The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 6 min to read
I'm Rod Serling. You're listening to The Zero Hour. Rest your eyes. Exercise your imagination. This week, Merwin Gerard's study of a man who sued. Dead Man's Tale. Starring George Maharis, Craig Stevens, and Charles McGraw. In Elliot Lewis's production of The Zero Hour. The Mutual Broadcasting System presents The Zero Hour. Sponsored in part by contact and the Ford Motor Company. This is the Zero Hour on Mutual Radio. Brooks was a man in the wrong place at the wrong time. He arrived at a downtown hotel, per instructions, to pick up a locked attache case for his boss, District Attorney Lloyd Mercer, only to find an empty case and a dead man. Seen in the room and falsely accused, Carl Brooks, a man in a panic, chose to...
Four years later, in a town far away, this same man, haunted by the past and the lie his new life had become, made still another choice. To return and face whatever the charge, whatever the consequences. He returned to find all charges against him dropped. The case was history. But for Carl Brooks, the consequences were immense. His closest friend had been judged guilty and executed. The only man who could have saved him was absent from the trial. That man had run. That man was Carl Brooks. Our story, Dead Man's Tale, resumes after this message. I love Tommy. You know, he's, well, no different than my own grandchildren, except he's never had much love and attention. When I first met him, he never talked, and everyone thought he was mute. I'm a foster grandparent to Tommy.
Not long ago, I began teaching him how to match up colors with words and objects. It just wasn't working, and I was getting frustrated. Then one day, he looked at an apple. He said, red. He said, red. I lit up inside, and I cried, and I kissed him for loving me. The Foster Grandparent Program has many volunteers over 60 years of age devoting themselves part-time. giving personal care and attention to children in institutions. The Foster Grandparent Program is one part of action. Action is doing something. There is something you can do. Get into action. Yuga left me standing in the hotel lobby like I was nailed to the floor. Barry Wilson and I had been friends since before I could remember. We'd done everything together, school, baseball. I even introduced him to Ellen. Now, Barry was dead.
executed by the state for a crime he did not commit. And there was nothing I could do to bring him back. I had returned to my hometown for a purpose, to clear myself of any guilt. I never dreamt how terribly guilty I really was. I understand, Carl. I understand how awful you must feel. But what can you do? I'm not sure, Jenny. I only know there's Ellen and her little girl. And they don't pay widow's benefits to the wife of a man convicted of a capital crime. I've got to do something for them I should have done four years ago. Prove Barry's innocence. It's the least I can do. All right, but Carl, you sound as if you feel guilty. I am. No, you're not. You didn't kill anybody. Neither did Barry. Oh, Carl, don't do this to yourself. What happened is unfair, and I'm not asking you to do nothing about righting a wrong, but... Jenny, please, just give me a little time. I mean, what I said before still goes. This is...
Something I have to do before we can have a decent life together. Does that mean you want me to stay here in Coulter? For now, yes. Do you understand why? I'm trying to. All any of us can do is try. Goodbye, darling. Goodbye, darling. I didn't know exactly how or where to start. From the beginning seemed like a logical place. I checked into the Delta Hotel, and then I arranged to meet Lloyd Mercer at the Skylight Lounge. Well, Carl, what's it going to be? Dinner or just a quick drink? I've canceled my reservation. Oh? I thought you had a young lady breathlessly awaiting your return. Well, that was before I found out what happened to Barry Wilson. I hope you spare you that. Terribly unfortunate, unpleasant all around. But what's it got to do with your changing of plans? Barry was innocent. He had a jury trial, Carl. He was convicted. Who prosecuted the case? It was my job.
Not a happy one under the circumstances, but I had no choice but to prosecute without fear or favor. Well, did he tell you I saw him at the Delta Hotel that he was arriving five minutes after I found the body? So he claimed. Well, it's true. Since we couldn't find you, I weighed the possibility that it might have been true. You didn't believe him? It gave me pause. But then I realized he could have come back to the hotel after killing Henley so that you could see him just arriving to be his alibi if he needed one. As matters developed, I'm certain that that was the case. But he shouted to me as I was running for a taxi that you had asked him to meet me there. Yes, he made that allegation at the trial. Untrue, of course. Why would I do that? I don't know. All I heard him say was that the chief sent him. Not much of a defense. I guess not. Just one man's word against another. Don't be petty, Carl. It doesn't suit you. Look, was there any hard evidence against Barry? I could let you have the transcript if you like.
But briefly, motive. He was rather deeply in debt. An opportunity? He obviously listened on the inner office intercom to my instructions to you about picking up the attache case from Henley. We both know they left the office considerably ahead of you. Yes, but he was going home. I mean, Judge, you and Harry... Naturally, he claimed that he'd never heard of Henley, so we'll never know. Were there any fingerprints? Only yours and Henley. A murderer would have been more careful. Barry couldn't account for his movements just prior to or during the time of the murder. He had 500 in cash he couldn't explain. And then the ball...
