The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 11 min to read
My granny's Abner. I believe that's our ring. Aye, doggy's Lum. I believe you're right. I'll see. Hello, Johnham Downs store. This is Lum and Abner. Let's see what's going on down in Pine Ridge. Trial against himself. Justice of the Peace, Lum Edwards, adjourned court and asked for a change of venue. It seems that the evidence against him was getting a little too damaging. And Lum felt that he would have a better chance before a judge who knew less about the case. So, Lum has written to Judge... at the county seat asking for a trial there. As we look in on the little community today, we find Lum and Mousy in the Jot-Em-Down store. Abner's gone out for lunch. Lum seems to be making some kind of a speech. Look, gentlemen of the jury, look at these gnarled old hands held by years of honest toil. Do they look like the hands of a fellow that could even kick a rob in his beloved partner? I ask you, gentlemen, do you feel like crying yet, Mousy?
No, sir, I don't believe I do, love. Well, I don't believe you're trying. Now, concentrate. Yes, sir. And look at these gray hairs, gentlemen. Look at these gray hairs which killers the honest old head, which has for many years been a familiar figure in the peaceful community of Pine Ridge. All is admired for his upright living and doing rescued gentlemen of the jury. Should these revered gray hairs be hid behind iron bars just because of a misunderstanding? For goodness sake. Huh? What in the world are you doing, Lum? Oh, I never heard you coming in, Abner. Just practicing up my plea to the jury when I go into the county seat for my trial. Oh, I don't believe I can cry at all today, Lum. I've been trying, honest, I have. Well, never, Mousy. You ain't gonna be on the jury no way, so it don't matter. Well, I tried, Lum, but, well, me and Gussie are just so happy since we got married. She's so proud that I have a job at your store.
Well, I just don't like crying. Well, just forget about it. You see, Gussie's just like a mother to me, and I'm so happy... Never mind, Mousy. I don't care whether you cry or not. Just forget about it. No, Mousy, you better go make a deal of her. Yes, sir. Well, while I'm driving around, Lom, I'll try to think of something that'll make me sad, but, well, Gussie's just so wonderful. She's just like a mother to me. You already said that. Hurry up and get out. Yes, sir. Crannies, are we going to have to keep him around the store all day? Well, I hired him while I was trying to run the store by myself, Lum, and he's sort of getting on to things. He tries awful hard to do everything you tell him just right. Yes, it's trouble he tries too hard. I was asking him if my jury speech made him feel like crying, so now he thinks he's got to cry about something. Yeah, yeah. Crannies, he gets on my nerves. What are you practicing up jury speeches for?
Are you going to defend yourself at the trial there at the county seat? Of course I am. This case is getting too serious to trust anybody else to handle it. It is, huh? Since Cedric messed everything up by bringing that paper I signed right into court the other day, everybody knows there's some awful damaging evidence against me. Yeah, yeah, you're right, Mom. Cedric ought never to have done that. Well, of course, I know he thought he was doing the right thing, but he's made it awful bad for me. Oh, yeah. The fact is, I don't know whether I'm getting... A change of Venice and taking my case to another court is going to help me after all. Well, you know you're going to get convicted in your own justice of the peace court, Norm. At least you still got a chance of getting free in somebody else's court. Yeah, but it's an awful slim chance, Abner. I've been reading in some of these law books we got in the library, and to be honest, it just don't look good for me.
Well, now, I doubt you'd better figure out a good case for yourself now before you go into the county seat. When's your trial gonna be? I don't know yet. I read Judge Parker all the details of the case a couple of days ago, so I ought to hear from him today or tomorrow. Yeah, yeah. But it don't make no difference when it is. The facts of the case still shows I'm guilty of breaking in a store that belonged to you at the time. So I got to take the consequence. Well, get out them law books again, Lon. Let's see what we can figure out here. All right, doggies, I ain't gonna stand back and see my partner get sent to the penitentiary for nothing. Go ahead, get out them books. I got them right here. Oh, well, that's interesting. If there's a case in one of them, it sounds quite a bit like mine. We'll find it here. Yeah, yeah, fine. We'll figure out something. Now, don't worry, Lon. Don't worry now. We'll figure it out. Here, this is the one. It's under burglary, breaking and entering. In the case of the state of Illinois, this is Fenwick Hibbing, 1917, X-42, J-21.
Well, I do. That's what become of him. Become of who? Old man Higgins, his boy. And here his mama thought all the time he was up there on a wheat farm in North Dakota. Instead of that, he's burgling down there in Illinois. Well, wait a minute, Abner. This ain't what you think. Well, we mustn't tell his mama now, Lum. It'd just break her poor heart. She just thinks the world and all for that boy. Abner, his name was Francis, and the one in the book here is Fenwick. Oh, give a different name, huh? Well, good for him. He more likely done that just to spare his mama. I believe underneath it all, he's still a good boy. Facts is, the reason he went up to North Dakota to work there in the first place was to earn enough money to help his mama. For goodness sake. Reckon he couldn't make the money fast enough on the farm, so he just went down to Illinois there and taken up robbing. Does it say what he robbed? It was a bank, but this is different.
A bank. He oughtn't to have did it. I wish he'd have come to us first. Listen, Abner, the book ain't talking about Francis. In the first place, this robbery taking place in 1917. 1917? What, little Francis weren't over two or three-year-old, in love? That don't seem possible. A three-year-old young'un doing such a thing as that. Well, it ain't possible. Besides, this fellow was also charged with manslaughter on account it was a bank teller accidental kill. Oh, my goodness. Are they accusing little Francis of that, too? Of course not. He weren't anywhere near there. This was a different fellow altogether. Man, I'm glad to hear that. Hates to see a three-year-old young'un sent up for doing such as that. Reckon who could have did it? Snake Hogan's mean enough, but I don't think he's ever been up to Illinois. Abner, I just read you this to show you what was going to happen to me. I'm the one I'm worried about. You? Well, you never... Wait a minute.
Aye, doggies, that's right, ain't it? You was in Illinois once, and it were in 1917, too. Uh-huh. I recollected you went up there to visit your uncle, um. Aye, doggies, we gotta keep this quiet. Keep it quiet? Why, sure. If this ever comes up at your trial at the county seat, why, you'll lose a case, sure as a world. Well, Abner, I never done that bank robber, that manslaughter. No, you never, Lum. I know you wouldn't do such a thing as that, but you was there. You know how folks get to talking, spreading rumors around. Was you in the bank any time that you was in Illinois? I reckon I was. Yeah, see there? Somebody might have saw you go in there. You never can tell. Yeah, might have, might have. Why, sure. Then they'll tell somebody, and then that somebody will tell somebody else, and, well, that's the way things get started. Oh, my goodness. Just a misunderstanding. Well, in fact, your whole trial is just a misunderstanding twixt me and you.
Granny's that's right, ain't it? Why, sure, Ted. And we're friends, too. Why, sure. You know, Abner, I'm liable to be a victim of circumstance evidence. That's just what I'm liable to be. Oh, my goodness. This thing's getting serious, Sloan. What do you think we ought to do? I don't know. I don't... Read some more in a book there. Maybe it tells how to get out of situations. Yeah, let's see here. Here we are. Evidence which was brought out in this trial definitely proved that the charge of manslaughter... Let me take a footnote here. It says... How? Compare this case with the following. How? Norwich versus Monette versus these Ridgeway, Bower Bank versus these... Oh, my goodness. What's the matter, Lord? Oh, my... Listen. Bower Bank versus these Eddards. I knowed it. I knowed somebody seen you go in there. That can't be me, Abner. This must be some other Eddards. Yeah, but who will ever believe it?
Give me that book lump here. We've got to get rid of that thing. Poor Judge Parker. Somebody seizes her up. Give it to me. It ain't no use, Abner. Judge Parker and every lawyer in the county has got the same book. How do you know? Why, you saw them judges' offices just jammed full of these same kind of books. Yeah, yeah. I've saw them a thousand or a hundred times. And I know Judge Parker's been sitting there in his office reading up on this case. And he'll see that thing sure as the world. Oh, my God. He'll think I'm a hardened criminal and I won't have a chance to win my case. Well, I know. Well, what do we do, love? Ernie's here liable to open up that old manslaughter case and try me for that, too. I wish you'd never made that trip up there to Illinois. Wait a minute, wait a minute. There comes Cedric up out there. Don't mention nothing to him about that trouble I'm in up there in Illinois. Oh, no, no. He'll have it all over town. I won't mention it to him. Wait a minute, wait a minute, wait a minute. Well, howdy, Cedric. Come on in.
I got a letter here for Mr. Long. For Long? Who's it from, Cedric? I don't know. It says something about Judge Parker up there in the corner there. Uh-oh. Mr. Dick Huddleston said it must be something important. I don't want to see it. Well, you better read it, Long. Setting a date for the trial is what it is. Here, I'll read it. I'll read it. Bet you're pretty glad to get out of jail, ain't you, Mr. Long? Don't talk about jail around me, Cedric. Mr. Long Eddard, justice of the peace. Pine Ridge, Arkansas. Dear Mr. Edwards, in answer to your letter regarding the charge against you for burglary, I do not feel that this case should be tried in my circuit court. Oh, my goodness. Must have heard about that Illinois business. Uh-huh. Hi, Grannies. I'll bet they're aiming on taking it right straight to the Supreme Court. Yeah, well, wait a minute. Wait a minute. Here's some more of them.
Furthermore, in view of the circumstances, I find no basis for a trial and advise that the case be dropped. Yours truly, Judge Parker. Oh, my goodness. Grab him there, Cedric. I think he's having another one of his sinking spells.
