'll be back shortly.
It was Elizabeth Barrett Browning who wrote, I love you with the breath, smiles, tears of all my life. Alvin Freiberg could never have expressed himself so well, but beyond question, he felt as deeply for his Sarah as Elizabeth Barrett felt for Robert Browning. The quiet, unnoticed ones love as deeply and perhaps more securely than they do in the great or famous. Let this be Alvin's epitaph and the end of his story.
Our cast included Norman Rose, Nat Polen, Carol Teitel, and Bryna Raeburn. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.
And now, a preview of our next tale.
"But John, this is the only time we can call Winn-Dandingo at midnight. It's the only time he's able to hear the voice of mortal man. And the clock just struck. Listen."
"He, he's here. That's his voice."
"Jabe, that's just an echo way off."
"Listen. Will you go back to sleep? Who's that?"
"Sounds like Enoch Frazier. Enoch must be having a nightmare."
"Boy, Enoch does drink an awful lot."
"It's Winn-Dandingo, all right. And justice is being done."
"I didn't think Enoch's crimes were that serious."
"He's dead."
Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Anheuser-Busch, Incorporated, brewers of Budweiser. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre.
Until next time, pleasant dreams.
