Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

The Secret Chamber

Episode 547November 5, 197641 min 21 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 17 min to read

A philosopher so recently stated, nice guys finish last. True, perhaps, but there are also some last guys who finish nice, should we say. Our mystery drama, The Secret Chamber, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dann, stars Ian Martin. It's sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and True Value Hardware Stores. I'll be back shortly.

Flatly refused to recognize the existence of ghosts. As Mark Twain once said, those are the people who never saw one or heard one. There is something about the sight of a ghost, the sound of a ghost, an art night in a deserted house that will dissolve the doubts. Fervent converts of the most cynical, isn't it? Well, why don't we discuss this matter with a man who's more or less enough? Oh, just playing Tommy suits me fine. Been a real estate agent all my life. Nowadays we have a fancy. You say you're in the market for a fine old colonial, huh? Dating back to the revolutionary period, where the real beauty is the Hargraves house. Oh, you know about that one. You hear it's haunted. Now, would I sell you a haunted house? It used to be haunted, but no more. Extra charge, and you can decide for yourself, huh? Is that fair enough?

I didn't get to go on myself. I was just a shade too young. Too young for a beautiful girl. Lieutenant Bobby in France with the Rainbow Division. Well, one morning... Felicity's mother asked me to draw...

Thomas, you have to help me. Thomas Hargraves. Bobby. Bobby Lightfoot is dead.

Bobby Lightfoot?

Yes, Felicity was notified. Bobby fell at a place called Chateau-Thierry. I feel so bad for Felicity.

Yes, Felicity. You see, when Felicity found out she was standing right here in this room, she didn't say one word. Not a solitary tear ran down her cheek. It was silent for at least five... four minutes. And then she turned around and went upstairs to her room. And... and she said nothing at all?

That was three days ago. Still won't say one word. She won't touch a bite of food. A single swallow of water. What do you suppose I could do? Oh, I'm at my wit's end. Only her father, the judge, was alive. And her uncle Dumont's off in the Navy.

Oh, Miss Hargraves, what could I say to you? She was always fond of you, Thomas.

Oh, yes, ma'am, but...

She cannot keep sitting. She cannot keep sitting in that room forever. What am I going to do?

Oh, ma'am, I sure wish I knew.

Oh, if you'd been a little older, perhaps she might have fallen in love with you instead of Bobby Lightfoot. Why, you've got to help her.

Oh, I'm willing to help, ma'am, but...

That might be enough. Talk to her.

Felicity? Tommy... Tommy Tattersall?

Felicity?

Yes, I know. Bobby. Bobby Lightfoot? I don't know anyone named Bobby.

No, Tommy.

Well, but you've been cooped up in your room so long, you'll be...

I want to stay here. It's such a lovely room, isn't it?

Well, yes, but...

The house is such a magnificent house. I was born here. Did you know that?

Uh, well, yeah, I...

There was my dad and his dad before him. I never want to leave this house.

Well, Felicity, why not?

Because... He can wait everywhere. Death... Don't leave. Death is waiting there outside. But he didn't listen. My Bobby didn't listen. But I won't leave this house. I won't go out there.

Out where? Oh, now, look, Felicity, I...

Could I tell you something? I'm safe here. These rooms, these walls, these floors and ceilings, they all know me. They all love me. But look through the windows. Look out on the street and see how bright and how clear and how lovely everything is. This house, it shelters and protects me. I'll never leave.

Just look at the street. You see my dad's office? You see?

I don't want to look out on the street.

Look, stop. I'm afraid.

I go to work there. Why don't you come by early in the day and just, you know, say hello to me?

I... No, I...

You can trust me, Felicity. I wouldn't let him... Something bad happen to you? Just say hello to me at the office tomorrow. Take a... Take a walk over.

It'll have to be a very short walk. I'm so afraid to be outside. There's so much death.

You should come by, say hello.

I'm the only one she ever talked to. What did we talk about?

Good morning, Tommy.

Morning, Felicity. How do you feel this morning?

I... I don't feel well. I did a terrible thing.

Oh, not you, Felicity.

Yes, I... I did. I... I saw him. You... You... I... I should have waited till he'd come. He had gone by, and I did stop. But then so did he, and I thought he was just going to stay there, and it would be safe for me to... And then I... I... Just as I stepped forward, so did he, and... And... And my... My foot... It was too late.

I'm sorry, Felicity. I'm... I'm... I'm really, truly sorry.

That is a living thing. It's one of God's creatures. It wasn't your fault. One of God's plans. Felicity, it won't be held against you.

Not, Tommy?

Of course, honey.

You're not just saying it to make me feel better.

Would I lie to you?

And I... I'll be forgiven someday?

Been forgiven already?

Liveliest young lady in the county. And she got no better. I guess you could say she got even worse. Years went by, and I got a call from the shark. She'd been such a sturdy, well-built Felicity's mother. All of a sudden, it was as if she'd shrunk to almost nothing.

Tommy?

Oh, Mrs. Hart?

Yes. Oh, you don't know what you make of me. Can't understand it myself. It happened almost overnight.

What's wrong?

I... I... I'm dying. And Felicity's going to need a friend more than ever.

Well, she's always got a friend in me.

Uncle Dumont will take care of the financial affair.

Yes. The judge has him named executor of the...

I know he'll pay her bills. The fact she always has this house won't have time for her.

The judge? The judge? The judge? The judge? The judge? The judge? The judge? The judge?

Felicity will need someone more than me.

The fine lady was dead. She took active charge of the family money. Dumont was running through all the assets. He was making unwise investments that he was gambling. And, of course, Mont came into the house. How a snake looks at a bird.

You don't like me, Tommy.

Tommy, it's not my fault.

Felicity.

Well, what about Felicity?

Well, where will she live?

Well, he simply is not right. Would you say that?

You suggest another one of the...

Look, Dumont. It's all she has in the world. It's all...

What do you mean? I'm set to continue as executor.

Sure. But he does. Ashes and ruins and...

You want to be Dumont?

You, Tommy, you... Oh, no. This is all you're doing. You're going to tell her. She just demands it. But if you tell her, well, she'll believe you.

Why do they do it? What makes the Tommy Tattersalls of this world tick? Since there's a little bit of Tommy in so many of us, even in you, why not ponder the problem for a few moments until I return shortly?

What I said once is not necessarily a... What can hardly be in dispute is the fact that, of some kind, anyhow, it has to have form and structure. It must protect and shelter. It must be fortress and sanctuary.

Felicity Hargraves is about to be evicted.

I can't leave here, Tommy. I can't.

I know it's difficult, Felicity.

Oh, it's much more than difficult, Tom. It's...

Felicity, just...

I'll die.

No.

Oh, yes. There's death outside. You know that. I'm not safe anywhere else, Tommy.

You'll be safe with me, Felicity. I spoke it over with my mother. You'll stay at our house for a while.

No. I want to stay at my house.

Mother's alone all day, and you'll... You'll be such good company for each other. You always liked my mother, didn't you?

Yes, Tommy, very much.

I have a wonderful idea. Let her come and stay with me at my house.

But, Felicity, she...

Won't you try to understand?

Understand what? Your house. How can it not be my house? It's got to be sold. It's a part of me. According to the law. Every part of this house is a part of me, Tommy. It knows me. It sheltered me. It kept me warm. It kept me dry. It kept me safe.

No. No, Tommy. No. I'm only trying to...

Could I sell part of myself? Could I sell my heart? Could I, Tommy?

Yes, I could.

But how are you? Felicity, I only want to help you. Now, you know that. You believe me. Soon the war in France will be over, and Bobby will be back. And if I'm not here, he won't know where to look for me.

Well, I'll keep an eye out for Bobby, and if he comes along, I'll...

No, don't say if. When?

Well, when he comes, I'll bring him to you. Come with me.

Let me just stay here one more night. Let me stay here tonight. And say goodbye to the house. And then in the morning, I'll go away with you. Please. Goodbye, please.

I came by for her in the morning.

It's Tommy Tattersall.

It's Felicity Hargrave. She's gone. That's what I mean. She's disappeared. The house from top to bottom is out of sign. Where could she go? Is it some old foul play? Or maybe she might have just wandered off into the woods and beyond them, down into the swamp. If she'd gone and done that, then she'd be lost forever.

Felicity had been trying to tell me that if she had to leave that house, that's what all the talk about death had been on it, too. Stay that final night. Why had I left her alone?

Imagine the disappearance of Felicity Hargrave. It was a sensation. But like all such sensations, it only lasted a while. We had the elections and the circus come to town. And one thing and another. And gradually, it was forgotten by almost everyone.

How could you hear it? There were three of us this night. We heard it. I still say it's impossible. Conscience, you robbed a troubled woman. It comes to the same thing. One thing she couldn't live with. Out this house. Go ahead and suffer as you deserve it.

Felicity Hargrave.

Felicity's dead. Tommy. It's not your imagination.

My face. Is it my imagination? If she'd come home, I believed it. She always liked you, Tommy. That's a fact. Now, now, now, explain to her.

Aren't you crazy? Please, Tommy, I have to sell this house. I am.

Felicity, you shouldn't be here. You only scared Felicity. Forget it, too much. It's Felicity's house. It's Felicity's house. It's her house. Dead or alive. It is. She wants to live in it. I say more power to her.

With a sharp and boomy face and long jibber in my office. And down my spine.

Countess DeGeneres. How do you do, ma'am? Charmed.

The, uh, vanishes the evil spirit. Look, the joke is this, Dumont. And this lady is a great artist.

What is she here for?

I am to exorcise the evil spirit from the house of Hargrave.

And there's no evil spirit in the house of Hargrave.

There is a spirit.

Well, that's Dumont. You just get taken in by this mumbo-jumbo.

Tommy Asprin. Mumbo-jumbo. Mumbo-jumbo. Now, now, I've irritated her.

You do not believe in spirit.

She must return to the grave. She will never know peace.

That's right, Tommy. Good.

Well, what do you want with me?

Somebody has got to go into the house with Countess DeGeneres.

All right, that's you, Dumont.

Climate of violence. How do you wish to walk into that house?

That's a secondary. You have to go into the house with a witness. A witness is required by astral law.

I just have a witness. I respectfully decline the honor.

Tommy, you've got to do it. Everyone else in town turned me down.

Now, do it, Felicity. So that his letter spirit find peace. She can't keep wandering around that house forever. Do you want to be guilty of depriving Felicity of her rest?

This is business.

Business? He dares to call it business.

It is a sacred profession.

It's a fake.

Is it? And do you know everything, young man? Can you swear that Felicity's ghost isn't in the house? What have you got to lose?

He has a great deal to lose. His arrogance. His intolerance. His ignorance.

All right. As you have already seen, he does get to run a great many errands.

Coming up looks like an authentic first. Join us for dinner this evening, Tommy?

No, thanks. I have work to do.

What kind of work?

Exorcising a ghost. How's that for a conversation piece?

Yes. Our exercise in exorcism is scheduled for act two, which is only a few moments away. Exorcising spirits is a practice that's as old as mankind.

In practically all recorded cases, spirits were evil and therefore deserved to be driven out. We have a slightly different problem here. We have a spirit that's kind and gentle, the ghost of a beautiful lady. But evidently that won't help her. She's a ghost. She must go.

All right, Madame Desjardins. When do we go to the house and start your little con game?

Mr. Hargraves, I simply cannot tolerate the attacks of this, this, this boorish, ignoble mountebank.

Now, Tommy, in the first place, she's a countess. In the second, it's an ancient and honorable profession.

Yes, but since I'm to be a partner in this deal, all I want to know is when it starts.

When the moon has risen and Venus has approached perihelion.

All right. Just give me the time.

At the stroke of midnight. You and I shall stand in the geocentric ordained perimeter of the presence. And the ritual shall begin.

It was easy enough to laugh at this dame. But the more she got herself involved in what she was doing, the more she started to, well, to kind of scare you. Her eyes began to send out sparks. You could feel fire in her voice. And before you knew it, you kind of began to believe it wasn't an act. But that there was something doing. Mysterious hands against her head as if her mind was in... trying to burn her bones.

Felicity Hargrave is the soul of the high priest of the temple. You pronounce me ineffable. Forbidden tetra—

A rickety old rocking chair on the porch. Set her down on it. I waited for her to come to.

I'll be used to the—

You're outflanked. Outflanked. You were right about me, pal. Back there in the office when you called it a con game. That's all it was. A racket. Figure. I'm saying, pal, that you just heard the real McCoy. Nico, you heard a ghost. You know there's no such thing as a ghost. The house here. Is ditching. All right. Can that countess label, pal? The handle's Molly McGuire from Union City, New Jersey. Racket. Now it's a gimmick. A hook to cast the rubes with. But you know something? I see now the rubes were right. Maybe the rubes were always right. Because there are ghosts.

Ghosts became more haunted than ever. It's to recoup. Unless they believe in ghosts. Do you want to know what folks hear in that house? They hear a loose ball. Gap in the mortar of a chimney. A missing tile. Every house. It has creaks and moans and strains. And a fellow's imagination takes it from there. Top to bottom. Nathaniel Hargraves. He sure knew how to build. Solid oak walls of thick and heavy plaster. After all these years, everything was still sound and true. Blow through. I made sure the shutters hung firm and steady. I bought where the doors and titers sounded. Before a ship-shaped house simply didn't exist. And clean. And even put in a telephone. Against the possibility of believing it was haunted. And it proved there's no such thing as—

Felicity. It's me. It's Tommy. Tommy Tattersall. Talk to me. Felicity, don't you remember? Tommy.

Felicity.

Searched every room, every closet. I pulled nook and cranny. Cellar to attic. I decided to try something else. Actually, I said, Felicity, it's me. Felicity, it's your own true love, Bobby Lightfoot. Back from the war.

You think you're alive? I'm back.

How did you? I had to stay. Bobby, you'd never find me if I'd left.

Yes, but where did you... Don't you remember the room? We found it when we were children. Where they used to hide the runaway slaves. Remember?

But everyone says it's a haunted house.

Haunted? Oh, you know how sounds go in this place. Crying. I was calling to you, Bobby.

How did you live? I mean... How funny how I don't need food even if I'm dead. Looks around here, no one ever locks a door. All I ever needed was... A crust of bread, a swallow of milk. No one ever missed it.

Felicity, now, come on, let me take you...

He mustn't. Never. Always wants to take the house away from me. Don't let them come. Don't let anyone take this house away from me. Never.

Come and you'll visit me every day. Stay here until we're married. And I'll plan for a big wedding.

Oh, yes. It will be a big wedding. The biggest this town ever saw.

Yes, Felicity.

Don't let anyone ever take this house away from me.

$350,000. Attention to my house. I'm not being haunted, right? Be haunted. Oh, nonsense. There's no such thing as a haunted house. Bring your buyer here. I guarantee he'll hear enough to run screaming out of the premises.

No. I'm afraid you're going to have to.

Felicity Hargraves. Hidden. Instructed the most attractive colonial period home in the entire USA. Each and every beam. Even show you the secret chamber. Forgive the expression. There are many ways to skin a cat. Just as many ways to sell a house. People who peddle large tickets are known for their enthusiasm. And up to date, they should be. They are also incurably romantic. And in many cases, stories so convincingly, they actually believe it themselves. I'll be back shortly.

You have just heard What is a Ghost Story. Indeed, what is a ghost? As we are all ghosts, we have inherited parted ancestors, dead ideas, and beliefs. Our cast included Ian Martin, Marian Seldes, Joan Shea, and Leon Janney. Our production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by CertainTeed. CertainTeed fiberglass attic insulation. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑