Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Lum and Abner artwork

From the Lum and Abner collection

Ownership Paper to Trial

Episode 358January 27, 194211 min 41 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 9 min to read

That's Rennie's, Abner. I believe that's our ring. That dog is Lum. I believe you're right. I'll see. Hello, Jot'em Down store. This is Lum and Abner. Let's see what's going on down in Pine Ridge. Today's the day of the big trial in which Lum Edwards, justice of the peace, is trying Lum Edwards, defendant, on the charge of attempting to break into the Jot'em Down store. That same store has been converted into a courtroom. and the town spoke are gathering now to witness this unusual trial. As we look in on the little community, we find Lum and Abner back in the feed room, waiting for everyone to arrive so that the trial can begin. Listen. Yeah, yeah, the jury's all here just waiting on Squire Skimp. For goodness sakes, I wish he'd hurry up and get here. I want to get this thing over. Well, I don't see why you had to get him mixed up in this no way, Lum. I had to get somebody to prosecute me.

I couldn't be the justice of the peace and defend myself and prosecute myself, too. No. I don't want nobody to ever say I've taken the advantage of my office of justice of peace to let myself go free. Of course not, no. That's the reason I got a jury. Yeah, yeah. Well, I still wouldn't have got Squire Skimp mixed up any toll. Well, he's the only one in town that knows anything about law matters. Don't worry, I'll clear me all right. I told Cedric to look for that paper I signed giving you my half of the store and told him when he found it to tear it up. Yeah, that's a thing to do. That's the only evidence they got again. Yeah, yeah. If they don't find it, wait a minute, wait a minute, there comes Squire now. Well, good. Let's get in there and get the thing over with and go ahead. Good morning, gentlemen. Good morning. Proud to see so many of my personal friends on the jury. Sit down, gentlemen. Sit down. Grandpap, I'll ask you to act as court clerk.

Here's a list of the witnesses. You can call them up as we need them. Yeah, sure, Lom. Squire, are you ready for the case to start? Anytime, Your Honor, anytime. All right. The court of Lom Edwards, Justice of the Peace, Cloverleaf Township, County of Polk, State of Arkansas, United States of America is now in session. The first case on the ducat this morning is that of Lom Edwards versus his State of Arkansas. Fact is, that's the only case we've got. Mr. Eddards is wrongfully charged with attempted robbery. I object to that. I object to such personal comments from the bench. That's what we're having a trial for, is to see if you're wrongfully charged. Objection overruled. By the way, gentlemen of the jury, Mr. Skimp here is handling the prosecution, and Mr. Eddards is being defended by L. Eddards.

Call the first witness, Mr. Spears. Oh, yeah. Mousy Gray. He's the first one. Mousy Gray, please come forward. Yes, sir, I'm coming. Just sit in the witness chair there, Mousy. Yes, sir. Now, hello, Mousy, old boy. Howdy, Lon. Mousy, do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Yes, sir, I guess I do. All right, Squire, you're a witness. Uh, Mr. Gray, are you acquainted with the defendant here, Mr. Edwards? Why, yes, sir. He was my manager when I was a box fighter. Mm-hmm. And while he was serving in that capacity, did he do anything to induce you to quit your job at the mill and spend all your time training for your boxing career? Why, yes, sir. He said that...

He'd quit his job, too, that he'd give his half of the store to Abner if I'd quit my job over at the mill. And did he sign a paper to that effect? I object. On what grounds do you object, Lum, for your honor? I just object, that's all. Justice of the Peace ought to have some rights around here. Well, all right, all right. I think the fact that the justice, who is also the defendant... The objection to that question is sufficient for an answer. There's that troll, Mousy. Wait a minute, Mousy. Sir, defense is turned now. Yes, sir. Mousy, this paper the squire just mentioned, do you see it anywhere in this room? No, sir, I don't believe I do. Well, don't start looking for it. This ain't no game we're playing. Do you know where such a paper as that's at? No, sir. All right, that's all, Mousy. Next witness, Grandpap.

Oh, yeah. Let's see here. Milford Spears. Milford Spears. Is Milford Spears here? I reckon not. Next witness, Abner Peabody. Yeah, I'm here. I'm here. You want me to sit? Oh, wait a minute. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. What's the matter with me anyway? I'm Milford Spears. Get out of the chair, Abner. Oh, no, sir. You're too late, Grandpap. I'm done here now. Blame it. I wanted to do some witnessing, too. Well, I want to witness myself here. I don't think we'll need you, Grandpap. All right, Abner, do you swear to tell me... I do. Come on, Squire, ask me the question. Yeah, you're a witness, Squire. Uh, Mr. Peabody, uh, the defendant here is accused of breaking into your store on the night of... Half his store, so he weren't breaking in. That's a time, Abner, that's a time. Answer my questions, Mr. Peabody, answer my questions. Now, you say that it is half his store.

But isn't it true that the defendant signed a legal document giving you his share of the business? Well, uh, I don't know. Calm, calm now. Isn't that the truth? Didn't Mr. Edwards sign such a paper? Well, I believe he did put his name on some kind of a thing, but I don't recollect what he said, no. But you admit that he did sign it. And because he was no longer a partner in the store. Isn't it the truth that he was forced to seek other means of making a living, such as, oh, selling lead pencils, magazine subscriptions? I object. I object. That's an unrevelant question, because nobody can make a living selling them things. I found that out. Well, all right. I think the prosecution is satisfied. That's all, Mr. Peabody. Your witness, Justice. Thank you.

Mr. Peabody, can you produce that so-called paper Squire Skimp keeps referring to? No, sir, I can't. Well, why not? I don't know where such a paper is at. That's all, Admiral. Go back to your seat. Who's next, Grandpap? Uh, let's see. The defendant's next. I'm Edders. Don't shout. I'm right here. Mr. Edders, do you swear... Just a minute, Your Honor. In spite of the fact that you're the Justice of the Peace, I believe you're required to go over to the witness chair at this time. Well, in view of different circumstances, since he's trying to sit on the bench and in the witness stand at the same time, I'm making a special ruling in my case. Ruling sustained. Proceed, Your Honor. Thank you. Mr. Edders, do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do.

Do you want to ask your defendant any questions, Squire? There's only one. And if the defendant tells the truth, the prosecution will rest. Mr. Edwards, did you sign a document giving your share of the Jordan Downs store to Mr. Peabody? I object. That's a leading question. I stand on my Constitution right. That's our time, Lob. Well, this is quite a regular, I must say. But I feel that the defendant's evasion of this question, gentlemen, is as good as an affirmative answer. That's all. Yes, sir. Now, I'll ask the defendant a few questions. Mr. Eddards, have you known the defendant to be an honest, upright citizen, never committing no crimes? Yes, sir. Do you know the whereabouts of any document he signed giving away his half of the store? No, sir.

Thank you, sir. That's all. Gentlemen of the jury, you've heard the evidence in this case, and there ain't none. Nobody's been able to produce no such a document as the prosecution's been talking about. And nobody knows where such a document's at, neither. Therefore, the defendant, who is a fine, honest, noble fellow and citizen in good standing, still owns part of the Johnham Downs store. And, therefore, this trustworthy gentleman could not be guilty of breaking into somebody else's store. Gentlemen of the jury, as I see this case from an unpartial viewpoint, there's only one verdict that you can bring in. Not guilty. The defense rests. All right, Squire, go ahead. Well, in view of the lack of evidence, Mr. Lum... Please, Cedric, don't interrupt. Court's in session. Well, I just wanted to ask Mr. Lum if this is the paper he wanted me to destroy.

Cedric, you get out of here. Oh, my goodness. Just a minute, just a minute. Let me see that paper, Cedric, my boy. That may be evidence in this case. Just as I thought. Gentlemen of the jury, I offer herewith as exhibit A the document signed by Mr. Edwards giving away his half of the store, the prosecution rent. Oh, my goodness. The court is now in recess. Recess? Yeah, come here a minute, Abner. Huh? This is terrible. What's the matter? Oh, that dead name Cedric losing the case for me that-a-way. Well, you ain't worried, are you? Can't you just let yourself go free? Well, it ain't up to me to say whether I'm guilty or not. It's up to the jury. Oh, well. They'll have to say I'm guilty now. Well, let them say you're guilty. Then you can just sentence yourself to just about one day in jail. I can't do that, though. Huh?

According to the law, I got to sentence myself to one to five years in a penitentiary. Oh, my goodness. I believe I'd rather take my chances with some other judge. I know too much. What are you going to do, Long? I'll show you. Course reconvene in session again. Due to the peculiar circumstances of this case, the justice of the peace is asking for a change of Venice. This case will be tried before Judge Parker enters the county seat. Case dismissed.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑