Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Doctor Eduardo

Episode 878August 11, 197843 min 48 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 32 min to read

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. My wise old grandmother, whom I've had occasion to quote to you before, had sayings for almost everything. And almost always, Grandma was 100% on the button right. One of her favorite maxims was, "Do unto others as if you were the others." Prejudice and its wicked power is what she was talking about. And the story which Conan Doyle tells us now illustrates how far misjudgment can take you. Even as far as murder.

Pop, are you going to let that fellow marry Susan?

Eduardo, yes, I think I am.

You mean you don't mind? But he's a foreigner.

I can't say I do. Some of us in town think pretty highly of him.

I think you've all gone crazy and I don't aim to stand for it. Now, we here in Winter Harbor have a tradition to uphold that marrying an outsider could mean lots of trouble.

Mystery drama, Dr. Eduardo, adapted from a story by A. Conan Doyle, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Gerald Keene and stars Norman Rose. It is sponsored in part by True Value Hardware Stores. I'll be back shortly with Act One.

One has to remember when America was first settled, there were no roads or telephone or telegraph to link one town with another. So the settlers had to go it alone. The years passed, life became more standardized, more the same. But those folk who were there first, the town founders and their sons and daughters, always felt very special. Outsiders had better stay out.

Hey, Pop! Hey, Pop, there's a letter for you.

How many times do I have to tell you that when I'm here at work in my office, it is not "hey, Pop," it's Mr. Mayor. And not "hey, Mr. Mayor," either. Do you understand that, Matthew?

Gee, I forgot, Pop. I mean, you're Pop at home. Mom calls you Pop. Sue calls you Pop. Dad. It's hard for me to remember that when you're in the mayor's office, you're not my Pop, you're Mr. Mayor. Here's a letter for you.

Thank you. Put it on my desk.

Well, gee, Pop, ain't you gonna open it? This is the first letter we got in Winter Harbor since the spring thaw.

Matthew, haven't you anything better to do than stand around? It's quarter to nine, and you've got a great many windows to wash in our public buildings, so get to it.

Oh, Pop, Mr. Mayor, haven't you got a better job for me than to wash windows?

As long as you're on the public payroll, I expect you to do an honest day's work. Oh, I almost forgot. Hold on, Matthew. We put in new locks in the library and the courthouse. You keep these keys so you can get in early in the morning to do your work. All right, now beat it. Where's your sister, Sue? It's almost nine.

Oh, Miss Goody Two-Shoes will be here on time. She always is.

Now, don't speak disparagingly of your sister. She gives the taxpayers their money's worth.

Good morning, Mr. Mayor. Beautiful morning, isn't it?

You see, Matthew, she doesn't call me Pop. She says, "Good morning, Mr. Mayor."

Ah, yes, it is good morning, Susan. We had a letter this morning. You may begin by dealing with that. Matthew, don't stand there one foot in the Cranberry Bog and don't use too much soap. Clean the windows. This town's not made of money, you know.

Yes, Mr. Mayor.

Uh, what's in that letter addressed to me?

Mr. Mayor, we're getting ourselves a doctor. A real live doctor for Winter Harbor?

That's what the gentleman says. He's decided to come to Winter Harbor to set up a practice.

What's his name?

Eduardo Columbus.

Eduardo, that's Spanish for Edward. A Spanish doctor? Here, in Winter Harbor?

Think of all the Portuguese fishermen who live in town. You'd be perfect for them.

A Portuguese, is that the same as Spanish?

Well, I'm pretty close. And they make up most of the folks who work here.

What about the rest of us? We get sick, too.

Ah, how do we know he speaks American?

He writes American. After all, his kinfolk came here before we did. They could have been on that boat with Christopher Columbus.

This time of the evening is when your mother's gone to bed and I can rock peacefully in my rocking chair on the front porch. What do you think of Dr. Columbus?

Well, let's see now. How long has he been in town?

Six months. I think most folks like him.

Some don't.

Why?

Nothing.

Don't tell me nothing, Susan. When it comes to a woman and a man, there's no such thing as nothing.

Dad, there's a fire down the street.

Huh? Whose house is it?

I'm not sure. I wonder if... Here comes Matthew on the run. He probably knows.

Whose house is on fire?

He's on fire.

What's that? Is there a fire?

Yes.

Oh, no. I came the other way.

You did not. I saw you back there, crossing the street.

Well, I'd better get myself over there. That crowd's getting bigger and there'll be sparks and danger. Someone's got to restore order.

Doctor, have another cup of coffee.

Susan, more coffee.

Dad, Mom's gone to bed. You'd wake the whole house.

Oh, I'm sorry. Bring the coffee pot from the stove, will you? The doctor can use another cup.

Why do people do things like that?

People do... Do what?

Here. Let me fill your cup, Eduardo.

Are you all right?

Excuse me. Sorry if I'm a little low. There hasn't been a fire like that in Winter Harbor for a hundred years. There's no way it could get started.

There is a way, Mayor Greeley. I wish I did not know it.

Eduardo? You mean you saw something?

Six months I have been here. I thought we could be friends. I love this town, but I see that feeling goes only one way. The town does not love me.

What are you saying? Everybody likes you.

Well, sure, in the beginning... You do know something, don't you? About how the fire got started.

I want to be thankful. Only my clothes and books are gone. The medical equipment is safe in my office.

Eduardo, there is something.

Dad, it wasn't an accident. That's what he's saying.

How do you know?

I bring here your son's wallet. Take it, please. It is your son's, is it not?

Matthew? Matthew, Matthew, come down here.

This is very sad for me. Why would he do it?

Maybe he dropped it another time.

Your brother is not the only person in Winter Harbor who thinks I do not belong here.

Gee, Pop, how's the sleep? What's the problem?

Here's your wallet, son.

Hey, thanks. Where did you find it?

Where did you find it, Doctor?

By the back steps of my house. I picked it up after the fire.

Oh, gosh. I must address... I dropped it there when I went to watch.

You told me you weren't anywhere near there. You didn't even know the house was burning.

Also, the fire chief and I, we went inside and he found a can of gasoline all burned. And I... Do you know whose keys they are, Mr. Mayor?

Sure, Matthew. You didn't realize what he was doing. I am so sorry it happened.

Eduardo, what are you going to do?

Well, you're not going to press charges?

Oh, please. That is only for criminals. For the boy's sake, I hope it will be a lesson.

Dad, Eduardo has no place to go. Could we put him up until he finds a new house?

Would you stay with us, Doctor?

Oh, that is very kind. After all this business with Matthew, I wasn't sure you'd want to be under the same roof.

I should be delighted.

I'm so glad. I'll go make up the extra room.

It's funny how the right words don't come when you want to say them. They are burned out of your home. No place to stay. Hey, my boy and what he did. All I can think of is I wonder if my pajamas will fit him.

Eduardo, you know what day it is today?

Oh, let me see. I do not think I do.

It's exactly one year since you hung out your shingle on Main Street.

That long, Mayor Greeley?

I asked you personally to come to my office for two reasons. One, I want to thank you for everything you've done for Winter Harbor. We haven't lost a baby. No measles, no chicken pox. And that child care center is really a fine thing. Just the same, though. You worry me.

I do?

You're probably the most eligible young man in town. Most of our boys have gone off to the big cities. But I never see you with a young lady. We have square dances, hoedowns, sleigh rides.

It is only because a doctor does not have much time for those things.

Well, anyway, I've said it. My wife asked me to ask you, and I've asked you. Well, I've said it. I guess the young ladies in town will just have to take care of themselves, huh? Anyway, on Saturday, we're having a special birthday party for you. Just us menfolk. At the Fisherman's Hall.

But it is not my birthday.

No, but it's the town's birthday. And we thought, good. We'll celebrate one year of having the best doctor in the state right in our own backyard.

I say.

Well, you be there at seven o'clock. Eduardo, I'm going to make a little speech. You know, this town is over 200 years old. We don't take to strangers. But when we do, we do. And that brings me to the other reason I asked you to stop by here.

Yes?

Eduardo, I want to ask you, now that we know each other a little better. Eduardo, can I call you Eddie? More American?

Susan, I do not think you ought to live here. You love the ocean.

Eduardo.

Eduardo. I've lived here all my life. And I never came to this town until you and I started picnicking here.

It is a little dangerous for a young lady alone. The lighthouse behind us, it clips to the sea. Where I was born in a town like this, it is called Vigo. In Spain, you have lighthouses, too.

Oh, yes. It has been my dream to live in one.

Mine, too. You know, your Winter Harbor is much like Vigo. We have Portuguese fishermen there, also.

In Spain?

Oh, no. No. America. It's my home now.

I think our town has finally accepted you.

Susan, it is not the people in the town who have made me feel at home. It is you.

You think anyone watches us taking walks, spending time together?

Now, what does it matter? Your father has no idea. He did not take one of the local beauties on outings and dances. I had to stop myself from saying, "Mr. Mayor, I am in love with your daughter."

Yes, Eduardo.

Are you going to let that fella marry Susan?

What?

He proposed to her, and she accepted. I heard them.

Dr. Columbus? Eddie? Where were you?

Right behind them. Cleaning the windows of the Bear Point Lighthouse.

Well, I'll be... I wondered who was going to grab him off. I never thought it'd be Susan.

You mean you don't mind?

No. No, I can't say I do. Eddie's a good man.

Well, I don't like it. And I don't aim to stand for it.

Well, I'm afraid there's nothing you can do about it. I don't imagine they're going to ask for your permission, Matthew.

It is not right. We here in Winter Harbor, we have a tradition to uphold. And marrying an outsider, it's wrong. It is a disgrace to our family.

I'll give you some advice, Matthew. Don't stick your nose where it ain't wanted.

First a fire. Danger signals to watch for from the prophetic pen of Conan Doyle. How far will bias and blind spots push our tale into tragedy? People like the mayor's son are hard nuts to crack. As they say, there are none so blind as those who will not see. Turn shortly.

A fine young doctor born in Spain takes up residence in a New England seacoast village. Folks in town admire him for the good medicine he practices. Some, one in particular, do not. One can't like everyone. There's nothing sinful in disliking someone. But for the wrong reasons. For the wrong reasons.

And so, fellow citizens of Winter Harbor, in recognition of our doctor's service to the community, I propose he be made an honorary citizen of our town. Now may I have a show of hands? That looks pretty unanimous. Motion carried. Eddie? Eddie Columbus? Please stand up.

I thank you all for this honor. You know, coming from another country, you have to take your medical examinations all over again. But I did it... because I wanted it so bad. I also wanted to be an American so bad that I changed my name. My real name is Eduardo Colombo, which I changed to that good American name, Columbus. Anyway, I thank you. You have made me feel very welcome. And I would like to add a little announcement of my own. Friends, Mr. Mayor, your daughter Susan and I are planning to get married.

And did you know the doctor got a letter with a foreign stamp on it today?

Matthew, I couldn't care less.

Matthew, you're getting to be a gossipy old maid. So why shouldn't Eddie get married? Everybody else does.

Pop, you don't seem to realize we don't know one darn thing about him. He shows up. Now, who knows who he really is, huh?

Some people, my boy, show you what they are by what they do. Others are just a lot of wieners.

Well, did you know he bought that old lighthouse on Bear Point?

Of course I did. That's where they're going to live. Remember that little incident of the fire, Matthew? We've hushed it up, kept it inside the family. And Eddie marrying Susan will make sure it stays there. Now, don't make a pest of yourself. I'm asking you nicely. Stop this vendetta you've got against Eddie Columbus just because he wasn't born in Winter Harbor.

What did you tell your patient? Go home? I have to go to my lighthouse to see how my fiancée is throwing up our curtains?

Oh, let me hug you. What is it, darling? You haven't said a word.

I do not know what to say.

Oh, you don't have to be so serious. You're acting positive and tragic.

You're dumb. Not for you alone, silly. The little study is finished. I unpacked all the medical books you ordered from Boston. And I put that big photograph of me right on your desk. What's Susan? The bedroom's all finished. The curtains hung. The coverlet made. Oh, I haven't told you. Mr. Harvey's retiring from being doctor. He's a dog catcher. His sister told me he's going to hate doing nothing, so I hired him to come take care of us. He can live up on top where the light used to be. He said he'd love it, and he'll make himself right-handed.

I just wish we weren't waiting till June to get married, don't we?

Susan. Susan, sit down. You sound so ominous.

Darling, you know I love you, don't you? And whatever I feel I have to do will change that, you understand?

What happened?

We should get married.

Oh?

Not now. Not right away. Not... Is this unusual?

No reason. Why not?

Yes, it is, I'm afraid.

I see.

You don't see. You've given me very much to go on. You just said no marriage.

It is all that I can say right now.

Don't you trust me enough to tell me why?

It has nothing to do with you, darling. It is all part of me and who I am and who I was before I ever came to Winter Harbor.

Is there a date on your decision? A time limit?

I wish not forever. I mean, I'm not breaking off just like that. How could I?

You seem to be doing it very well.

Susan. Do not be angry, please.

Angry? Out of the blue, you say the wedding's off and no date for when it's on? If it's ever on? Be angry? You won't share your problem, whatever it is, with me?

I can't. I could not make you understand. How can I share my feelings with you? Right now, this is just the worst thing that could ever happen to me. But I can't share it because I don't think I could make you understand either.

Are you going to let that foreigner treat Susan this way and do nothing?

Matthew, it's between the two of them.

Yeah, well, I think he ought to be run out of town.

Oh, Matthew, use your head. What good will it do Susan to stir things up? There are plenty of folks around here who never liked him. People who weren't raised here are different from us. They speak different. They are different.

Well, of course, you're upset. So am I. I keep telling myself it's a lover's quarrel. They'll make up and everything will be all right.

Yeah, well, that's not what Susan says. It's off, over, finished. I asked her to give any reason and she just shook her head. She went up to her room to cry. Listen, I'm not hanging around this town any longer. Everything about it gives me the creeps. My sister gets kicked in the teeth and my pop says, well, well. Well, I don't see it that way. She can't protect herself. But I am not letting that guy get away with it.

I'm coming. I'm coming. What are you doing here at 5:30 in the morning all dolled up in your police chief's outfit?

You had better get yourself dressed, Horace. And hurry.

Well, would you mind telling me why?

There's been a murder.

What? Here? In Winter Harbor? What, in time of the morning? Harry's just been telling me.

Do you mind if I come in? I'd rather you didn't discuss what I just mentioned.

Oh, all right. I only came down to see what all the noise was about. See you at breakfast, then.

You could have talked about the murder in front of Susan. She's not squeamish that way.

No, no, not me. I wasn't going to be the one.

Horace, get a move on, will you? I've got the car outside.

What do you mean, you didn't want to be the one?

To tell Susan. That's what I meant.

Harry, who's been murdered?

The doctor. The man she was going to marry. Eduardo.

This is quite a place he picked out. Imagine wanting to live in an old lighthouse.

The way you go inside. Susan's made this into a really nice place to live. As I was inside an hour ago when old Harvey first called me.

There he is. Oh, back again, Steve Teller?

Morning, Mayor Greeley.

Well, you haven't touched anything, have you, Harvey?

Oh, no, sir. I left the body just as you saw it.

Good. Well, a few questions before we go inside. First of all, Harvey, what are you doing here?

What? I live here.

Thought you lived with your sister.

The doctor hired me to take care of the place.

When did you last see the doctor alive?

Well, I didn't exactly see him, but I heard him.

Well, tell me. Go on.

About... 11:15 last night, I heard the doctor call out, so I went down the stairs. You should see those stairs, Mr. Mayor. They wind down and down like a corkscrew. I'm way up top where they used to burn the light.

The lantern gallery.

Oh, what a view.

Well, you came downstairs. 11:15. And I knocked on the door, and I said, Did you call? And he said, No, I didn't call. And go back up to bed and don't annoy me. Well, I was kind of surprised. He never talked so... snappy like to me before.

Well, did you go right up to bed?

No, I didn't. Now, I'm not used to living on the top of a lighthouse yet. So I opened the little door, and there's a raven, and I can walk around the light. It is a clear night. You could see for miles.

And then you went to bed.

After I saw Matthew.

Matthew?

Yes. Matthew. Maybe about midnight, maybe later. There he comes along the path with a flashlight. Then he turns out the light, and I do not see him. I don't see him anymore.

Are you sure it was my son?

Oh, yeah, I didn't know Matthew anywhere. He was just taking a walk, I guess.

And when did you discover the body?

About four o'clock, I'd say. What time did I call you, Chief?

There was very little noise. And I woke up all of a sudden. Mind you, I'm up there at the top of the lighthouse. Fifty feet up.

Seventy-five.

And I hear the front door squeaking open. And I'm thinking, what's going on? Maybe it took me five or ten minutes to find my slippers and put my pants on. I come downstairs. And there's a light on in the room where the doctor has his books. So, I knock on the door. I'm thinking he was reading or something and fell asleep. No answer. I open the door, and there he is. Dead. On the sofa.

All right. Let's go inside and have a look.

Order, please, order. Hi, everybody. Foreigners in question for the town of Winter Harbor in Summit County is in session in the matter of the apparent murder of Dr. Eduardo Combo. I am George Payson, the coroner, and witnesses will come forward as they're called. Will Chief Police Harry Tanner step forward to give evidence?

Chief Tanner?

Yes, sir.

In what condition did you find the deceased?

The deceased was lying on his back on a sofa, and it was evident he'd been subjected to violence. And while he was fully dressed and had on his slippers, the soles of which were perfectly clean.

Uh, Chief, is there any traces of the assailant?

The insolence? The side of the door and the carpet had traces of dirt and boot marks, presumably made by the murderer, uh, the assailant. From the size of the footprints, I would say it was clearly a man.

Any evidence of robbery?

Oh, I would say no. Only one item appears missing, and that's, uh, an 8x10 photograph which has been removed from a frame on the doctor's desk.

Uh, do you know who this photograph was of?

No, sir. Is there anyone present who knows who the photograph was of?

I do.

Oh. Miss Berry, if you don't mind, would you step forward, please? Harry, let her get closer to the bench.

I-I know whose picture it was. It was of me.

Oh, and it's missing. Well, thank you, Miss Berry. You may return to your seat.

Uh, yes, sir?

Uh, may I have a word with you, George?

Uh, what is it?

Well, my theory is Susan's brother, Matthew, may have a good deal to do with this case.

Uh, I'll explain later. Uh, where is he?

Uh, that's just it, George. He's disappeared.

Well, that puts quite a different complexion on this case, don't it?

Well, we've got a couple of leads. I think in a day or so, we'll be able to bring him in.

Yeah, good enough. We'll adjourn then. Uh, ahem, ladies and gentlemen, this inquest will stand adjourned. Too close a notice. You each be notified when we appear. I caution each of you here today not to leave town.

It's always been fun going back as far as the days of Adam and Cain. As the good book says, the wicked flee when no man pursueth. However, the devotees of Mystery Theater know better than to accept what seems or what is. We'll be back shortly with the hard evidence of Act III.

It's a well-known fact that the smaller the town, the quicker the justice. Unlike in a city where the courts are clogged and backlogged for years, the murder trial in Winter Harbor began right away. And although the coroner's verdict was death by person or persons unknown, it was no surprise when Matthew Greeley was found, suspected, accused, and held. It is now the second week of the trial.

Horace, I can't tell you how terribly I feel that your boy is charged with this crime.

I understand you had to bring him in, Harry. He hasn't given me a satisfactory answer why he left town. He keeps saying he didn't know anything about Eddie being murdered, that there weren't any newspapers up near that cabin. Well, I kind of believe that. I know that boy. He may talk big all over town about what he'd do for the honor of his sister, but he's gentle. What went badly was him admitting he had gone to see the doctor that night, but then didn't, and decided to leave town.

Who's being put on the witness stand today?

Susan. I said to Jack Smite she was on the stand yesterday. Why do you have to call her again today?

Ah, she really loved Eddie. This must be traumatic for the poor child. Here we go. The judge is coming through the door.

Honor, I'd like to recall Susan Greeley to the stand, and may I remind the witness that she is still under oath?

Yes. Now, Susan, yesterday you told us that your engagement to Dr. Columbus had been broken at the doctor's request. Did he tell you why?

I understood there were personal reasons connected with his family.

Mm-hmm. And your brother? Matthew. How did he take the news of the broken engagement?

Well, not very well, I'm afraid.

Do you harbor any ill feelings toward Dr. Columbus?

Oh, no, no. He acted in a perfectly honorable manner.

Did you ever hear your brother Matthew utter any threats against the doctor?

Ah, yes, I'm afraid I did. But he couldn't have killed him.

Well, why do you say that, Susan?

Because Dr. Eduardo Columbus is not dead.

With your Honor's permission, I would like to resume questioning Ms. Greeley. Now, would you tell the court, Susan, how you know Dr. Columbus is not dead?

Because I have received a letter from him since the date of his supposed death.

Have you the letter?

Yes, yes, I have it with me in my handbag, but I should prefer not to show it.

Oh, well, may we see the envelope?

Yes.

Would you take it out, please, and tell us the postmark?

Portland.

And the date?

June 5th.

Excuse me, I'm not feeling very well.

I'm sorry, Ms. Greeley, these questions must be painful to you.

It's no care.

Yes, Joseph? Can you tell us what is particularly upsetting?

Well, you see, June 5th was the date on which Eduardo and I were going to get married.

Susan, are you prepared to swear that this letter is in the actual handwriting of Dr. Eduardo Columbus?

Yes, yes, I am.

Now, Susan, there will be those who... You say you have been in possession of this letter during the proceedings at the inquest, and then when your brother was apprehended by the police, and at the beginning of this trial. Why did you continue to conceal evidence which might have brought these proceedings to an end?

Dr. Columbus wrote, asking me to keep his secret.

Then why have you made it public now?

To save my brother. I asked the indulgence of the court to declare a recess until tomorrow.

Well, we shall bring forth witnesses. This is to verify that the letter is indeed in Dr. Columbus's handwriting. However, it does present us with a dilemma. That if the deceased is not Dr. Columbus, then who is he?

This morning, before the court resumed, with the consent of the prosecution, Miss Susan Greeley has been excused from cross-examination. I now call the next witness, Dr. Eduardo Columbus.

Did you know about this horse?

No, I sure didn't.

Don't tell me this is surprising.

Well, until they brought up that letter, I was sure the deceased was the doctor.

I wasn't. For one thing, didn't the autopsy show the deceased had a congenital heart defect? Eddie didn't have a bad heart.

Well, it doesn't look the better for wear today, does he?

I'm looking at Susan. She still loves that man.

When you look at us, he's been sworn in. He's taking the stand. Dr. Eduardo Columbus. Do I understand you wish to make a statement? Regarding the events on the night in question?

Yes, I do.

You are aware, doctor, that anything you say in this trial may be used against you?

I am aware of that. Proceed, doctor.

Your Honor, first of all, before the night in question, I received a letter sent to me by my brother from Argentina. I have a twin brother whose resemblance to me is so great that when we were together in Spain, people could see no difference between us. Painful for me to say this. From an early age... I conceived a horror of him. Because of him and his dishonest actions, I was compelled to leave Spain and seek a new life and a new career in America.

The letter told me he had discovered my whereabouts and would surely be here. On the night in question, I was sitting in my study in the lower part of the lighthouse by the window. Your Honor, I saw his face through the window. The resemblance between us was still so great that for an instant I thought it was my own reflection. I went to the door and admitted him.

My dear, dear Eduardo. You look well.

Thank you. What has happened to you? For heaven's sake, brother, come over here. Sit down. Look at those shoes. What's left of them, eh? Of course, Eduardo, you... You wouldn't know what it is to travel by foot.

Thank you. I cannot believe you came all the way from Argentina looking like that.

Oh, but I did. In these ragged clothes, I blend perfectly. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. In these ragged clothes and boxes in the airplane baggage compartment. Best way to travel, although the cheapest. You see, don't eat the baggage under 25,000 feet. You can freeze, but frozen or not. I had this urge to visit you.

Why were you in Argentina? When did you leave Spain?

When the police became impatient. They thought I had broken the law once too often. And besides, there was a little matter of a watchman with a crushed skull in a warehouse. Oh, and you're stealing, housebreaking, robbery. How did you come to it?

Very easily. When you have no profession, no ambition. And a watchman, stupid man. He died. What he deserved, trying to resist me. So I disappeared. Went to Argentina and lived like a dog.

I suppose you wish anything to eat.

Oh, how well you remember my dear brother. No food, thank you. But the largest bottle of the strongest drink. It will be appreciated.

I'll see what I can do. I am not really in store yet.

Oh, I'm freezing today. There is nothing worse than a chill when the weather turns warm. Here, give it to me. Do you want a glass?

What for? The neck of the bottle fits into my mouth.

Encio, Encio, I know you are past reasoning with. Not only in mind, but in body. You have abused yourself like a sick animal. You always had a weak heart. You have diseased your liver. Look, your face is swollen. I cannot believe you are my twin brother. I cannot.

Thank you for the medical lecture, dear brother. But now, let us be serious. First of all, you can have these rags. I want clothes. Good clothes. Then money. All the money you have here. And don't think you shall be rid of me when I leave. Oh, no. I shall return whenever I feel like it. And you shall give me more money. What was it Cain said to the Almighty? Am I my brother's keeper? Well, so you are, Eduardo. For as long as I choose, you shall be my keeper.

Still, let me help you. There, enough. You see, you do have some brotherly affection, Forenzo. But believe me, it is quite one-sided, for I despise you, Eduardo. I detest you. Always have. Always will. Saints in heaven, how I hate you. I hate you.

Encio up from the floor and carried him to the sofa. I felt his pulse, but the hand I held in mine became cold and clammy. His diseased heart had broken down. His own violence had killed him. I am not very proud of my cowardice or my fears. Although Encio lay dead and was no longer a threat, I had seen enough of the people here. Hasty judgments, unkindness, prejudice. Now, suddenly, I had the chance to make a clean break. I dressed Encio in my clothes and I put on his. I would be discovered dead and that would be the end of it.

And so, to cut all ties with this town, you left that night?

No one saw me. I did not think about tomorrow, what would become of me, the career I was throwing away. All I wanted was to leave a dead brother and a dead town behind me.

Where did you go?

I'm sure I could find the place. I'm sure I could find the places on the map. I did odd jobs. People were friendly, but I thought once they get to know you, they are not so friendly. I traveled light. All I carried was a photograph of the woman I loved.

And you wrote to her?

Oh yes, almost right away. I told her not to grieve that the body in the lighthouse was not mine. I told her to forget me. That I could never return to Winter Harbor. It never occurred to me that someone might be accused of killing me. I got as far as the border of Canada when I happened to see this story in a newspaper.

And so you returned to Winter Harbor of your own free will, Doctor?

How free one's will is, who can say? But what alternative did I have to come back and explain?

Your Honor, the defense rests.

I said at the beginning that Conan Doyle had been very prejudiced. And I am happy to inform you that shortly after the trial was over and the town returned to normal, Susan Greeley became Mrs. Eduardo Columbus. Did I say the town returned to normal? No, Winter Harbor was never again the same.

I shall be back shortly. Sometimes I think it a little presumptuous of me to be trotting out maxims and proverbs by way of warning or encouragement. Ring down the curtain on mystery theater. Frankly, I'm really too down to earth to believe people take too much preaching. But sometimes our story reminds me of a truth so clear I just have to pass it along. And this one happens to be, Let he who is without sin among you cast the first stone.

Our cast included Norman Rose, Betsy Beard, Lloyd Batista, Earl Hammond, and Robert Dryden. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.

A preview of our next film. Smoking a pipe. A pipe. How was he smoking it? Upside down. I see him. Yes, that's what he does. And the bridge of his steps that way. Thought because it was raining he smoked his pipe upside down. Did you see his face? Yes. He had lots of freckles and a sharp pointed nose. I could see by his lips. That's him. That's him in here. That's him. Oh, heaven protect me now. I can't sit still to get like this. What am I going to do? Uncle, you're living in a civilized country. It was the law if people threaten you. Now let me drive over to the county police station tomorrow morning. No, no, no. It's too late. And I'll see that those sailors are taking care of him. No, no, no. He's coming. He's coming. He'll keep me this time for sure.

This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time. Pleasant dreams.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑