The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 9 min to read
The Hollywood Radio Theater. Every day at this time, Monday through Friday, a J.M. Colas Enterprises production, The Hollywood Radio Theater presents an unusual tale of mystery and suspense. Every week, Monday through Friday, The Hollywood Radio Theater presents... I'm Rod Serling. You're listening to The Zero Hour. Rest your eyes. Exercise your imagination. This week, Merwin Gerard's study of a man who sued. Dead Man's Tale, starring George Maharis, Craig Stevens, and Charles McGraw. In Elliot Lewis's production of The Zero Hour. The story this week is a case for rebuttal to the old adage, dead men tell no tales. It's the story of Carl Brooks, a young man, a practicing lawyer, one of two junior district attorneys under political zealot Lloyd Mercer.
It will be Carl Brooks' misfortune to be asked to perform a favor by and for his mentor. Misfortune that begins with murder and proliferates over a life reborn and a span of four years' time. His initial chance discovery and subsequent smoldering guilt will prove to be the driving catalytic force to spirit him back to the scene of the crime. A dead man knows the truth. And for Carl Brooks, a mission of repentance and search for that truth. will lead him to peel back the layers of deceit and uncover what we can only call Dead Man's Tale. Our story begins after this word. Picture this. Dusk of a late autumn day in a seemingly typical Midwestern city of 300,000. In the office of District Attorney Lloyd Mercer, the day's work is winding to a close. The secretary has gone home, leaving two young men to their game of darts in the outer office. Bullseye!
How about that shot, Barry? I don't know. Good, Carl. You stepped over the line. Now, come on, Barry. You're not going to take 100 points from me over an imaginary line, are you? Carl Brooks and Barry Wilson, both 24 years old. Close friends and Lloyd Mercer's junior DAs. Gentlemen, who's winning? You are, Chief, if the latest figures in the polls are right. Yes, they were very encouraging. Come to the office. Encouraging? 57% for you? 36% for all the other candidates combined, 7% undecided. And less than a week to go, you're a shoo-in for another term. I never count votes until election night. Which one of you can spare me a small favor this evening? I have to get home and change for that rally. Well, I still have some work on the Bostwick brief, and you'll need it first thing tomorrow. Right. And you've also got a family awaiting dinner. Which, by the process of elimination, leaves the bachelor with a clear desk. Okay, what can I do for you, Chief? Barry, would you close the door on your way up? Hmm?
Oh, sure thing. Well, I want you to go to the Delta Hotel and pick up an attaché case for me. The man's name is Robert Henley. He'll be expecting you. He's in room 515. And when you get it, bring it straight to me at election headquarters. I'll need those documents tonight before the rally. Now, I'm off with you. Yes, sir. Good luck tonight, Mr. Mercer. What could go wrong? I'm addressing our 57%. I left the office and took a cab to the Delta Hotel. The desk clerk waved as I walked by, and I told the elevator man, fifth floor. The door to room 515 was oddly not quite closed. Mr. Henley? It's Carl Brooks from Lloyd Mercer's office. Mr. Henley? Mr. Henley, I... Mr. Henley? What? Oh, my God. Main desk. Get me the food. Cute, but not cute enough. What are you doing here? No need to ask what you're doing, is there? Calling the Red Cross, maybe? Donating blood?
This man's dead. Very good, counselor. Very good indeed. I'll take that money now. What? Come on, come on. It's too late for games. You're out of your league, sonny. What are you talking about? You think I killed him? Fancy that. Tell you what, just hand over the cash and I'll forget I saw you here. You can run and maybe you can beat the murder rap. Wait a minute, this is insane. Not insane, just stupid. But then you couldn't know I'm making a habit to keep my eye on my investments. Your investments? Look, I don't have any idea what you're talking about, Ferris, but I'm going to... You're not going to do anything or go anywhere until you cough up that 150 grand. A hundred and... Get out of my way, Ferris. Sorry. The money book's handed over. Lloyd Mercer, please. It's urgent. Carl? Sir? You're lucky I'm still here, boy. What's the matter? Everything's the matter. Robert Henley is dead. What? I'm sorry, Carl. I couldn't hear you. Robert Henley. He's dead. What?
I went up to his room and found him on the floor. His throat. It was cut from ear to ear. What about the attaché case? It was still handcuffed to his wrist, but it was broken open and it was empty. Empty? It's all $150,000 worth of documents. Mr. D.A., are you there? You'd better get over here right away, Carl. Joe Farris was there. He saw me in the room. He thinks I killed Henley. I don't think I've heard it. He said there was money involved. Where is he now? Farris? He's still up there. I don't know. I don't plan to be around when he comes to. I had to hit him to get out. Come over to headquarters. I have to see you. Well, everyone else has. Ferris, the desk clerk, the elevator man, my fingerprints. They're all over that room. Well, I'll explain, but not over the phone. Well, just explain two things to me. $150,000 and one dead man. You get over here, Brooks. Now. Right now. Mercer? Mercer! Taxi! Taxi! Get off, baby!
The airport. And move. And it wasn't intelligent. It was sheer blind panic that made me take the first westbound plane out of town. After all, I was innocent, regardless of how it looked. But it looked like a setup, with me, dead center in the frame. When the plane landed, I bought a hometown paper. The story of Henley's murder was all over the front page. Carl Brooks was a wanted man. I dumped the paper in the trash can and moved on. And on. From town to town. The days ran into weeks and then months. I never read anything more or heard about it. I didn't want to know. Guilt is not always something that can be determined in a court of law. I had to establish a new life if I was to survive, beginning with a new name, Charles Barrows. A three-day construction job brought me into a small central town in California, the town of Coulter. I stayed four years, growing with the town. I enrolled in a real estate school where I met Jenny Duncan. We studied together.
And in four years, our friendship blossomed into something far greater. Be right there, Jen. How's my land bearing doing today? Fine, let's go. Where? Anywhere. Just start somewhere. Rough day at the office? You sure had me fooled, Charles Bills. What? What do you mean? Honey, all I meant was you're terribly cranky today. I'm sorry, Jenny. I didn't mean to take it out on you. That's the last thing I want to do, believe me. Let's go to the lake. We've always been able to say what we mean there. All right. See the circle the pebble makes in the water? I bet you can't throw one inside it. I thought we came here to say what we meant. What is it, Charles? Oh. Well, a man came in today. He was interested in a piece of property over by Golden Valley. I was showing him the brochure when he... He said he thought he'd seen me somewhere before. Well, that is possible. Coulter isn't San Francisco. He just moved here from the Midwest.
He probably thought you were someone else. Like Carl Brooks. Who? Charles, what are you not telling me? Jenny, do you know how much I love you? I mean, how much you mean to me? Four years ago, a man was killed in a town I grew up in. Carl Brooks worked for the district attorney at the time. He found the body, but that's all he did. But it was somehow made to look like he was a suspect, the prime suspect. What happened to him? Well, he disappeared. And you have the same color hair, right? We're one and the same. I don't believe it. Well, it's true. And if it weren't, well, I'd have proposed marriage a long time ago. Charles. My conscience wouldn't allow me to ask. I mean, I'd give up anything for you, Jenny. I would. And I will. What does it all mean? Well, I've decided to give myself up. I'm going back, Jenny. Clear myself. Clear my name. What happens to us? I love you. Whoever you are.
I'm going with you. No, you mustn't. Please, Jenny. I mean, it's painful as it is. But what if... You said you were innocent. I was weak then. I was a coward. I couldn't have fought the law even though they were wrong. But it's different now. I have something to fight for. And that's exactly what I plan to do. It was only two hours by air back to the city where I'd lived most of my life. But it seemed an eternity until the plane touched down at the airport. The moment I stepped under the ground... A feeling of guilt returned. Hundreds of people in that city knew me by sight. And if I was picked up before I had the chance to turn myself in, it would be impossible to prove I came back to give myself up. Voluntarily, that is. Taxi, mister? Yes. Where to? The county offices. Right. Would you happen to know, is Lloyd Mercer still the district attorney? Not since the election last month. We got a new one, Baylor Jameson. Oh, I see. Then Mercer won a second term and was defeated this year. No.
Mercer didn't run for DA this year. The way I hear it, Jameson's his boy. Mercer ran for superior court. Judge? Judge Mercer? Yeah, another landslide. They're saying he'll run for governor next time. That Mercer's got one smooth machine. Well, he's the one I want to see. Well, that'll be the courthouse.
