The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 22 min to read
<!-- kimi_cleaned -->
Death to carrots.
Death to carrots.
I have been thinking, Comrade General.
Yes, Comrade Secretary?
Those spacemen may be bourgeois, but they are also meat.
Meat?
Yes. And if they are meat, they must have meat-eating habits.
What are you getting at?
Why not send a spy into Carrotopolis? A meat-eating spy. Something they would never suspect. Something so ferocious, so terrifying, that the carrots would be paralyzed with fear.
A meat-eating spy? But what?
A rabbit.
A rabbit?
Exactly. A rabbit in the role of a Trojan rabbit. I have one all trained. He speaks their language perfectly. He will pretend to be a defector from our side. And once inside, he will eat the Secretary of the Interior and his family, and bring the spacemen back to us.
But Comrade Secretary, rabbits eat carrots.
Exactly.
But if he eats the Secretary and his family, he might also eat the spacemen.
A calculated risk.
But rabbits are not ferocious. They are not terrifying.
This one is. He has been conditioned. He has been watching television.
I see.
He will go tonight.
Our scene shifts back to Carrotopolis, where the two Earthmen are confined in a damp cell beneath the palace of the Secretary of the Interior. Commander Potter sits on a stone bench, his head in his hands. Caudill paces back and forth.
I don't understand it. I simply don't understand it. Concentrated carrot juice. Emergency rations. And they arrest us for it.
Well, you heard the man. He thought we were onions in disguise.
But that's ridiculous. I'm not an onion. You're not an onion.
Maybe it's the way we're dressed.
Nonsense. A Navy uniform doesn't look like an onion.
Well, maybe to a carrot it does.
Oh, this is absurd. Here we are, the first men on Venus, thrown in jail for being onions.
Well, at least we're not in the soup.
What?
That's what the Secretary said. If the onions got us first, we'd be in the soup.
Oh, that's very funny.
Thank you.
I was being sarcastic.
Oh.
Look, we've got to get out of here. We've got to get back to the ship and get off this crazy planet.
And go where?
Anywhere. Mars. Jupiter. Back to Earth. Anywhere but here.
But we can't just leave. We're on a mission. We're supposed to make contact, establish friendly relations.
Friendly relations? With vegetables?
They're not vegetables. They're carrots.
Same thing.
No, it isn't. A carrot is a specific type of vegetable. Like a... like a leek is a specific type of vegetable.
Oh, you're impossible.
And you're panicking.
I'm not panicking. I'm... I'm strategizing.
Well, strategize quietly. I'm trying to think.
Of what?
Of how to get us out of here.
Any ideas?
Not yet.
Then don't think so loudly.
Suddenly, there is a scratching at the door. A small panel opens, and a pair of long ears appear, followed by a twitching nose.
Psst. Psst. Are you the spacemen?
Who's there?
It's me. Me. The rabbit. I've come to rescue you.
A rabbit?
Yes. A rabbit. But don't be afraid. I'm on your side.
Our side?
Yes. I'm a defector. I couldn't stand the onions anymore. Their propaganda, their slogans, their... their smell. So I've come to help you escape.
Why?
Because I believe in freedom. Because I believe in... in carrots.
You do?
Of course. Carrots are my favorite food.
Wait a minute. Rabbits eat carrots.
Exactly. That's why they trust me. That's why they'll never suspect.
Suspect what?
That I'm here to eat them.
You what?
Eat them. The Secretary, his wife, his daughter. All of them. And then I'll help you escape.
But... but that's murder.
No, it's lunch. And then we can all go back to Onionopolis together.
We don't want to go to Onionopolis.
But you must. The Secretary is waiting. He wants to meet you. He wants to learn about bicycles.
We don't know anything about bicycles.
Then you can learn together. But first, I eat.
Look, rabbit, I don't think you understand. We're not going to let you eat anyone.
Why not?
Because it's wrong.
Wrong? But I'm hungry.
That's not our problem.
But it is. You see, I've been conditioned. If I don't eat carrots, I get very nervous. And when I get nervous, I eat other things. Meat things.
Are you threatening us?
Not at all. I'm explaining. I'm a reasonable rabbit. Let's make a deal. I eat the carrots, you come with me to Onionopolis, and nobody gets hurt.
Except the carrots.
They're vegetables. They don't feel pain.
How do you know?
They never complain.
Maybe they can't.
Semantics again. Look, do we have a deal or not?
No. Absolutely not.
Then I'm afraid I'll have to eat you.
You wouldn't dare.
Try me.
The rabbit advances, his teeth bared. Potter grabs the stone bench, ready to defend himself. Caudill backs against the wall.
Now, now, let's not be hasty. Maybe we can work something out.
Too late. I'm hungry now.
Suddenly, the door bursts open. Fido rushes in, his wings spread, his beak snapping.
Back, you fiend! Back! Leave my master's guests alone!
Fido!
Yes, it's me. I heard the commotion. I knew something was wrong. No rabbit can be trusted, I always say.
But he said he was a defector.
They all say that. It's in the manual.
The rabbit lunges at Fido, but the griffin is too quick. He seizes the rabbit by the ears and flings him against the wall.
Oof!
And stay down!
Thank you, Fido. You saved our lives.
Think nothing of it. Now, come quickly. My master has had a change of heart. He realizes he was hasty. He wants to apologize and get you on the air as promised.
Really?
Yes. But we must hurry. The broadcast is in less than an hour, and the onions may try to stop us.
Stop us? How?
They have agents everywhere. Even here, in Carrotopolis. You can never trust an onion. Or a rabbit, for that matter.
They follow Fido through winding corridors, up stone stairs, and into a large room filled with strange equipment. Edwin and Edwina stand waiting, Alice nearby, humming a tune.
Gentlemen, please accept my apologies. I was hasty. I was... emotional.
That's quite all right, Your Excellency.
Please, call me Edwin. We are all friends here. And friends help friends, do they not?
They do indeed.
Then you will help us? You will find out about the nematodes?
We'll certainly try. If we can get through to Earth, I know the CBS research department can find out anything.
Splendid. The equipment is ready. Fido, show them the microphone.
Right here, sir. Just speak into the carrot.
The carrot?
Yes. It's our latest model. Carrot-sensitive. Picks up vibrations from the root system.
Well, if you say so.
Caudill clears his throat and speaks into the carrot.
CBS on Earth, this is Caudill on Venus. CBS on Earth, this is Caudill on Venus. Come in, please.
Static. Then, faintly, a voice.
Venus, this is CBS on Earth. We read you faintly. Repeat, we read you faintly.
CBS, this is Caudill. I have a research request. Urgent. About nematodes. Citrus nematodes. California, 1940s. Fumigation methods. Can you help?
Stand by, Venus.
They wait. The silence stretches. Then:
Venus, we have your information. According to our files, nematodes in California citrus were controlled by DBCP, a soil fumigant. Also known as Nemagon. Effective but... but controversial. Repeat, controversial. Use with caution.
Did you get that, Edwin?
Yes, yes. DBCP. Nemagon. But what does it mean? How does it work?
It kills the nematodes. In the soil. Before they can attack the roots.
But would it not also kill the carrots?
Well, yes. I mean, no. Not if used carefully. In controlled amounts.
Controlled amounts. Yes, I see. But the onions would never agree. They would say we were trying to poison them.
Could you not use it only on your side of the border?
And have the onions accuse us of building up our defenses? Of preparing for war? No, no. It must be universal or not at all.
Then what will you do?
I don't know. I simply don't know.
Suddenly, alarms sound. Red lights flash.
What is it?
The onions! They're attacking!
But how?
Through the tunnels! The old root tunnels! We thought they were sealed, but—
The door bursts open. A squad of leeks rushes in, their green tops waving like bayonets.
Death to carrots!
Death to carrots!
Stand back! Stand back, I say!
But the leeks are too many. They seize Edwin, Edwina, Alice. They grab Potter and Caudill.
Take them all to Onionopolis! The Secretary demands it!
Even the spacemen?
Especially the spacemen!
They are dragged through dark tunnels, past strange roots and glowing fungi, until they emerge into a vast underground chamber. Above them, a dome of crystal. Beyond it, the surface of Venus, dark and starlit. Before them, a throne of polished granite. And on it, Odor, the Secretary General, his white layers gleaming.
So. The spacemen. And the carrot leadership. All together. How convenient.
Release us, Odor! This is an outrage!
Silence, carrot. You are in Onionopolis now. Here, we do not listen to carrots. We eat them.
You wouldn't dare.
Wouldn't I? General Shallot, prepare the soup.
No!
Wait! Wait, Odor. You don't want to do this.
And why not, spaceman?
Because... because it's wrong. Because killing doesn't solve anything. Because if you destroy the carrots, you destroy yourselves.
Nonsense. Without carrots, we are supreme. We are the only vegetables. The only life.
And then what? Who will you fight? Who will you blame? What will your slogans mean?
They will mean... they will mean...
Nothing. Without carrots, you have no purpose. No identity. You are just... onions.
Odor hesitates. His layers seem to droop.
But... but we have always hated carrots. It is our tradition. Our culture.
Traditions can change. Cultures can grow.
Grow? Like... like a garden?
Exactly. Like a garden. Different plants, different roots, but all growing together. All needing the same sun, the same rain, same soil.
The same soil.
Yes. The same soil. And the same threat. Nematodes.
Nematodes? What do you know of nematodes?
We know they threaten you all. Carrots and onions alike. And we know how to stop them. But only if you work together.
Work together? With carrots?
With carrots. With leeks. With all the life on this planet. And maybe, with Earth too.
Odor is silent for a long moment. Then:
General Shallot, release the prisoners.
Comrade?
You heard me. Release them. And... and send for the carrot delegation. We will discuss this nematode problem. Together.
Together?
Yes. Together. It seems we have much to learn from these spacemen. And from each other.
Death to carrots?
Not anymore, General. From now on, life to all. Life to all.
Our scene shifts to the surface of Venus, where a great ceremony is taking place. Carrots and onions stand side by side, their differences set aside. A treaty is signed. The Nematode Accord, it is called. And beside it, another agreement: the Earth-Venus Friendship Pact. Caudill stands at a microphone, broadcasting to both worlds.
And so, ladies and gentlemen of Earth, and citizens of Venus, a new day has dawned. A day of cooperation, of understanding, of... of semantics. For we have learned that what matters is not what we call each other, but how we treat each other. Whether we are carrots or onions, meat or vegetable, Earthling or Venusian, we share a common fate, a common garden, a common need for peace.
He pauses. Potter steps forward.
In recognition of this, I am proud to announce that the United States Navy has established the first interplanetary base right here on Venus. And I am honored to serve as its first commander.
Applause from the assembled crowd. Alice pushes forward.
And I am going to be the first interplanetary actress! I'm already working on a play. It's called "Romeo and Juliet, or The Onion and the Carrot."
How does it end?
Happily. They make soup together.
Laughter. Then Fido, his gold collar gleaming, spreads his wings.
And I, Fido, loyal servant of the Secretary of the Interior, now servant of peace, propose a toast. To the pride of carrots! To the gaggle of onions! To the charm of griffins! And to the friendship of worlds!
To friendship!
To friendship!
Caudill turns back to the microphone.
And now, this is J. Alexander Caudill, signing off from the planet Venus. Until tomorrow night, when I will broadcast from the surface of Mars, where I understand the potatoes are very anxious to meet us. This is the CBS Radio Workshop.
This is the CBS Radio Workshop, dedicated to man's imagination, the theater of the mind. Tonight we heard "A Pride of Carrots, or Venus Well Served," by Robert Nathan, who told his own story. This is CBS, the Columbia Broadcasting System.
That is not the point, comrade. If we abduct these spacemen, we give Caritania a splendid opportunity to protest. And you must remember, comrade, protests are weapons, too. The very best weapons. They cost nothing, and properly used, they create an odor. A real onion odor.
Then you are opposed to kidnapping these spacemen.
Definitely.
Very well. I shall think about it.
You could go, General.
Thank you, comrade. Oh, by the way, I have news for you. You have just been promoted to Field Marshal.
Thank you, comrade. Strength to onion. Strength to onion. See you at dinner. Death to carrots.
I'll be there.
Death to carrots, eh? Thirty sharp.
Hello? Secret police? General Shallot has just left my office. Liquidate him.
I'm hungry. I wonder when they feed their prisoners in this lousy jail.
What difference does it make unless you have an appetite for bone meal, ammonium sulfate, and peat moss?
I guess I'm not hungry after all.
You shouldn't have shown him the label on the can, old man. That's what did it.
Well, how could I tell? I thought it'd be chicken consommé. Usually is.
Just when I had the greatest broadcast in history lined up. Now what?
There's a lady to see you.
Miss Alice!
Shh, not so loud.
Thank you, sergeant. You can leave us now. Mind you, Miss Alice, this is contrary to your father's orders and against my better judgment.
Oh, I know, sergeant, but it's utterly divine of you. I shall be just outside. Scream if you need help.
You wouldn't hurt me, would you, Potter?
Glad to have you aboard, ma'am.
They say that you're dangerous vegetarians, that you eat carrots. Do you really?
Well, you see, ma'am—
I don't believe it. You're much too nice to eat poor little me.
Thank you, ma'am. You know, you yourself are a vegetarian, Miss Alice.
I am not. I'm a vegetable. It's not the same thing at all.
Well, now, just answer me this. What will happen to you when you die?
I'll be buried, of course, in the national compost heap.
Ah, from which the rich steaming soil is taken to nourish the young carrots, right?
Of course.
Which then must of necessity feed upon your decayed flesh.
Why, of course. Why, how madly amusing. I really did eat my ancestors, didn't I? Oh, but I missed mother and father.
I should hope so.
But now what? What could be more satisfying to a girl's psyche than to have her father under her belt?
Oh, have you been through analysis?
Of course, haven't you?
Yes. Oh, it's so nice to be able to talk the same language, isn't it? My analyst says the trouble with me is my mother has a blue top.
Exactly. The active competition of an adult parent. It tends to make me aggressive.
Kiss me, Potter.
Huh? What?
Kiss me.
Good Lord, really, I—
Are you afraid, Potter? It isn't even spring. I don't come into blossom till July.
I know, but—
Am I not beautiful? Am I not to be desired by the Navy?
Oh, yes. Yes, indeed, but—
I could have your head, Potter, on a silver tray like Salome.
I know, but—
I could set you free.
Well, for heaven's sake, kiss her and get it over with.
No, but—
Mm, smells so good. Like a grocery store. Oh, it's like April. Is this love, Potter? How can I feel this way about a carrot? I feel a strange heat. Not like the sun. Like a garden in the summer. I don't feel at all like a vegetable. I wouldn't have thought it possible.
Look, how about getting us out of here?
The time is up, folks.
Oh. Oh, yes, I suppose it is. Oh, but don't worry, my darling. I'll be back. I'll be back quickly to set you free. You'll see.
Well, there's the Navy for you. What have you fellas got that I haven't got?
Blossoms in our hair.
Ah. You, uh, really like the girl, don't you?
Yes.
Well, now, of course, it's none of my business, but, uh... What about Mrs. Potter?
What about her?
Well, she isn't going to like this pretty vegetable of yours.
Caudill, could you be jealous of a stalk of celery?
I am not married.
No, of course, that does make a difference.
Oh, I wish we were safe at home. There's something frightening about being in love with a carrot.
You smell anything, Commander?
No.
That's funny. For a moment, I thought I smelled onions.
Well, that's not very likely.
I don't know. My eyes are watering.
Mine, too. You know, I do smell onions.
Gentlemen.
Huh?
Who are you?
You are free, gentlemen.
She did manage it, then.
This way. Hurry, please.
Where is she? I can't see very well. My eyes are full of tears.
She's waiting for you, sir.
Just a minute, Commander. This isn't a carrot. It's an onion.
Take them, comrades.
So, you see, gentlemen, we have no choice. The stakes were too high. Being no less than war... or peace.
What are you talking about?
Simply this, Commander Potter of the U.S. Navy. How do you make war?
How do we do what?
Make war. How do you destroy whole armies, cities, countries, with all their inhabitants, without, at the same time, annihilating yourselves? Unfortunately, there is no blight that will make compost out of carrots without doing the same for onions. I have to think of my people.
Bless you, little father.
Thank you, spindle-skull.
You see, Commander, we are still in the drawing board stage. We need technicians.
Don't look at me.
My dear Commander, you must understand that the end justifies the means. When onions rule the world, who would wish to be a carrot? I offer you an important place in history.
The only place I want to be is next to a girl with a carrot top who smells like a garden. After rain—
Now, now, now, let us not grow emotional. But perhaps you are closer to her than you think. Will you teach us to make war, Commander? You see, I am giving you another chance. Opportunity rarely knocks so often.
I will not.
Very well. Perhaps we will find a way to make you change your mind. There is a little experiment I am planning with a pot of boiling water. How would you like to see your, shall we say, girlfriend? Floating about with only a marrow bone for company. A quite excellent soup. Petite marmite, I believe it is called.
Sure, bluffing.
Am I? We shall see. Spindle.
Yes, little father.
Take these gentlemen to the solarium and entertain them. Show them the vampire marigolds and the lizard-eating oleander. And they might be amused to watch the muertevine digest its daily mouse.
I warn you, Odo, the United States Navy will not take this lying down. Nor will—
This way, animals.
Send in the other prisoner.
Well, well, come in, young lady. Don't be bashful. I won't eat you.
What do you want with me? Why did you bring me here?
I suppose you wouldn't care to tell me the whereabouts of the Carrot Eighth Army. No? Oh, you, so stupid. So impulsive. So desirable. But so uncooperative. So uncooperative. By the way, your friend Commander Potter is here. He, too, has proven uncooperative. We may have to press him a little.
He wouldn't dare.
He is being shown the muertevines at this very moment.
Not the meat-eaters.
Why not? The commander is meat, I believe.
Oh, no, no, not that.
Of course, I could be persuaded to change my mind.
Oh, you have such lovely skin, my dear. So moist and tender.
Please.
You smell good, too, like a salad. Fragrant, but delicate. What freshness, what youth. I adore you.
I loathe you.
You do not realize your situation. One word from me, you are in the soup.
I would a thousand times—
Or what is perhaps more to the point, your friend Mr. Potter is left alone with the vampire marigolds.
Oh, no, no.
Oh, that fetches you. You really care for him, don't you?
More than life.
All the better. It's much more exciting to make love to a woman. And already in love. It adds a kind of seasoning, as it were.
You, you nettle. You noisome weed.
Splendid, splendid. So sweet and so hot, almost like a Spanish onion.
Is this the way you make war on women and children?
War? Who is making war? I'm making love.
You are odious to me.
Very well. We will try Mr. Potter in the muertevines.
Oh, no, no. I can't stand it.
You give up? You give in?
Will he have a safe conduct back to my father?
Yes. Yes.
Will there be one for me?
Later.
Write it out.
But of course. For Mr. Potter, a pass. Also for Mr. Caudill. And now for Miss Alice.
Yes, little father?
Spindle, you will let the spaceman go. And you will see that this lady is returned to her own people.
Later.
It shall be done, little father.
Now, divine creature, at last you are mine.
No. No, stand back.
Silly girl, drop that paper knife and receive the kiss of the little father.
No, no. It is thus a carrot kisses.
Alice!
Oh, Potter, Potter, thank heaven you're safe.
You're crying.
It's nothing, nothing. It's only onion juice. Here are your passes. Go quickly, both of you.
And you?
I must wait for a little while. If I go with you now, they'll be suspicious.
No. If we have to die, then we'll die together.
Oh, no, no, my dear Potter. That wouldn't help my country. Or this little world. Or even me. I've become very sensible, Potter. Very realistic. Don't you see? It doesn't matter about me. But you, you, Potter, you're the hope of the future. Look, I'll try to catch up to you at the frontier. If I don't come, be kind to carrots, Potter. For my sake. Go now. And God bless you.
Come on, Potter. We're on the air in an hour. Hurry, hurry. They're coming back.
I'm staying with you.
No, no, my dearest Potter. Go. Go. The world needs you. The universe needs you.
Come on, Potter.
Farewell, then, my dearest Alice.
Good evening, ladies and gentlemen of Earth and other species throughout the planetary system. This is J. Alexander Caudill bringing you the very first broadcast from Venus through the courtesy of Caledonia Oil, Shirley White Toothpaste, Innes Klein's Nock Beer, and Barnum Dog Food. Oh, excuse me a moment, ladies and gentlemen. There's some confusion. Here in the studio, we've just received a bulletin. What's that? Oh, no. Alice? In the soup?
Let's see. And I'll need a pound of peas. A pound of peas. And a cauliflower. Cauliflower.
You must be very happy to have your husband back again, Mrs. Potter. And all those write-ups in the papers. My goodness. Did he really get to Venus like they said? I missed the broadcast.
Yes, he did. A bottle of ketchup. You know, he looks a little thin in his pictures. I guess maybe they didn't have much to eat up there.
I guess not. What was it like? Did he tell you?
He hasn't said much. Four dozen onions. Four dozen? That's right. He eats them all the time. Raw.
Raw? They say onions are good for colds.
I know. There's lots of things like that. Like carrots make your hair curly.
Oh, he won't touch carrots.
He won't?
Not even cooked.
Not even cooked?
I served a petite marmite the other night, and he got up and left the table.
No. Now, isn't that something? One sack of peat moss.
What's that for?
He says he's got blossoms in his hair.
That'll be $3.47, Mrs. Potter. I'll have someone take them out to the car for you.
Thank you. Goodbye now.
Blossoms in his hair? In February?
The CBS Radio Workshop. Produced in Hollywood by—
Mr. Robson has presented A Pride of Carrots, or Venus Well-Served, by Robert Nathan, with the author as narrator. A Pride of Carrots was adapted for the workshop by Mr. Robson, who also directed the production. Heard in the cast were Helene Burke, June Foray, Tracy Roberts, Daws Butler, Ted Bliss, Richard Hale, Alan Reed, Sam Pierce, and Bill Thompson. The original score was composed and conducted by Jerry Goldsmith.
Next week, from New York—The workshop will examine that so often discussed and little understood subject, the Oedipus Complex, with illustrations from Sophocles, who first dramatized it, to Eugene O'Neill, who is by no means the last to probe its dramatic depths.
For Mozart's Concerto for Piano and Orchestra in A Minor, played by Robert Casadesus, and for Elisabeth Schwarzkopf's moving interpretations of songs by Richard Strauss, join us on Sunday, when on most of these same stations, World Music Festivals will be on the air, with highlights from the famous Salzburg Festival.
Stay tuned for five minutes of CBS News, to be followed over most of these same stations by My Son Jeep.
America listens most to the CBS Radio Network.
